Ive only begrudingly read books in school, but i think games have well written stories
>>751587340Even the absolute height of vidya writing is comparable to a Marvel movie. That includes shit like Planescape: Torment.Anyone that disagrees needs to read more books. Nothing wrong with enjoying a games story, but that shit is never "good".
>>751587340Books are shit, for retards who think saying "HURRR READ BOOK!" is the epitome of culture and intelligence, books are obsolete garbage there was no reason to read a book after film became a thing, and there's doubly no reason after video games became a thing. The only reason people read books is because they are worried how they appear to other people, it's pathetic really. Fuck books.
>>751587484
>>751587340Leon looks fucking weird in this game.
>>751587508Writing is obsolete?How did you read this?
Manga completely mogs books and game stories.
perhaps the answer lies in the middle
>>751587340Start reading books, they're much better written than games.
>>751587552Unfortunately there hasnt been a good manga since 2005
>>751587571Bookfags would say these don't count
>>751587543I said books are obsolete, in your case though I'd probably say it wouldn't hurt for you to read a book.
>>751587594Fags of any kind are fags. You can enjoy things without worrying about fags.
>>751587602You didn't say anything. Do you think we're talking right now?
>>751587484The particular medium used for publishing a piece of writing has no inherent effect on the quality. You are a pseud.
>>751587508Did a book rape you? Why the vitriol?
>>751587340There's something wrong with people that refuse free entertainment.
>>751587689It does.You think there's zero academic taboo about writing for videogames? Are you honestly going to say that?If half the writers in the world consider it beneath them to write for videogames... Sure, you have exactly the same quality of writing as novels. Yeap.This is ignoring published works that prove it. There's no such thing as a videogame with anyone near the level of prestige for writing as any literary classic.>B-b-b-but I think TLOU has great writing!K. The rest of the world doesn't.
>>751587943>You think there's zero academic taboo about writing for videogamescaring about "academics" is a sign of being a mongoloid
>>751587689A book is 100% writing so naturally you’d expect a story to be more complex than that of a video game.
>>751587943TLOU doesn’t even have good writing though. It’s derivative and uninspired, and normies rightfully turned against part 2 because shit writing is still shit regardless of the medium.
>>751587943>If half the writers in the world consider it beneath them to write for videogamesThen chances are they're not nearly as good as they think they are anyway, needing to rely on the prestige of books as a medium rather than the strength of their own writing
>>751587484Planescape is not the height of vidya writing. There's 2 real problems:>Vidya writing, near universally, is badand>Good vidya writing is inseparable from its mediumi.e a good video game story cannot be told in another medium, be that book, film, or something else. Some stuff which is more pulpy/action oriented like Halo or the Witcher could theoretically get away with it (if they get good adaptations, which they haven't) but games that have genuinely well written stories that utilise the full strengths of the medium are unadaptable due to the nature of that medium. Which is another reason they're so rare, because most vidya writers think they're writing a normal story that just gets told in a videogame instead of a book or movie, and it takes real talent and vision to write a story that transcends that perspective. It is also why it is so easy to dismiss vidya writing as pulpy slop no better than the MCU, because most of it is exactly that. Really brilliant video game writing, the kind you see in Pathologic or Outer Wilds, is extremely rare and most people never play those kinds of games.
>>751587994more verbose maybemost novels that exist can be effectively condensed to short storiesits a bloated medium by nature and that is despite using "homages", tropes and references to convey ideasits how you get retarded writing this this>“Sunset found her squatting in the grass, groaning. Every stool was looser than the one before, and smelled fouler. By the time the moon came up, she was shitting brown water. The more she drank the more she shat, but the more she shat, the thirstier she grew.”
>academic>publishersDo you have to makethe baitsso obvious?
