How's your block pushing going?
I took me nearly a month to realize the boat is making a pun when it calls her "skipper" because she's skipping stones.
>>7516074381 left. You know which one.
Is the thief always a yellow crystal when petrified, and everyone else red?
Also what's with the color tint on some finished levels?
>>751608191"Difficult and Unrewarding" does not count to the tally.
>>751608478
>>751608478Thanks. I missed this one.
Are there any optional untracked secrets to the game other than the treasures?
>>751607438More like, Order of the Stinking Star.
>>751610971Yes.
wat
>>751608850Wow, this puzzle is kicking my ass.
>>751612453You thought you were done? One more puzzle.
>>751612735yeah nvm, I forgot I had the pusher gadget
I'm almost completed 200 puzzles. I've heard that the normal game ends after about 300 puzzles.Is it obvious what you need to do to access the rest of the game, or is it cryptic?
>>751612453Prod with the prod.
>>751613183It might be a little cryptic. Just be mindful of the lecterns you see around the map.
>>751613183Not really cryptic, just investigate the red areas on the overworld.
For the second endgame I managed to activate the yellow beam, is the mechanic that altered yellow only breaks stones of the same type ever introduced in any puzzle before that?
>>751608360My understanding is that level colors are manually assigned and the completion color is algorithmically determined by brightening this base color by a factor. In some cases you wind up with a color that's farther from white than it should be (the first patch addressed this for some very early skipping stones levels, which were showing up lightly pink and leading players to believe they held incomplete secrets). In short, it doesn't mean anything and is the result of a strange design decision.
I have been stuck on this one for ages. Is this the one people were saying is a binary counter? I did a thing that sort of reminded me of one, but it still isn't enough.
>>751614228I don't think that property is explicitly shown anywhere other than its designated area in world 3. Prior to that, any puzzle featuring the altered yellow beam (which are all optional as far as I know) only has a single block type until the puzzle you're working on.
>>751614385hmmm, why would the pushers be crystal variants, what new capabilities could that provide?
>>751614385What you've heard about is much later, this one is more about just using the stuff in the puzzle, along with the entire playspace.
>>751614692I've tried every variant of making them go through walls, and getting the green beam in a place where that would actually be useful. If I could get it across the barrier and into the water that would be great, but it's impossible, or would require sacrificing both pushers making it pointless.
>>751614385>Is this the one people were saying is a binary counter?Lmao, no.
>>751614843>If I could get it across the barrier and into the water that would be greatWhy do you think you need to do that?
I gave up weeks ago
>>751614914to get the minecart through the barriers? I noticed another interesting property when testing it on the sides (which are too far out to be useful), which is that objects on top don't follow the friction of the minecart and get left behind on solid ground. It seemed like a relevant approach.
Just finished the game, really liked the final endgame with one exception. The idea flow section was ironically torturous, I have no idea why you're forced to repeat a long sequence of levels after correctly demonstrating your understanding of their increasing complexity, five fucking times. I think this game has the best credits and dvd bonus features of any game I've ever played, hope to see more games do cool shit like that. I don't think I will ever touch another sokoban game.
A FUCKING HANOI
Thinking about getting this for my Nintendo Switch 2!
>>751614228>>751614560Wasn't there that one puzzle where you need to break a mirror and then a stone and then use the alt to break all instances of both so you could reach the goal since it was in a tight hallway? Pretty sure that was World 2 or perhaps a World 1 revisit from 2. At the very least, I was already aware of the distinction the beam makes when I had to go do that.
>>751615107>when testing it on the sides (which are too far out to be useful)All 4 sides? Or 3 in your case, since you can't get it across the wall.
>>751615118Oh and I think I've developed a permanent wrist injury as a loving keepsake.
>>751615147Kino.
>>751615219It's possible that I missed it, I don't remember doing stuff with mirror shards until the third part of the game.
I got bored like 100 puzzles in. and I typically love puzzle games
was the intended solution really making a bridge out of your crystallized clones? that's fucked up
>Tfw you notice the amount of goalshttps://youtu.be/zaF3XcAPGvU
>>751616315did this one the other day. what was really annoying is how the members you leave behind need to be crystalized for some reason, had to rewind everything and redo it for 0 actual difference
>>751616269Does that actually work? My solution did not involve cloning, but it did involve using the mirror guy as a bridge.
>>751616269>The Prestige
didn't even use all the pieces lol
>>751616464It's not "for some reason". If you have live characters left over, goals don't work. Crystallizing them bypasses this restriction.
