Playboy X or Dwayne?Francis or Derrick?Deal or Revenge?
>>751584510Dwayne. Playboy X is a hustler with a double digit IQFrancis. Derrick is a fucking snitch and Niko's entire existence in that point of the game is to find the fucking snitch who took away his life.Deal. Because Roman says to Niko that he shouldn't seek revenge any longer after killing/sparing Darko Brevic, which makes it fitting that th story ends with Roman getting killed. It's the darker ending and it fits the theme.
all the choices are obvious. the only ones you need to be careful with are the ones who you can kill or spare in which case you spare so they show up as stranger encounters later on (ivan, clarence, cherise)
GTA for Boomers
>>751584762>all the choices are obvious.Not reallyIf you go on date instead of saving Roman, then you get one more mission(picking him up from hospital).
>>751584510Dwayne, the ability to call goons he gives is better than 20k. You also get playboy x's penthouseFrancis vs derrick is an either or since the ability francis gives you goes away at the end of the game while thay one lawyer chick gives you a permanent ability Deal for the same reason >>751584685Gave
>>751584510Dwayne. Both are low iq but at least Niko would never have to worry about Dwayne betraying him.Francis. Derrick is a piece of shit but he will probably overdose before he ever gets a chance to fuck Niko over. Francis however could easily make Niko the fall guy if he was ever to get in hot water for his corruption.Revenge. I like how dark the Deal ending is but Niko, Roman and Lil Jacob fucking shit up one last time together is a guilty pleasure of mine.
>>751588232>Francis however could easily make Niko the fall guy if he was ever to get in hot water for his corruption.Niko has the backing of the ULP CIA guy, Francis couldn't do shit.
>>751584510Derrick rat out on Gerald didn't he? The moment he's back in America the cops took Gerald immediately.
Which was the guy that was suicidal and constantly crying about being depressed? I think he just got out of jail. I killed him and everyone acted like I'm some psychopath. Well no shit didn't all the other people I killed give you that impression? The writing in this game is abysmal.
save dwaynekill francisrevengeall fit Niko character more. Niko isn't a materialistic type.
>>751584510the one that gives me the penthousein terms of character both characters suck
Kill Playboy X, namely because the Algonquin penthouse is better and the "shun the player character" outcome was rewritten in GTA V for Ending B because they wanted to signal it's not the canon one.Kill Francis, mostly because he is a crooked cop and his ability is replicated through a cheat phone number anyway, though FYI Derrick dies anyway.And 1000% Revenge. Because Dimitri betrayed you how many fucking times? LOL
>>751584510>Playboy X or Dwayne?There's no reason to ever kill Dwayne. Playboy's more of a retard, less of a friend, has the cooler mission/challenge and has one of the best rewards in the game (unique safehouse + unique outfit)>Francis or Derrick?Call Francis right before the call to have Niko tell him the whole thing doesn't feel right, turn down the money, then shot him. Derrick might be more of a fuck up and end up dead with a needle up his arm in a few months anyways but if there's one thing Niko doesn't seem to be fond of is beying a traitorous rat and Francis is a snake putting on a good son facade. His death will hurt Mama McReady more but, you know, fuck him>Deal or Revenge?Deal is the worst mission (going back to where it all began vs some random ass empty warehouse in Alderney) but it leads to the more depressing kino ending of the two. You feel Roman's death far more than Kate's, and Dimitri fits being the final antagonist more than Pegorino. It's sadder which means players like it less, but GTA IV is ultimately a sad game with a sad narrative. The Darko situation leading to Niko going against his instincts and forgiving Dimitri which gets Roman killed is fucking crushing. Absolute cinema.https://youtu.be/bGi-fGP5lAc?t=1002
>>751588232>Revenge. I like how dark the Deal ending is but Niko, Roman and Lil Jacob fucking shit up one last time together is a guilty pleasure of mine.The final "boss" being Jimmy Pegorino and all the conversations during that mission doesn't hit on any buttons at all. It just makes Niko seem dumb. When he asks what Kate ever did to him like he doesn't understand that it was Niko who was the target and when he says that the five families thought he was a joke when no one said it to Niko. Yes, it's possible that Niko said it to spite Jimmy on his deathbed, but it doesn't make it any better. >>751591548>kill francis>all fit Niko character moreYou obviously didn't understand Niko's character at all if you think he would choose to kill Francis instead of a guy who's betrayed his whole old crew.>revenge>Niko isn't a materialistic typeNo, but he says he will do the deal when he speaks to Jimmy Pegorino. Niko isn't the type who'll go back on a word once given either.
>>751590979It's a good theory. I don't know if he would ever rat out his own family though. Niko on the other hand... >>751591756>but if there's one thing Niko doesn't seem to be fond of is beying a traitorous rat and Francis is a snake putting on a good son facadeThere's one traitorous rat in that family and that's Derrick.
