Why did RE succeed while Silent Hill failed?
>>751602708>pumping out a billion cheap outsourced games during the PS3 era>doing that same strategy again 15 years later
>>751602708same fate as Konami's other IPs>whored out the IP to westoid noname studios who only know about it from the movies without a care to understanding why it was good in the first placeall KDE cares about are the pachinkos and Master Duel (barely)Capcom for all its other faults at least knows better not to whore their IPs out (ignoring the recent RE movie)
>>751602708I don't have a bunch of trauma garbage so Silent Hill would probably be a normal tourist town to me.
>>751602708RE actually has gameplay but no story.SH has story but no gameplay. Go figure which one gamers have more fun "playing."
>>751602708Legitimate horror, the kind that is designed to actually scare you, is much harder to do (whether it succeeds or not is another question.)Resident Evil isn't horror. Its action with a horror aesthetic. Like a funhouse. Its much easier to do and has a much wider appeal. Its not particularly surprising that they're more successful.
>>751602708superior girls
>>751603668Just played re8 for the first time I couldn't believe the castle was like, two hours
>>751602708Resident Evil 4.After RE2, the series was slipping in sales, not as bad as the SH franchise after SH1, but it's golden age looked to have long passed. RE4 revitalized the franchise again.
>>751603201>Capcom for all its other faults at least knows better not to whore their IPs out (ignoring the recent RE movie)The Street Fighter movie is more recent
>>751603813>After RE2, the series was slipping in salesprobably because every traditional new release besides RE3 (which sold twice as much as SH1) was locked behind the worst performing consoles at the game
PACHINKOACHINKO
Who knows how things would be going if Silent Hills came out.A big part of Resident Evil's resurgence was capitalizing on the hole that Konami left when they shitcanned Kojima after the huge reception P.T. got. Resident Evil 7's demo was a pretty obvious response of "Well if you're not going to do a big first person horror game, we will." It came out during a time where people were still streaming horror games with facecams and being annoying dickheads over reacting to everything. You can't get anywhere without making games.
>>751602708Silent Hill filters normgroids while Resident Evil embraces them with guns and sexy Leon.
>>751604375Silent Hill is like the most larper infested franchise after RE.
>>751602708RE has always been all about corny, horny and dumb stuff. It is action oriented instead of horror.
>>751602708RE lucked out with a generational hit that made the whole series mainstream. Silent Hill meanwhile peaked early with 2 and never had a RE4 moment. They tried and came up with Homecoming instead
>>751605223Yeah they got pretty lucky with RE7
>>751602708Because literally 9 out of 10 best selling horror games of all time are zombie games.
>>751602708>>751607397>cont.Also those two shouldn't be placed next to one another because - let's just face it - Resident Evil are action games under a B movie horror veneer, not actual horror games.
>>751602708Capcom treats its IPs with proper devs. Konami sells out Silent Hill like a cheap whore.
>>7516074527 is a horror game, to the point that it hurt sales in Japan as it was too scary for the 5'2" rice farmers. As always, Japanese artists are a different race from their Dalit commoners.
>>751602708RE has completely changed its target audience at least twice now, always trying to please more and more casual, braindead dude-bro audiences.SH has been just whored to random Westoids for the past 22 years now, trying to chase the RE4's success, while failing to realize that the core audience does not give a fuck about that.>>751605223>Silent Hill meanwhile peaked early with 2You mean SH1, no?>>751607349RE7 was the most insulting shit to ever happen to RE at that point. Until the de-makes of RE2-4 happened...
>>751607727That's one game out of a dozen and it stops being a horror game halfway through.
>>751603280Harry Mason didn't have a bunch of trauma. Silent Hill also involves a cult actually making shit happen.
>>7516082271fags need to accept that nobody cares about the cult shit. EVERYONE prefers the trauma metaphor version of SH. Even the Japanese, as SHf is the same shit. Yes, magic is real, but it's used to pull out and make corporeal a person's fears and regrets. That's just what the franchise became, even to the Japanese, hence them calling it a "phenomenon that can happen anywhere in the world" when marketing f.
>>751608408Cry more.
>>751608408You 2fags are a cancer upon Silent Hill.
>>751608408>retarded secondaries act like alessa's manifestations aren't caused by trauma
>>751602708Capcom continued making Resident Evil games while the Silent Hill IP was passed around all over the place. Silent Hill also wasn't marketed as well, and horror has more of a niche audience to begin with than RE's heavier focus on action. The latter has become an increasingly big issue as development costs rise, and developers find themselves pressured to target only the largest audiences possible because they feel niches can't sustain them anymore.>>751603343I don't think you've played either of them.>>751605223The series was mainstream from day 1; RE1 was a big deal when it came out, moreso than any Silent Hill game. RE4 did revitalize the series and put it back in the spotlight at a critical moment, though.
>>751604486Define larper in this context.
>>751608408SH1 sold more than SH2.SH2 was not the darling psychological horror game on release, being criticized for moving too far from the first game.
>>751602708Konami is extremely fucking stupidCapcom is also stupid but not as stupid as Konami
>>751610665People are fans of watching other people play it, or reading the wiki to argue about lore. The games don't have anywhere near the sales compared to the amount of online discussion the series gets.
>>751603417Why didn't they ever let James have a crowbar
>>751602708I thought silent hill succeeded too? Did the new game with the black guy flop or something?