>>751616546put mirrors in same row with gap, crystallize merchant, you can clone him infinitely and use sailor to place the excess crystals wherever you want. since crystallized characters are alive but not "active", the failstate does not trigger as long as nobody drowns
>>751616682Cool exploit. It has to be pretty hard to anticipate tricks like this in every case.
>>751616546Did you have a crystalised mirror guy left over?
>>751616682Looks like you could do it with just four mirrors.
>>751616796Running my solution through my head, it's possible I had a crystalized guy left over and didn't even notice, since the last step would seemingly clone him.
do I have to put it on my head or something?
>>751617176Stare at this image for a few more minutes
>>751617176did you try mapping out the path you need to move it?
>>751617176just push it left? there's a little gap north of mirror that i didn't notice
shouldn't standing on a stone while in a yellow beam cause the stone to break? gravity causes your character to perform a "move down" action on purple and orange beams so I feel like it should...I guess it would also mean green beams cause you to sink into the floor which would be fucked, but then it just seems inconsistent with the ornage and purple ones
>>751617680And red ones.
>>751617680That's what I thought it would do too, but it didn't.
>>751613183I just went to the second part of the game today. You can complete 390 or so puzzles before that (I didn't check, I stopped at exactly 400 after doing a few post transition). It shouldn't be remotely cryptic if you are a completionist because the accessible but not yet used items and areas stick like a sore thumb.
>>751617680I don't think the game treats moving downward the same as pushing, but that's all I've got.
wtf, last time i've seen this lil nigga was like 70 hours ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sC0cvwnG0IkAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
>>751607438I'll miss these threads when they're gone for good, I should probably finish the game before then
>>751620045i keep seeing this level, which direction in layer 2 is it?
>>751620476Layer 3, southeast.
>>751615147I was stuck on this for an embarrassingly long time before I realized the mirror guy could reflect gobbies in both directions.
>>751607438Bit late to the party but getting along well, recently got to Beamcasters, quite liked the gem collection puzzles at the beginning.
Reminder that there is a fanmade level editor out there. It's closed source and likely vibecoded, though, so be cautious.https://sinkingstarwright.com/
>>751622921Someone do one with the red and purple beams where you have to open a force field from below, I ain't goin anywhere near this.
>>751623153Could you elaborate?
>>751623232I think there are puzzles in the game where you open a gate with the red beam by touching it from the sides, there are puzzles where you open the gate by walking over it, but I don't think there are any where you open it by touching it from the bottom. I think you could probably arrange this with the purple beam and a mirror and some other contrivances.
>>751608191>>751608850It's over.
>>751623486
>>751623406I don't think that endpoint would work for that. You can't move or push along its length. You'd need a gate that closes upwards, but that would probably crush anything that does the opening.
>>751623406Also, doesn't look like you can rotate gates at the moment.
>>751617680they also had to make an exception for green beams since otherwise you'd always fall into the floor.
>>751623979I don't think the direction the gate opens in is relevant for this. If endpoint doesn't work, a vertical doubling might. Something likeLocked Gate (locked)SpacePlayer + Red BeamVertical non-magic mirror (receiving doubling beam)deactivated gate (pointed upward)The bottom gate could then be activated by pressing a button (either with another character or a crystal moved via magic mirror). At this point, either the upper gate opens or the mirror shatters since the system is jammed up, not really sure what would happen.
I'm drawing a blank here. In order to get the stone down I assume I have to get it through the newly opened bottom left region. I can't push the stone past the enemies. I can be cleric but cleric can't move anything.
>>751624738You have four gobbies and you need there to be zero, it's simple arithmetic.
>>751624738if only there was some way to remove those bottom 2 goblins
>>751624508>deactivated gate (pointed upward)That's what I was referring to. You can't do that in the editor yet. They all point downwards. Also, I don't think you need a mirror for this.
>>751624793fug, there's too many game mechanics for me to remember the very basic ones
Why was there a barrier in the block to the right of my character here that got lifted? Am I able to drop down this hole somehow? I would never suspect a thing if I wasn't hyper attentive to what changed in this particular area. There was one blocking the exit block to the bottom right, but top-left diagonal was another blocker.
>>751624837>Also, I don't think you need a mirror for this. You're right, I just have it in my mind that you'd be opening the gate in midair with a vertical beam (ideally from a great distance with the endpoint beam- can't the druid do remote touching? I thought this was something everyone could do. A proper level editor would be fun to play with.). For the doubling beam setup, we can drop that component.
>>751624967It's possible this area got changed and the barrier is no longer where it's supposed to be, it was supposed to block you from walking over to the dragon's line of sight. Feels like they break something like this with every patch.
