Real fans play on ps4.

If I start a new save, the game renders fine, but if I load an imported shadps4 save it's just a white screen with the UI on it.

>>750089313
did you use the in-launcher import option or do it manually?

File: ps5.gif (1.27 MB, 456x600)

1.27 MB GIF

Sony could actually made serious cash from a PS5 port. Now it's too late for them.

my fucking face when i only learned in an ai slop port with fan made online that nightmare frontier is an active pvp zone until you kill a bell lady
i played fully offline on ps4

File: Screenshot 2026-10-22 011830.jpg (633 KB, 2560x1440)

633 KB JPG

I am beating the game

>>750089947
>depth 8
wat

>>750089830
I beat the game with like 6 characters on psn and got invaded one time

Is there a way to make depth 4 or 5 hintertomb? Or cursed? Do people make custom chalices with story stuff like with The One Reborn as a boss?

File: save.png (86 KB, 1920x1080)

86 KB PNG

>>750089494
In-launcher. Got the same result with manual import, too.
Shows up fine in shadps4

>>750090137
cummm is more filling at higher depths

>>750090192
i loaded in twice yesterday and got invaded both times

>>750088997
I loved playing this game growing up.

File: 1792001318934735.jpg (1.25 MB, 2560x1440)

1.25 MB JPG

>>750088997
every souls game has to have a poison swamp area

>>750090441
I can at least see with motion vectors on, but I'll probably just finish this save on shadps4 then start a new file on lantern engine

File: Untitled.png (2.76 MB, 1920x1080)

2.76 MB PNG

>>750091702

>>750091770
the hunter’s lsd

File: Screenshot 2026-10-22 015009.jpg (1.09 MB, 2560x1440)

1.09 MB JPG

What?
smart man, you will explain this to joe

>>750089947
This actually works on PC? How? Did someone remake it or is it actually capable of accessing the servers?

nightmare frontier is really funny at higher levels sl~85
because these dudes 100% cheated in souls so they're like SL90+ with dogshit weapon upgrades doing no damage whatsoever

>>750092383
just tried it on a whim and it works just as it used to. i'm online using huntersdream

DS3 really was just Bloodborne but we put back in shields and backstabs and instead of sidehops you can just roll 15 times with one stamina bar.

>>750092783
and with none of the charm of bloodborne

>>750092783
Yeah it felt like BB but downgraded in order to fit into the DS gameplay style

File: cainhurst.jpg (907 KB, 2560x1440)

907 KB JPG

Brehs... this game is so good

This seems an appropriate a place as any to ask
Any news on a Unicorn Overlord decompile?

>>750092174
chalice dungeons have weapon drops
they have special prefixes though, Uncanny or Lost
They have different blood gem slot shapes depending on its prefix. Other than that, they are identical to the vanilla weapon

>>750088997
I desire more first timers experiences. Tell me first timers what has been your favorite boss so far? Your favorite area, what do you think is total bullshit? Let me live vicariously through you and experience my first time once again.

>>750094004
i tried a few new weapons but they're all just shittier than the saw cleaver
what's up with that

>>750093112
cainhurst is kino, have fun

Can I do keybinding on this or am I gonna need a controller?

>>750088997
Are there any mods that I should get?

>>750094004
i just beat the mystery niggas and honestly all of the bosses except father gascoigne have been a little disappointing so far, im hoping they start getting better soon
blood starved beast was alright, vicar amelia and darkbeast paarl were cool but kinda easy

>play through the game multiple times years ago
>starting a new run now
>post gascion
>going through yarnem picking up stuff i missed
>go to gascions lanturn
>two random npcs ive never seen before are fighting eachother
>one aggros on me, other aggros on me after i accidently poke it with my sword
>kill both
Wtf was that. Did i miss anything by killing both npcs? I figure i was supposed to kill the vaguely yellow guy without aggroing the other one? Ive played this game like five times and had no idea they were there because why the fuck would you realistically go back to that lanturn. Fucking fromsoft npc quests

>>750089191
LOL no

>>750094538
You've never done Eileen's quest?

>>750094153
hunter's axe is pretty good but feels underwhelming compared to the saw cleaver until you have a shitload of strength and relevant blood gems (which is way outside the scope of a normal playthrough). whirligig saw is fun, but a DLC weapon unless you go cave-diving to find a lost/uncanny variation.

