[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 7y2wyjke6boh1.png (1.42 MB, 1697x967)
1.42 MB PNG
Can we finally say it's a good remake?
It seems everyone is focusing on very minor grievances
>>
>>751584625
>Can we finally say it's a good remake?
Yes

>It seems everyone is focusing on very minor grievances
It fucks up enough serious things that it cannot be considered a definitive version and there's easily enough reason to want to continue to play the original over it, in spite of all it does well or improves. It ought to be straight up better, but isn't.
>>
It's the best video game I've ever played
>>
>>751584625
The original is the definitive experience and always will be.
The OoT remake looks ugly, lacks ambition, and what changes it does make are mostly for the worse.
>>
>>751584843
Can you list all the major fuck ups please?
>>
Graphically its nice but it sucks that its the same game i was expecting something new a new dungeon something like that for veteran fans
>>
>>751585007
>The original is the definitive experience and always will be.
That's really unfortunate though. I shouldn't have to keep telling people to play a version of the game with muddy textures on tons of things, no gyro aim, limited NPC interaction where characters just mostly repeat lines after certain points, ice arrows that barely do anything, no extra dungeons or proper difficulty modes etc.

The game *should* be redone to greatly improve it and completely cement it as the absolute GOAT in all possible ways. It's a shame the remake just falls short of that.
>>
>>751585156
The uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh big octo fight doesn't have spikes anymore literally worst game ever (do NOT talk to me about shaboms)
>>
>>751584625
I don't like the plastic look. Sheik looks like one of those deformed crack babies. I hate that the hookshot now only attaches to points instead of anything wooden. Other than that it seems to be alright so far.
>>
Anyone else trying to get the master medals on zelda notes? It's making me appreciate the combat on a whole new level. This shit has attack canceling and everything
>>
>>751584625
b-but they add 2 vases before the boss!!
>>
>>751584625
The gameplay changes are too much for me. I'm fine with just continuing to play either the original or the 3DS version, same with Starfox.
>>
>>751584625
Nah. Its a mid remake that sucks the soul out of the original and takes away loads of the charm the original has. Is it awful? No, but its hardly a good remake either.
>>
>>751585463
I got done with the hall of fallen foes yesterday. Figuring out the quick kill was fun but some of it was weird.
Like charged up spin attacks hit 3 times or comboing deku stick's normal attack being faster than stick jump slashes on dead hands.
>>
>>751585671
Did you realize you can cancel the end leg of deku stick jump attack by locking on or swapping items? That makes a huge difference
>>
>>751585732
>swapping items
Not sure if that's fast enough when menuing counts towards the timer.
>by locking on
I had a clue some animation got cancelled when going for the quick kill on King Dodongo but I might have just been mashing buttons at that point.

Got any applications for your technique yet?
>>
>>751584625
Mediocre and lazy remake
>>
There are a lot of changes that make it iffy for me. It’s a neat reimagining I guess
>>
>>751585905
>when menuing counts towards the timer.
No it doesnt.

