[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


I never played this one and heard it was bad. But is it really?
>>
If I'm not mistaken they basically removed failstates inbetween The Dark Descent and The Bunker, A Machine for Pigs and Rebirth are more like horror walking-sims.
>>
>>751651074
It's a walking sim adventure game. There is no attempt at horror, either mechanical or thematic, whatsoever. If you go into it with that knowledge, maybe it's not so bad?
>>
>>751651074
You're literally better off playing SOMA or even Penumbra if you haven't already played those next to this trash
>>
>>751651074
Pros
Alexanders homeworld
Workshop > Monke Island 1 & 2
Cons
Everything else.
>>
It's a textbook "protagonist never shuts the fuck up" modern game which is absolutely horrible for horror game immersion, and half the "scares" in this game are literal jpeg jump scares.
>>
>>751651074
It's pretty good, not great but still a good horror walking sim. I dint like Bunker but did like Machine for Pigs, Rebirth is more like Machine for Pigs with cosmic horror.
>>
>>751651074
>new writer
>new writer just had a kid
>new writer's brain conjures up the most revolutionary horror thought: "what if my kid... le died?"
>nobody ever thought of this before, we must make an entire game about this o algo
the main character being pregnant was unironically kind of interesting but they had to ruin even that by filling the game with unnecessary hamfisted pregnancy ""symbolism"" that was already done a million times better by Silent Hill 3 17 years earlier
visually it's good, it has decent atmosphere and the worldbuilding that expands on things from the previous Amnesia games is also somewhat interesting but it is by far the weakest of the series in my opinion
>>
>>751651074
It should be pretty cheap these days. It's not great, but I enjoyed it for what it was, with the exception for the pregnancy / birth giving scenes *blargh!*
>>
>protagonist never shuts the fuck up
>every puzzle and piece of worldbuilding is constantly and repeatedly explained to audience, zero sense of mystery
>set in 1930s, white feMC is knocked up by a feminist Muslim
>annoying constant flashbacks have gay couple ("awww they're so cute), heroic black man leading expedition, evil white chud in the party seething constantly
>levels weren't playtested, so dying just leads to you getting teleported to the end of the level
>obnoxious match/candle/lantern system + obnoxious insanity system (also not playtested)

the only upsides are beautiful scenery and the fact that all characters die horribly
>>
>>751651074
All the amnesia games are bad
>>
>>751651074
Penumbra black plague and the sequel are the only ones worth playing and this was in the drought of survival horror games in the late 2000s where it was basically Dead Space or indie steam games.
>>
>>751651074
better than a machine for pigs and bunker but shit compared to dark descent
>>
It's overhated.

The plot is pretty good, the world building is pretty well done, although maybe they go a little too far in explaining some things. They just really fucked up the actual game mechanics, but those are almost practically nonexistence for Amnesia games prior to The Bunker anyway.

If you like the other Amnesia games it's worth a play through. It's a great connection between The Bunker and TDD and explains a lot of things about The Bunker.
>>
>>751651074
It retcons the backstory of Amnesia a bit, isn't very scary since it takes place in the desert and not-Xen and the pregnancy mechanic is annoying.
Still, I'd give it a pirate if you liked A Machine for Pigs because it's a relatively short experience.
>>
>>751664971
just curious as to why you rate it better than bunker as that's almost universally rated very highly due to it having some actual gameplay and all killer no filler playthroughs. i'm not a rebirth hater either, I do enjoy the desert setting a lot actually and think it's a bit underused when it comes to horror games. interested to hear your thoughts.
>>
I hated it when it came out but I replayed it a few years ago and actually thought it wasn't as bad as I remembered. They had made some tweaks in the meantime too. I guess it benefits from going in with your expectations low.
>>
>>751651074
Drop this shit and play either amnesia the bunker or alien isolation, which are the good ones in that category. Good friendly advice.
>>
>>751665427
it's been a long fucking time so i dont recall exactly in details but i remember hating how repetitive and short it was. i also remember the creature being easy to deal with by virtue of having a gun which completely fucked the fear factor. also it was buggy as FUCK. i really liked the claustrophobic premise but the result was just sloppy
>>
>>751655193
Yeah penumbra 1/2 and soma are the shit. Forgot to mention them.
Afraid of monster, cry of fear and lost in vivo too OP, look it up.
>>
>>751661782
Already done by that dragon : cancer.
>>
>>751665603
You were playing in easy with lot of item spawn and reduced ai difficulty or something? And most of the glitches were ironed out because I didn't have any. Plus you can play it with randomizers so it's a great Halloween game to come back to after a year.
>>
>>751651074
Tried to play it after finishing Bunker, and couldn’t stomach the whiplash of going from a good game with actual gameplay mechanics to a game with basically none.
>>
>>751651074
I like how you can see the character's body so you can check out her boobs and pregnant belly
>>
>>751665603
that seems fair, i like guns in horror games even if they can't 100% kill due to feeling like the choice between fighting or running leaves me with uncertainty but if you game the system hard in bunker I totally can see how it feels sorta trivial to deal with the monster unless you're on shell shocked/random mode which wasn't out at launch
>>
File deleted.
It's dogshit dude. Totally boring, anticlimactic final boss, boring non-challenge "puzzles", walking simulator. I try to be charitable to games, but I felt like this one was a direct insult to me from all the time wasting "OoOOoOO something's gonna happen! For real this time!" moments that went nowhere. The script needed major, major revisions i.e. scrap the entire thing and use whatever sparse morsels of anything good are left over in the next draft. I heard the one set in the bunker is alright, I'd say go for that if you're feeling the Amnesia itch.
>>
File: tasi bare stomach.png (194 KB, 515x698)
194 KB PNG
>>751666010
modders at it again
>>
>>751651074
It is labeled as "the weaker one of the series" (saying this from memory years ago) but still good enough to enjoy it.
All Amnesia games are good by tradition, unless you don't like to read.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.