Wait a minute, that key...
It's not a puzzle dude in the slightest, it's just basic world building.
>>751647725puzzle dude fell out of a window before he could set up his puzzle
>>751647868I agree, DS3 is pretty basic
this stupid fucking key is why DS3 is the worst souls
>>751647725Yeah this one took me a while too.
>Demon Souls is entirely linear but is widely praised>DaS3 is linear but is despised for thisWhy is that?
>>751647998>despised for thisIt's literally just one mentally ill loser
>>751647998Because DeS was the first souls. The next entries improved over the level design, so it felt a bit underwhelming when DS3 was basically a downgraded DaS.
>>751647998DS was proto darksoulsDS3 was an even more watered down DS1
>>751647725im stuck on champion gundyr and it's pissing me the motherfuck nigger off.
>>7516479983 was a rolling simulator. Really fun for the first month but after that.. the games get harder and harder to go back to. I'm so out of practice even ds2 feels bad to play. 1 is still slow, 3 is spamming roll, elden ring is full of empty space. It's a shame what they did to that franchise. 2 was at least a true sequel.
>>751647725>you can beat dancer and dragonslayer armor early if you got the balls,>"nope ashen one, this door is too much for you, go kill those three lords of cinder now"Shame on Miyazaki for this
>>751648783have you tried not being a shitter
>>751647998because..ur GAE.
>>751648942no, because im not a fucking faggot like you are you little bitch.
>>751647998dark souls 3 sold the most in the series, it's where most "souls fans" started. it's an incredibly bland easy game, and the pointless nostalgia pandering was obnoxious. everything wrong with elden wrong started there
>>751647998The obsessive DS3 haters are usually DS2-loving freaks, ignore them
>>751649248>STILL hasn't just picked up and played ds2Holy fuck lol. How long will you seethe about a game you've only seen youtube reviews of?
>>751648884>you can kill Dancer, Dragonslayer Armor, Oceiros, Champion Gundyr early>no special reward for it Its kinda absurd. At the very least you should have been able to enter the GA.
just replayed demon souls, i think i hate it.great atmosphere though
>>751649171>it's an incredibly bland easy gameI guarantee that you died a double digit number of times on bosses like the Nameless King, Sister Friede, Midir, or Gael. And that the first Lothric Knight and Winged Knights both fucked your face hard. And then the Gru got you a few times, And so did the Outrider Knights. And the Pontiff Dogs. Oh, and the giant chain Snakemen.
remember how in bloodborne killing the blood starved beast just causes the door in the oedon chapel to open?this is dark souls 3's version of that, it's just a way to block players that kill the high priestess and go to upper lothric at the start from going straight to twin princes.
>>751650856Killing BSB has more effects on that though. It makes the Snatchers appear which also opens up another new area, and also allows you to effectively skip buying the hunter’s insignia by going around the main gates in the cathedral. Thats an interesting alternative to a roadblock a player might come across or wish to circumvent. Here its just…blocking you. Even if you made it that far and are willing to tackle it on, they’re denying you the last half of Lothric Castle, when you can kill everything else in it. And personally I found the Dancer and Gundyr to be harder than the Twin Princes anyway.
>>751647998Because DS3 is an overall casualization of DS1 to appeal to wider audiences and the linear design is part of that.>But DS3 is harderThat's the problem, DS1 never focused on combat difficulty, it made everything into a skill issue. DS3 moves it more into just a game with hard fights, easier everything else, and just formulaic in general. It's DS3 that standardized the industry wide souls formula that everyone else copied.
>it's the corpse of the wrong guy
>>751651370>it made everything into a skill issueYeah and everyone loved it lmao Dark Souls 3 is by far the most popular and well-received out of all the Dark Souls games
>>751647998In DeS after completing stage 1 you get five choices on where to go.In DaS3 you get at most two choices on where to go at any time and the second choice is always only a short diversion before you return to the main path.DaS3 is more linear than DeS was. More importantly, DeS was the start, and DaS3 was a regression.
Why does DS3 feel good to play, while Elden Ring is dogshit? Can't wrap my head around it.
>>751647998Demon's Souls is not linear, in terms of stage progression you're free to do whatever you want after 1-1 and several stages give you plenty of freedom in how to progress. Why is it that whenever someone makes a remark about Demon's Souls it always seems like they never played it and don't have a clue about the game?
>>751647998>Demon Souls is entirely linearIt's really not though. You can call the levels themselves linear but you're free to do things in almost any order you want.It would be like calling Mega Man linear.
>>751652484you can rolly poly more and enemy combos less
>>751647998People praise dark souls 1 for letting you go in high level areas when you're not readyLike it doesn't break progression and ruin the whole gameAlso like they didn't follow a guide telling them where to go, so the freedom doesn't matter
>>751648884Realistically if they hadn't done this, then 80% of the game's actual content could be beaten before leaving Undead Settlement. Almost everything after that door with the spaz knight is unfinished stub areas and swamps.
