Kind of insane how Ocarina of Time "fixes" every complaint i had about Breath of the Wild>side content is worth engaging with because the rewards are useful>the world is smaller, but feels more alive because its packed with content everywhere you go>weapons dont break>dungeons are huge and each feels like its own major adventure instead of an optional single room with one puzzle in it>it actually has a story and charactersDid they forget how to make good Zelda games?
>Did they forget how to make good Zelda games?Nintendo forgot how to make good games in general. That's why they make so many remakes and remasters now.
I only play old Zelda games
>>751664136>>weapons dont breakAre you retarded?
>>751664136BOTW/TOTK introduce some good concepts (larger size world, more NPCs) but classic Zelda is a better template to follow.
>>751664136You forgot to mention that it also has a legendary soundtrack unlike breath of the dogshit
>>751664294Yes he is don't bother engaging with it
>>751664294When do your weapons break in OoT?
>>751664136>Did they forget how to make good Zelda games?They put Aonuma in charge because he was the least likely to use the position in the company to fight for a position on the company ladder and when he stepped back after TP Miyamoto ran the team through intense crunch that steamrolled over most of their creative input just to release Link's Crossbow Training. You can really see the decline in quality going from TP to SS just in terms of the amateurish mistakes they started making, there was either a significant turnover or everyone burnt out.The Zelda team has been reduced to a bunch of people with no initiative being directed by people who usually have some expectation that they don't need to hand-supply every single idea that goes into the product to the point that they are no longer self-sufficient and need to rely on outsourcing.
>>751664136>side content is worth engaging with because the rewards are usefulWhat are you talking about, Anon? Just with the three starting hearts, the hearts that bosses drop, and the items you'll inevitably collect as you progress through the game, you'll already have a great chance of finishing the entire game without dying a single time. That's how easy OOT is.The game's side content won't give you anything truly useful, it'll just inflate a few numbers to give you the illusion that you're making progress. As far as I recall, only the masks side-quest will provide extra content in the form of lore.
>>751664837Answered it myself: Giant's Knife. I always forget that weapon exists.
>>751664136We don’t have the technology anymore
Breath of the Wild is the CandyCrush of Zelda games.
>>751664136Just wait until you experience Tears of the Kingdom, Zelda peaked there.
The erroneous lesson they took from the decline in the popularity of the series is that people were sick of the "zelda formula". They weren't. They were sick of gimmicks that ruined the games added out of this fear of people becoming fatigued. People hated wolf sections because they were tedious and changed the moment to moment gameplay in a way that was straight-up worse. People hated Skyward Sword because the entire world was sick of waggling by that point. They threw the baby out with the bathwater to chase the open world meme, and while they found success with that they certainly didn't find anything approaching a Zelda game.With any luck, the OoT remake will be successful enough to teach Nintendo this same lesson. Stop putting fucking trains and shit into the game out of some unfounded fear of losing appeal to an audience that is here for the very thing you're inexplicably eschewing.
>>751664136>>side content is worth engaging with because the rewards are usefulFedEx quests...
>>751664136>side content is worth engaging with because the rewards are usefulIt's not, and the rewards aren't. The main reward you get from exploring is heart pieces you'll never need because no enemy in OoT can hit anyone with a pulse, unlike BotW.>dungeons are huge and each feels like its own major adventure instead of an optional single room with one puzzle in itHoly shit, you desperately need to play any other conventional Zelda. OoT's dungeons are minuscule and far too simplistic to offer any semblance of challenge.There are individual Shrines in BotW that require more brain power than entire dungeons in OoT
>>751665990>tp>declining salesRetard.And SS also sold really fucking well but was cut sort by how late on the wiis deathbed they released it.
>>751665880TOTK is a valley, not a peak.
>>751664136shit tier inventory remains
>>751665990Wait, do you OoTFags genuinely believe the majority of people hate Breath of the Wild...?It's undoubtedly the most popular modern Zelda game.
>>751664136>weapons dont breakAre you just pretending deku sticks and giants knives don't exist?
>>751666571>pretending deku sticks are weaponsNigga.
>>751666402Oh, so they had even less of a reason to go chasing trends instead of sticking to what made their series good! Thanks for making my argument for me, now go dilate.>>751666514>while they found success with that
>>751666603they do four times as much damage as the kokiri sword, and you have like 40 of the son bitches
>>751664136The problem is Aonuma gets bored easily and goes too far in the opposite direction of precedent. I love Breath of the Wild but I don't want another open world checklist game from this seriesBut yeah it's clearly obvious that based on the remake's success that people miss this format and want it back
>>751666612>they certainly didn't find anything approaching a Zelda game
>>751666514Where the fuck did you get that from? Did you read the post you're replying to? He said it was successful. He just said it wasn't much like Zelda.
