[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1764271040679169.png (2.43 MB, 1137x1350)
2.43 MB PNG
These are the best games ever made according to people who actually play them on a regular basis.
If you didn't play at least half of them then you should refrain from positing opinions about vidya on this website.
>>
Saying a game is the greatest of all time when it's only been out for less than a year should permaban you from whatever website you share such a shitty opinion on
>>
I'm a normalfag and have played most of these
>>
>>751619981
I don't see an argument in your post. thus manifesting your low IQ.
When Brothers Karamazov dropped nobody had to wait one year before calling it a masterpiece of literature, what an absurd and completely arbitrary requirement. The arrogance if off the charts.
>>
>>751619871
OoT shouldn't be on there purely by virtue of the fact that it's a remake. No remake of anything should ever be a replacement of the original, nonetheless be placed on a top 30 list
>>
>>751619871
>These are the best games ever made according to people who watch their favorite streamer play them on a regular basis.
FTFY
>>
>>751619871
What a fucking garbage list. These people just accept race to the bottom quality tier games. Wow. This is an actual terrible list
>>
>>751620361
>OoT shouldn't be on there purely by virtue of the fact that it's a remake
Irrelevant. A remake is a standalone game, there's no reason why it should be excluded.
>>751620370
>>751620446
>no arguments, just lashing out at an objectively correct list or the people who made it without presenting any reasoning of why supposedly it's wrong
Secondary tourists and frauds in gaming get exposed so easily.
>>
I use Backloggd more than I should and
>people who actually play [games] on a regular basis
isn't really how I'd describe it. It's also probably worth noting that the average ratings tend to differ from what people actually vote for as the best when GOTY votes come around. e.g. Astro Bot didn't win anything in 2024 despite having the highest average rating for a game released that year (Metaphor got the GOTY instead iirc), RE4make didn't win anything in 2023 whereas games with lower average ratings than it did, etc
>>
>>751620361
The new ocarina of time is more like a directors cut where nintendo gets to release the game they envisioned but couldnt release back in the 90s
>>
>>751620361
OoT shouldn't be on there are all 3d Zelda is fucking garbage. And there's like rows worth on that matrix. Gamers who believe they have 'taste' are all confirmist sheep that think pressing crates into proper formation is the height of gaming. I can't understand the amount of brainwashing on Nintendo kids in the 90s that caused this to happen.
>>
>>751619871
There's a huge recency bias on half this list. In a decade nobody will talk about most of those games.
Most of the rest are the 'I'm legally obligated to include these in a top games list'
>two versions of Ocarina of Time
lol, lmao. Might as well make a list out of every version of Skyrim
>>
>>751619871
zoomers have awful taste, holy shit
>>
>>751620703
>There's a huge recency bias on half this list.
Nothing wrong with that, since games are tied to technological progress is it really surprising that pixel dogshit from the 90s doesn't make the cut, while polished games with modern features are all there?
>In a decade nobody will talk about most of those games.
Irrelevant.
>Most of the rest are the 'I'm legally obligated to include these in a top games list'
Projection.
>two versions of Ocarina of Time
Yeah, thus dismissing the claim that a remake shouldn't be there. Games are evaluated individually without considering if it's a remake or not. What's wrong with that?
>Might as well make a list out of every version of Skyrim
And zero versions of skyrim are present here.
Dismissed.
>>751620906
Backloggd has a younger userbase which makes the list even more objective, they have no nostalgia or bias towards old games therefore only the best games that have aged well can be selected. You are literally confirming why the list is actually correct.
>>
>OoT remake
Having a remake as the best game of all time is genuinely laughable. Retarded recency bias behavior, especially when the remake virtually stays extremely faithful to the original.
>RDR2
Dogshit writing. Meh gameplay. Forgettable characters.
>BG3
See above
>MGS3
Fair.
>SH2
Fair.
>AC8
contrived shitty sequel that misses the mark in both gameplay and story.
>Mother 3
Garbage writing and dialogue. Bad gameplay.
>E33
I think that it's a decent game, but it should be nowhere near a top list.
>KCD2
Game that literally calls you a goy LMAO
>Elden Ring
Fair.
>Bloodborne
Fair.
>Last of us Part 1
A worser version of an already meh game with poor and forgettable writing
>MGS2
Should be way higher desu.
>Sekiro
Good but not one of the best games of all time.
>RE4make
A masterfully made game but still a remake that all in all is worse than the original.

tl;dr the (people) who made this list are genuinely retarded
>>
File: 3x3.png (422 KB, 760x596)
422 KB PNG
>>
>>751621158
Better taste than the OP image (except TTYD which is insanely overrated)
>>
>>751621052
>which makes the list even more objective
except for the egregious recency bias? zoomers think everything new is "peak" and won't touch things that are "old" or untrendy
>>
>>751619871
>No Persona or Metaphor
Fake list, fake gamer.
>>
It's amazing how there's only one game here I'd even consider putting in a top 10 list, and it's MGS2. Even then, it's probably only a top 20 game.