>>751584510Playboy is straight with you. He's a nog but he doesn't act above you. Dwayne comes in after a decade in prison and expects to be treated like royalty by Playboy, and even when offered a gig he bitches like a baby that ''He ain't got it no mo mayne''. Another small detail, if you kill Dwayne, Playboy cuts ties with you. Saying he can't hang out with the guy who murdered his mentor, which makes sense. Dwayne has no problem hanging out with Playboy's murderer, and told Niko to kill him despite not knowing about the hit. Even Niko gets sick of Dwayne bitching and complaining, exactly like Playboy was sick of him. The only reason to kill X is to get his apartment and Claude's outfit.
>>751591756>but GTA IV is ultimately a sad game with a sad narrativeI replayed Nico's part not long time ago, and amount of pretty good banter between characters compared to SA and 5 is amazing. Funniest game in the series
>>751591919Go to sleep Francis, Derrick's only ever straight with Niko; you're the one constantly blackmailing him and threatening him with jail and shit and forcing him to do your bidding because you're a CROOKED COP. Get sniper'd.
>>751592101This lmao. Niko is already under investigation by the CIA, what can Derrick do to him? Francis however threatens him constantly. He would be no different than Tenpenny, constantly breathing down Niko's neck.
>>751591984You can literally see Playboy showing his real colours when you're about to kill him. Saying he owns Niko and calls him motherfucker and a bunch of other shit. He's a fucking bitch.>>751592101>Derrick's only ever straight with NikoYeah, having Niko kill his old buddies that he snitched on.>you're the one constantly blackmailing him and threatening him with jail and shit and forcing him to do your biddingFrancis doesn't blackmail Niko. He tries to threaten Niko once and it backfires because Niko knows that Francis is crooked. Francis is also crooked in a an acceptable way. He just wants to kill criminals instead of spending years on getting the evidence. The lawyer you kill for him even says Francis is good at his job.
Dwayne was an entitled retard that invited his troubles but playboy was a snake that hates you for doing what he told you to. In the end, do it for the apartment.
>>751592220Except Niko made it very clear that Francis is not going to breath down his neck at all and is in fact going to help Niko if he has trouble with the law. Derrick can snitch on Niko whenever he feels like it after IAA says to Niko that he's on his own after Darko.
>>751591984>Even Niko gets sick of Dwayne bitching and complainingI was trying to hear all the friend hangout dialogue on my last playthrough. It's funny that one of the conversations will have Niko call Dwayne out on being a depressed sad sack all the time
>>751592746I did the same thing. It's funny when Dwayne says he grew up poor and Niko says that they didn't have electricity until he was twelve and Dwayne says: Oh shit. My bad.
>>751584510Playboy for the houseFrancis because he's a faggotRevenge because losing Kate feels more thematically appropriate for post game mayhem
>>751584510Kill PlayboyKill DerrickRevenge
People only pick Revenge because they like Roman more and because the mafia signing Jimmy’s death warrant is the coolest moment GTA has had in the history of the series.But Niko has always been a backstabbing asshole who betrayed half of his employers for a quick buck, so the Deal ending is thematically more correct.
>>751593548Why would Niko trust Dimitri, who kidnapped Roman and told Niko straight on the phone, that he will find them and kill them.
>>751591919>I don't know if he would ever rat out his own family thoughFrancis specifically mentioned Derrick talking to a reporter to snitch on him.
>>751594318Francis is a fucking lying rat
metal breast implants and the sopranos box set would have fixed her
>>751584685Roman dying is definitely the more thematically fitting ending, but the setup was always so contrived. Why does Roman of all people know Dimitri's exact location, and why would he ever suggest working with him.
>>751584510blast playboy not for the flat but because dwayne lets you have henchmen NPCs to go driveby the police withi love AI companions and watching them fight the other AIs trying to pretend they dont know every daatapoint about each other
>>751584510Kill Francis, Derrick dies from drugsPick Revenge, Kate diesTake Patrick to the cannibals in GTA VTotal McReary death
>>751594318True. I forgot about that. Then, yes, it's very possible that it's Derrick who put Gerald in prison.>>751593708Jimmy says that he won't have to deal with the Russians directly. And that's true.>>751594805That's more of a setup to the revenge ending though. But yeah, I feel like it's added as an afterthought.
>>7515845103rd choice is easy, the bitch dies obviously
>>751595293based fuck the IRAlong live thatcherism
every choice boils down to wacky retard seconds away from death anyways vs pensive and experienced wise boomer who just wants to live in peacethis really says a lot about society
>>751595293
>>751584510Kill Playboy because money is worthless and Claude's outfit from 3 and a free apartment has more useKill Derrick because money is worthless and I think Francis's ability when it isn't broken has more useRevenge because money is worthless and Roman's free cab service has more use than a worthless girlfriend that fucks off
>>751595678Just like real life, huh.