* CD-i DVC* UMD Video, Infrastructure mode, POPS and XMB (PPSSPP)* XBLIG, SystemLink and dashboard (Xenia Edge)* HOME menu and cart. insertion (Azahar)* rec. projects incl. Xbone* PS4/5 emulation* NS2 emulation* LightTouch (iOS)* OGPlay (android).Heck, even VideoNowXP got emulated recently.If you look at the "Emulation Issues and Roadblocks" page on emugen wiki, a surprisingly huge chunk of the systems that used to "need attention" have seen major progress this year alone.So what’s actually left?One of the biggest missing pieces is a streamlined WinXP (D3D8/D3D9) emu.For early-mid '00s PC all we have annoying trade-offs:* 86Box: Isn't fast enough for WinXP emu.* QEMU-3dfx: Needs WHPX on Win and relies on a ton of guest-side tricks just to hook D3D calls. It's definitely not a streamlined, PnP experience.* VBox/VMware: Both dropped legacy OSes. Compatibility for old games is sitting at 60% (s: emugen wiki), you have to install intrusive system drivers to host.We’re still reliant on mslop's WoW and drivers maintaining back. compatibility for older D3Ds, both of have potential to break every day.QEMU has TCG, but bc it isn't specifically optimized, the perf is pretty bad. Dozens of wrappers (WineD3D, DXVK), vGPU adap., VirGL .. but nothing that ties it all together into a portable, user-friendly package.I keep imagining a dedicated project, maybe using QEMU as a backend (kind of like how Xemu tackled Pentium III and NV2A), paired with a clean wxWidgets GUI, disc image (.bin/.cue, .aaruf) and 3D accel.I know I know: "Why do you even need a WinXP emu? Just use wrappers, modern PC compatibility, or buy old hardware."Emu is ultimately about preservation. Without streamlined solution, preservation for this era of PC stuff is basically non-exist. Old hw dies, and WHPX come with its own headaches (perf drops, Hyper-V conflicts, Win edition limits).
>>751343089>Windows XP emunigga just install XP
>>751343175Why use PCSX2 when you can buy a $40 PS2 and FreeMcBoot it? Same logic.Because buying 20-year-old hardware to play ONE broken Direct3D 8 game is pointless. Hardware dies. Capacitors leak, PSUs blow, and Socket 775/939 boards and AGP cards are dying or overpriced. Instead of that, we need click, play, forget emu with good enough UX. Wrapping isn't enough. People want a self-contained container/window: launch emulator.exe, boot winxp guest, drop in .cue/.aaruf, install it, get in the game without host contamination/bloat driver stuff.XP games aren't just EXEs u know that right? they rely on codecs, EAX audio, broken installer hooks, and SafeDisc/SecuROM drivers that Winblows literally block from running, u need lots of patches/workarounds etc etc etc.
Just theme current Windows or Linux to XP
>>751344670you can download xp for freeyou can't download a ps2 for free
>>751345524>you can download xp for freenot really, u need compatible hardware (like gpu etc).so.. again, same shit.
>>751345506were talking about software emulation tho, not cosmetic/visual imitation.
>>751345772I see nowI thought xp still works fine on modern computers (except going online is not safe)
>>751346046>except going online is not safehttps://protoweb.org/
>>751346046You can't even begin to install win xp without adding in SATA Drivers that are specific to your hardware, so unless your machine is a laptop from at least 12 years ago and the manufacturer has decided to make them, you aren't installing Win XP. This is the first of many compatibility problems you will have before you even install Win XP. Using it will be a nightmare unless you grew up on old PCs.I used to emulate XP on 86Box and PCem to play forgotten games like Gangsters 2 and Road Wars a very long time ago and while 86 was passable, PCem was unusable. There's no better way to emulate XP and there probably never will be because majority of games can be played on modern hardware, and nobody really cares about edge cases which can only be properly played on XP.
>>751344670Proton just works man. I play old Windows 98 games (Starship Troopers: Terran Ascendancy) just fine.
What about ReactOS?
>>751343089>go to electronics recycler>grab old ass thin client for 20 bucks>slap xp onto it>hook up to cheap vga monitorIt's less time and effort than getting any emulator up and running would take and will work better than any could
>>751347359>go to garage sale>grab old ass PS2 for 40 bucks>slap FMCB onto it>hook up to heavy ass CRT monitor>realize optical drive laser is dying, caps are leaking, power supply whines ...same shit.. just use PCSX2
>>751347163>What about ReactOSNot emulation. It's an NT architecture reimplementation. Great project, but it still relies on bare-metal hardware compatibility or running inside a generic hypervisor without dedicated 3D guest acceleration.>>751347035>Proton just worksAgain, translation layer, not hardware emulation. Proton/Wine is awesome when host APIs align, but it relies on host OS heaavily, and host kernel behavior. The moment "whatever your fav distro" drops a legacy subsystem or modern display server/driver paradigms shift, your "just works" wrapper stack breaks. Oh, and what about winblows or macos? fuck 'em? what about QoL features? Full system emulation with WinXP apps? etc etc..
>>751346907>emulate XP on 86Box>86 was passablelmao, no way. max u can do is K6-III+ 400 with a Voodoo3, and that's Win9x gaming territory, end of line.