>>751666643>they do four times as much damage as the kokiri swordOnly an autistic fucking sperg would know this.Real human beings use the sword because its a fucking sword.
>>751666675Well yes, BotW is not a Zelda game and BotW: Nuts and Bolts is even less so.
>>751666663Sure you do, you enjoyed 100% Ocarina of Time after all.
>>751664864>You can really see the decline in quality going from TP to SS just in terms of the amateurish mistakes they started makingName one
>>751666687It's the most Zelda the series ever has been.
I don't consider the Deku stick to be a "breakable weapon" in the sense that BOTW has them because I can carry 40 identical ones and that's that, the three "normal" weapons the game offers are all simple unbreakable options.
>>751666693They're nice to use in a no-hit run.
>>751666830>no-hit run>of fucking OoTAutistic fucking sperg.
>>751666785Sorry, no. "Zelda" does not mean "100 bite sized puzzles you can do in any order". Even Zelda 1 went out of its way to have multiple instances of needing to find an item in one place in the world to progress in another.
>>751666762They made the combat deeper for one. Zelda isn't about combat, it's about puzzles.
>>751666856You're just salty you could never pull it off.
>>751666785Yeah, what anon said. Zelda means 100 bite sized puzzles you have to do in order. Even Zelda 1 had bite sized puzzles you had to do in order.
>>751666693>real human beings never once saw that they could use the stick to attack and actually tried it on an enemy>real human beings don't notice how fast enemies die?
>>751666942Yes. What you're describing is your own fucking 'tism. I use the sword because its a sword and its on the big green button on the screen.>>751666903I could never pull it off cause I can't imagine myself wasting my time on a fucking no-hit run of a videogame. I wanna play the fucking game and go on a cool adventure, not stroke my e-peen over how good I am at dodging attacks in an E-rated game.
>>751667112>press button once to see it swings>oh it's used like a weapon, and it has bigger reach>you have the tism and you should ONLY be attacking with the swordProjection.
>>751667209>>you have the tism and you should ONLY be attacking with the swordYes.
>>751666942Probably not desu. Anything besides bosses that early in the game dies in one or two swings of the sword, so my concern for running out of sticks to light torches would probably outweigh my desire to use them for direct damage.
>>751667234It sounds like you are currently displaying a common trait of autism known as black and white thinking. Because the sword is a sword, you strongly believe nothing else should be used to attack for any reason that it doesn't strictly have to be. That is autism.
>>751667329Did knights fight with sticks or swords?
I enjoyed botw and totk, but OOT blows them both out of the water. I never grew up playing OOT so I don't have much nostalgia with it other than watching videos online. The main thing I like about it is how much more grounded it feels.
>>751667372Doesn't matter to how I play this video game, because it's more autistic to apply outside rules of what a character's equipment "should be" to a random game than it is to let the game speak for itself. They let me attack with sticks. I noticed that things died faster to them than the sword. You are having a fit over this. You have autism.
>>751667471>word saladAnswer the question, little man.
>>751666352don't insult the oot snoys
>>751667524It doesn't matter. Link fights with both.
The only good Zelda's are OoT, Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess
>>751667664Include some of the 2D ones at least, dude. Eagle Tower is one of the best dungeons in the series, bare minimum.
>>751667585>doesn't matter IT DOESNT MATTER OKAYlol
>>751665309>he doesn't know about the item trading sidequest that gets you the Biggoron Sword
>>751664228fpwp
>>751667739>it matters to your choices in this specific game what equipment "knights" in general fight withautism
>>751666514>dude, this game is obviously better because after 20 years of good games building our reputation we finally released a massive budget game in the era of everyone is a gamer and totally sold more than we did before when we released games during the era of nobody but a loser is a gamerThis logic is how we get shit like ToTK or Pokemon Scarlet and Violet. Wow, more people bought this game than bought previous game, nevermind that the market cap for previous game was only x and now it is y
>>751667864If it doesn't matter, then just answer the question anon.
>>751667909Usually swords, spears, axes, hammers, or something else with a handle and at least a somewhat pointy bit.
>>751668104>Usually swordsThank you.
>do the spirit temple>fight the twin grannies>they fusion together for phase 2>my dick when
>>751668128Like I said, you'd have to have autism to let this affect your gameplay choices.
Why is 2d Zelda so much more unpopular than 3d Zelda? You look at the sales of all the handheld games and despite them having a big install base no one seems to care. Link's Awakening remake did decent and EoW did much worse. Meanwhile 2d Mario would regularly outperform 3d Mario. And Metroid Dread became the best selling Metroid game.
