if you truly value gameplay over grafix, why not play roguelikes?As in ROGUElikes. Games like Rogue. ASCII games.You have vast sandboxes of endless emergent gameplay with systems upon systems creating genuinely unique and interesting stories and gameplay.What do true roguelikes need to do in order to finally attract you? What's the barrier? What features are missing?
Give me a roguelite with the same depth of Morrowind with at least 50 times the content and I'll consider it. This includes the intricate world building, of course.
>>751578680Roguelikes are garbage. They're just gambling. Procedural generation in general is something I loathe.
>if you truly value gameplay over grafix, why not play roguelikes?I do.
>>751578936>They're just gamblingindeed, many rely far too heavily on random aspectswhat about one that relies less on random levels and enemy placement, though?
>>751579737I also hate them. I don't feel like I'm getting any better; I feel like it's just RNG and luck whether I get a good power or level chunk. So gambling. I swear they're only popular because devs are lazy and people aren't honest with themselves about their addiction.
Quddish Atari res is as primitive as I can tolerate. ASCII is just too painful, I use tilesets for nethack
>>751579927how many have you played and which ones..?some are far more randomthere are roguelikes with handcrafted areas and narratives, you know
>>751578680ADoM 1.1.1 winbeta foreverNone of that modern 3.~ trash with all the funny things like dragon gold duplication and uberjackals removed.
>>751578680>bump your thing into other thing or don't have your thing bump into other thing at all costsWhy aren't you fucking playing atari COMBAT, OP? Tank duels were perfected 50 years ago, and have never improved.Be a man, not a little rogue.
>>751578865Caves of Qud
>>751578680Roguelikes require intelligencemost sloppers can't handle it
>>751578680>Turnbasedwhere the gamplay?
>>751578936Nah, that's a zoomer take.The entire point of the genre is to win with whatever shitty hand you're dealt. The worse your luck, the more fun you should be having.It's a post-Isaac thing to treat them like slot machines where you only have fun when things go perfectly.
>>751580282>The worse your luck, the more fun you should be havinglol no
>>751580015You hit a sewage line. Stop drilling. But I will oblige. I tried Enter the Gungeon, Skeleton Boomerang's Vampire Hunter DLC, and my little brother made me play Issac once. Also, I have mixed feelings on Pikmin 2. I tried them more than once and never liked it.>>751580282Yeah, keep hitting that slot machine. Eventually, you will get an argument that works.
>>751578865Cataclysm, either dark days ahead or bright nights.Deeper than most mental submarines can explore, leagues of content, and still getting multiple experimental builds a month.I should replay morrowind again
>>751580402Uh...those are rogueLITES?? Not rogueLIKES. Did you even read the thread >>751578680. Geez.
>>751578865>Morrowind>DepthCaves of QudUnReal WorldCDDAShadow of the Wyrm
What are some good newbie friendly ones? I tried Cogmind and got filtered hard.
>>751578680Because I do value graphics. Gameplay is the most important thing, but I do need at least a minimum level of graphical fidelity to enjoy a game and my screen looking like a command prompt threw up ain't it.
>>751578865Literally Angband and its variants, pleb.
>>751580402Oh, you are retarded.My bad, I thought I was talking with a real person. Carry on then.
>>751580757Brogue is retard-proofIf you want something more complex, DCSS is nice
Blood In The Panopticon is a ASCII top down shooter and you can barely tell what the fuck is going on but its fun
If you didn't grow up with a shitty old computer that could only play 20 year old games and roguelikes you never developed a soul
>>751580757>I tried Cogmind and got filtered hard.The best ones will filter your ass. Rite of passage or something, I dunno. Buckle up, dig in, and count the teeth that get knocked out as lessons learned. Once you claw your way up that learning curve you'll feel like a god.
>>751578680if you value gameplay why would you play a game that is 99% just bumping into things.check and mate.
>Playing video gamesAll you do is press buttons how is that fun?