>>750094434
I imagine you'll be disappointed by most boss' difficulty until the DLC or lower chalice depths.

File: 2026-10-21 12-16-02 AM.webm (3.8 MB, 1920x1080)

3.8 MB WEBM

AIEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>750094218
You can use a mouse and keyboard. You really shouldn't, but you can.

>>750095259
out fucking played

seamless coop mod when?

is it a good idea to just go all the way up to level 250 on my first character if i want to try out everything in the game before i start making specialized characters? i'm guessing there's zero online activity at that level

File: 1772484865410040.png (577 KB, 736x736)

577 KB PNG

it's literally ds3 without shields
i feel like such a cuck for desiring it for 10 years..

>>750089313
@claude fix this save for me
use this reference [shad save] [original save] [decrypted original save]

>>750096120
and with better movesets, better areas and atmosphere, ranged parries, and rally
which makes it ds3 but good

are upgrade materials all farmable? pissed me off only getting 14 or whatever titanite slabs per playthrough in DS3

File: 20261021093859.jpg (575 KB, 2560x1440)

575 KB JPG

I have no idea why I decided to attack that window. I think huntersdream had gone offline or something and I didn't restart it because I had stopped seeing messages and any online features for a while yesterday night. I imagine if you're online you'll do it because there's a bunch of messages there. But if you aren't, I guess you just do it on a whim? The window looked inviting. But this is not the sort of game where you're usually breaking glass, I can't think of another instance where this is a thing, there's like 5000 glass windows in Yharnam and I guess that is literally the only breakable one.

So really I don't know why I attacked it. I cannot explain.

Is lantern engine a whole lot better than bbport?
I was playing with that just fine at 180fps with fsr 4.1.1, would I get better GPU performance out of it?

>>750096780
i used lantern for the most part at ~90 until i kept crashing at the Rom cutscene
switched back to supermedo and get 120 fps now for some reason
at this point that one seems to be better, at least for me

>>750092383
>>750092665
unless you are unaware, chalice dungeons aren't truly random
all the various possible dungeons technically exist
when you 'create' a dungeon you are just revealing its glyph
thus, the glyph will always represent the same dungeon

>>750096780
>>750096981
gotta add that i don't use any of that upscaling mumbo jumbo
1.0x at 1080p

>>750097035
And yet it still needs online to fetch it.

>>750095347
I beat every single souls game, sekiro, and elden ring on keyboard and mouse. I think I'll be fine

>>750097253
you could drive a car with your ass while your hands operate the pedals
that doesn't make it not miserable

>>750088997
Bros I'm playing blind and having a blast.
Just beat Amelia and it feels like the whole game just opened up. There's like 3 or 4 new places I could explore right now.

File: 1781221010229911.png (475 KB, 1127x426)

475 KB PNG

Could someone go pay the Huntersdream guys so their servers don't run on cardboard

>>750097336
any game where you can freely control the camera is played better with a mouse unless you're mentally disabled or brown

File: 1b9.jpg (80 KB, 640x539)

80 KB JPG

>try lantern engine
>actually add options in the game
>pc camera control too
very good

>>750088997
midborne

File: 20261021055242.jpg (518 KB, 2560x1440)

518 KB JPG

Are these guys supposed to ever drop gems with 2 good stats on them? I keep hearing about gems with shit like phys atk + atk at max hp + a curse or something like that but I've only ever gotten gems with just 1 positive and 1 curse. Not sure if this is how it goes and it's just super rare or what, I've killed them some 30 times.

Had a bug with Mergo's Wet Nurse. Half her body was missing and her clone wasn't coming out to attack. I am using Lantern Engine.

File: file.png (1.68 MB, 1026x1080)

1.68 MB PNG

>A single solitary specimen on the entire base game
>at the back of Byrgenwerth, looking at the lake
>part animal, part insect, part glowing plant
>conjures meteors
>when it's dead, it warps out to god knows where
>not a single fucking word about this thing anywhere in game

kino

>>750096731
wtf do you need that many slabs for?

>>750088997
I have little experience with Soulslike games in general and had a pretty rough time defeating the Blood-Starved Beast. Really goes to show how Soulslike players having a rough time with the Nioh games also makes the opposite true.

