>game has medieval setting>actually there's high tech
>game set in a different universe from our own>gets mad when its different from medieval europe
>>751673652>Magitek setting>Medieval setting with guns or generic sci-fi setting with crystal guns
that's an interesting question, would there be a need for technology if magic is a thing? like what's the difference
>>751674475Technology is the equalizer for the people who can't do magic.
>Game has classical setting>They perform a D-Day style assault
>>751673652That's every single asian-made medieval fantasy game, they can't help themselves
>>751673652its realistic
>>751673652Might and Magic? Wizardry?
>>751673652https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0_bnnaHwSAThe Sothisverse has done irreparable damage to Fire Emblem
>>751673652>fantasy setting>has niggers
>>751673652It's funny because the idea was to avoid falling into the eternal medieval trope, but a bunch of talentless hacks all had the same idea at the same time so now we have a bunch of this shit being produced.Then in a few years we'll get an abundance of eternally medieval because they're all stupid cunts and follow trends.
>>751673652>the dragon is a starfighter pilotkino of the highest order
>>751673652
>>751676267Queen's Domain that I'm currently playing, all of a sudden you find out there's an ancient world with tech.
>>751673652>game introduces high tech almost immediately >years later people still insists the game is set in a medieval setting and high tech breaks the "canon"
>>751673652>game has 1120s medieval setting>immediately see 1520s armorWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW
>>751677936yeah I'm ok with that
>He doesn't like fantasy with rocket launchersWhat's it like having shit taste?
>Game features fluted armour>People insist it is set in a medieval setting
>>751678182
>>751678182>game is set in medieval 1295>immediately see a knight wearing a bascinet with an aventail instead of a great helm over a mail coif WOAHKAY I GUESS WE JUST DON'T CARE ANYMORE HUH
>game promises thrilling sci-fi space adventures>immediately dumps you on a dull, formulaic medieval jarpig planet
>>751679123Source? Is this the one with the courier elf with nice legs?
>>751673652Holy shit taste, fantasy with sci fi elements is peak, from Shining Force to classic Final Fantasy.
>>751679123ENTER
>>751674475People are retards that can't study shit now despite having infinite tools at their fingertips. Look at how people are paying $20/mo + tip to claude to make newbie projects that they could just learn to do for free in honestly a lot of the same timespanAny setting with magic you have to learn is going to have people that'd rather just have a gun than to spend time learning firebolt
>>751679424The one and only.
>>751679464I don't think it's bad, I just don't like when it starts fantasy and all of a sudden there's le tech
>>751674526in other words, for heathens
>>751674475Magitek is for common people as proper magic usually tends to be out of reach for the average person
>>751673652This has been part of fantasy for a long ass time. D&D did it too.
Star Ocean 3
>>751675390>>751673652That's actually a lot of WRPGs too, especially the really early ones. Like that Ultima game where you go into space in a fucking space shuttle. Or the first Might and Magic game where you find out the world is just a giant space station managed by a tech guy.
>>751681036>for a long ass timeConan was one of the earliest pulp sword and sorcery stories back in the 1930's, and some of his stories already had sci-fi elements like aliens, high tech stuff being mistaken for magic, alien tech, etc.
>>751681370Star Ocean is always both since the first game
>>751681370but star ocean 3 starts as a sci fi, star ocean 1, 2 (if you choose to play as Rena), 5 and 6 (if you choose Laeticia) are the ones that starts as medieval fantasy
>>751673652>game is set in the far future with advanced hypertechnology>all screens and audio recordings are low quality with the world's thickest scanlines and xbox live tier audio compression
i have seen some people said that the Xenoblade games are that, but the first thing you fight in the first game is a crab that was inside of a mech lmao
>>751681542>Like that Ultima gameThe very first one, pic related. As already stated in this thread, this was common. Sci-fi and fantasy were both nerd stuff being published in pulp magazines, I think the strict separation of both is relatively recent, as in, the last few decades. So you have Ultima, Might and Magic, Wizardry, Final Fantasy, D&D, Dying Earth, Conan, Thorgal... tons of stuff in the past century mixed fantasy with sci-fi, but also the other way around with Star Wars being the most famous, where they mix sci-fi with fantasy.>>751681036I mentioned Conan, but in writing my other reply I remembered that D&D copied its magic system from Jack Vance's dying Earth. That series takes place in what looks like a low tech medieval world full of magic, but it's actually in the far future when Earth's Sun is dying, and all magic is just ancient lost advanced technology
>>751675320> D-Day style assaultWhat do you mean? Like throwing a massive human wave against a wall of spears ?