>>751649248Yeah the people who hate DS3 are the ones who started with DS2 and were desperately looking for a game worse than theirs so they could stop being shat on all the time by everyone
>>751653701>irithyll>deep chapel>catacombs>unfinished stub areasEven Claude would at least do some research before posting.
>>751648884It's understandable that they wanted to have the Archives locked off as the final area. It's worse that you can't cross the great bridge at the start of Undead Settlement and go down to Farron Keep first, and then you could go to the Catacombs or back to the Cathedral of the Deep, I mean the world layout is literally already made. Imagine how much better Dark Souls 3's early game would be if you didn't have to do High Wall -> Settlement -> Road of Sacrifices in the same order every playthrough
>>751655343>Cathedral of the deep isn't an unfinished cathedral filled with enemies from the previous area and weird counterintuitive or outright broken NPC triggers>Catacombs of Carthus totally aren't copypasted corridors that show up again in Lost Izalith. Can't even do proper reanimating skellies with negromancers, they just waste your time by forcing you to kill them twice.At least you didn't try to defend something like Profaned capital. Irithyll is the only real area you encounter.
>>751653143Elden Ring feels unbearably slow compared to BB and DS3 and Sekiro. Even with no armor on.
>>751647998Demon's Souls is linear but has gimmicks and puzzles and harder enemies to offset its linearity.DS3 is linear with 0 depth, braindead enemies most people run by to get to the boss gauntlet.Demon's Souls is the antithesis of 3.
>>751647725The only reason it's there is to arbitrarily block the way in case you went through the dancer early. The key only spawns after you finish the lords of cinder, that's it.
>>751657396Wasn't there some mod that restored some of the area connections?
>>751647998>>Demon Souls is entirely linearSince when Demon Souls forces you to play through the archstones in a fixed order you fucking retard?
>>751647725>claymoreNPC build
realistically what does this even prevent?there's nothing past here that could let the player sequence break too badly, you always have to return to the shrine to beat the game anyway
>>751647725>heavy claymore>poopy knight armor>great heal
>>751660152It's still linear shit. No different from Dark Souls 3 sometimes letting you pick two different linear paths.
>>751647868Why not just have the door unlocked at this point?
>>751647998Souls 3 is not linear unless you count 2 paths combining into 1 which then splits again, linear.
>>751662464Every Souls level is a ''linear path'' then you utter retard, people are talking about the choices of progression
>>751662687Because the guard holds the keys
>>751652896To be fair he did only watch a streamer play a bit of the remake six years ago (yes its that old), his memory is a little foggy now.
>>751657739>>Cathedral of the deep isn't an unfinished cathedral filled with enemies from the previous area and weird counterintuitive or outright broken NPC triggersItroduces two new enemies, also nothing broken in its triggers>>Catacombs of Carthus totally aren't copypasted corridors that show up again in Lost Izalith. Can't even do proper reanimating skellies with negromancers, they just waste your time by forcing you to kill them twice.or you can use blessed weapons, and the skeleton boulders can be defdeated by sniping the necromancers controlling them
>>751662464Wrong, if Demon's Souls was like Dark Souls III you'd finish 1-1 and then have the option to go to 1-2 or 2-1, but if you chose 2-1 it'd lead into 1-3 just like 1-2 would making the choice moot. Demon's Souls lets you basically tackle any of the archstones in any order you want after 1-1. I personally finished 4 first and then went to 5 before going back to 3 then doing 1 and finally 2 before finishing off the game. Dark Souls III just doesn't offer you that level of freedom of progression and it makes every replay fucking monotonous and boring which is why it has the least staying power of any game in the franchise. No one gives a fuck about Dark Souls III in the same way they care about Demon's Souls, Dark Souls, Dark Souls II, Bloodborne, ect. Once you've done it once there's nothing to revisit because its so damn linear, you can't rush different weapons to give yourself a new playstyle, because everything is so gated and locked off. They made Dark Souls III for the retard who quit Dark Souls because they went to New Londo or the Catacombs and got lost/stuck.
>>751662731I consider that linear.
>>751647868But enough about Bioshock infinite
>>751649331your reward is hoarding titanite chunks and nuking the rest of the game
>>751651370>DS1 never focused on combat difficultyDS1 tried. You think the Capra Demon was an accident or that the Black Knights weren't meant to kick your ass?Hell, O&S are legendary gatekeepers because they were such a hard combat challenge. Same with the 4 Kings. And doing Gwyn with no parries is a genuinely hard fight. Then you have Artorias, Manus, and Kalameet in the DLC.You literally can't beat DS1 without overcoming several hard combat challenge roadblocks. DS1 is not a puzzle game, you can actually skip most of the exploration, and there are few choices and consequences. DS1 is a game about its combat and cannot be beaten without glitches without going through several very hard combat challenges.