>>750097729
Any game that requires 360° movement is literally unplayable on KBM
It works for grid based shit or games where quick movements don't matter.
Guess i'll have to call you a TRANNY since brown is already taken

>>750098181
i played a LOT of pvp, 14 slabs isn't nearly enough if you like to play around with different weapons

bbport or shadps4? I'm on linux

>>750098176
There's a bunch of them in the labyrinth, the one in Byrgenwerth obviously came from there. Considering Byrgenwerth's connection to the labyrinth, then you can think up of any reason that makes sense for it to be there. Maybe they brought it back up to study and it just escaped. Maybe they were "communioning" with it. The connection is there, but the specific details is something each person has their own. As is often the case with a lot of souls stuff.

>>750096120
tasteless post
nobody actually misses playing Dark "seven fucking poison fucking swamps" Souls 3

>>750096731
If I recall correctly upgrade materials for weapons up to +9 are easily farmable. The upgrade to get it to +10 (max) I think is only 1 or 2 per playthrough. So you'll get more on ng+1 and so on.

Mind you there isn't much of a difference between 9 and 10.

>>750098386
the latest beta release of lantern engine has its first linux build, you could try that

File: 1784470900110222.webm (3.61 MB, 1920x1080)

3.61 MB WEBM

i feel like i made a mistake
why's her body all fucked up too

>>750098479
There's been a lot of people baiting pretty obviously in these threads for whatever reason. Maybe they're upset a ps4 exclusive is being played on pc. Maybe they're just upset at people having fun. Maybe they are just monkeys in nature. Who knows. I don't even bother replying.

Abhorrent Beast is the hardest boss in the game and you can't convince me otherwise
The Depth 4 one is unironically harder than the Depth 5 one too

Where do I get the game files?

>>750098482
the wiki says you can get blood rocks from depth 5 chalice dungeon bosses, is that true?
i assume it is but >fextralife

>>750098583
I fought the one in the loran story chalice yesterday and I did not think it was a difficult fight. Is that the one in depth 4? Is it because I'm only on NG (not in any +) or does it not affect chalices?

Also, my build is pretty busted so maybe it just got stat checked.

>>750098482
i mean you can also grind insight and just buy them outright

>>750094538
That's Eileen's quest, bucko. Henryk, Gascoigne's partner, went mad and Eileen was tasked with taking him down before he succumbed to the Beastly Scourge. You can meet her after you reach the Oedon Chapel lantern, she's hanging around the balcony outside. She'll likely die if you let her fight Henryk alone, but if you help her and you both kill him you progress Eileen's questline.

>>750098628
I can't confirm because I just didn't really dabble into chalice farm stuff, especially because I played without ps+. But I don't doubt it. It's probably right.

>>750098368
gotcha, i thought you meant for a single pve run

>>750098628
nigga stop using dextralife
BB already has a borderline perfect wiki without that garbage retroactively shitting up search results
https://www.bloodborne-wiki.com/2015/03/blood-rock.html

yes blood rocks are in D5 chalices
you can also just buy em for an ungodly amount of insight

>>750098176
Fluorescent Flowers are found in the chalice dungeons. Also shoot the flower, it triggers the black hole to instantly consume them and you don't have to actually fight them.

>>750098594
i got mine from a reddit discord, seemed more trustworthy than torrents that have duplicates for some reason and "download ps4 gaems free" sites with rapidshare tier download speeds
go to their bloodborne pc sub and go to the sticky, you dont need to talk or do anything there just use a burner email to make one if you don't use pisscord, game files download is in one of the channels

>>750098729
probly using serrated weapons like a BITHC

Ludwig's Holy Blade feels really satisfying thanks for the rec

>>750098878
cheers anon

>>750098730
Oh yeah right. That's the sort of stuff that made it so I started the post with "if I recall correctly". It's been a while.

>>750098878
>>750098594
literally just google it
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=cusa03173

>>750098418
I'd like to think it's an "animal" that coexists with the great ones, probably a descent of some insectoid unnamed interdimensional being,
like a moth to the flames, wandered into the reflection reality warping Rom was performing at the lake, maybe the scholars kept it there for study

>>750098986
oh, i guess i got covered with reddit piss for no reason then
well whatever, either way works

>>750098901
I'm using the church pick see >>750096751

Like I said, it probably just got stat checked. My character is insanely powerful for a ng0 playthrough. I assume if you get in there at the powerlevel the game actually expects you to be at that point then it's a much tougher challenge.

