Which is the best Cyberpunk RPG?
>>751616060Cyberpunk 2077 is neither cyberpunk or an RPG so Deus Ex wins by default
>>751616128trying too hard
>>751616060i like both. i never got around to the sequels to deus ex though
>>751616060Cyberpunk 2077 is more fun so Cyberpunk wins :)
>>751616060these are both first person shootersshadowrun hong kong
>>751616060its kinda funny how dude sex manages to be the better RPG, despite ostensibly containing far less RPG mechanics than cyberpunkcyberpunks biggest issue is that they spent all that time and money developing a pretty interesting looking world. and then somehow forgot wtf they were even supposed to be doing making an open world RPG and decided to make an extremely fucking linear, story driven singleplayer campaign that you cant even rly opt out of. the fact that there wasnt just a sandbox mode on release is just baffling to me. tf do they think ppl even play these games for?by contrast, dude sex is maybe even more linear, but somehow manages to give far more choices, with far more impactful results, than anything CDPR managed with all their gorillions of dollars
>>751616060Cyberpunk is more of an RPG and more cyberpunk than Deus Ex.That said, Deus Ex is a much better written and streamlined experience.
>>751616060Deus Ex, obviously. HR and MD are better too. I still like Cyberpunk well enough though.
>>751616418they should have released a sequel by now if you ask meall the work they put into the world, to never properly use it again and when they ultimately do its going to be UE5 slop
>>751616565Have you ever played an RPG?
>>751616060Only one of those is a cyberpunk RPG, and its Deus Ex.
>>751616060never played CP 2077 but Doose Sex isn't a RPG
>>751616128DX is barely an RPG too.
>>751616060Out of the two probably Deus Ex. But Shadowrun Dragonfall I think overall is the best RPG in this genre.
>>751616767Immersive sims have more Role-playing DNA than whatever Cyberpunk 2077 ended up being.
>>751616854your mom's pussy has more DNA than whatever you ended up being
>>751616684yea its actually fucking crazyidk who tf is in charge of all these big studios, and i dont rly care tbpfh, but holy shit do those retards leave soooo much money on the table. all the fucking time too. like how has no one made a pirate game since asscreed 4? wtf is anyone even doing? just shitting their pants?
>>751616908bodied that freak lmao
>>751616684>they should have released a sequel by now if you ask meThey spent 3 years fixing the game because it was broken as fuck. There was no releasing a sequel in the first place. You turdworlders and Gen A fucks are retarded as shit
mancy
>>751616565Cyberpunk by definition is a power shift marked by technology to make the rich richer and the poor even more destitute.Deus Ex explored the rising power if the information age and how a group of select could manipulqte waorld events through media, falseflag operations, scarcity manipulation etc. (oy vey).CP2077 asks "what if GTA with neon lights?"
cp2077 is world/city (night city) isn't really a convincing cyberpunk city to me even if there's neon and ads everywhere
>One of the best games ever vs open world slopI genuinely think I'm a better human being than anyone that thinks CP2077 is better.
>>751616060Cyberpunk. It's a flawed masterpiece. Like a shit covered diamond.
>>751617032I mean, what WASN'T that game?
>>751616691Why yes, I did! And are you aware that big choices and such don't make an RPG?In the past, RPG were entirely linear experiences, hell even some actual modules from the original D&D didn't give players much choices in how the narrative shaped up. On the other hand, there are numerous games that have nothing to do with RPGs that do feature branching storylines and "big choices".
>>751616060Cyberpunk if you want an open world shooter with rpg elements. Deus Ex if you want an immersive sim with rpg elements.
>>751617056Aesthetic vs themes.Aesthetic wise, Cyberpunk is closer, but Deus Ex does explore its themes with much more nuance and care, it's part of why I said it's much better written.
>you have the power to choose moving at sonic speed, moon jumping, and sneaking (0% noise) at sonic speed too>OR>walk quietly>do super extra powerful melee attacks>OR>move boxes that are blocking stuff 2 times in the adventure>you can do things the thoughtful, time-consuming and sneaky way and Carter will give you his pocket lint and a tiny handful of bonus ammo, while every soldier insults you, and still having all the captured soldiers get murdered by UNATCO anyway>OR>you can be mean to terrorists a littleStarting to wonder what I liked so much about this
>>751617063Why? Designing Night City so that it has that typical look and feel of classic cyberpunk is one of the better realized aspects of Cyberpunk 2077, even if it pays for that by having very little environment variety.
Deus Ex effortlessly mogs Cyberjunk.NO LAW has a chance of being the CP2077 I wanted.
