[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_3793.jpg (373 KB, 1920x1920)
373 KB JPG
Are the top down Zelda games on Switch any good?
>>
Echoes is pozzed
>>
EoW sucked ass
>>
One is a demake of a GB game while the other is the worst game in the franchise
>>
Link's Awakening runs like shit on the original Switch. On Switch 2 it has no problems aside from looking fucking hideous thanks to the garbage art style.

Echoes of Wisdom doesn't know what it wants to be. It's top-down with a tedious summoning mechanic with puzzles "designed" to be beaten multiple ways like the ones in BotW/TotK. You end up stacking furniture to do everything. The overworld is also very uninspired.
>>
>>751630659
yeah
>>
is LA on sale on switch, i don't want to bother turning it on to look
>>
>>751630659
Echoes was great, at least.
>>
>>751630854
>worst game in the franchise
Not even including meme shit like the CD-I games, Echoes is still probably a better game overall than the DS games or Triforce Heroes. Spirit Tracks is more soulful at least
>>
File: 1780185607206840.png (3 KB, 156x103)
3 KB PNG
>>751630659
op:only;boards:v;/\b(zelda)\b/i
>>
Both are better than where 3D Zelda presently stands.
>>
>>751631181
how do I filter gay posts like yours
>>
>>751630854
>One is a demake
More than one equitable item at a time makes it superior.
>>
>>751631207
that's straight up a fucking lie considering eow tries to be like botw
>>
>>751631305
Not really.
>>
>>751631301
Making the combat and movement clunky garbage makes it inferior
>>
File: 1769017546405886.png (58 KB, 256x239)
58 KB PNG
>>751631213
easy, do this
>>
>>751631390
shouldn't you be getting butthurt over people shitting on indies lmao
>>
File: 1783942039173726.jpg (19 KB, 409x393)
19 KB JPG
>>751631557
>responding to bait
>calls others butthurt
kek project more faggit
>>
>>751630854
>One is a demake
Link's awakening remake is bad? Why, I thought about buying it.
>>
>>751632258
If you're not playing it with mods, then you'll have to deal with 30FPS + shitty blur. Then you'll have to deal with the awful funko pop artstyle, but if you like them for some reason, it's irrelevant. Then you lose the photo sidequest.

The only upgrade is the inventory management, and even then they did the bare minimum and left the dpad completely unused. You are not even allowed to use it despite the game being locked to 8 directions only

Just play the original instead, it then makes it easier to play the oracle games afterwards since it's the exact same engine and those games are never ever getting remade ever
>>
>>751632445
>If you're not playing it with mods, then you'll have to deal with 30FPS + shitty blur
it's 60fps on switch 2, and the blur is an intentional tilt-shift effect
>>
>>751631305
EoW has actual dungeons and the overworld density is closer to an updated ALttP than the vast, empty bullshit of the last 2 3D Zeldas. It inherited the menuwork and open-ended exploration, but it's been placed in a game that is structurally closer to earlier Zelda.
>>
>>751632504
>and the blur is an intentional tilt-shift effect
And it looks fucking terrible. Do you think I give a shit about their retarded artistic vision?
>>
>>751632769
I don't agree, but stay mad
>>
How is Links Awakening a demake? It’s a one to one recreation. Fucking stupid old fags larping who needs to see pixels. Also what they expect from a top down Zelda? They need all the autism in the world to play a Gameboy game at 999 fps
>>
File: Photograph_3.png (10 KB, 480x432)
10 KB PNG
>>751632842
>30FPS gets removed (by nintendo)
>this is a good thing even though it goes against the original vision

>blur gets removed (by me)
>AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

kill yourself

>>751632976
>It’s a one to one recreation
Where is pic related bro?
>>
>>751630854
>One is a demake of a GB game
wrong