>>751659342DS3 is linear but has gimmicks and puzzles and harder enemies to offset its linearity.>there's a giant archer you can befriend and he helps or hinders you in areas near a white birch tree>there's a bridge you can destroy to kill a whole bunch of skeletons that are after you, and it turns into a bridge>you can bait skeletons and a mimic into killing a demon>there's a giant crossbow, you can use it to break open a shortcut, reveal an item, and kill a worm>there's enemies that reduce your max hp, but you can distract them with throwing knives, use a ring that silences your footsteps, a branch that transforms you into an object and spells that let you sneak past and get the drop on them>there's a dangerous enemy you can run past though a magic barrier, but it'll jump down and attack you later>a giant boss you need to destroy fragile weak spots on its body>a boss that generates many weak clones, which clever players can kill with throwing knives>a boss that's fighting itself>a boss that travels from one mob to another mob in a crowd>a boss you can kick the shield and guardbreak>a boss you need to break 3 bracelets to win, or you can also beat normally>a boss you need to plunging attack to win, or you can also beat normally>you can mute spellcaster bosses with a miracle>a boss you beat with a special weapon art, and if you free an NPC he'll use the weapon art with you>a boss that is on the back of another boss, so you are rewarded for hitting the rear
>>751664321To be fair that applies to DeS as well, although the boss gimmicks in DeS are much weaker and can be bypassed more easily.
>>751650706>you died a double digit number of times on bosses like the Nameless King, Nope>Sister Friede, Nope>Midir, Correct>or Gael.lol nope
>>751647998>>751649248>>751654748This. DS3 haters are always, always, ALWAYS DS2 who're trying to throw DS3 under the bus.
>>751663297>the almighty titan killer that can swing a giant 60kg slab of iron... gated by a wooden doorcan't all bosses just stop the murder hobo one by giving the key of their chambers to "the guard"?
>>751647998Linearity was never the problem.DeS was innovative and experimental game with unmatched atmosphere. It respected player's intelligence which was basically an antithesis to conventional AAA game design back then. Fromsoft and japan studio created this game in spite of what publisher was saying and it became a cult classic.Meanwhile, bamco basically forced fromsoft to make multiplat DaS reskin of Bloodborne. That doesn't sound this bad until you realize they also removed everything that made Bloodborne actually cool without introducing anything substantially new. Except for PvP, DS3 isn't particularly great at anything so it's the most forgettable souls game imofirekeeper is sex tho
>>751647914>Heh heh heh. I'll just place the key to the Grand Archives a the tip of this extruded and extremely narrow ledge on the roof, just how I do with so many other shiny items in this ga- aah AAAAAAAHHH!
>>751666901it's a special wooden door, the same they used on gas chambers.
>>751669036>unmatched atmosphereDS3 has the best atmosphere in any Fromsoft game.
>>751672432I played every souls game and I don't agree with this statement
>>751673830DS3 has the best sense of the world being cold, dead, and begging to be put out of its misery.
>>751662687Because you can get there before the corpse is there.
>>751647998Because DS3 is Bloodsouls: Darkborne Edition.They fucked a lot of things up too, like armors becoming actual fashion instead of actually offering protection, rollspam, more animefest fights, bonfire placements, no powerstancing unless allowed for a specific weapon, a whole lot of other things that ruin gameplay. Oh, and game missing silver knight sword, that irritated me to no end.The first time i played it, i kinda liked it. But on a subsequent playthrough i loathed it, and so dont bother playing it anymore.
>>751674460It's the least replayable soulsborne
>>751650706I didn't play the dlc because the game is garbage, and no boss took me more than 3 tries. I will admit tho that nameless king is one of the few ones that required me those 3 tries.In comparison, some Elden Ring bosses took me hours to beat. I played both games at release.
>>751674539One thing i will give DS3 - Follower's Javelin. I had a lot of fun with that weapon, even if its bad.
>>751674685Isn't that just a worse version of the throwable spear (or Messmer's spear) in Elden Nig?
>>751647998The fact that it took 9 replies for someone to mention that this is literally just incorrect is fucking pathetic. The people bitching and moaning don’t play these games.
>>751674724I have not played any souls game past DS3. I despise Elden Ring purely because its even worse slop than DS3.
>>751674797Then your opinion is of no value in discussions about the games as a whole
>>751674952Are you retarded or clinically autistic? Call it.
>>751647998>Demon Souls is entirely linear>5 different starting paths>fairly easy to get whatever gear you want without having to beat 75% of the game first the exact same way every time like DS3You DS3 secondaries are so bad at this, you must share DNA with FFXIII schizos