>>750098594
internet archive has a bunch of them from usa to eur
slow DL speed though

Just tried LanternEngine, but for some reason the camera is giving me huge motion sickness which I never had on PS4, possibly because of how fast it moves at 120fps (even if set at 0 speed in the settings). Is there another option I'm missing?

>>750099053
turn off motion blur
fuck, turn it of for every game ever

>>750098987
They're classified as Kin, so they were mortal and ordinary at some point.

>>750099108
bold of you to assume it isn't already off

>>750099053
if you're on controller and mean the camera is doing weird shit when you try to turn it diagonally, go to the graphics tab in the launcher and set the camera thing near the bottom to "FPS++ retune", then go to the engine tab and check "camera easing for high fps" under experimental

Who is Mensis?
Who is Mergo?

>>750098594
Fitgirl repack is just the extracted game files and a folder with the bbport launcher. You can just replace the launcher with any other LanternEngine works best.

>>750099187
Margo, Mensis got circumcised

>>750099049
yea fair church pick is utterly busted
and more importantly fast

both runs (beast claw + Arm) i got stuck on Abhorrent now for whatever reason
even my summon buddies die to a single good hit

>>750098535
>the ass was out of this plane good
>in fact, Oedon tapped that so hard that made it formless

the lore runs too fucking deep

>>750099187
some loonies that are a split off group from the Healing church
mensis just means moon
mergo is the baby

File: Hunter_Axe.jpg (20 KB, 408x407)

20 KB JPG

easiest game of my life

>>750099187
mensis is the name of the academic school of the church that founded yahargul, they're the scholars who wear cages on their heads
mergo was the stillborn great one child of yharnam, which sucked all the mensis scholars into the nightmare when they tried to contact him

>>750099187
>Who is Mensis?
Mensis is a group within the Healing Church that skews more towards Byrgenwerth's teachings and wish to raise themselves up to become Kin to the Great Ones, by any means necessary. They are rivals to the Choir, another group within the Healing Church. Think of them as secret societies.

>Who is Mergo?
One of the Great Ones, and the one that the game is centered around. He's the stillborn son of Queen Yharnam and Formless Oedon, and him being born dead caused the Great Ones to curse the Pthumeru civilization, which caused their collapse and descent into the catacombs underground. Queen Yharnam is bound to Mergo, and her blood makes up the Old Blood that the Healing Church uses in blood ministration. Mergo's influence within the Old Blood spreads the beastly scourge that's affecting the city. The School of Mensis made contact with Mergo to ask him to grant them insight, and he was happy to oblige, but being an infant he couldn't control his power, and accidentally overloaded the brains of the Mensis scholars, causing their deaths. Very few survived, including Micolash's mind, stuck in the Nightmare.

Banishing Mergo from Yharnam though killing his tether, Mergo's Wet Nurse, is the only way to end the beastly scourge and conclude the Hunt. That's your objective throughout the game.

>>750099515
thats not the sawblade

>>750099187
Mergo is a great one infant that presumably Oegon (another great one, remember Oegon's tomb where you fight father gascoigne?) impregnated Queen Yharnam with.

how 2 play?
what version or whatever should i use?

>>750099180
My stomach thanks you, anon

So Queen Yharnam was a cheating slut, got it.

>>750099579
i still don't get where people get the Oedon connection from
his chapel presumably hadn't even existed by the time blood ministration started considering its in New Yharnam and the space between Oedon Chapel and Tomb having been used to call him

Can we still not customize our hunters without the game exploding?

>>750099694
https://github.com/Awakenchan/LanternEngine
grab this, shove your unpkg'd bloodborne files into it and enjoy

>>750088997
idk wtf lantern engine is but it looks like shit on PC. the graphics are truly dated. 6900xt and 7900xt

>>750099579
Not necessarily trying to contest because I don't claim to be an expect, I'd just like to have a conversation.

I always figured the original blood the church used was from Ebriatas. What the scholars found in the depths was Ebriatas. So for the subject of Bygenwerth and subsequently Healing Church, it all stems from Ebriatas. Ebriatas being there in the labyrinth and having been found by the scholars is basically what set the entire thing in motion. Ebriatas again, because apparently this post needs to have this name being mentioned 100 times. Anywyay, you're implying they were using Yharnam's blood? So which is it?