So much fucking trash here it's insane.
>>
>>751621052
>Nothing wrong with that
Everything is wrong with that, it means the list is just social talking points rather than objective criticisms of what the games contain.
If you had a film list and the majority of it was from 2018-2026 people would think you just recently discovered films. Things don't magically get better as the years pass, they just get different. Something made in 1990 has as much a chance of being a truly inspired piece of workmanship as something made in 2020
>>
>>751621136
>>Elden Ring
>Fair.
Sorry, you're as retarded as the people who rated the rest of the slop on this list highly.

ER is literally the second worst nu-From game, after DS2. It's obscenely poor, and Sekiro is 10x better despite being a very dumbed down souls game.
>>
>>751621469
I never said that I enjoyed it, but you can't deny it's objective quality in terms of evolution and general world design. It is masterfully made in those regards.
>He thinks that ER is worse than DS3
Everybody point and laugh
>>
>>751621272
>The people who called TBK a masterpiece when it dropped have recency bias! They didn't go through centuries of literature before that!
Again, sounds absurd, I'm sorry but this is just how cultural artifacts are getting evalutated. Only the best gets passed on.
By your logic to make the list valid someone needs to make a time machine and release the switch 2 remake 20 years ago just to make (You) happy.
You have zero arguments for why it actually shouldn't be rated that highly since you likely didn't even play it.
>zoomers think everything new is "peak"
You are projecting and making up a strawman. No, not all zoomers think like that, and it's irrelevant to the discussion.
>and won't touch things that are "old" or untrendy
Which is, once again, dismissed by the fact that old games are present there. I'm sorry that your favorite uncslop didn't make the cut, but the list is as objective as it gets.
Will it look the same in 10 or 20 years? Maybe, maybe not. You are lashing out at something that doesn't really matter.
>>751621384
>Everything is wrong with that
That's like saying nothing.
>it means the list is just social talking points
Not an argument.
>ather than objective criticisms of what the games contain.
It is objective.
>If you had a film list and the majority of it was from 2018-2026 people would think you just recently discovered films.
Which is why most movie lists are not like this, you can easily watch a silent black and white movie and the experience wouldn't be so different than if you were watching a modern movie. The same can't be said about games.
>Things don't magically get better as the years pass
Which is exactly what happens with video games, that are directly tied to technological progress and improvements in hardware.
>Something made in 1990 has as much a chance of being a truly inspired piece of workmanship
Exactly, which is why old games are in that list, clearly the majority of which don't make the cut.
>>
>>751621357
Would you mind sharing your top 10? I'm genuinely curious because I personally would say that MGS2 is a top 3 game
>>
>>751621623
It's garbage. The world design is 90% auto-gen slop and the fundamental issues with such a design aren't even recognised by the game.

Any game where you can take the wrong turn and wind up having to come back to an area later after you're massively overlevelled for it is atrocious. Sekiro is the best souls game because of how simplistic it was in terms of scope, without things like builds or different weapons they were able to actually craft a cohesive experience for once. Open world is the exact opposite of what FromSoft should've been aiming for.
>>
>>751621810
Have you ever considered formatting a paragraph instead of responding to each sentence or phrase individually? It helps make it seem like you have an actual stance instead of just wanting to argue for arguments sake
>>
>>751621812
Electrosphere (JP)
Virtua Cop 2
Void Stranger
Deus Ex
Planescape Torment
Linda Cubed
Sakura Wars 2
Timesplitters 2
Densha De Go pro 2
MGS2

I haven't really thought about it that much though. MGS2 would probably drop a few places if I did.
>>
>>751622105
>Have you ever considered formatting a paragraph instead of responding to each sentence or phrase individually?
I'm exclusively addressing the actually relevant parts for the discussion, leaving ad parsonam attacks and other irrelevant bs out.
Instead of latching to the formatting of the post try to address any of the claims for once, and if you want to go the extra mile then keep your feelings to yourself as nobody is really interested in them.
>>
>>751622246
>Sakura 2
>Densha 2