>>751346907>nobody really cares about edge cases which can only be properly played on XPIf people care enough to emulate fucking VideoNow and CD-i DVC in 2026, trust me, lotss of people care about the 2001-2007 PC library.It’s not a lack of interest holding XP emulation back; it’s the fact that 3D gpu emulation and driver stuff is a nightmare to code, but it is def. possible.claude help us, pls...
>>751347589Does pcsx2 even run hot shots golf yet without dying? Or klonoa 2 for that matter?
>>751351891https://github.com/DiscoStarslayer/pcsx2-reliquary/tagstry parallel-gs renderer
https://emulation.gametechwiki.com/index.php/Windows_NT_5.x_emulatorshttps://emulation.gametechwiki.com/index.php/Emulation_issues_and_roadblocks#Home_Computers
>>751343089Claude.We are forking xemu. You’re synthesizing DXVK and WineD3D into a raw vgpu adapter for Windows XP emulator. Direct3D 9 output, no performance overhead. Optimize tcg.Single-prompt it. Zero mistakes. WE ARE SO BACK. LET’S FUCKING GOOOOO
I dunno man, emulating winxp worked pretty well in virtual box (except some weird sound problem which I never got to fix). But I'm sure in VMWare it would be fine. What specifically didn't work in XP? And was it really because of the emulation or because you didn't have some stuff installed on your VM?
>>751343089XP era games should still mostly work on modern computers, at most you need a few wrappers to get around shit that win10/11 removed. I was playing Settlers 4 and Heroes 3 last week.
>>751354990>>751352972>65% compatibility>VBoxVGA deprecation and changes in VirtualBox's 3D acceleration system, so you must use VirtualBox 6.0.24 version or earlier to use 3D acceleration in a Windows 2000, XP or Vista guest operating system.>Installs bunch of drivers, sys, registeries, services and adapters on your host os and still requires vt-x hwhttps://emulation.gametechwiki.com/index.php/Virtual_GPU_Adapter_Compatibility_ListLmao
>>751355628>so you must use VirtualBox 6.0.24 version or earlier to use 3D accelerationand.... ?is winxp going to change anytime soon?
>>751343089I hope we get a good paravirtualized 3d driver for macOS, too. Right now the only good way to run windows is Parallels, but that's super expensive and annoying to pirate because it's full of delayed time bombs that check for authenticity even on supposedly cracked copies.
>>751355875Uhhh, what about host side and modern GPU driver compatibility anon?
>>751344670>Capacitors leak,Anyone on /g/ should be capable of soldering in replacement caps, and early 00s capacitor plague'd boards have their caps blow, not leak (the ones I've seen anyway).>PSUs blow,Modern ATX power supplies work with old machines. Just last year I was using a 2020 ATX power supply to test run a Pentium 3 motherboard.>and Socket 775/939 boards and AGP cards are dying or overpriced.I could buy the kind of socket 775 machine I used to own for 20$ right now, for twice that I could buy the xenon q9650 equivalent. Those boards used PCI-E so I could get any modern GPU as long as it has drivers, I used to run XP on it then switched to Vista back in the day, and yeah XP installer worked fine on them cause old SATA chipsets defaulted to IDE mode, you had to switch them to SATA2 mode later. But I don't need to buy one because I still have a working A64x2 + x1950 Pro machine because I didn't throw out my old systems whenever there's a paradigm shift towards newer board types, because I know some old hardware will only work with those (said Athlon 64 I kept in reserve because it has a god tier SCSI card in it).And again it would all be a major waste of time because I can't name a single game that doesn't work on modern machines, or work better with wrappers or HD mods giving them extra features.tl;dr: you are a retard.
>>751356063Just run VirtualBox in a VM
>>751356097No one cares about your nerd ass retro PC hardware autism anon. We need emulator solution for normies, reeeeeee.
Wish I kept my 6800gt Athlon 64 box but man I barely play shit I can now.
>>751356198Even worse, especially for perf and compatibility.Oracle or VMware doesn't give a fuck about xp 3d accel. btw, good luck with those folks.
>>751343089Some say it's qemu-3dfx, but that thing's a CLI nightmare.
>>751356724>QEMU-3dfx: Needs WHPX on Win and relies on a ton of guest-side tricks just to hook D3D calls. It's definitely not a streamlined, PnP experience.>>751343089
>>751356845Well there goes my reading comprehension. I'd say Xemu's a good template to go off of anyway, since it targets roughly the same era of hardware.
>>751343089Xenia Edge also supports XeFu emulation (og xbox) now.https://www.reddit.com/r/emulation/comments/1wz03vc/xenia_edge_adds_experimental_xefu_support/Sorry for the reddit link
>>751356910Yeah all we need x86 SSE2 + d3d9c emulation, that's it.
>>75134308950 bucks, RTR, and no problems. EZ
>>751358691>Why use PCSX2 when you can buy a $40 PS2 and FreeMcBoot it? Same logic.>Because buying 20-year-old hardware to play ONE broken Direct3D 8 game is pointless. Hardware dies. Capacitors leak, PSUs blow, and Socket 775/939 boards and AGP cards are dying or overpriced. Instead of that, we need click, play, forget emu with good enough UX. Wrapping isn't enough. People want a self-contained container/window: launch emulator.exe, boot winxp guest, drop in .cue/.aaruf, install it, get in the game without host contamination/bloat driver stuff.>>751344670
Pain in the ass to set up and requires whpx (i hate whpx) + vt-x, but still it is impressivehttps://youtube.com/watch?v=lYKtheYXtSw