>>751664136Darksiders 2 is Zelda but better
>>751666762>All voiced text boxes remain on screen until the text has finished scrolling, generally 10 seconds per box>Almost all hints are auto-deployed>Game displays pick-up hints after every fresh boot>Default UI is a literal Wiimote on the side of the screen, minimal UI just removes the Wiimote overlay>Several unused buttons, but no quick use hotkeys>Can't slash sword while running around>Game can't come up with real justifications for why you are doing anything, it constantly relies on fiat explanations and minigame logic even weaker than what WW and TP relied on>Aggressively linear and transparently padded progression through 3 areas that is structured more like 1/3rd of a 3D Mario game, not a Zelda game, including structuring every visit to an area like you are attempting to find a Star>No day/night cycle>Basic traversal of 3D environment is extremely rigid and forcefully optimized due to stamina flowers needing to be picked up whenever you run or climb anywhere, demonstrating less understanding of how to structure 3D gameplay than Mario 64>Completely achiral input device, no option to switch to left-hand mode>2 year delay, still lacking in contentShit I failed, I can't name just one
>>751668457>shills will read a well thought out post like this and think it's just a hater instead of a life long fan upset that one of his favorite franchise is going to shitand this is why they're all going to shit
>>751664136I was thinking the same thing while playing the remake. It is much more dense in content and just feels more satisfying to play. It really makes the flaws of the BOTW design stand out. At the same time, OOT also feels really small now when compared to modern games. BOTW does a better job of making it feel like you are going on a journey and actually covering significant distances. Future games should really think harder about why both games work and what should be emphasized in a new game. I would personally abandon the BOTW's design of giving you everything and letting you go anywhere from the start since I think that is the root of the problem. However, that also means having some faith that your players will be able to recognize real road blocks that are impassible with their current equipment from puzzles that need to be solved. It also depends on your designers being able to make the distinction between those two clear enough so the player will know when to give up.
>>751667747tbf i never used giants knife and ive 100%'d twice
>>751668697Nah, shills will read a post like this and tell you with a straight face that all of this is actually OoT's fault so BotW was justified in throwing out the whole formula
>>751664136The only hope I had for this demake was to see it make people wake up and realize that Zelda was once more than some generic lazy ubislop game.
>>751664136>Kind of insane how Ocarina of Time "fixes" every complaint i had about Breath of the WildIt's more that Breath of the wild forsakes everything that makes Ocarina of time good in favor of it's own strengths. (being pretty soild open world sloppa, which people seem to like i guess.)
>>751668457Holy fucking based. the person you're replying to is a retarded faggot who just got obliterated by facts.
>>751665990>TP sucked because X>WW sucked because Y>SS sucked because ZWhy do you retards act like each Zelda doesn't have a big cult following? A following that has no problem admitting it's better than OoT.TP has sold more than any individual version of OoT.
>>751669494WW, TP, and SS represent a fairly clear trend of Aonuma being progressively less able to keep up with the game he's nominally been making sequels to the whole time.
>>751669494>TP has sold more than any individual version of OoT.And it's still worse than OoT MM by a considerably margine. TP was a honey pot. People thought they were going back to oot and they were tricked. Also it launched simutainiously with new hardware. It was one of the only worthwhile games for wii at launch.
>>751664136Bros, I need to confess something: I fucking hate dungeons. Maybe hate is strong word, but if the options are hanging out in the colorful overworld where the music is catchy and cheerful and pushing blocks in a dark room with ambient music, I choose the overworld any day of the week. I'm glad shrines are single room affairs because that's about as long as I care to be in a dreary, sterile enviornment. If my Zelda playthrough ends prematurely it is mostly likely at the start of a dungeon, dreading the next 45 minutes of lock and key monotony. I think a lot of it just comes down to the themeing, especially in older 3D titles where you weren't getting much in the way of environmental design other than a flat box with blown out textures. At least 2 of the Child era dungeons have interesting themeing in the Great Deku Tree and Lord Jabu-Jabu's belly, the rest I can take or leave.
>>751669671I must be seeing things, because I think what you wrote is that dungeons and shrines have the same level of atmosphere. That's so obviously nonsense that I think I'll extend the benefit of the doubt and assume it's a typo.
>>751669902I'd rather spend 5 minutes in a featureless dev room than 45 minutes in a dungeon that looks like this and sounds like this.https://youtu.be/B4JTOabD4jASorry, bro.
>>751670237But that looks and sounds kickass. What is the problem?