>Got any applications for your technique yet?
Canceling megaton hammer jump attacks with an item swap is killer especially when combine with nuts
>>
It's the purest form of a perfect adventure game. If them bringing it into the Wilds canon is what needs to happen to make them move more away from the Wilds game mechanics for future Zelda games then im all for it
>>
>>751586107
>No it doesnt.
I just tested it. Looks like it really doesn't count. That's a surprise.
>>
>>751585156
It doesn't look like vaseline smeared shit as the original did.
>>
you paid full price for a game you already played
>>
You can finish it in a day if you have already played the original
>>
>>751584625
No, stop sucking dick and accepting garbage.
>>
>>751584625
Did they fuck up the boob smothering?
>>
>>751586506
and in another twenty years ill do it again
>>
>>751586506
>you paid to see a band you've already heard before!!
Yeah, and?
>>
>>751586641
>comparing a cultural and social gathering to consooming video games
big whiff
>>
>>751586551
thats good though, the game has near infinite replay value, and with it already being on PC and soon to have mods, it will achieve infinite replay value
>>
>>751586584
Wrong game you fucking secondary
>>
>>751584625
It's great
>>
I can, but /v/ will forever have random hangups about inconsequential shit
>>
File: 1790661234141953.png (91 KB, 253x242)
91 KB PNG
>>751586708
Video games, and especially OOT provide both of those
>>
>>751586506
>You paid
I did not
>>
>>751584912
Play more than one video game
>>
>>751586506
I've paid full price for worse games that I played less
>>
>>751587031
why would he need to he already has the best one
>>
File: OoT.webm (3.8 MB, 854x480)
3.8 MB
3.8 MB WEBM
Besides the stuff in this webm, my only complaint is Treehouse's gay localization where they take out Darunia saying that you became a MAN AMONG MEN or really any "gendered language" for the most part. But really, nothing serious, I'd prefer the shit in the webm still be there, but the pros massively outweigh these minor omissions. It's nice that someone can make a game this pretty without it having to take up 150+GB.
>>
>>751587154
mods will fix it
>>
>>751587154
>really any "gendered language" for the most part.
Nabooru compliments you for growing into such a fine young man when you save her. The Twinrova also calls you a boy, not saying some of the words weren't changed in places, but acting like they took out gendered language is retarded. Tons of other people referred to Link as a boy as well those are just the examples i saw in the past twenty minutes of playing
>>
>>751584625
No, in truth it's the worst kind of remake, people are only ignoring that because they're in the honey moon phase
It does the same thing to the og OoT that the Demon's Souls Remake does to the og Demon's Souls, it's an arrogant, pretentious, self serving remake that tries to usurp all the merits of the og for itself, it arrogantly tries to substitute the original OoT and the devs arrogantly think they know better than the artists that made the original masterpiece, they change the design willy nilly without no regards to the intent of the og artists. It exists solely for the devs' desire to erase the legacy of the original and to substitute it with their new version
A good remake is more akin to Resident Evil 2 Remake or the Final Fantasy 7 Remakes, where the game doesn't try to usurp the original and substitute it, it tries instead to stand on its own merits, with the devs respecting the legacy of the original enough that they don't try to remove it from the fans and shove the new version on them, instead they simply offer an alternative version that can stand side by side with the ogs instead of being it and only it
>>
>>751587279
They made the girls pretty thats why the remake is good
>>
>>751587279
Lmao
>>
>>751585156
Zelda looks like a man.

Thats a start.
>>
File: banooru.jpg (1.03 MB, 1920x2487)
1.03 MB JPG
>>751587256
There's enough for it to be annoying if you know what it's supposed to be.
>>
>>751584625
For whatever gripes people may have, I think it just feels really, really fucking good to play. Manual jumping really does not add anything meaning and can go but I think in terms of general feel it is one of the best in the series
>>
>low res UE slop dependent on upscaler garbage
>weird ass block nose people
>good
I feel like I'm taking crazy pills.
>>
The game does nothing to offer a challenge and is braindead and easy.