>>751587340
>>751587484>Even the absolute height of vidya writing is comparable to a Marvel movie. That includes shit like Planescape: Torment.not evenI don't know why gamers can't accept thatremind me of that /a/ "I'm failing english but anime is deep" starter pack
>>751587943>It does.it doesn't. you don't know why it does and you can't explain why, either. it's a fucking guarantee
I've been trying to read the lord of the rings books but I've been at the Hobbit for like 3 years now. I'd just rather do anything else, words on paper does nothing for me when words on screen include human interaction and visuals on screen include gameplay or storytelling. The medium of literature as entertainment has far been surpassed decades ago with the inventions of the radio and television
>>751588716How come it hasn't then?Is it possible for a game to have truly great writing? Sure. It hasn't happened though. And until it does, videogame writing is not on par with novels.Wish in one hand. Shit in the other. Let us know which hand filled up first.
>>751588963You just want to look at game Shelob, admit it
>>751589026The last time I read a book front to back was in jail, that's how dire the medium is as an entertainment platform
>>751588963hobbit is a childrens book my man
>>751589071>In jailIf you were retarded enough to get caught, no wonder you can’t appreciate a good book.
>>751588963To be fair, reading Tolkien is exactly the same feeling as reading a history textbook. Great stories, but awful books.>Hey guys, let's pretend for the next 350 pages that we didn't just tell you what happened from another perspective and act like we're in suspense, ok?
>>751589149Very boring for a children's book. Been sitting on my nightstand for years
>>751589269It's more engaging if you don't block half the page
>>751589357That's a bookmark faggot, a 2nd grade child could tell you that
>>751589392Not that anon, but I can see by your inability to pick up on a joke why you were in prison.Wish you luck in life
>>751587340I read The Odyssey recently in anticipation for the movie, and I realized... this is the second oldest piece of western literature but this could've been written today with the same exact drama. And stories aren't getting better, if anything most books I've read are actually significantly worse than The Odyssey.
>>751589469>Retard thinks jail is prisonI hope you never get pulled over
>>751589269Eeeeww, why is it so dirty?
>>751589525I never pick it up. I left it dusty to prove a point, books are for faggots
>>751589560You make sure to sleep with something "for faggots" within reach and have done so for yearsur a faget mate
>>751589601I store my hair clippers on top of it
>>751589525Uhh it's called mass market paperback, it's basically books but for poor people who don't mind reading words on toilet paper.
>>751589694Next to your makeup kit?
>>751589735>Poor>White skinlol
>>751588043It's unfair to use world design, art direction, sound design, etc as some sort of inclusion when talking about writing in videogames though.If you're talking about videogames as an "art", yes. Or if you're talking about design in general, yes. But when you're talking about writing, specifically, you don't get to include the fact that you felt uneasy tension floating in space while playing Outer Worlds, because that's not the writing.
>>751589768>White people can't be poorThen why are you reading the poorfag edition
>>751589754No, I got lotion for dry skin, my wireless phone charger, a wireless mouse for my 4k projector, and my clippers on top of the gay book
>>751589842>No, I got lotionfaget
>>751589835I clearly stated I was using it as a coaster you retarded inbred
>>751589873>Buy a $4 version of the Hobbit>G-guys I'm not poor! I just bought it as a coasterThe only one you're fooling is yourself.
>>751589768your skin tone didn't keep you from adopting the darky trait of being a jailbird, why would anyone assume it stops you from being a poorfag too
>>751589919It was a box set you gay retard
People like to blame the publishing industry for men not reading but in reality a lot of men just don't read and brag about it
>Reading booksWhat is this 1785
>>751590035>bought the version that lets him look at Viggo's face>keeps it by his bed
>>751590035Yeah and did you pay $25-$30 for it? 4 books for $25 is how much per book?
>>751590116I didn't buy it faggot I was a child
>>751590046Huh? The fuck are you even talking about? Don't think I've ever once heard someone use "the publishing industry" as some sort of boogeyman.How many men do you actually know that are running around paranoid of Penguin Press?WHAT are you even talking about?
/v/ book club? so what are you reading rn? I'm half way through Thanquol's Grey Seer novel and it's really fun and Skavens are really fun to read.