File: file.png (27 KB, 450x487)

27 KB PNG

>>750099694
Lantern Engine + superpsx to download PKG files
base game, update and DLC
and learn to unpack PKG files
configure resolution and patches
and free online account on the launcher

it's a bitch to do but it works really good

why's Formless Oedon Formless?

>>750099975
It’s very similar to DS3 where everyone has elongated faces with wrinkly waxed skin. And no mouth movement.

>>750099187
Who is Mario?

>>750100063
you can grab all the game files you need already unpackaged from the link in the r*ddit d*scord, no need to mess around with unpacking

does lantern fix the occasional crackling sounds like when you warp or enter a new zone?

>>750100118
Not to meme but literally because he doesn't have a form. Great ones are not really a unified species that follow any set of rules. Or if they do, it's not one we can understand.

>>750090839
Zoom zoom

File: 1766604774294990.png (32 KB, 334x73)

32 KB PNG

>>750100026
not that guy but Ebrietas was the last chalice found, specifically be the choir which was founded way after the Healing Church
Ebrietas was when the beast epidemic was already on and they switched from blood to communion to the old ones

>>750093112
You didn’t find that place yourself. You’re using a guide don’t you

>>750100138
I know this well sound odd, but I'm truly VPNs just wait for the PC release, or at the very least, for emulation to clean up the graphics and stuttering

>>750100270
I know of this text but I always interpreted it as they brought the chalice up and with it they managed to actually commune with Ebriatas in some way because for whatever reason she had an interest in it as an offering. But she was already there under the Cathedral. She just didn't respond to anyone.

>>750100326
Dude the invitation straight up tells you where to go
and its not that hard to find either

>>750089680
they fired everyone that worked on that and the entire issued is most likely backdoor politics because of that
>jap devs dont want dei back then when it started being pushed
>close studio
>fire japanese devs and team
>reopen studio
>now with DEI and new slop devs
from what we knwo its what happened

What's the best way to play this, Fatboy repack?

>>750100428
Maybe he meant before that. Finding the invitation itself. Which granted, getting inside Iosefka's clinic can be missed.

>>750099264
>>750100213
Mergo, why does mario get hit by the spinning wheel

>>750099765
>A great relic, also known as the Cord of the Eye. Every infant Great One has this precursor to the umbilical cord.
>Every Great One loses its child, and then yearns for a surrogate, and Oedon, the formless Great One, is no different. To think, it was corrupted blood that began this eldritch liaison.
Taking it at straight value it describes Arianna's child, but the "eldritch liaison" could also mean just spreading Old Blood through blood ministration, which implies that Mergo was the child that Oedon lost, and then sought a surrogate for. The Yharnam Stone is most likely Mergo's crystallized body, his mind having ascended to different planes of existence.

>>750100026
Like that other anon said, Ebrietas was found in the Great Isz area of the labyrinth, and by that point the Healing Church was already established and Old Blood was spread around Yharnam. Contact with Ebrietas lead to the founding of the Choir. Ebrietas is also Kin, so she was a mortal raised up to become a freaky squid creature, she wasn't one from the start.

>Anywyay, you're implying they were using Yharnam's blood?
I'm not implying it, I'm outright saying it. Queen Yharnam is the ultimate target of the chalice descent, and her blood, corrupted by the influence of the Great Ones, is what the game calls Old Blood. Laurence discovered Old Blood and sought to use it for medicinal purposes, and left Byrgenwerth to found the Healing Church. He became the first Cleric Beast from use of Old Blood, and while his mind was drawn into the Nightmare, his mindless beast body descended back underground as the Bloodletting Beast.

>>750100502
yea sure in the same way hemwick can be missed
but nobody is expecting people to run around without runes unless they used a guide

>>750100501
fattroon repack if you're a lazy retard, you can always just take the game files from it and throw it into lantern engine later if it bugs out on you (it will)
otherwise just get the files from archive or reddit yourself and set up lantern, takes like 5 minutes not including download time

File: file.png (776 KB, 736x1308)

776 KB PNG

what is the deal with the Cainhurst nobles?
why there is a beef with the church, what's their role in the story?