>>751673652>lost ancient civilization>sci-fi metal corridors with neon lights and floaty bits
>>751682004Xenoblade is very explicitly a post apocalyptic setting. In 1, life grows atop Titans and said Titan will regularly exterminate all life and renew the cycle. So whatever new life arises well have no idea what the techno beep boops are even for. XC2 trades a lot of little apocalypses for one big apocalypse and the setting is atop the clouds that hides the ruined mega cities before and the space stations above. XC3 is an apocalypse that has been on pause for thousands of years. You can't allow time to progress since if you do then you march towards False Vacuum Decay and everyone just dies unless you build an impossible machine to save you.
>>751679424>>751679827What's the name of it?
>>751677129this image never made sense, yet chuds keep spamming it for years
>>751682362>pretends to not understandyeah we know
>>751676646>see the teaser trailer for FW>looks like absolute shite>pre-order and forget about it>random package arrives at my house>ignore it for months>pop it in a couple of weeks ago>mfw the prologueWhat the fuck am I even watching? I say watching because DAMN, there's like zero gameplay in this shit holy fuck, I'm almost at the end of my first route (Cai's) and it feels like I haven't done anything. The game has the "freedom" of a hub and a world map, but it still feels completely on-rails, like I (the player) have genuinely zero input on what the fuck is going on and the maps/battles are Sesame Street-tier. No joke, those fucking Mario x Rabbid games had more SRPG gameplay than this piece of fucking VN shit. I wouldn't be surprised if the next entry in the franchise is just Fire Emblem: Venus Vacation
>Medieval-Fantasy setting>Ancient technology with blue LEDs>Randomly disappears in the sequel and everybody in-universe forgets it existed>Replaced with an even ancient-er technology with turqoise LEDs>
>>751683051Game?
>>751683051AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAalso>ancient-er tech and temples are "lost" >2 minute walk from the main hub, out in the open
>fantasy game with dragons, swords, magic, etc.>ancient dungeon has "ancient tech" from thousands of years in the past>its all futuristic shit like rayguns and mechas and nanotechnology amor, and ai
>>751682362you might be retarded
>>751683051Bonus points if you have blatantly cannibalized tech, degradering its usefulness while still being eons ahead of the native tech level.
>>751683193Its more fun when you can't just cobble it back together.
>game has high tech setting>there is only medieval technology
i wish more medieval games just had gunpowder in them.
these are all cool ideas why are you fags so against it
>>751683395wuuuut
Is there a single game where the "sci fi" reveal kills the fantasy retards with technology and the power of friendship doesn't prevail against lasers and guns?
>>751673652>medieval>except its not medieval>its renaissance - an early modern eraPeople need to get educated.
>>751683395I'll do you one better>game has medieval setting>there's ancient technology, but it's limited and generally inaccessible by the majority populace>the majority populace are depicted as mongoloids who never developed medieval-style technology that could actually be just as dangerous and all they do is use swords and maybe a bow here and thereI really don't get why games in particular ignore how much weird and fucking scary shit that people in that era developed. Full blown slingshots are scarier to me than any glock or laser pistol.
>>751679424Yes
>>751682326The Dragon, the Hero, and the Courier
>>751683489Harvestella has an ending where you do this.
>>751673652>use crossbows, power armor, robots, and teleportation in a medieval setting>board enemy ships for melee combat with axes and shields in a sci-fi settingTake the Vaulter pill. Become ungovernable.
>Game has fantasy setting>Find "ancient relic" that's clearly modern day tech>Go into a deep cave/temple find a ruined real world cityLove that shit
>>751683489https://youtu.be/GUbLlXHMPoI
>>751673652>medieval setting>""""magic"""" is just sci-fi powers like summoning what are basically lasers or black holes
>the world was on a spaceship
>>751683818You forget that the "crossbows" shoot plasma bolts, axes have molecular edge technology and can cut like a nippon steel katana folded over billion times, shields have repulsor fields, and other high-tech shit in a very simple wrap. Also, mind you, Vaulters left Auriga in cryo sleep. No time to develop refined bits of tech - if it works, it works, be it a plasma bolt or ordinary steel bolt.As much as i like them, they are annoying to play with.
>>751673652>game has medieval setting>go into "ancient civilization" ruins>they had the same level of technology as you
>>751674475Not everyone can use magic.
>>751684081>the world is a simulation running on a computer orbiting last dying black hole
>>751673652fire emblem just got ruined by this
>>751674475Yes, because you still need a mill to grind that wheat, you still need to lift heavy things, you still need a kettle to boil water.Just because there is magic, doesnt mean technology will be absent. It will be present, and it will use magic.
