It was perfect. Perfect! Everything, down to the last, minute details.
Now replay it as an adult
>>751642456Why would that be a problem?
>>751642313The first game ends abruptly and the second game is a patchwork of scrapped material from the first strung together to try to make it a coherent sequel.
It used to drive me crazy how the characters never shut the fuck up and repeated dialog constantly, but now every goddamn JRPG is like that.
>>751642838>second game is a patchwork of scrapped material from the first strung together to try to make it a coherent sequel.None of that is true but you keep believing it if it makes you feel better.
>>751642313NINTENDOHIRE THIS MAN
>>751642990It's obvious when the story is basically none-existent outside of the beginning sequence with Jenna and until Felix arrives at Lemuria, at which point the game is practically 90% over, and all of that time was spent on a giant fetch quest for a trident.
weird thing about this game is how PP regenerates when you walk. it means you basically have infinite healing in any dungeon. its kind of nice but also means the game is very easy.
>>751642313Nah, Lost Age's execution wasn't great. You start off with a party that you have no frame of reference for considering going by the title alone you can't tell that it's actually a sequel, considering there's no 2 in the title and the subtitle isn't out of place. I assume they did that on purpose to drum up sales, but I think everyone would have preferred if they had just sold the games as a pair.
>>751642838it was always supposed to be just one game anyway
>>751643858I think the idea is that the random battles are often and varied enough that as long as you didn't over-level, you spending PP on healing will only keep you at parity instead of making it easy. Maybe the problem is that the random battles give too much experience?
GS1 is really good, but GS2 is a drag. GS2 doesn't do anything interesting or different enough to justify being as long and padded as it is and the constant backtracking through super high rate random encounters with the ship is fucking annoying as shit. And god help you if you put the game down for a week or two and forget what you were supposed to be doing.
>>751642313Yeah, but it isn't the GOAT
>>751642313Golden sun is a very good game. The Lost age was the best.
>>751643858PP, heh
>>751642624It's the most generic jrpg ever made just in handheld form with some Wild Arms style dungeon stuff. There is nothing interesting, terrible, or great about it.
>>751642313I maintain that random encounters in puzzle dungeons are one of the most awful design choices I've seen in a video game.
>>751644569The issue is random battles become very easy to just slam attack on and then out of combat party heal after a few battles. Even more so if you do 2x earth+fire and 2x wind+water which fixes everyone's speed and gives you two party heals to split the pp burden
I liked the games. LOVE when games carry over stuff from the first game to the next. I remember being disappointed with the ending however, It was such a nothing end I cannot remember what happened besides a happy ending for everyone.
>>751645097it's still more cohesive and fun to play than ff shit, ff shit is carried by the music after ff6
>>751645238Can't imagine anyone thinking Golden Sun is more fun to play through than any PS1 or PS2 Final Fantasy game.
I played the second game first, then bought the first. GS1 is definitely better, but GS2 was more ambitious with the scope of it's story. Loved these games as a kid.
>>751644524Obviously, tendies tend to get mad if you point it out though>>751644776You can use avoid to skip most encounters in the overworld, Piers has it as soon as you get him iirc
>>751645531Why are you retards console warring over a decades old game on dead hardware anyone can emulate on anything, like the dumbest 12 year olds from the 90's who could only afford one console and are bitter about it but don't want to acknowledge how bad they want to play the other exclusives.
>still no jrpg that does exploration as well as GSDamn
>>751642838it was originally a single game that had to be split because1. it wouldnt fit in 1 gba cartdridge2. they were running out of time
>>751645724What does it do that series like Wild Arms or the best Tales Of games don't do better?
>>751645097>It's the most generic jrpg ever how many JRPGs actually have utility spells you can use outside of combat for puzzling and exploration though?
>rpg>it's actually a linear plot with no choice to play your role???????????
Dark Dawn was good
>>751645830Lol fucking nothing. It's just like Dragon Quest. JRPGfags will swear it's 'generic', but it does all kind of cool shit that other JRPGs don't and has the best exploration in its genre. Golden Sun is too good for people who 'like JRPGs'.
>>751645204it ends with a cliffhanger where alex climbs Mt. Alpeph when you're lighting the last lighthouse to recieve the power of the golden sun, once he does the sage stone appears and buries him under the entire mountain and tells him, "if you can get out, you're free to do whatever the fuck you want" and then in dark dawn nothing of that was resolved
>>751645830The exploration elements are what made this game novel to playthrough when it came out, though I don't remember anything in it that wasn't done in other JRPGs like Wild Arms, Breath of Fire, Tales etc.. Fun idea with hyper generic execution
Friendly reminder that the brothers that created golden sun stated that golden sun 1 and 2 were supposed to just be prologues to set the world building for the "real" stories they wanted to make
>>751645848>rpg>You play a role in the story
>>751646003You have never played Wild Arms or Breath of Fire or plenty of other JRPGs from the time that did this stuff.