>>751588043BG3 is a good example.
>>751590158Norm Macdonald's (not) memoirs
>>751590143So your parents are poor
>>751590149Anyone talking about "literacy crisis" would usually bring up the topic that boys and men read way less than girls and some blames the publishers for focusing too much on "women" books instead of publishing things that would appeal for men and boys
>>751589816Writing is more than just words or dialogue on a screen
>>751590293Young boys reading less than young girls has nothing to with the fucking publishing industry. It's because the boys dads take them fishing and the girls are told to go read a book.This hasn't changed in a very long time anon. It's not because of publishers.
>>751590280Idk man my mom defenitely is but my father's side is not at all. My grandparents attend college classes and they're almost 90
Games that block your progress if you fail to understand the significance of the text you're given to read > games full of text that paint some circumstance that still progresses to its inevitable conclusion no matter what buttons you press.There are exceptions to this.
>>751590372yeah that's what I'm saying, it's not the publisher fault that boys just don't read
>>751590360Trying to compare apples and oranges if you don't restrict it to actual writing.I guess we can judge a books quality based on the special effects during the action scenes now.
>>751590410It is a bit, it's just not the sole causeIt would be downright silly to look at the overwhelming trend towards publishing books by women, niggers and faggots and pretend like the garbage they write is just as interesting to boys as things used to be
>>751590360>Writing is more than just wordsIt's really not, the rest is presentation
>>751590149The publishing industry panders to women because romantasy books are their equivalent of porn, and the sheer volume of those books drowns out all others. Go to your local bookstore and check the size of the sci-fi/fantasy section compared to the others, and then try and pick out which books in the sci-fi/fantasy section are actual books vs shitty smut.
>>751590382That's a ridiculous number of repeated years. Just how retarded is your lineage?
>>751590441No because it goes back to that other anon's point on how good vidya writing genuinely cannot be conveyed well in other mediums, much like how there are books that are difficult to adapt to a film.Books will still outstripe video games in terms of raw writing quality but the key detail is in how its told.
>>751590372Boys are interested in books that exceed their reading ability, while girls are interested in books that match their reading ability. Twilight was super popular in middle school, yet boys want to read Beowulf or The Iliad and or Lord of the Rings, and it's way too advanced. Boys really need more books like The Iliad but with prose for kids, keeping with the same level of violence:>Idomeneus skewered Erymas straight through the mouth, the merciless brazen spearpoint raking through, up under the brain to split his glistening skull, teeth shattered out, both eyes brimmed to the lids with a gush of blood and both nostrils spurting, mouth gaping, blowing convulsive sprays of blood and death’s dark cloud closed down around his corpse.
>>751590543A market reality isn't pandering.90% of all porn sites are spammed with white women on the front page. Why? Because most people watching porn wanna watch white women.The reason Barnes and Noble has a tiny sci-fi section compared to romance is because... Wait, for it... More women read books.What the fuck else do you expect? Do you think they should dedicate 50% of the store to 10% of the customers? Why the fuck would they do that?
>>751590590they already exist
>>751590706Romance is the ultimate sloppa genre>I want to self insert into this character so I can imagine getting fuckedLmao
>>751590731Yeah, that's a good one and that's why it's popular.
>>751590784I mean, most games are power/self-insert fantasy
>>751587689The medium/format absolutely has an impact
>>751587508>books are obsolete garbage there was no reason to read a book after film became a thing, and there's doubly no reason after video games became a thingAh yes, the famous movies and video games about Descartes philosophical works. I forgot their names at the moment.
>>751587508lmao moron
>>751590831Go on
>>751590854>Ah yes, the famous movies and video games about Descartes philosophical works. I forgot their names at the moment.You mean Popeye? Popeye the Sailor Man?