No shit? I thought I was the only one who ever put Sakura on my 3X3. I managed to get Densha 2 a year ago and going back to it after PS4 Final felt pretty clunky. It also felt like the physics weren't nearly as precise. Man, why did Taito have to take the AC game offline.
>>
>>751621810
You sound like a faggot. You need to form your own opinions instead of being so obsessed with lists and consensus.
>>
>>751622581
>You sound like a faggot
Ad personam, no arguments whatsoever.
>You need to form your own opinions instead
This is irrelevant to the discussion but I do form my own opinions, and regardless of my opinions when someone mentions TBK or a video game equivalent you have to simply accept it as a masterpiece. Once again your feelings are irrelevant to the discussion.
>instead of being so obsessed with lists
I'm simply presenting a fact, doesn't mean that I'm obsessed with it (another projection btw).
>and consensus.
See above.
>>
>>751619871
rogert ebert was right. videogames are not art. look at this list lol. or maybe vidya enjoyers are just dumber. compare it to the letterboxd top list. it's night and day.
>>
>>751622482
I played the newer DdG game for about 30 minutes, it didn't feel fun and seemed more streamlined for modern kids instead of the nail-biting action of the older games.
>>
>>751622297
Alright let's use your format
>leaving ad parsonam attacks out
You eagerly accuse others of projecting
>try addressing the claims for once
Go back and take a shot every time your rebuttal is just 'not an argument', 'dismissed', or 'what about it?'
>keep your feelings to yourself
'What about it?' How about you include your feelings? Have an opinion, enjoy that other anons have opinions too even if we disagree
>>
File: 1770596117231429.png (1.31 MB, 612x1354)
1.31 MB PNG
>>751622867
>compare it to the letterboxd top list
What about it?
>>
>last of us
movieslop
>oot
uncannyslop
>eldenring
asset flip of every previous soulsborne, reuses bosses and enemies, lackluster unique endings
>re4
yellowpaintslop
>astrobot
little big planet clears this
>kingdom come deliverance 2
nobody even talks about this lmao
>disco elysium
politicslop
>baldurs gate 3
dialogueslop
>silksong
faded into obscurity after slay the spire 2 came out, should have picked the original
>ace attorney
would be valid if you picked the right version
>deltarune
pixelslop

most of the new entries in your shit list are just referential and has no leg to stand on. it's built by someone who only looks at how many people are playing a game and wants to placate the need to fit in. in summary, it's cringe.
>>
>>751622246
Interesting list. Thanks anon
>>
>>751623126
At least Harakiri is a great flick. The rest of the list is slop.
>>
>>751623227
>The rest of the list is slop.
you've never seen 90% of it, who are you trying to impress?
>>
File: 1788206305834270.jpg (64 KB, 602x709)
64 KB JPG
>>751620104
>Brothers Karamazov
>masterpiece
>>
>>751623281
I've seen half of it, and the half I've watched has been mediocre at best. I'd rate master and commander above all that shit.
>>
>>751623364
ok. whatever you say.
>>
>>751623061
>No you
Great start.
>not an argument
Present an argument then, otherwise I will just call it what it is.
>dismissed
Self-explanatory.
>what about it?
Just don't go on tangets completely unrelated to the topic, it's very easy.
>How about you include your feelings?
Your or mine feelings are irrelevant to the discussion, as I already explained. It's irrelevant whether you agree with the list or not, it's irrelevant what you personally think about TBK (if video games are too hard to understand then let's use another example), you are simply presented with a fact and nobody has asked your personal opinion. Keep your subjective judgement to yourself.
>>
>best GAMES of all time
>look inside
>majority of them are praised exclusively for their story
>>
Gen Z got obsessed with media rating sites during covid and now every new popular thing gets spammed with perfect scores.
>>
>>751619871
>If you didn't play at least half of them then you should refrain from positing opinions about vidya on this website.
Why?
>>
>>751624932
Because you are not equipped to formulate opinions that go beyond "I like it/I don't like it". Play more games.
>>
>>751625695
>Because you are not equipped to formulate opinions that go beyond "I like it/I don't like it"
Can't the same thing apply to the people whose ratings contributed to OP's list?
>>
>>751619871
Demake - No
Trails SC R - Excellent game, but original is better so it doesn't deserve it
RDR2 - Rockstar has never made a good game
BG3 - Divinity 3 with a BG skin
MGS3 - Worse than 2 in every way
SH2 - Not even a top 10 PS2 horror game
Ace Combat - Hasn't had a bad game so this is okay
Outer Wilds - Myst in space, its fine
Mother 3 - Obviously excellent but requires EarthBound knowledge and it's not here so i call bullshit
E33 - Baby's first RPG no
Disco - Its acceptable sure
KCD2 - No open world game has ever been good
Elden Ring - No open world game has ever been good
Ace Attorney - Inoffensive so fine
HL Alyx - VR shit is a meme
Bloodborne - Acceptable good game
Chrono Trigger - Square made a better RPG literally the previous year to this and so did Sega, hugely overhyped
TLOU - One of the most overrated games ever made, does nothing well, Naughty Dog made 7 better games than this on the PS1 and PS2 alone.
Hollow Knight - For redditors, its trash
Deltarune - /v/ core game, i'll allow it
MGS2 - Masterpiece, should be higher
Sekiro - Acceptable
RE4 Demake - Worse than original and every single classic RE game including RE0
Astro Bot - HAHAHAAHAAHA
Utawareremo - Haremslop
MM - Second best Zelda
Portal 2 - Worse than original in every way, Reddit slop
BOTW - Fails at every aspect of game design, genuinely TLOU2 level garbage
OOT - The Greatest game of all time
Trials and Tribulations - Made by the Ghost Trick guys, well deserved
>>
>>751627018
BASED
>>
>>751619871
NPC list
>>
>>751627018
>Deltarune - /v/ core
kill yourself
>>
>>751619871
>remake
Invalid post.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.