>halfway through layer 3>still haven't opened MxB and MxS in layer 1
Heroes > Skipping Stones > Beamcasters > MirrorsMxB > SxB > HxS > MxS > HxB > HxMnot gonna elaborate
>>751625969now rank layers, overworlds and endgames
>odor of the stinking saar
so when's JAI coming out?
>>751627162World 2 > World 1 > World 3 (just gonna treat layer and overworld the same)Endgame 1 > Endgame 3 > Endgame 2Next, I will do all of the puzzle elements individually.
>>751627529Here is my list of base elements, from memory. I will now rank them, feel free to add any I missed. For concepts, I tried to keep it very broad (never a concept that is element A + element B).WarriorThiefWizardPriestessDruidBardRockCrystalEnergy GateMonster GateButtonGoblinDragonPlantThe Caver/The Caver's CousinRed BeamOrange BeamYellow BeamGreen BeamBlue BeamIndigo BeamPurple BeamWhite BeamAlter BeamCartCrystal CartRodTorcPendantGemPower SocketFenceElevatorWrapping as a ConceptActive Zones as a ConceptAn Interconnected Array of Smaller Puzzles that form a Singular Larger Puzzle Through Reuse and Recontextualization as a ConceptThe Sailor/The SurveyorSkipping StoneCrystal Skipping StoneWaterLilypadRiverCheckpointA Linear Sequence of Smaller Puzzles that form a Singular Larger Adventure as a ConceptThe MirrorwrightMagic MirrorVertical Magic Mirror (angled upward)Vertical Magic Mirror (angled downward)Mundane MirrorVertical Mundane Mirror (angled upward)Vertical Mundane Mirror (angled downward)Mirrorable MirrorVertical Mirrorable Mirror (angled upward)Vertical Mirrorable Mirror (angled downward)Strength as a ConceptStacking as a ConceptFalling as a ConceptExit PlatformThe QueenFast TravelTeleporterClothing RackSignpostVoice Recording
You who call yourself, Order of the Sinking Star: Show yourselves!
>700 puzzles in, very early act 3>barely play the past 3 daysbros...I might not make it................
>>751607668Oh, I get it now.
>>751627479Its already out there in the net, multiplying, modifying, infiltrating, swarming, scanning.Can you feel it , something is off these past few weeks. Its testing us, probing.
>arbitrary mixture of abstract concepts, puzzle elements, and charactersbased, except why is the exit platform rated so low?
>>751628934
>>751629685meant to quote >>751628701
>>751629685>>751629738That's not the rating, those are just me enumerating everything I can remember, grouped by world the element is associated with. I forgot the serpent. Ranking in progress.
>>751629851isn't his voice credited as a "dragon" in the credits?
>>751629954Didn't remember, thanks.
>>751629851also what about the metal pushable block that controls layouts in the meta puzzles
>>751630027Good callout!
>>751628701SThiefGreen BeamWrapping as a ConceptSkipping StonePriestessAn Interconnected Array of Smaller Puzzles that form a Singular Larger Puzzle Through Reuse and Recontextualization as a ConceptDragon (hazard)ButtonCrystalStacking as a ConceptVertical Magic Mirror (angled upward)Mirrorable MirrorVertical Mirrorable Mirror (angled upward)Falling as a ConceptAWarriorWizardThe QueenEnergy GateAlter BeamRodTorcPurple BeamVertical Mundane Mirror (angled upward)Vertical Mundane Mirror (angled downward)Strength as a ConceptVertical Magic Mirror (angled downward)RockMagic MirrorBThe Sailor/The SurveyorLilypadExit PlatformOrange BeamRiverCrystal Skipping StoneThe Dragon (companion)Clothing RackGemMonster GateVoice RecordingMetablockWaterWhite BeamPower SocketA Linear Sequence of Smaller Puzzles that form a Singular Larger Adventure as a ConceptMundane MirrorThe MirrorwrightCGoblinRed BeamActive Zones as a ConceptElevatorCheckpointCartSignpostCrystal CartYellow BeamDDruidBlue BeamPendantFenceThe Caver/The Caver's CousinFIndigo BeamPlantBardCart ShardsBeamcaster ShardsMirror ShardsCrystal ShardsRock ShardsSkipping Stone ShardsDon't think I ever saw once:Vertical Mirrorable Mirror (angled downward)
one thing that seems illogical is that the beamcaster color changer only picks from colors relevant to the puzzle at hand. It's the only thing to my knowledge that works that way, instead of having an innate behavior that is consistent throughout the game.
>>751632781That and the dragon felt very underdeveloped. Alt beam was pretty good, but the advanced concepts they tried to do with Beamcasters is just another sign of it not really going well with the rest of the game.
