Why do they kill great trilogies with the third game?>movement is trash, one was betterSeriously you have to spend like an entire minute turning around while swimming, borderline usable on land but so bad.>story is retarded, choices are disconnected from anything you can decide as a player Took money from Emhyr? The adopted daughter all of a sudden thinks you're just doing it for the money. Fuck all the time they spent together with him raising her.Dijkstra trying to kill Roche in Geralt's presence? You sided with Roche? The north dies.Ciri's future? She either becomes a witcher (lol fucking why live like a scrub), empress or leaves her adoptive family behind because they chose not to be poor. I guess that makes sense because she wants to become a witcher for some reason.>equipmentAlmost all trash and not worth it, witcher school gear is underwhelming and costs so much it's easier just to get by with piecemeal found stuff until it's maybe time for grandmaster tier stuff. It also all looks pretty bad.
This criticism is valid, however even with all its flaws, W3 is easily the best in the trilogy.
>>751654905I'm loving it overall but there's so many awkward steps back from the previous 2 games. Still hate how it sets up the series to follow Ciri as a bitcher instead of finally letting us have a build-a-witcher in the past. Sapkowski made the future of the setting really lame.
>>751654645>witcher school gear is underwhelming and costs so much it's easier just to get by with piecemeal found stuff until it's maybe time for grandmaster tier stuffi had the semi-opposite experience honestly, except it was the Temerian, Nilfgaardian, Skellige armor sets. They were spaced so evenly throughout the game and their stats were so good for the level ranges you got them in in the world that there was basically no point in clown suiting with random pieces of gear when you could just buy those and be set for the next 10-15 hours. Made all the loot in the world completely pointless because I just sold it all immediately
>>751655775It gets way too easy after Act 1. Regretting picking normal difficulty but if I was forced to put together a build it would probably be about the same difficulty anyway.
>>751655358When it came out, the randomized useless loot, Ciri's segments, the endings, alongside the massive graphical downgrade scandal, were the main criticisms.None are fixed to this day.
>>751656118>Ciri's segmentsThis shit is so prevalent in video games nowadays.>spend all game learning combat as one character>out of nowhere total gameplay changeIn here it's particularly bullshit because I finally learn how to use teleports to get around being attacked and keep offense up by just teleporting behind people. Of course during the Kaer Morhen siege it doesn't work and even if you appear behind someone their attack still hits and earlier than it would normally!I still don't understand the downgrade, it honestly looked faked and like it wouldn't run at good enough framerates on then-current hardware. People are mad they didn't get the impossible.
>>751656359>it honestly looked faked and like it wouldn't run at good enough framerates on then-current hardwareBut it did run on current hardware and the E3 demo was in realtime. The biggest aspect of it was Global Illumination being killed in favor of flat lightning and meshes, shaders being simplified. Both for console parity.There were mods that reinstated most of the changes shortly after release, and there was barely any FPS hit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ro2Bwyn-Is4Vid related still looks better in some ways than the re-remaster out now after 13 years
>>751656359>People are mad they didn't get the impossibleGamers are fucking stupid and forgot the Killzone 2, the Alien Colonial Scam, Watch Dogs, arguably Bioshock Infinite and other lies that taught the following lessons1. Never trust a single thing a publisher/developer releases before the release2. Never feel excitement3. Never tell a woman how you really feel and that you want a lifelong relationship built on the foundation of trust
>>751656478>13 fps during the start where he rides a horse aroundYou've got to be shitting me. At least post a vid with the changes restored mod running at a decent cap.Anyway we'll never get any of this without gay tracing now. We used to have these techniques but Nvidia literally paid people to stop using the old techniques and force it all. They basically won over AMD through shady practices after the x1900 beat Nvidia the fuck out all the way back then and it's just been downhill ever since for gaming as a whole.>>751656609>1. Never trust a single thing a publisher/developer releases before the releaseUh huh. Honestly even before any of these this was pretty evident.>2. Never feel excitementTrue.>3. Never tell a woman how you really feel and that you want a lifelong relationship built on the foundation of trustDamn video games could have saved me time?