>>751646223you play no role, you're just an observer that barely take control of the character in battle
This is THE primary example of a mediocre game hyped up by an audience largely unfamiliar with the genre.
>>751645789>1. it wouldnt fit in 1 gba cartdridgeNot necessarily true>2. they were running out of timeDefinitely, it's especially evident at the Venus lighthouse area where the quality starts dropping rapidly
>>751645830Mystic Quest.
>>751646382apparently it was also a combo of playtime and how expensive the 32mb cartdridges were at the timeoriginally the total playtime of both games were estimated at 100hours which was too much for a handheldand apparently the 32 mb cartdridges were expensive to make at that time too
>>751646367The only other puzzle focused jarpig I know of is Lufia 2. Feel free to mention more mister animeweedlord
>>751646285It's at least as much an RPG as games like Witcher, which also follow a written character along a linear story path.
>>751642313Lost age ain't so good.
>>751646574I think Golden Sun is a JRPG, but The Witcher has choose your own adventure style choices to the story which makes it much more like a traditional rpg.
>>751646367Fable is this dynamic for western rpgs
yeah golden sun is pretty good but is the OST any go-https://youtu.be/c7pBcKlONnA?si=GR36xDAB6AogHaaH
>>751646837Sakuraba is one of the goats. His work on Tales Of, Valkyrie Profile and Shining Force 3 is great. He's more prog rock than uematsu is.
>>751646982>Sakuraba is one of the goats.LOLhttps://youtu.be/3QiidBcFWTE
>>751646543It's more likely they overestimated the time it would take to port their existing tooling and code to new hardware coupled with developing something new, psyenergy was a way more advanced system than what had come before>>751646546Pokemon and Zelda come to mind
>>751647093HOWEVERhttps://youtu.be/3bqLGebDRIY
>>751647093sometimes things sound like shit until you really listen.this is patient zero of "what is this shit" and then about half way through youre like "holy shit hes actually cooking and im a faggot":https://youtu.be/SRGqQ3a8ibM?si=lhS1DVmYsGnIXQzG
>>751642313Nobody shuts up or has any personality in these games
>>751647223>Zelda>actually it counts as a JRPG now, I swearlol
>>751647573I see people keep saying this, but to me it feels like they're real people since they're actually all talking. They all clearly have personality too imo
>>751642313the most gassed up mid of a RPG ever.
>>751648053Nah that's ff8. Fuck people that gas that filth
>>751647879Here we see garet is the big bruting firebrand of the group, or well not really he doesn't have any particular personality to speak of
>>751648146FF8 is a million times more interesting than this shit, this does not even try or fail anything and FF8 has a lot of good shit going for it in it's world, atmosphere, set pieces etc..
they were solid gamesi can't imagine being so cucked and mindbroken by them that a person would trash talk them in an online forum 25 years later, but ITT we really get to see the mental illnesses of the world come together
>>751651051Nobody is even saying it's bad, it is just very obviously to anyone who has played other JRPGs like it, that it is the most generically written and generic playing game you could ever find.
>>751642313>Infinite dialogue and cutscene works>Ridiculously braindeadLufia 2 is a similarly puzzle focused RPG but it's way better.
>>751645367I'd rather play it than 8 or 11.
>>751645724The first two Metal Max games are the best JRPGs out there for exploration.
>>751651216Great games, I played the SNES remake of the first, haven't played the PS2 one yet.
>>751642313and then the third game happened...
>>751651179FF8 is a peak in PS1 aesthetics, world and atmosphere, 11 is a peak of MMOs before they became casualized, likely unplayable as it once was today. Golden Sun is a flat line.
>>751642313I like it but we don't have to pretend the games don't have a problem with dialogue dragging on
>>751642313>i played it when i was 9Yeah we can tell.
>>751645830You need to play more games, Timothy.
>>751651840Play the DS games instead.
>>751643549The entire point of the first 2/3rds of TLA is for the player to learn in real time with Jenna and the others just how fucked the world is because Alchemy is gone. The dialogue in Lemuria and the reunion will then feel less out of left field because you personally experienced the shit yourself and can agree with kraden when he talks the king into helping them.The execution is not the best since its mostly just fetch quests but it makes sense.
>>751651936FF8 looks good but it plays like shit. FF11 is everything I hate in MMOs, Ultima was the peak.
too much talking
>>751651840Metal Saga is better than Saga DS, 3, and Xeno but worse than 1, 2, and 4 and the first two games' remakes. It's worth playing, at least.
>>751645830Pokemon
>>751644971>trannies out of literally nowhere
>>751642313>Bad guys are murdering random people>Actually they are le good people trying to save the worldFuck off, garbage game shit writing.
>>751642456I'm playing the decomp, it's great.
>>751651936>FF8 is a peak in PS1 aesthetics, world and atmosphereNot even the best Square game on PSX.