>>751581556uh oh someone got triggeres
Because my laptop doesn't have a numpad and most rogue likes are nearly unplayable without it I miss CDDA, I get cravings for it sometimes
>>751580350Yes, that's literally the whole point of the genre.Every run is random. The fun comes from being forced to try different things and thinking outside the box and having wacky situations arise from it.If you keep rerolling until you get the same godrun, it's antithetical to the whole point of the genre. This isn't some weird opinion, even the guy who made Isaac laments that people just spam R until they get a good start, and there's no real way to address this because it's a fundamental failure on the zoomer's part and not a game design failure.
>>751578680I do, but the number of quality roguelikes that aren't just hack clones coming out is very, very low, and I can't just keep replaying stuff like BN forever. I need more games.
Have you guys ever played MUDs? Is anyone here old enough to know what that is? Back when my computer wasn't good enough to really run anything I played one on an old website somewhere, or maybe it was mIRC. Remember mIRC? It was essentially a point and click with text and no graphics but also multiplayer and you could fight each other, all done through text. Go North. Get Ye Flask. That sort of thing. I wonder if they're still around.
>>751581812use vi keys
>>751578680I do play ragu anonymous poster but I like grafix too. ADOM's strictly better with ASCII but I like the goofy little sprites that got made for it>>751580854MOURNHOLD!CITY OF LIGHT!CITY OF MAGIC!
get with the times, uncit's all about incremental game snow
>>751582008I used to play a lot of HellMOO and also a dogshit DBZ MOO I don't remember the name of.
>>751578680I went even less graphics than that
important question:would you play a roguelike for mobile, assuming it is made to be a TRUE roguelike and not a lite dumbed down normieslop affair?Intuitive controls but emergent mechanics and every reasonable item combination (use knife on bone to sharpen it into a dart for example)
>>751578680>if you truly value gameplay over grafixI don't.
>>751581838It's definitely a game design failure. Those roguelite games are terrible and bad. Actual rogues are subtle, they were deliberately crafted by hackers according to the Berlin Interpretation, and this is something sloppers like the Isaac dev can't do and his game sucks.
>>751582008My sister got addicted to them after I showed her how to connect via telnet. She basically didn't leave her room for three years and ended up traveling out of state and marrying one of the other players, and they have a daughter. He died two years ago.
>>751582008I played a bunch of MUDs before EQ, then when EQ came out I thought "Damn that's going to be the best, I'll play that" and then I played for a few months and then they wanted to sell a full fucking expansion on top of a monthly fee for lizards on the moon and you know what fuck it I'm out. I tried to remember to keep my "New character" I made in January 2000 logged in occasionally but I finally fucked up and he was deleted. Damn shame since he had a bunch of ultra rare stuff that was removed from the game. I want some apple sauce
>>751580402Is there a Binding of Isaac clone out there but green and vibrant and cute instead of brown and drab and obsessed with feces?
>>751582094Can't be done, that game uses pretty much every key for something
>>751582220I played DCSS on my phone through all of college.At the time it was perfect for me but I can't really handle it anymore. It's just way too slow having to search and peck on a touch screen.Maybe if it had some kind of controller support or if I bought a phone with tactile buttons, sure.
>>751582328I'm building one about witches. Probably be out in another two or three years.
>>751582328There are hundreds of roguelikes like Binding of Isaac. It started a huge trend
>>751578865Caves of Qud is for you
>>751582428name one
>>751582483Undermine
>>751578680It feels more fun running around as a character. Being hunched over to stare at a grid is a wholly different experience. You could even change the same game into 3d view and it would still feel markedly different
>>751582348what if it had a drag and drop inventory?
>>751582521It's a bit subterranean and brown/gray but I do appreciate that you're not washing away sentient turds with body fluids
>>751578680Never played Rogue.Are these just Mystery Dungeons for pretentious autists?