YOU THERE, HUNTER

>>750098386
bbport is much better than shadps4 on my end, got like 20 hours on a rx6600 with just one crash

>>750100673
WAIT... IS THAT A FLOATING STATUE?

>>750100598
>yea sure in the same way hemwick can be missed
Not really at all. Hemwick is naturally there in a path for you. Getting behind Iosefka's clinic needs you to find a cave that is a bit out of the way. Not the same thing.

>>750100673
>>750100731
I remember thinking it was the statue talking to me the first time I played. I didn't notice the dude on the tower until he started shooting.

>>750097132
good thing shadnet lets us access online functions

File: 1451179409518.jpg (65 KB, 454x419)

65 KB JPG

How's the mod that lets you start the game with any weapon? They reduce the stat requirements to make all of them usable, yeah?

>>750098070
You need to go way deeper to get the good gems

>>750100859
There's a few mods that do that. The standalone one that just does that and nothing else literally says in the description it removes requirements so you can actually start with the weapon and use it. I tested it and it works fine.

>>750100879
How deeper? That's a code chalice at depth 5 FRC. Does it go deeper than that?

>>750100594
I still feel like thats a big stretch. Corrupted blood just means that shes from Cainhurst.
But i guess it would make sense if Arianna had very similar blood to Queen Yharnam which is why Oedon chose her in the first place and not Adella for example.

>>750100645
From what I recall, one of the scholars was from Cainhurst took forbidden blood back to his castle. They all got infected and became essentially vampires because for some reason that particular branch of the blood resulted in that. The church then started sending people to exterminate them.

>>750099127
Probably ptumerians though not actual humans.

>>750100645
>>750101162
yea they literally drank so much of Yharnams blood that they got cursed forever
the queen became immortal like Yharnam herself
then they started hunting hunters to get more blood
then the church sent the executioners after em and Logarius became a simp

in reality they were made really early in development and not cut despite not really fitting in the world because miyazaki liked em or whatever

>>750101397
They fit well enough to me. You can say "oh it was an excuse to have a vampire castle because it fits the theme" sure but it was well put in the context.

File: image.jpg (795 KB, 2560x1440)

795 KB JPG

I am cum

File: down boy.webm (1.56 MB, 1280x720)

1.56 MB WEBM

>>750098583

>>750101916
>flaming beast cutter+oil
>probably with top gems
you might as well have directly injected him with AIDS

>>750101916
one of my favorite bosses
>>750102067
lel, nta but gotta be satisfying to buckbreak him like that

>>750088997
tried downloading the repack, got something about a "Yoma!rfn" trojan virus. guess I'll just have to wait a few months until they patch it out...

>>750102497
>repack
don't do that, just get the game files and use lantern engine

>>750102638
is that any safer?

>>750102664
the game files from the bloodborne pc reddit posted earlier in this thread are clean, they're what i've been using to play
fitgirl repacks are known for being ridden with malware (maybe or maybe not due to fake sites, i wouldn't know because i dont use repacks)

So is better performance than ShadPS4?

>>750099694
if you don't want to do the extra work with the pkg files just download fitgirl repack for the base game and use any launcher you'd like. it'll save you an hour or two.

>>750102935
leagues better, lantern engine is essentially what would it would look like if an official pc port was done nigh on perfectly
>>750103017
or just make a burner discord and get the clean unpackaged files from here if you don't trust the repack: https://www.reddit.com/r/BloodbornePC/comments/1uymztw/new_discord_invite_link/

>>750090551
>hax dungeon
You didn’t beat the game.

File: 6687675675.jpg (776 KB, 1000x1400)

776 KB JPG

>Ring the bell at the most populated areas
>Wait and wait
>Not getting summoned
What the fuck, where is everybody? Why is nobody doing coop or pvp?

File: 1786218286846406.jpg (628 KB, 3840x2160)

628 KB JPG

Something tells me its not supposed to look like this.

>>750103327
I don't know about other people but I like the online just to see people's ghosts and spectres and to input chalice dungeon codes. I don't really want to summon help for bosses and the idea of playing pvp in a game with no netcode against some russian dude teleporting behind me seems very unnatractive.

YDBTG
YWNBAW
You lose DS2roonies

>>750103327
I've gotten consistent summons at rom and even a couple at One Reborn
And chalices you usually get two before you find the lever
More people are looking to be summoned than are summoning