>>751617461I wasn't expecting something this small. but might be my expectations were too high
>>751617608there's also this upcoming cyberpunk game named neoberlin something
>>751617302I left the courtyard of Castle Clinton a graveyard. Anna Navarra romance option when
>>751617615Cyberpunk map is already pretty massive and, honestly, bloated.Making it even bigger, while I may agree it would certainly fit the cyberpunk themes better, would have exacerbated some of its problems even more.
>>751616060It's kinda crazy that these two games are 20 years apart in release dates. Interesting to see how this genre has evolved
>>751617615>Expecting a city rebuilt after a nuclear bombing and years of radioactive and localized environmental apocalypse shit to be as massive as it once was.
>>751616974I dont why but developing a game has to be atleast 5 years nowback then youd get a sequel in 2 years tops, it was the same engine, it looked simmilar sure but it was a new game with improved gameplay and of course new storynow they need 10 years to remaster a game from 30 years ago
>>751616349>Orcs>ElvesFantasy, not Cyberpunk
>>751617852>>751617762not the game's problem, just me as I said
>>751616128>Cyberpunk 2077 is neither cyberpunkfucking this, it's some spiritual tarot mumbo jumbo with random wires tattooed on people
>>751618019>he thinks shadowrun isn't cyberpunk because it has orcs and elves
>>751618019It's both obviously. Just like how Arcanum is both Fantasy and Steampunk.
>>751617302Don't forget that UNATCO tortures the terrorists THEN executes them.
>>751616060>Uncslop vs Zoomkino
>>751616060Deus Ex probably but I haven't played past the fourth mission cause I keep restarting to try a different skill build.
>>751617871a lot of it has to do with gfxback when shit was all low-poly models and compressed textures and crap, you had other considerations, like not making everything crash or look totally fucked or whatever. but when it came to small details, like animating a cutscene? there was a much more laid back culture of getting it "close enough". the gfx were often shit enough that details like that just didnt matter that much. it wouldnt even stick out that much even if you DID fuck upbut now? the more realism you throw on top, the less you can get away with just gud enuffing it. think about the effort that has to go into any cutscene or dialogue exchange, where one character hands an item or something to another. you gotta do all those animations, sync the item to those animations, sync the VA lines with the characters lips, fix the lighting cuz now it looks retarded from this angle, oh shit now THIS guys out of the frame, gotta redo the whole fucking thing again goddamnit. and then it proceeds on from there, with small teams of several ppl working together for a week to get one fucking scene done. and when its done? itll probably look rly good. the problem is you now have to do that again with the entire rest of the game. the obv solution is just hire more grunts to work in tandem to lower dev time. but that costs a lot and bloats out the project budget. and as weve seen, without a rly strong lead keeping tabs on what everyone is doing under him, that can lead to its own problems
>>751616060Cyberpunk 2 Orion hopefully
>/v/ hates Ubislop but loves Cyberpunk 2077Why? The NCPD jobs are just bandit camps.
>>751617032Is it true theres a second game in the making?
>>751619181cyberpunk lets them romance women and/or play dressup as a woman
>>751616060Deus Ex both as an RPG and just as a game
>>751619356You can literally do that in AC games
>>751619181The issue with ubisoft games wasn't conceptual it was their dogshit business practices, laziness, lack of polish, invasive launchers, shitty repetitive gameplay, and lowest common denominator handholding difficulty.
>>7516199501nd they (ubisoft) still do dogshit games? why people keep buying ubishit games??
>>751616060Porch monkey, did you just compare the masterpiece that was Deus Ex with Cyberjunk?
>>751619216Daimon Blades, but it's roguelike early access unreal engine shite
>>751620569Wow this looks fucking terrible
>>751620304Because normies don't get bothered by shitty business practices as long as they're mildly entertained by new thing. It's a pretty big reason everything is so shit these days across several industries.
>>751620569huuuuh are you sure it was another game and not deamon blaide??
>>751616060
>>751620665Yeah eye was a lucky lightning in a bottleAlthough negrobunda hired gun and space hulk deathwing aren't half bad>>751620727Hmmmm I don't know of another project from them but maybe I've missed some news
>>751616060Idk I haven't played either but the cover for deus ex looks cooler
What the fuck even is an RPG? Everyone seems to have their own definition of what that means. These are two completely different games with entirely different goals.
>>751620878well ask D&D. they invented it
>>751620878When a game has character builds, stats, progression, and is set in some kind of interactable world or something like that I don't fucking know dude
>>751620878It's because there are 2 major camps of meaning when it gets brought up. One is in regards to narratives where people want to roleplay dialogue options and make up aspects to their character in their head that the game vaguely affirms by giving assorted dialogue aligned to their imagination. Personally I always found this very shallow and overhyped by certain peopleThe other is in regard to gameplay where your choices effect the way you play and how you complete missions in the game based on a "build". CP sort of has this the issue is that it very heavily rewards a "Generalists" who dips into most attributes a little bit instead of demanding and rewarding specialization. The issue is that the map design and enemy AI don't provide much challenge though so despite potentially offering four distinct playstyles replays sort of just melt together.