>>751580259>he doesn't knowwinning the game takes being knowledgeable, careful, and managing risk so situations don't spiral
>>751578680But I do.
>>75158363995% of ascii/tileset roguelikes are just relying on RNG and knowledge checks like the devs deciding to let a enemy from 10 floors down spawn on your current floor for no reason or you step on a trap and get paralyzed while enemies beat you to death
>>751580757Tales of Maj'Eyal. It has grafficks, you only need to press a few buttons to play, it slow rolls you on complicated mechanics with class unlocks, you have more than 1 life per run by default, and both skills and item stats will be intuitive if you've ever played a CRPG or dungeon crawler. Plus, it's [/spoiler]fun[/spoiler]. Path of Achra is also great, looks great, and is and pretty ez early on. Rift Wizard and Demon are fairly intuitive and cool, but will break your balls with a hammer difficulty-wise.
>>751582220Shattered Pixel Dungeon is pretty solid.
>>751578680dnd is the better stone age crpg
>>751582328>instead of brown and drab and obsessed with feces?But that's where the soul is.Anyway there aren't any BoI clones, I'm not sure why. Most roguelites hate synergies with a passion, except for maybe the deckbuilders which obviously aren't BoI clones. Tiny Rogues, I guess, though that's barely a fraction of what BoI has to offer.
mythical whalers comes out soon, I might give it a try
>>751584037If you're looking to try a weird roguelike, pirate Approaching Infinity. Very autistic and very cool
>>751583717>knowledge traps>you step on a trapDo you really consider how to not step on a snare unfair gatekept knowledge? I think you're more on the subway surfers level of brain activity
>>751583717I'm amazed that you've played 100% of roguelikes
>>751584116that falls under RNG
>>751578680Becase I value gameplay over graphics but I still think artstyle and atmosphere are important. They are called VIDEOgames (as in, the ancient greek world for "seeing"), after all.
>>751583717so in nethack, traps can only appear in roomsit's important minimize the amount you travel in an unknown room, observe other creatures to detect traps, search when you must, and backtrack over squares you know are safe. moreover, you learn to keep items that can be damaged in bags to safeguard them.when all else fails, it's important to have a means of escape or two.it's called minimizing/managing/mitigating risk.with enough experience and equipment, no trap is dangerous barring doing stupid shit that always finds a way to spiral out of control. and then you learn not to do that.
>>751584628Play Path of Achra you pretentious weeb
>>751578680The premise is good in principle, but in most games of this genre the RNG largely determines your progress. You're often die from out-of-level monsters, monsters that you can't see until it's too late, or simply having no equipment to handle a bad situation. You can play for hours or days and still not make any progress beyond the first several floors. It gets boring when the bulk of your playing time is concentrated on the early floors.
>>751584895>but in most games of this genre the RNG largely determines your progressliteral skill issue
I have 2400 hours on Binding of Isaac
>>751584895start as valkyrie instead of wizard dude cmon
>>751578680because roguelike gameplay is a glorified slot machine unless you're wikimaxing
>>751578680I do and they ruined all other games for me
>>751585475i wish stealth build and avoiding all enemies wasnt so encouraged in this one tho
>>751578680my computer broke, I'll never get to play another roguelike, rts, indie, or tactical strategy game again.
>>751578680Trad roguelikes have awful gameplay
>>751585070I didn't ask
>>751582275Dang, RIP to a real one.
I can only play DCSS and occasionally Cata: Last Generation at this point>>751578865>with the same depth of MorrowindI don't think there is a roguelike that shallow
>>751579927You are not being honest with yourself that you are not a good player and you never master a game
>>751578936>They're just gambling.Post your win streaks.>>751580757Start with Nethack. Once you get your first ascension, switch to DCSS. Nethack is the most culturally important roguelike but it was designed before people fully understood the boring risk-aversion required for successful play in all roguelikes. It's not possible to eliminate all rewards for boring play, but DCSS at least makes a serious effort. If you start with DCSS you'll never enjoy Nethack.
