Following Bioware going the way of the dodo I decided to replay ME1 and I don't remember the gameplay being this horrifically bad. I definitely didn't remember it being stellar but this is atrocious, there is zero feedback for anything in combat. Maybe it's because in my first playthrough I was a generic Shooty McSpacemarine but this time I'm trying out a Vanguard. The combat is a giant clusterfuck of particles and cooldowns where I don't even know if I'm hitting an enemy before I get shredded immediately by every single one of them rushing the cover Shepard decided to weld his ass to against my will. I can't even tell if my bullets are doing anything half the time, the shotgun is a cruel joke that either atomizes anything remotely close to me or does literally no damage. I guess the biotic powers are serviceable but not particularly useful in combat against a dozen enemies with a 30 second cooldown when most of them in practice end up as single target effect.Mass Effect thread.
>>751624906My biggest gripe in ME1 are the soldier class enemies using immunity and they are fucking invincible for a minute. Combat in ME1 just sucks and I understand why people say go for adept so you can throw everything and everyone about
I just replayed ME1 and I don’t remember it being this kino.
>>751625186For what it's worth, everything except the combat is as kino as I remembered it.
>>751625472Mid to late game ME1 is fun. Early game ME1 is a slog. Play Adept like the anon below you said
>>751624906Yeah. It's obviously not as bad but it's kind of like playing morrowind combat after years of Skyrim combat.The game is fucking awesome though.
kills me how some people want to slight me2 by saying it copied gears of war as if me1 isn't an even shittier gears clone
>>751625615I only really picked Vanguard because I'm aware it gets kind of stupid in ME2 and want to run through the trilogy with one character. I'm also in that messy transitional spot where I'm too early for the class to not be shit but far enough in where restarting would kill any motivation for me to keep playing. One thing I do acutely remember though is your squad being nigh useless and dying within seconds of starting a combat encounter. Either micromanage every movement with the janky RTWP tactics menu or have both companions blow all their cooldowns on a single enemy then stand in the middle of the arena and get shredded.
You can play the entire game and not even notice the cover mechanic. It's also better this way.>>751626996The problem with ME2 is that it threw out a ton of things in return for mildly improved shooting.
sentinel best class
>>751628242>The problem with ME2 is that it threw out a ton of things in return for mildly improved shooting.Honestly ME2 is just better across the board. It has better gameplay, less fluff, and mostly just trimmed the fat in terms of both story and combat. It wasn't just the shooting that was better either, it was the enemy variety, powers and interaction.
>>751624906it's cuz you're replaying the remaster which broken combat ai to an extreme degree
>>751630635then why do I dread the slog of basegame ME2 every 4-6 months I replay the trilogy?It's because ME2 isn't a better game, it's actually a downgrade in every direction but more focused and therefor strikes the normies as "tighter" even though the main protagonist is even clunkier than before, levels are built like quake arenas rather than actual lived in places, the blue suns/eclipse/blood pack/geth are just reskins of the same enemy faction, etc.
>>751625173>this anon has not discovered the simple pleasures of the hyperrail/explosive ammo sniper rifle / shotgun
>>751631296>then why do I dread the slog of basegame ME2 every 4-6 months I replay the trilogy?My man, why are you replaying the entire trilogy multiple times a year and how do you have so much free time?
>>751632230hyperfixation/insanity complex + neglecting relationships mostly
I've never actually played Soldier because it seems boring. The benefit of the class is being able to use any weapon, but you're gonna focus on one maybe two weapons anyway so that benefit doesn't really do anything
>>751630635GCD and defense system ruin ability varietyit feels less clunky but that's about the only good thing to say about it. i suppose enemy variety is true. otherwise its a D-tier cover shooter, a prototype for 3 where bioware finally managed to make the gameplay not ass (shame about the rest of the game though)
>>751624906I picked a psy-sorcerer build (don't remember what they're called) and immediately got filtered by like the first boss encounter of the game. I died so fucking fast it was just impossible. When I looked up advice on how to beat this encounter the gist I got was just "reroll to the guns build lol." Lost interest after that.
>>751633075soldiers are op but mostly because of how strong immunity is. combined with their other tanking abilities and hp upgrades makes you unkillable as you waltz enemy to enemy blasting them in the face. pistols are S-tier in ME1, so access to other weapons is really just for variety/entertainment.soldier is also OP in 2 because adrenaline rush is hilariously overpowered. however, solider is also incredibly boring because the optimal way to play is to hide behind boxes using adrenaline rush every gcd. play vanguard instead.
>>751624906Combat was pretty stale in 1, it was more of an rpg with tacked on shooter mechanics. Me2 massively improved the combat
>>751630904I'm playing the original because I got the trilogy a million years ago for like 3 bucks on Origin
So, what did you guys think of the ME Universe leaks?I, personally, had been saying for months now that Mary DeMarle had left Bioware, and if you look at her LinkedIn profileSenior Narrative DirectorEA/BioWare · Permanent Full-timeJul 2022 - Dec 2025 · 3 yrs 6 mosMontreal, Quebec, CanadaShe did, in fact, quit. Almost a year ago. So whoever thought this was going to be a well written game, you were going to get Catherynne Valente's sloppy seconds and ask for more.Frankly, with the things that came out, I am so freaking glad it got cancelled. The protagonist was allegedly going to be "The Shepard" and wearing N7 apparel, 600+ years after ME3. Like, if you want so desperately to bring Shepard back, just bring Shepard back. But Bioware didn't want to please chuds, and Valente was likely actively working against that.What do you guys think?
