[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: images.jpg (25 KB, 523x382)
25 KB JPG
Describe a game that could realistically have matched this, and it doesn't mean temporary but rather permanently being rated a 99% with more reviews than this.
>>
Final Fantasy 7
>>
Grand Theft Auto VI
>>
>>751652676
It barely scored a 91 at the time, GoldenEye ended up with a 96% from the same year
>>
>>751652630
Hades 2 just last year had a score of 99 when it had 20~ reviews.
But naturally, its score went down with more reviews.

People need to start taking averages into account when boasting "highest rated game ever!1"
Because there are several games with more impressive scores than OoT. Mario Galaxy 2 being the obvious one.
>>
>MUH SCORES MUH SCORES
>MUH CHILDHOOD MUH CHILDHOOD
The reaction to the OoT remake has been fucking embarrassing from journos and gamers.
>>
>>751653262
It already had a 99.2% from the other site GameRankings with 35+ reviews at the time, so it doesn't matter.
>>
https://web.archive.org/web/20000707224055/http://www.gamerankings.com/itemrankings/singleitem.asp?Itemid=460
>>
>>751652630
Sonic 3K
>Zelda OOT shouldn't even be 99
The pacing of the water temple and backtracking to learn Saria's song is retarded. That alone brings down 5 points
>>
If FromSoft didn't rush Dark Souls it would have easily been a 99% rated game.
>>
>>751654787
The pacing of Sonic Triple K should have barred it from ever being released, has Sega/Sonic Team ever had a functioning QA team?
>>
>>751652676
Held back by turn based combat even at the time. Turn based combat was just seen as an abstraction of what a "real" battle would look like for lack of technology.

>>751654787
This is why it needs to always be seen in the context of the era a game came out in. Games being cryptic or requiring lengthy backtracking was not seen as a flaw in 1998. If anything it made them go "oh I get to experience more of the game before finishing? Splendid."
OOT was for all intends and purposes one of the very first 3D Open World games. Nowadays we'd consider the game largely linear with just a big open central hub.

So the OOT remake's score at 96 is more or less a reflection of what the game would be like by using current metrics and after removing the more cryptic aspects of the game. Would probably be closer to like 91 nor 89 had the cryptic aspects stayed in.
The fact that areas are now also much faster traversed due to 60fps, Link having a sprint and there being fewer loading zones also means that backtracking is much less of a problem as you can cross the entire map from end to end within 2 minutes (like I went the long trip from the Laboratory to Biggoron and it took me 150 seconds from Lake Hilya to the peak of Death Mountain)
>>
I've thought about this, and pretty much the reason OOT is so highly regarded (apart from being very good in almost every way), is it kind of has something for everyone.
>it's a very simple fairy tale type story that anyone can enjoy, and it's told well, for what it is
>it has just enough combat, just enough puzzling, and just enough exploration
>It has fun memorable characters, and great tunes. Spending time in the world is a fun time in itself.
>no part of it is too much. It's not too hard. It doesn't beat you over the head with stats and RPG mechanics. The cutscenes don't go on forever

If you theoretically want to dethrone it's status as "the best game ever", you need to find something that does all of that better. Which actually is very hard.
You can very easily walk in and say "Deus Ex and Planescape Torment", but those are strange, experimental games, for a very specific audience, and are maybe less consistent in terms of quality than OOT. Maybe they're a little more jank than OOT. Maybe they fall off in places.

The next best thing that comes to mind is maybe MGS3, but even that maybe loses people with the writing.
>>
>>751654787
Pretty sure you can learn Saria's song before you ever go to the Mountain. Just saying.
>>
>>751655350
MGS2 is literally better than 3
>>
>>751655432
It's not more crowd pleasing. That's a game for sickos, like me.
>>
Dead or Alive 2 with the online features that DOA4 implemented and seamless 3D Lobbies of PSO on the same system and a story mode (which was included in Dimensions) covering the first tournament and second tournament could have easily got a 98
>>
>>751655093
>>751654787
It wasn't cryptic, even the text/hint was colored according to the location you're supposed to go.
Also it's an adventure game with puzzles, if anything it says more about (You) than about the game.
It's not even really backtracking, they make full use of the whole world and there is a warp to the lost woods as well.

>how should've I've known?
Bitch, NPCs tell you and also you try stuff.
In the introduction dungeon you light up torches and get treasure, so you see some torches, a NPC mentions how the torches are supposed to be on and how the boss has a burning torch in his room. So you go and light up the torches. Two stone torches are in front of the fucking warp with an NPC going "hey, that music is sick"

This is you
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_u18_BKczg
>>
>>751652630
>22 reviews
This would probably be like 91 if it came out today with no nostalgia attached.
>>
>>751656365
More like 95 if I had to guess
>>
You must be below 75 iq if you take critic score seriously
>>
Literally any trash Reddit chooses could have this same score. It’s padded out by losers with nothing better to do
>>
No game ever will because the 99 score was biased

>only 22 reviews, only three of which are from contemporary magazines, all three of which are scored as 100s
>excluded magazines that scored Ocarina lower like Game Informer's 98 and Nintendo Power's 95 (whose reviews for other games were counted)
>included Famitsu's 10/10 even though Famitsu's reviews aren't counted for other games of the era
>GamePro is included as a 100 even though they actually gave Ocarina a 98
>the Cincinnati Inquirer review is included for some reason
>excluded tons of websites that scored Ocarina below 100 like NetJacks (whose reviews for other games were counted)
>included retrospectives written by outlets that didn't even exist until years after Ocarina released (like from 2005)
>included an outlet that reviewed the Japanese version and couldn't read the text so they just recommended the game but didn't score it, Metacritic counted that review as a 100
>>
Oblivion with grim+dark ambience, realistic faces, no level scaling and a bit more creative artstyle, sense of scale.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.