>>751616060Deus Ex for sure but you'll get fags arguing about RPG vs "immersive sim". It's an RPG. Ain't nobody used no fucking "immersive sim" language when it was released you dumb shits.
>>751616060System Shock 2 mogs both
>>751621685>Deus Ex for sure but you'll get fags arguing about RPG vs "immersive sim". It's an RPG.If Deus Ex is an rpg Far Cry is 3 is too.
>>751621423They should contain a non-insignificant amount of core elements from TTRPGs. Just having loot, stats, and arbitrary dialogue choices are not enough.
>>751616060Nah
>>751616060HR and MD mog both
>>751622496Most TTRPG mechanics exist to simulate a real time event within a turn based system that needs to be tracked by a human with a pen and paper. Videogames don't need a lot if those elements they can just simulate the experience itself in real time, but instead the genre holds onto a lot of elements for the sake of seeming more like an RPG instead of focusing on immersion and fun.Like it's dumb CP2077 has damage numbers and health bars it should just fully simulate the experience if braining a Maelstromer's skull pan eith a .45ap
>>751623363Powerful take
>>751623909What you just described is far closer to how it works in the Cyberpunk 2020 TTRPG
>>751624276Well no, that system still relies on numbers and is turnbased it's just that the numbers and systems are tuned for high lethality if you don't take advantage of systems to keep your dudes alive.My issue is more just raw presentation and feeling. RPGs are always trying to emulate elements of older RPGs instead of pursuing the immersion elements those original RPGs would have killed for the ability to simulate. It's really quite silly. There is of course a niche for "I want to play a TTRPG" but CP2077 clearly isn't chasing that goal, yes it sticks to a highlights primitive sim elements because it needs to in order to market itself as an "RPG"
>>751616128>not an rpgThen WHAT THE FUCK IS?!!!You retards say this about EVERY game! Fuck!
It's the SEGA Genesis Shadowrun.
>>751624834Shockingly, most games aren't rpgs.
>>751623909Action mechanics are from wargaming, the predecessor. TTRPGs add taking on the role of a character and acting as if you were them.
>>751623909>instead of focusing on immersion and fun.Hm?
Whichever one let's me have a rocket punch.
>>751623909Actually kinda true, I get what you mean
>>751616060Deus Ex. As much as I love 2077, Deus Ex beats it due to a more thoughtful and coherent plotline, and they did it without swearing every second word - it had a greater impact on me years afterwards than 2077 did, and I remember it fondly. Hot dogshit to play though. 2077 is still great, and has better characters too.With that being said, that's "the best cyberpunk rpg" between the two. If you asked me which is the more FUN cyberpunk rpg between the two, 2077 leaves Deus Ex smoldering on the floor.>>751616128/v/ contrarianism at its finest. You're a retard
>>751616060I'd say probably Deus Ex despite the fact that it's a more linear game
>>751624723>>751624723I feel like something you're not considering is how the turn-based nature of TTRPGs naturally results in the player(s) having to make well considered, tactical decisions. The consequence of failure is generally far greater in TTRPGs than in >90% of games. I don't think its logical to say that in order to be a true RPG you need to have permadeath for instance, but there should be a middle ground that respects TTRPGs mechanically and doesn't dilute them to the level that CP2077 does.
>>751616060Cyberpunk 2077 is pretty close to its inspiration which is Neuromancer even some of its story beats are quite similar down to the protagonist(Case) from Neuromancer discovering an rogue AI on an artifact that attempts to hi-jack his life.
>>751625868My argument hasn't been over what a true RPG is it's been a critique on the nature of the ARPG genre. The extent to which you have to be careful and think ahead in a TTRPG can be carried over to ARPGs by directly simulating the elements the TTRPG creates in the abstract. You could make an action game that captures the lethality of 2020 by upping the damage output of enemies and the potential effects of injury to be more like Stalker or a similar more "hardcore" game.
>>751616128Bait used to be believable.
>>751626484Wintermute was based though and gave Case everything promised. Johnny is a cringe body snatcher
guys I'm about to finish cyberpunk, which ending should I get?>the one where you die>the one where you die by suicide>the one where you die in a suicide mission>the one where you die eventually>the one where you die metaphorically
>>751626748Dude hasn't figured out the major theme of the game is coming to terms with the inevitable yet
>>751626484Case doesn't find Wintermute, Wintermute finds Case and then subsequently makes a Faustian bargain with him. What artifact?