>>751625186You just replayed it and you already don't remember it? Damn, that's bad.
>>751624906>Following Bioware going the way of the dodo I decided to replay ME1 and I don't remember the gameplay being this horrifically bad.This is why we keep saying ME2 is the best one, but its only retard hipster purists who insist on being the "real" fans that try to claim 1 is better.
>>751634349No sane person thought it was good. It's like the Witcher series where they take Ciri being a Witcher as canon. It's a flesh walker and the saudis put a stop to it unlike CDPR.
>>751636589ME2 has better gameplay but ME1 does everything else better.ME2 is the posterchild of consoleization.
>>751634349It was literally impossible for bioware as of 2026+ to make a passable game, not to mention a good one. We got spared from ME:Veilguard/
>>751624906Mass Effect is effectively Gears of War but with RPG checks
>>751637573>ME1 does everything else betterLike driving around empty planets for 30 minutes?Pass. Inventory was awful, weapon mods were awful, driving was awful, dialogues were awful, story was awful, world-building was awful, characters were awful. Admit it. We gave it a pass, because it was an early 360 title, with Bioware's name on the cover, which meant something back then.
You guys better not say anything bad about Batarians.
>>751637881Right? Supposedly we're allies now, against the evil council races.
This is why you play Infiltrator in ME1 then switch to Engineer in ME2 and then Soldier in ME3
>>751624906Look with your special eyes.
>>751624906It has aged very poorly. 2 is even worse
>>751637831>nope all bad :)You're an insufferable faggot
someone post the pic where shepard shits all over the place
>>751637831The little fluff writing pieces about each planet in a system alone contribute more to ME worldbuilding than the entirety of ME2 which decided to hyperfixate on the crew.
>>751624906Me1 is honesty easy even on insanity. It's just crowd control and don't get hit in the face with a rocket. It feels pretty dated for 2007, it's like if kotor wasn't turn based.
>>751638093It took humanity something like 20 years to go from "there are no aliens" to "vying for Council seat". You heard some guy with a TV game show presenter voice tell you things and you fell for shit, hook, line and sinker. Admit it.>>751637936Oh, yeah. I forgot about that. Remember all that work Shepard did to get humanity on the council? We're enemies now, haha!
>>751638245>The little fluff writing piecesRandom stuff on an excel spreadsheet Casey had lying around. That's not world building. I can write such bullshit blurbs on excel with enough time. Besides, didn't we have those in ME2 and ME3 as well? Why did ME1 do it better?
>>751637831>Like driving around empty planets for 30 minutes?Yes, 100%Driving around on ME1 planets are some of the most sovlful experiences I've ever had in my life.
>>751639868>Yes, 100%SIMP!SI-IMP!
When I played it I put everything into an assault rifle build + charisma/speech/whatever it's called and by the end of the game I was blasting through the enemies like if I were in Contra.
Have mods made andromeda worth playing? Also whatever googledoc modding guide I used for the ME trilogy replay I did some months ago wasnt bad at all. Think a tranny wrote it though>>751639868Was as dogshit driving around as I remembered especially since they wanted to cuck you out of boosting all the time lol. Those recyled maps too were also obnoxious
>>751639868So fvcking based... Anyone who hated the random planets you could visit are FAGGOTS who don't understand ME.
>>751640308>>751639949
>>751640182>Have mods made andromeda worth playing?No? Frostbite engine hardly has any mods for other games. The trilogy is heavily moddable because its Unreal Engine.
>>751639868uncharted worlds WAS Mass Effect and neither of the sequels are truly sequels by ditching that conceptMass Effect was designed to be a spiritual successor to Star Control
>>751639868>>751640308>>751640812You should honestly try Starfield if you like driving around uncharted planets, gathering minerals, exploring caves, or searching bases
>>751641403>not telling me to play NMSME2 zoomer must be a really young zoomer. Maybe 20
>>751640812>uncharted worlds WAS Mass EffectAbsolutely not. Play NMS or Todd'sfield instead.
>>751641631how bout (you) go play exodus or something in a few weeksit's made for your exact iq/phenotype
I'm waiting for the Mass Effect 2 re-write to happen so I can play through the intended version of the game.https://youtu.be/UeVRSI8bC5o?is=KKv4x9iK0tK4k1p_
>>751629001That's not infiltrator
>>751641802Why are you telling me to play Andromeda tier games?NMS and Toddfield at least are better than ME1.
>>751624906play adept in ME1. every ability just works with no restrictions.
>>751641951So you're gonna play the entire game solo?