>>751656750The choppiness is not low fps, it's because the video is upscaled from the original with horrible encoding at the time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdinzNN93-MIf you think CDProjektRed had some ultra-secret NASA computer more powerful than current HW running this demo or that it would be more demanding than shitty raytracing, I don't know what to tell you.
>>751657107No, I don't think they had supercomputers just still not trusting pre-release footage. Also it doesn't look better at a glance (compared to remaster I'm currently playing) but the video has a pretty bad resolution so it's not exactly easy to see details.The one thing I can agree is the footage of voyage at sea I once saw definitely looked a lot better so they definitely nerfed water.
>>751654645in a perfect world we would have gotten the perfect w3 remake by now where they fix the dijkstra/ roche story, flesh out the wild hunt and skellige and rework the combat completelybut here we are enjoy the "remaster"
>>751658254In a perfect world we'd get the pre-release graphics while consoles got fucked over. On top of that we'd also have a sensible movement system that wasn't redone 3 times only to still end up dogshit. Alas, >tries to rotate in water in you're pathGotta admit, the remaster is at least somewhat of an improvement and they didn't try to remake Witcher 1. Imagine the shitshow, not one titty card in sight.
>>751658254I think Skellige should've been DLC.Write out all main quest content from skellige, expand the other city whose name escapes me that serves almost fuck all other than optionally visiting Baron's daughter and repurpose the content there.
>>751659058What was wrong with Skellige?
>>751654645Retard. It's obvious you didn't play TW2.
>>751654645>Took money from Emhyr? The adopted daughter all of a sudden thinks you're just doing it for the money.It's almost as if Emhyr specifically set up the situation to make it look like that to manipulate her or something....
>>751660476>Geralt, not the step dad but the dad that stepped up>Emhyr, the psychopath who disowned his own daughter until it was time to secure succession of the throne>Ciri, the femoid that gets easily manipulated by Emhyr into thinking Geralt raised her and then saved her just for a big payoutIt's like pottery
>>751660378It's been 20 years since I played W2, I've forgotten everything so I'm inclined to believe it's actually better than 3.
>>751661453>stealth section>useless traps>QTEs>Potion duration running out mid-dialogue>The shitty roll>Console UIAnd assuming you played it on launch>Unskippable cutscenesTo reiterate, retard.
>>751661570>stealth sectionThere was at least one in W3>useless trapsOk so don't use them?>QTEsI like QTEs. Uncs get filtered because they're slow.>Potion duration running out mid-dialogueKek. Was making potions even a problem in that one? I played W1 recently and there you have to just make them every time instead of refilling.>The shitty rollNo idea, it's been 25 years.>Console UITbh that also goes for W3>Unskippable cutscenesThat's the only that's truly bad.>you're retarded because you forgot a game that came out 30 years and never replayedWhat got sand in your vagina, anon?
>>751661720>Was making potions even a problem in that onethe problem was drinking potions because, unlike Witcher 1, you have to drink while kneeling in Witcher 2
>>751660243its the least done map by farthey just added a bunch of sunk treasures and called it a day
>>751661720>There was at least one in W3No there isn't.>Ok so don't use them?Missing the point retard. A gameplay feature being useless isn't a good thing.>I like QTEs. Uncs get filtered because they're slow.For the third time, retard.>Kek. Was making potions even a problem in that one? I played W1 recently and there you have to just make them every time instead of refilling.Potion making wasn't the problem you troglodyte, the problem was not being able to drink potions without meditating, which you couldn't do in combat.>Tbh that also goes for W3Not even remotely close to TW2's UI where you could only see 6 items at a time>What got sand in your vagina, anon?Retarded faggots like you giving your worthless opinions.