>>751611039If you've read the lore you understand the themes of Silent Hill
>>751604629>Works for Wesker and therefore Oswell Spencer Ada Wong sucks jewish dong
>>751611495Yeah, the lore that says "Silent Hill" can happen anywhere in the world now. Nice to know I have a spiritual therapist on speed dial if I get brain damage and forget my sins.
>>751602708Capcom never gave up on RE for gambling machines for a start
>>751602708Guys, i lost my gps signal. Which way should i go?
>>751611868Capcom still gave the license to make a shitload of them.
Zombies are badass. Shooting zombies is badass. Silent Hill, I've never played, because it seems gay and for women.
RE was campy and pretty broad. It let devs play with the series a lot more and try weird stuff. Silent hill feels far more focused and the pile of stuff that doesn't fit silent hill is much bigger than resi's. Konami didn't really understand it and neither did any of the teams who picked up the torch.
Silent Hill was the edgy alt franchise and RE was the mainstream oneSilent Hill died at 4 and RE became a trendsetter at 4Silent Hill is a cult icon which is fancy wording for sold like shit but people still remember it to this day and word of mouth devolved into a game of telephone where everyone just regurgitates a Silent Hill 2 analysis on youtube instead of playing the game
>>751603761I thought it was the funniest shit that Lady D was like 97% of the marketing and then you kill her in practically no time flat.
>>751612093Yeah, but they still made games while they did. Not good ones, but still games
>>751603761Yeah that's how teasers work, they don't reveal the full game.That only works for hollywood slop that practically begs you to watch their dogshit
>>751612182I really don't think the franchise would be safe after SH3 regardless of who was developing it. Konami wanted to make money, so they wanted the series to jump in on the current trend.PE could have been the franchise's RE4 moment, where it completely reinvented itself into a successful first person horror game. But who knows now.
>>751602708RE did have a rough period in the early 2010's, Capcom in general was floundering and losing a lot of goodwill and I recall RE6's reception being mixed or poor. RE7 was a pretty big title that also heralded the company finally getting its shit back together and they've ridden that wave of success, which meant capitalizing on it as their biggest title sans MonHun. RE also has the advantage of being able to switch into more action oriented gameplay to keep things lively. I think RE9 should have stuck to one or the other but it does demonstrate how both styles coexist.Without strong leadership and a full commitment to make games that appeal to general audiences, I don't think RE would have succeeded. But Capcom is also solely a game company, whereas Konami has a lot of ventures outside like slot machines and pachinko, so they have something to fall back on.SH also had a rough period during the 7th gen with Homecoming and Downpour, but Konami's struggled to put out a big hit that really garners attention. The closest they got was PT, but that ended up blowing up in their face when they sacked Kojima. I played a little bit of F and liked it, but I avoided SH2remake because I dislike Bloober; all their games are weirdly pro suicide. Even though the response felt generally positive I don't see people raving about them like they would RE. Townfall had zero impact, and Ascension was baffling levels of awful, just from like a conceptual level.SH also has a longrunning problem in that every fucking title post Team Silent wants to just do SH2 again, where it's revealed the MC is some deluded schizo who's hiding a dark secret, and it's botched nearly every fucking time. They have a perfect setup for an anthology series but everyone just ends up being some new flavor of James instead of trying to do something unique within the setting. And you could easily brainstorm some broad character concepts that might make for an interesting story.
>>751603761RE8 is too shit of a game, takes ages for it to start with all the cutscene like gameplay. I think first time where you actually get to control Ethan is the moment after the sisters hang him up and he saves himself. Not to mention the Donna section, the game has way too many cutscenes that makes the subsequent playthroughs a bore
>>751613350>RE7 was a pretty big title that also heralded the company finally getting its shit back togetherThis was not a creative renaissance for Capcom, they just started pandering better to what was viral at the time. RE7 and every RE game made since then has ranged from okay to outright garbage.
>>751611495Regurgitating what you read isn't the same thing as experiencing it for yourself and participating in a discussion. It wouldn't be surprising if some of the most adamant SH2 defenders who attack other iterations of Silent Hill were people who didn't even play the game.
>>751602708whats straight ahead
>>751616484resilent hilvil
>>751602708People don't actually like Horror games when they're boring walking Sims. They just want action slop with puzzles and good level design.
>>751613830>I think first time where you actually get to control Ethan is the moment after the sisters hang him up and he saves himself.Negro what? The first time you're in control of Ethan is the intro before Chris and the Wolfpack or whatever he calls his commando squad shoots fake Mia. Then you're in control again after the van crashes. Then you're in control until you get into the castle and you have to play Running Man in Heisenberg's initial bullshit. Then you fuck around in the village and the castle a bit before the sisters abduct you. I don't think RE8 is good but you clearly remember it being bad for the wrong reasons.
>>751617860Yeah but those are extremely scripted scenes where it feels more like watching a cutscene than playing the game, kind of shit PS3 games used to get for being movies rather than games. I can't wait to slowly walk through the snow in search of Rose in the most one straight line known to men in my 2nd playthrough, you're just pushing forward.
>>751618903>those are extremely scripted scenesSome are. Some really aren't. Overall I agree that RE8 is too linear and plays out the same way every time but there's having a point and there's being ridiculous.
>>751611440It did. The fact that they both still exist today with new games coming out shows that neither was a failure. Zoomers and trolls just have this retarded idea that anything that doesn't become the next avengers is a failure. Don't worry about it.
>>751616484Detroit