>b b but the original was easy too
Then dont make a remake if you arent gonna fix the problems. Dont add a manual jump button unless you plan on making insanely difficult platforming segments to compensate.
>>
>>751585459
>I hate that the hookshot now only attaches to points instead of anything wooden.
See, I think that was their whole issue. It didn't attach to anything wooden. It was inconsistent because there's a lot of stuff with wooden texture that can't be hooked and it'd be more apparent in HD. They probably had to choose between simplifying it to make the game's rules more consistent, or making EVERYTHING wooden hookable which could create more issues.
>>
>>751587516
OoT remake is on the BOTW/TOTK engine, not UE. Sempai why are you lying on the internet?
>>
>>751587723
>OoT remake is on the BOTW/TOTK engine, not UE.
Not much of a difference.
>>
>>751587792
What did she mean by this?
>>
>>751587813
They're both the same slop.
>>
>>751587723
I don't know what that is and those games were shit too. So maybe that explains more.
>>
>>751587538
>if you arent gonna fix the problems
This problem exists only in your mind when you're talking about one of the best rated games of all time.
>>
>>751587279
>A good remake is more akin to the Final Fantasy 7 Remakes
boi am i laffin
>>
>>751587279
Remember that people were also rigorously defending Demon's Souls Remake when it first launched and the sane ones that were criticizing it were in the minority, but later most of the defenders turned around when the honey moon phase ended, the same will happen to OoTR, you can already see that most people have gritantes with the game, they just fail to ponder them adequately, but once they get their heads straight they'll start noticing how heavy these grievances feel
>>
>>751587931
>muh ratings
And why should anyone listen to mindless goy sheep?
>>
>>751587992
Most people have grievances * jesus wtf did I write there
>>
>>751587992
I wish I could live in a fantasy of my own making so convincingly
>>
>>
>>751584625
It toned down so much stuff, i never finished the original but even i could tell this game was way too easy.
I 100% it too
>>
>>751584625
>remove mappable hotkeys because kids can't comprehend them
>combo buttons for no reason when L and R are duplicate buttons, can't aim shield manually either
>navi is even more annoying in case you were on the phone during cutscenes
>ear rape from 4kidz eng dub
>dialogue rewrites stray from source material for no fucking reason
>scrub mature subject matter clean because it needs to be a pixar movie for gen z/alpha
>downgraded puzzles/cut rooms because it's not like people play this game for the dungeons anyway
>fsr1 smear filter to make you feel nostalgic for the n64 days, despite switch 2 supporting dlss
>modern graphics and art only to cover everything with anti soul gas 5 feet from you
yeah minor grievances, makes me question why don't I just play the OG recomp
>>
>>751588325
>anti soul gas
When did this stupid meme take off?
>>
If they wanted a quick select, why didn't they do it like Skyward Sword so they could use all three shoulder buttons for items?
>>
>>751588417
2017 I think
>>
eh i dunno, the vibes are so different. dungeons dont feel oppressive at all in this one
>>
enemy designs being dogshit is not a "minor grievance". puzzles removed and simplified is not a minor grievance either.
i really like how the actual locations look, but it's going to require a very good romhacker with good artistic taste to turn it into the definitive way to play the game this should have been.
>inb4 claude
AI cannot magically make people with dogshit taste make something that looks good. it just makes what you ask it to, but if you ask the wrong questions all it will output is garbage.
>>
My biggest complaint by far are that the cutscenes are not skippable and that they put the fucking Owl everywhere. In any game where the cutscenes are not skippable I imagine tranny devs screaming "NOOOO YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO SKIP THE CUTSCENES WE PUT SO MUCH EFFORT INTO THEM" instead of devs who prioritize gameplay and replay value most which are the only devs I may trust.

So for one playtrough the remake is fine, but if I want to replay OoT I think I will stick to the 3DS remakes.
>>
>>751584625
No.
>>
>>751588762
Um, AI will solve everything thoughbeit.
>>
>>751585396
>>751586478
>>751587372
My two main issues are the faces and English VA. Most of the "dumbing down" was just removing tedium rather than difficulty. Some things are baffling like the drawbridge staying down at night makes sense from a friction POV but ruins the environmental story telling.
>>
It’s missing Master Quest for some dumb reason
>>
>>751589312
>removing tedium
Oh, heaven forbid a game not roll over and give you an instant wim button every 5 seconds.
>>
>>751584625
This is not minor
>>751587154
Every secret is now hidden behind a "there is a secret here!" texture.
Dungeons are inferior/butchered (fire temple for example)
I mean it's good but I also don't understand why it has less mechanics and inferior dungeon design