>the other is the worst game in the franchise
also wrong that goes to SS and TotK
>>
>>751633081
The 30fps performance wasn't "removed", it was always targeting 60 but dropped to 30 frequently on switch 1 due to bandwidth limitations, which wasn't an issue on switch 2 where it ran at 60, They later gave it a switch 2 patch anyway.
>>
>>751632976
I dunno and I don't care. It's a good game either way.
>>
>>751630659
LA remake is better because of the dungeon maker. It's so fucking fun.
>>
File: 2022051120555800 S-1.webm (2.88 MB, 1280x710)
2.88 MB
2.88 MB WEBM
I had fun.
>>
>>751630659
EoW is more of a bad puzzle game. It's my second least favorite Zelda game after tri force heroes. Links awakening remake is more or less the same game again but in an ugly art style but I'm bias since I fucking love the oringals art style
>>
File: zeldalist.png (506 KB, 1140x646)
506 KB PNG
Here.
>>
Should have kept the albw graphics
>>
>>751630659
Links awakening was good and I had a good time with echoes of wisdom
>>
>>751630827
you shut your fucking mouth. It was decent.
>>
>>751634207
Wind Waker's way too high.
>>
>>751634207
>LttP is A
Any list that has it below the top tier is irrelevant
>>
>>751634207
why didn't you rank all the other remakes
>>
>>751630854
It's not as bad at the DS games or Triforce Heroes.
>>
Can’t believe the Wii U era nearly ended zelda
>>
They’re thoroughly okay.
>>
>>751634207
This looks like a genuine opinion that mostly matches mine, so I'll ask if you had gripes with the DS games beyond touch controls, instruments, boat/train, or Temple of the Ocean King to rate them that low. Personally I loved Spirit Tracks and thought Phantom Hourglass was alright.
>>
>>751632258
I liked it. Yeah the art style is ugly but it's a better experience than the old game. If you liked Link's Awakening you'll like it.
>>
>>751634609
NTA but phantom hourglass is, by far, the worst zelda game I have ever played. It's so bad I skipped spirit tracks entirely. I would say a combination of the crap dungeons (repeating ocean king, what, 6 fucking times?), and the controls are what killed it for me. Linebeck was the only interesting part of it.
>>
Link's Awakening with the DOF effect turned off is great, Echoes of Bed Stacking gets old really quick
>>
Triforce heroes should have been Zelda’s game
>>
>>751634442
I forgot kek. OoT 3DS in A, same with LA remake, and MM3DS probably like C or something.
>>
I love EoW but they really messed up by doing the summoning mechanic. They should've just gone all in with goddess magic power that worked like the ALttP medallions and Oot magic spells and have zelda mainly use a bow & arrow.
>>
>>751634207
>NES Zeldas in C instead of S
Garbage taste.
>>
>>751630659
>LA
okay remake. Some changes are good, some are really weird. Some omissions from DX too. Hate how D pad does nothing but joystick moves, except it's 8 directions only, even though Link Between Worlds had 360 movement. It's like mapping the D pad to the joystick. Honestly that sums up the remake.

Echoes of Wisdom has a button that turns the game into a real Zelda game and it's an obvious band-aid because the game is built for one thing but still demands ACTUAL Zelda gameplay.

Just play the Switch Online Zeldas. Gameboy has LA and the Oracle games, GBA has Munish Cap, SNES has LttP.
>>
>>751634440
I'm with him on A. That game's got some minor technical quirks like Link's swing not being as wide as it looks or bottomless pits having gravitational pull that's a bit too strong, plus it overloads its action button when the SNES controller has shoulder buttons. Structurally speaking it is a perfect game, but the playability's got a few rough quirks that later entries ironed out.
>>
Tier order is how you personally rank the Beatles.
>>
>>751634609
Mostly the touch controls because I'm a lefty. Also I really disliked TotOK in PH and all the strange stuff. It's been a while since I played ST and I was genuinely in a bit of a slump with the Zelda series at the time given we had PH, ST and SS all in a row (I played ST after SS).
>>
>>751635739
all the stealth stuff*



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.