>>751580757DCSS is the easiest one and also the best one, game design wise is one of the best videogames ever made, just the fact that it doesn't reward grinding puts it above most games.
>>751584835DCSS does it better. Traps are either immediately visible (and therefore tactically useful, e.g. for luring monsters onto them), or randomly triggered when you reveal tiles without requiring you to actually step on them (and therefore interesting because you're forced to deal with the effects). Traditional traps encourage boring play by rewarding you if you track all tiles which could potentially contain traps.
>>751585475literal tranny game
>>751590596>DCSS is the easiest oneDCSS species selection is actually the difficulty option. Play the "advanced" species for more challenge.
>>751578865>MorrowindCaves of Qud for bros first roguelike with weird lore.>SkyrimAny of the many *bands to get the exact theme you want.>OblivionNethack for typical roguelike experience>DaggerfallIncursion the under appreciated masterpiece that hasn't been surpassed.But unironically, best ROGUElike is Jupiter Hell.
>>751578680>why not play roguelikesBecause the gameplay is shit
>>751582220Pathos nethack could be better but it does scratch an itch
>>751578680truly shitty graffix get in the way of gameplay>there's a C on that tile. what the fuck did C stand for again? *checks manual* oh right a cockatriceAlso people are generally put off by roguelikes because they abhor the loss of progress. Imagine if you were sketching shit and making a mistake meant you need to throw away the entire thing. Everyone would hate drawing
chat you won't relive your minecraft childhood days by playing this crap
>>751591292yellow c -> cockatricebrown c -> baby cockatricered c -> pyroliskthat's the entire *trice classnigga, it's not hard to remember themin addition, only a handful are REALLY important to remember and always be wary of purplea quick "look" is all it takes to verify what it isbesides, if you play the game seriously, you almost certainly have taken notes to reference
>>751578680rogue games are paid demos
>>751578680does Elin count? it's very fun and comfy
>>751578680uhhh I like the occasional NetHack, used to play it in computers class when the other mouthbreathers were being taught how to turn the PC on and what a keyboard is
>>751582328I feel like Enter the Gungeon is sort of a Binding of Isaac clone that pushed the genre
>>751580757Try out Zorbus, it's a very newbie friendly RL that will teach you all the basic without overwhelming you with timers, numbers and mechanical bloat, it also has a lot of QoL.Cogmind is a meme, it's one of those games made by people with actual psychosis who do not really like roguelikes nor understand how to design them.
>>751578680>if you truly value gameplay over grafixI don't, they're both mandatory.
>>751592632well then you're just a faggot
>>751578865Elona+ or Frogcomposband
>>751578680Where dragon rogue like be at?
Any game like tales of majeyal with lots of class autism/complexity?
>>751594407Kimchi crawl
>>751594439Frogcomposband
I don't play rogue-style games because of their crappy controls.>"What??? Are you trying to press Enter to go up staris? Are you an idiot? Of course, to go up you have to press C, for 'climb.'">"Wait, now you want to go down with 'C' too? Now you have to press 'Shift+C,' of course!"This kind of shit...
DoomRL and Sil are fun.
>>751578680I dont have a full UNIX 125% keyboard with metakeys that functions with my intended architecture.
>>751578680>if you value gameplay over graphics that means you must not care about graphics at all and should not want anything beyond ascii charactersextremely flawed premise based on fallacious logic, delete this thread and fuck off
>>751578680I play rougelikes. I enjoy Noita very much.
>>751596519get out
how do you deal with aquaforsI noticed they start spawning on floors 10+ regularly, and my current strategy is to take off my armor and only equip it if I see centaurs or yetis. but doing this guarantees they get at least two hits on me.also how do the weapons work? is a 0/0 longsword as good as a 0/0 mace? are there damage types (e.g. slash/strike)?
Play FurybandAbsolute Angband cinema with crazy classes and items