>>751626748>Game has a theme and narrative>Anons get angryNo wonder the term "media literacy" drove this place into such hysterics
>>751626748https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZ8yN5BiEIo
>>751626854So it's a cuck game.
>>751617063they designed it more like a theme park than a cityconsequences of modular construction, everything looks the same with no real architectural style. an abandoned shack in the desert is made from the same stuff as a brand new corpo tower
>>751627028>Persona 3 is a cuck game because you die at the end
>>751627028bruh
>>751626910people don't like a lack of agency, especially in RPGssame case with sacrifice in fallout 3
>>751616060>old gay shit vs new cool shithmmmmmmmmmm
>>751616060play both these arent comparable experiences cyberpunk on the nintendo switch 2 with motion controls was very fun.
>>751627104I think they call it "NTR" over there.
>>751626565Kek
>>751627186No? Fallout 3's forced sacrifice is bad because there's no narrative reason why anyone has to die. It is not the same as you dying from the chip and then choosing how you die.
>>751627028i know its wrong, but it makes me happy knowing you dont actually enjoy anything
>>751616060Deus Ex is vastly superior in every way, because the Cyberpunk setting is retarded.In Deus Ex, society still cherishes humanity and highly augmented humans are considered outcasts. In Cyberpunk, everyone including their grandma has a cybernetic butthole for shits and giggles.
>>751627393you lack media literacy
>>751616060Deus Ex. The world just feels a lot more interesting to learn about. Cyberpunk just kind of feels 2026 but instead of tattoos everyone has cybernetics.
>>751627079is it that why I felt that emptiness when I look at the city. there's a je ne sais quoi that make the city feel not right to me
>>751628162Deus Ex also feels like 2026 desu
>>751627028This but unironically.
>>751617032My legs are OK
>>751616060deus ex is vastly more interesting
>>751626748>malding over FO3 againkek you faggots are pathetic.
>>751619216Yes.
>>751630015nice can't wait to gain brouzouf
>>751616060Deus Ex is one of the greatest games of all time. Cyberpunk is normalfag trash for the kind of people who are excited about GTA6.
>>751630215
>>751630474>popular = normalfag trash
>>751616060Only one of those games is an RPG.
>>751627484>In Cyberpunk, everyone including their grandma has a cybernetic butthole for shits and giggles.Damn anon, if you had any comprehension skills, you would understand why
>>751620665daimon blades is a blatant cash grab to get money to maybe make EYE2. they should have just done a kickstarter.
>>751630474When did I say that?
>>751620475>masterpiece>game only sometimes reacts to your choices, halfway in it stops reacting entirely>plot is just every 80s/90s conspiracy theory shoved into the game and played totally straight (only tolerated because the average fan is was too young to know about these conspiracies and DX was most likely their first exposure to them)>pistol is objectively the best weapon>several worthless skills>stealth is comically easy>no mantling so platforming sucks ass>every non-plot character sounds like a beatnik reading excerpts from a book>combat is trash because enemy AI is too predictable, you just hold a corner and shoot heads as they run through
>>751616128Got the troons mad with this truth
>>751616060You're looking at it
>>751622425That's not even English and I agree with it.
>>751616060Don't mind me, just posting the best Cyberpunk JRPG, SMT 2
>>751633846>>no mantling so platforming sucks assGMDX
>>751634170mods don't count and you know it.
>>751627409>dude I heckin LOVE being railroaded into miserable endings in my vidya while pretentious midwits claim its the deepest shit ever
>>751634219Is it because cybercope doesn't have any good ones?
>>751633342Explain it then. I'd like to see you make a fool of yourself, retard.
>>751634228>dude i heckin LOVE pointing out when someone likes something more than they should!>i was bullied in school so that means i have to bully everyone i see whos acting up!>this makes me feel like the bullying i got as a kid meant something and wasn't just youthful cruelty!
>>7516160602077 is a more coherent and satisfying experience but deus ex is a way more memorable one
>>751616908destroyed that troglodyte
>>751624834fps with an upgrade shop?
>>751633507for>>751633251
Cyberpunk because I didn't read any of the emails there, reading emails is the worst gameplay genre there is.
>>751616128Hm idk maybe
>>751616128I hate posers.Kill yourself
>>751616060Deus Ex. Not because I love it but Cyberpunk 2077 is just a really mediocre game.
>>751616128/thread
>>751616060Human Revolution.
>>751627484The people with augments were actually in vogue before the Illuminati did the biochip bullshit and Darrow caused those with augs to go berserk