>>751590558They take art classes in their spare time because they can afford it. They've been retired for longer than I've been alive
>>751590706It's a chicken and egg scenario. Do publishers pander to women because they read more, or do women read more because publishers pander to them? It's pretty clear that it's more difficult for books to be marketed to boys just because of womens market dominance, which creates a feedback loop of more books for women than boys because boys don't read which means there needs to be more books for women. The solution is to take a risk and publish more books for boys that aren't Sanderslop but that's obviously not going to happen because markets are the most risk averse they've been in history. Harry Potter would likely not be published today.
>>751590976The men that pick up books and read them front to back today will be virgins forever unless their prison friends take their virginity. Good thread
>>751591040Reading is the most attractive hobby btw
>>751591040You would know lmao
>>751591097That's just because reading and arousal are inexorably linked in the female mind since all they read is smut
>>751591131Sure buddy
>>751591097Reading is the most low effort of all of these, how funny
>>751591040>He doesn't know about the librarySingle best place to meet women.
>>751587571Cooking With Wild Game was kind of boring
>>751591157ikr! it's just that easy!
>>751587571These are all pretty shitty, if you want actually good isekai (and i mean actually good and not what normgroids consider good) read Dungeon Defense, Your and My Asylum, Ishura or Grimgar
>>751591131>>751591152It's true.
>>751591131Women like men that will rape them not book reading faggots
For me, it's Star Wars Expanded Universe books.
>>751591270Is that why women like Indian men sir?
>>751587484And the good ones are 11 times out of 10 just direct 1 2 1 story beat ripoffs.
>>751591297Sorry I'm white I wasn't considering your country of origin
>>751591268pretending you wouldn't read the same book if it was about a milf vampire raping a helpless dude instead
>>751590158>Mycelium The only objectivist book in years that doesn't read like libertarian shitpost.>MeekhanRe reading Każde martwe marzenie to catch up on story before moving to new book. At least Wegner didn't go GRRM on us and actually keeps on writing.
>>751591326Why would I read cuck fantasy?
>>751587508Vidya is SHIT its for people who dont live life
>>751591306>a young Queen>the daughter of the Kingbased
True books btw.
>>751591316I am sorry to hear that about you sir
>>751591347
>>751591326No, it's gay.Vampires are inherently a female fantasy.
>>751591326Well yeah, I love Bakemonogatari
>>751591390
>>751591425fat ugly bitch
>>751591425Never understood why anyone cared about this bitch when the trio of daughters are so much better
>>751591463They all needed more screentime they should have been the main villains. Cut Miranda, the fish man, and Magneto completely and give the doll to one of them.
>>751591463this, 1,000 redhead flies sucking my dick would probably feel awesome
>>751591171>Fake overpriced glasses >Infinite Jest in one hand>Lolita in the other>Cashmere sweater>Fake British accentYep, it’s bitch hunting time
>>751591425Hard pass.
>>751591569Is this the fabled "horse ass" the negro males make poems about?
>>751587340That's the worst thing about school assigned books. They want you to read stories you cannot possibly appreciate as a kid unless you have some kind of severe autism. I.e, they want you to read stories that are important to them as adults, but that have little or no impact as you as a kid. They should be letting you read books that are meant for you so you develop a love for reading early on. Later, when you're an adult and you read every day, you'll pick up those important books anyway.
Why the fuck did they make Aragorn black in the gay ass card game or whatever the fuck it was
>>751591727I would not even as an adult pick up Night by Elie Wiesel and the only good thing about being made to read it was that it must have been such generic slop that the school couldn't tell that I didn't read it
>>751591776You know why.It's the same reason 99% of CEOs have a last name similar to shekelstein.
>>751591727I was made to read a book called hatchet, that's about all I remember. Everything else was voluntary in a way, you picked what you read but you actually had to read it and talk about it
>>751591850Kikes.Every time.
>>751591850>You know whyBecause he runs away from his responsibilities?
>>751591727Modern school isn't really about teaching you to appreciate good books, it's more about impressing children with the accepted values and ideals that the government wants them to. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, you need a population that has a common set of values for a country to work, but it does mean that children must pursue an interest in real literature themselves or be encouraged by their parents.