>>751589361
Because it's going to be a DLC for $20 :)
>>
>>751588762
>enemy designs being dogshit
what?
what enemies look bad?
>>
>>751589312
It's not baffling at all, you either get stuck outside waiting, or you play the sun song and negate the mechanic. The job of a remake is to fix that shit.
>>
>>751589945
ganon
moblins
jabu jabu
most characters
honestly almost anything aside from exterior locations
>>
>>751590312
>or you play the sun song and negate the mechanic
You literally cannot do this by design
>>
>>751584625
there's basically no reason to play this game
>>
>>751590312
doesn't it automatically transition to night as you get closer to the castle?
>>
File: 20240411_072247.jpg (102 KB, 1080x1121)
102 KB JPG
Why is everyone so fixated on Master Quest? When's the last time you actually played it? That shit is ass, the dungeon design is so much worse like 80% of it is just fucking Song of Time blocks dude
>>
>>751585156
The presentation for the entire game is bad, which is a non-starter for a primarily aesthetic remake
>>
>>751585156
Worse level design
Worse puzzles
Worse cutscenes
Worse characters
Worse dialogue
Worse controls
Worse movement
However, it's still fun, but now I've 100% it, I re-sold it on and will probably never play it ever again over the original which I revisit once or twice a year.
>>
>>751590732
I like that there are more mini boss encounters
>>
It's not just a good remake, it's the best. /v/ contrarians need not apply.
>>
File: 1794555498302344.jpg (2.17 MB, 3577x2047)
2.17 MB JPG
>>751587154
>>751587256
>ACK
>>
>>751591047
you can fight the bosses again whenever you want in the remake
>>
File: 1780401004902925.jpg (50 KB, 750x504)
50 KB JPG
>>751586506
Very astute!
>>
>>751587992
What's actually wrong with DeS Remake? QRD TLDR if you want.
>>
>>751591279
>for the most part
Learn to read. It's a little inconsistent and not as bad in this game as other Nintendo games, but you'd have to be retarded, blind, ignorant, or some combination of the three to be able to pretend any and all Nintendo games haven't been trying to erase any form of gendered language every chance they get. Pokemon and Splatoon are particularly terrible about this, since those are games where you can make your own character, and nowadays everyone has to be the same human shaped person that mostly just gets an undershirt for some clothes or maybe some very small tits barely visible unless you're wearing specific clothing.
>>
>>751589737
>Dungeons are inferior/butchered (fire temple for example)
Such as?
>>
>>751587279
Truthfully there's no such thing as a good remake because none of them are subtle about their intentions to replace the original game, while profiting from its name significantly of course. That's also the reason why they only go for the big name games that were already successful before rather than the games that 'need' a remake more, but I digress. You're right about what this game is though and more people will realize it eventually, but tendies were already a particularly stubborn breed of cattle before and as they are only now being properly exposed to the demake treatment after only being observers of other companies doing it before, will declare it the gold standard of what a remake should be, because it's their company doing it. That along with a complete lack of integrity is why you'll see them happily adopt the demake shilling strategy of shitting on the original game even when it's OoT, the 'greatest of all time'.
>>
>>751591894
They did this to breath of the wild too, which is funny.

>for 10 years they swore that 20 fps was perfectly serviceable and only pc fats and snoys cared about it
>years later nintendo does an upgrade if you buy it on the switch2
>now suddenly they care about higher framerates
>>
>>751591640
Completely butchered artstyle because bluepoint in their arrogance thought they knew better than Miyazaki-san, as a result the remake misses all the marks when it comes to "translating" the og view of Miyazaki-san to the new iteration, what is worse is that the remake was done with the intention of replacing the original, hence forcing players to experience the arrogant vision of Bluepoint instead of the original artistic view of Miyazaki-san
>>
>>751591957
I still don't give a fuck about framerates.
>>
>>751584625
>Game is still the same as it was in released footage and launch
>Low effort, untalented development, jarring art style, jumping
>Can we finally say it's a good remake?
Sure, once they release a massive update fixing everything unnecessary/ retarded thing about it



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.