>>751642103cope
>>751642162he'll probably have miranda/jacob defect with TIM's dossiers. Or have Liara as a shadow broker agent give Shep the dossiers
>>751641951The effort is worthy of praise but that still looks and sounds like shit.
>>751643484Denial
>>751644086to be fair you'd have to be over 70 iq and from a first world country to understand Mass Effect
>>751644154Ah! So he's Somalian.
>>751642159vanguard+ singularity is a better adeptsame with infiltrator + hackingME1's the best in the trilogy but the fatal design flaw is the hybrid classes are all better than the pure ones due to too many overlapping abilities
>>751644659>ME1's the best in the trilogy
>>751644792what's your take then?If you say ME2 you're as black as your gif
>Quickie? Yeah I'll get the tweezers
>>751645584How can you not rape?
>>751624906>feedbackmeme term that people throw out when they have no actual criticism. the game has ragdolls from explosions and force powers, bodys disintegrating from plasma and fire, powerful sounds for weapons firing and overheating, xp delivered on every kill, shepard yells "LOST SHIELDS" when losing shields. legendary edition has hit markers for headshots and bodyshits, red shit on your screen for taking damage. it literally has more feedback on all aspects of combat than the majority of shooters
>>751637992MY BRAND
>>751646945can't rape the willing
>>751641951saw this in my feed. looks cool, like the other guy said the effort is commendable. with this, cerberus is far more consistent across 3 games than the roller coaster we got on release. even so, if one is going to rewrite to this degree, why not just eliminate the whole normandy gets destroyed and shepard gets resurrected thing? that whole setup was just a contrivance to put shepard with cerberus and make them gather a new crew.
>>751647667>why not just eliminate the whole normandy gets destroyed and shepard gets resurrected thing?exactly. I think the Normandy getting spaced is thematically necessary unfortunately but why not make a mod where it's the original "geth revive Shepard" plotline, but maybe cerberus or the alliance performs a rescue or something
>>751647295Unless an enemy is ragdolled they don't react to being shot whatsoever until they crumple over and die. Trying to figure out what is actually damaging you or if you're even being damaged is nearly impossible with a pack of enemies bigger than 3. Combat feedback has a twofold effect, say something like a flinching animation, A. it lets the player know they are actually doing damage to an enemy and B. allows for minor crowd control so you don't get into a situation like an enemy bumrushing your position while repeatedly taking slugs to the face only to blend in with your squadmates at close range adding unneeded chaos, which is a huge problem with the extreme close quarters maps in ME1.The lack of feedback is a pretty large criticism when all but two classes fold like wet paper under fire, and one of those classes is entirely reliant on CD uptime. Getting an XP message after an enemy died doesn't do anything to help a player out during combat.>legendary editionI don't give a shit about LE.
Fuck batarians
>>751651693NO
>>751638420>The descriptions of worlds across the galaxy?>Not world buildingUsually people of your intellect can manage>ME2 bestBut you've really shoved your morning cornflakes up your nostrils and shat in your thinking hat
WE ARE going to the Citadel, boys!
>>751647890>blend in with your squadmates at close range adding unneeded chaosSkill issue, work on your eye skill you blind faggot lmao holy shit
>>751633975Tbf every class is busted in ME1 save maybe the engineer.
>>751637831I'd much rather engage in immersive sci-fi planet exploration than do that fucking horrendous scanning minigame. I genuinely just used mods to cheat it last playthrough, it's not worth it.>>751638245That said I think the focus on the crew was strictly positive. The crew got shockingly little development in 1 outside of (funny enough) arguably Wrex. 2 really went out of its way to explore and develop your crew and I'd argue it's the most enjoyable crew of the three games because of it.
the first game is total ass gameplay wise, yeathat being said, im playing vangaurd for the first time in 2 right now and holy shit is it ever fun, and i seriously cant wait to get to 3 because i know it added better melee attacks, a roll, and smoother movement, which im already finding the vangaurd class desperately needs. the bigggest shortcoming of the class in 2 is that the clunky movement is constantly in direct conflict with the classes play style
>>751647783>maybe cerberus or the alliance performs a rescue or somethingHow would anyone know that the Geth took Shepard's body, of all people, and why would anyone believe he is a live, let alone resurrected. It makes a thousand more times sense for Cerberus to do it, than the Geth.
>>751645060>make retarded claim>now you are forced to abide by itFuck off.The vast majority of people that bought ME2 are white, the vast majority of them liked it more than ME1, provably true btw, and you are throwing tantrums because you don't like the truth.Not my problem.
>>751651720Stupid blurbs are not world building, anymore than the Dark Souls Zanzibart meme.
>>751653279>I'd much rather engage in immersive sci-fi planet explorationNMS, Starfield.You're playing neither.Guess you're not really into immersive sci-fi planet exploration.ME1 did absolutely not do it better than either.
>>751647890theres on screen health bars for every character and a physics system. what do you want? enemies and shepard to just gyrate and do the truffle shuffle for every assault rifle bullet that hits them? >hurr game is too hard for my class and theres no feedback but no i won't play the version that buffs my class and adds more feedbackhonestly just lower the difficulty then? if this is still a problem below hardcore the issue is 100% you