Tell me your 4-combiner ideas anon, they don't have to be sokobans.
Odor of the Stinking Saar
Someone really needs to make a collage of gemwagie in his cages.
>level has 1 guy 1 exit>clone 1 guy>get 1 of 2 guys on the exit>okay, the rule is 1 exit to 1 guy to win, got it>kill the other guy>okay, there's also another rule>80 hours in>get a puzzle with 5 guys>seems impossible>turns out there is only one exit here but you didn't notice this because it's a level with 5 sections so you probably didn't investigate the exits too closely and you are allowed to kill the other people because??????>and this is introduced in a puzzle that is top 10% difficulty even after knowing this trickwhat the fuck were they thinking here?
>>751628701S tier>druid>pink beam>vertical mirrors>dargonA tier>red guy>Wizard>crystal guy>Green beam>Beam spinner>Beam color changer>Yellow beam>White beam>cart>Beam spinner>lilypad>Skipping stone>current>gobling>elevatorB tier>pull girl>the normal sokoban characters >druid>bard>Rod>Cyan beam>wrapping>non-magic mirrorC tier>Orange beam>dark blue beam>vanilla mirror>mirrorable mirrors
I never thought I'd have to write pseudocdoe to solve a sokobon puzzleif on: place if 0 crystals or 2 crystals keep on if 1 or 2 crystalsif off: turn on if 2 crystals place if 1 crystal what a cool section
>>751640878you can see the single exit from the start and you're explicitly not allowed to kill any guys
I got to the second level after credits but I still have parts of the map fogged out that I have tried but couldn't find ways to access. Will they unlock where I am playing or do I need to go back and search the overworld closer?
>>751641219>crystal guy>a-tierI think I know who wrote this. Detected any pocket sizes lately?
>>751641824I think you can access all of those at this point. You may need to drop down from the ascended map to get to some fog sections in the other.
>>751642123As in I need to go down from certain spots to clear the fog?
>>751641219Are Mirror Man and Boat Girl the most useless characters? They can't do anything except push and Push Hero Chad can push better. At least Cave Man can pick up gems which is unique to him.
>>751643286Yeah, the drop-down spots look like the silver platform in this screenshot.
>>751643406>can't even turn
>>751643686
>>751643686kekHe is pretty useless but at least he can do something the others can't. You could replace Mirror and Stone characters and not lose anything. Pure redundant characters.
>>751607438What is this game and why does it keep appearing on the board even though I've literally never heard of it?
>>751643876Puzzle game made by the guy behind Braid and The Witness. Has a ton of reviews on Steam, which is surprising for what should be a niche game.
>>751643876It's an indie puzzle game that came out 2 months ago so not a lot of marketing or mass appeal and time for much word of mouth to make it big and famous.Made by Jonathan Blow who made the Witness so it gets some traction though. Fun if you like puzzles. Journalists gave the puzzle game negative reviews for having too many puzzles so that's a good sign of quality.
lost literally all interest when blow started blowing himself for being a video-game developer in the third world.
I'm not designing the game for you, pal.
> endless skipping> if you get the rock endlessly skipping it still never quite lines up with the buttonis this a "think different" puzzle or a "time your shit better slowpoke" puzzle
You guys find cheese solutions to any puzzles? I had one where you do a mirror/stones puzzle without using any mirrors and a beam puzzle where you ignore 2 of the beams
>>751649386This one was so easy to cheese I don't know how they didn't catch it. There was also one puzzle where I brute forced it with cloning stones.>>751649224There is some timing involved, but it sounds like you also need to think differently.
>>751649386There was one big water puzzle with two mirrors and a skipping stone. I cloned 100 stones with the two mirror trick and filled the giant ocean and walked to the end.I also did one without using a lilypad
My gripe with this game is that I solve some really tricky puzzles right away but then get stuck on ones that are the equivalent to a trick question of a quiz for half an hour
So the only way to make it go up or down is to move a stone onto it. Once this is done it can never be moved in the other direction as it has to bank for the stone to be removed and be able to accept another. It is also not possible to get a stone onto it from above, even with the tightest timing and a clone positioned to intercept the stone sent from below, it moves to the side too fast. Therefore, the only way to get the lilypad to go down at all sacrifices both stones, as you need to make it go to the side a generous amount then come back in time to be sent down. The two mirrors seem like they can't have any purpose other than to clone the player, since the only other unique function would be to place the player on the lilypad from the top island, which is useless given the obvious function of the lilypad as a bridge at the end.
>>751650586>It is also not possible to get a stone onto it from aboveWrong>it moves to the side too fastBelieve it or not, there is a way to get a stone up there and in a recoverable position without affecting the lily pad's movement. Think about the mechanics of lily pad skip pushing.
>>751650586>It is also not possible to get a stone onto it from above
>>751650860They never do
>>751650586I don't even know what the proper solution is to this one. I did it prepatch and it required 3 copies of the sailors in very specific locations and movement perfect timing. it's not possible anymore since some of the tiles I needed are covered up
>>751652046Looks possible to me.
holy shit these levels are so excruciatingly long I wish I wasn't being held hostage here
>>751650556> spent 2 hours on this puzzle because I'm retarded but not quite retarded enough
>>751653630I really liked most of these big beam puzzles but the layer 3 one where all the areas are mostly seperated by a gap is paralyzing me because I feel like some of the solutions involve knocking beams off the edge but I worry I might need them later and don't have enough brain to keep track of everything.
>>751654065Just trust the plan, it'll all work out. Unless you toss the wrong beam.
>>751653943this one is devilish
>>751650556>>751653943I used a guide 6 or 7 times so far (750 puzzles in). 2 were actual difficult puzzles that had plenty of false leads but the rest were all this kinda shit where it's mental RNG whether you see the trick in 5 seconds or 2 hoursthe actual difficult ones were1. a stacked skipping stone puzzle that I found over 5 completely unrelated approached that are 1 tile off from solving the puzzle2. a puzzle that expected you to figure out a new interaction wizard teleporting skipping stones while over water on a cleric platform in the middle of an already complex puzzle with expensive setups
I 100%'ed the game in 160 hours, it makes me feel pretty stupid seeing all those 110-130h completion times. Though to be fair to myself I played for 12h a day for two weeks right after release, so not having many breaks between puzzles contributing to my playtime is going to be my cope going forward.
>>751650586Miracle is going in my official report!
>>751641326Anon, that's just a full adder. You don't need pseudocode once you realize that the 3rd button does.
>>751650586This level is annoying since it doesn't follow the theme of the area its in. You don't need to reflect across multiple mirrors.
>>751656892>B-but others did it fasterWho cares, man. You won! You beat the game.Show me the puzzle they could solve that you couldn't.It simply does not exist.
I feel a bit disappointed having had hints to two puzzles,world 3 warrior alter-beam one where the solution is BUILD A BRIDGE not too pissed about that one since it's a copoutand warrior priestess goblin on the floating platform with the button on a pillar to the left, I got a hint saying "duplicate the priestess"For the latter, how was I supposed to know that one priestess can float while the other is protecting through the fence, and she can keep floating even if not next to the other one? How does that mechanic even work and how was I meant to figure it out?
>>751656892Comparing clear times for puzzle games is stupid.As long as you beat it yourself and didn't look up solutions/ hints you won just as much as everyone else who did.The way people's brain's are wired there will always be things that are easier or harder for you in these games. Something that was an immediately obvious 10 second solve to you will have kept someone else racking their brain for hours and vice versa.
>>751661967I thought that clone protection sharing was already explained. I just blocked one of the clones between 2 mirror, the goblin, and the warrior and freely walked with the other one.
>>751662050Yeah that's what I wanted to know. Where was this done beforehand? Somewhere in world 2?You, just now, made me realise how it worked, because they are clones they share protection status. I can only remember puzzles with brown haired priestess, so I was very confused as to why two of them got the same protection if they are separate...
>>751661967You stumble into it. That's what I did. I didn't get any hints and got pretty annoyed when I found the interaction. Not the best puzzle.
>>751662640Not really that upset I got spoiled since the two I listed sound annoying as hell, would not be a satisfying solution. There's no logic to that. I was thinking of pushing the goblin, or maybe a line of priestess copies.If I were to design an introduction puzzle, it would force the player to mirror the priestess in a position which puts one clone in danger from a dragon, but the other not (but above water/pit), showing this interaction, and then a more advanced puzzle)
For someone who just did Heroes 3, everything posted in this thread scares the shit out of me.
>>751664983A tip: 99% of things you see in a puzzle have to be used in some way. Think you can solve it without that block? No. Why is there space to move something over there? Something needs to be moved there.
>>751665257Thanks, this has definitely been true so far. A question I had: How does the difficulty progress in this game? Of course characters are different and new interactions are introduced, but does it get notably harder over time?
>>751665509I'm on the final section of the game. It definitely gets more hard, but the most important things are to remember that rule I said but also the other sokoban technique, always work backwards from the solution. I feel like my initial fear of the new mechanics evolved into understanding what's needed, which usually makes the sequential puzzles easier.However sometimes things are NOT made clear, requiring you to do something which hasn't been hinted at before, which is kind of annoying.