>>751684161The problem with the Agarthans is that they were written like super retards, not that they existed.
>>751683051>>751683129Zelda BotW and TotK
>>751683489Shin Megami Tensei 4, the fantasy place becomes completely irrelevant very early on and most of the game is fighting in Tokyo with guns and Mad Max armor
Any games where you discover an ancient civilization with advanced technology and they're alive and well and just chillin'. They're not evil or anything, they just left the "mainland" to get away from everybody else.
>>751684125https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FKcxyCTDW1A
>>751684090I can see the logic from a writing perspective. As technology increases in scale, you'll inevitably reach the FTL combat wall. Where if you have a projectile that can hit and destroy a target before they even have a chance to react, then that's all combat will ever boil down to. But if you want futuristic looking shit then you have to manufacture a reason why you'd have an exchange of blows that looks impressive without devolving into FTL combat. So swords become laser katanas. Shields become hardlight structures. Etc
>>751673971Literally me, fuck Fortune's Weave.
>game has fantasy medieval setting >later on is revealed that all the magic is just very advance technology >the final twist is that the technology is powered by advance magic powers
>>751673652I hate that shit, and Korean games seem to do it most.
>>751674475>what's the differenceThere isn't any half the time. If you accept that magic is something that can be studied and researched, then it would be logical to assume that someone would also build devices specifically designed to reliably channel magic in a certain way. So technology would still exist, but it would be augmented with magic.A magic system is just an extra natural science the world can build around, and magitek is just technology that exploits that magic science. Instead of using gunpowder to fire a bullet you just assemble magic rune rocks in such a way that a fireball comes out. Or you'd use it to launch a bullet more efficiently. So either way you'd have guns or something gun-adjacent.Magic would just solve things normal tech is bad at doing while normal tech would support magic at things it is bad at doing. Kinda like how in the real world we have different means of transporting and using energy depending on what you need.
>>751682186I think he means the absurd beach landing scene from Ryse: Son of Rome https://youtu.be/K8xgufvK3Lw
>>751673652Actually, that's kino.
>>751679123This is exactly how the average 'historical accuracy fan' behaves whenever a trailer for literally any kind of loosely medieval inspired game comes outand every single time the developers end up wasting time and effort trying to placate autists who never wanted to play the game in the first place
>>751684287You're not wrong but the problem is that the tech the Agarthans have has trouble scaling with the general setting. You have a group of people who can shapeshift, teleport, create portals to alternate dimensions, and thanks to clarification by FW we now know they're connected to an orbital satellite and receive instructions from fantasy Grok. At some point the fact the Agarthans are always on the back foot or are forced into guerilla warfare becomes distracting
>>751684287it's that they existed with orbital space cannons, actually
>>751683051I hate TotK's plot so much bros. Single lamest thing they could've done for the sequel desu.
>>751673652I normally hate it but older games like Might and Magic and Wizardry stuck a nice balance. A good modern example is Final Fantasy 14 from ARR to Endwalker where it also strikes a nice balance. Dawntrail gets too stupid with it.
>game has futuristic sci fi setting >discover an ancient civilization >they had classic medieval technology
>>751675320I think I know what you are talking about. Is it the Roman invasion of Britain in Ryse of Rome?
>>751684831>Crazy advanced tech from another dimension with nano machines and the ability to teleport an entire megacity>Loses a war in one battle to Mexicans with sticks
>>751684413this reveal was always cool as fuck. more games need this
>>751673652Just like this one.>a fucking motorbikehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjdnXBQFc5o
>>751685132The Mexicans empower themselves with magic even as something blunt like warriors, we went over this with Eorzea VS Garlea already
but what if we combine both?
>>751685536>What if we went full RETARD with it?ftfy
>>751681769Who's that lady?
>>751673652that's kino though
>>751673652>>751673652>The Gods are fucking machines againhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jij16d0jn9Q
>>751679827And then you see how barely usable it was in KCD2
>>751673652A modern trend is fantasy RPGs having gunz.Atlyss, Outward, Avowed and Crimson Desert.Gunz are all the hype.I guess you can't say it's stupid when magic exists but it feels weird.
>>751674475>would there be a need for technology if magic is a thing?Why not? If magic is a real thing in the universe then you'd theoretically be able to figure out how to channel it without trained mages needing to be a thing outside of specific circumstances.If you can make it so that Thunder can be controller and can summon it to charge something then why not supply batteries with it? Or create some sort of device that can take advantage of it?If you can cast Fire why not figure out how that happens and utilize it to create an object that summons it in a forge scenario?If you can cast Blizzard why not create some perpetual freezer by constantly calling on how it works?If you can cast Esuna why not just sell consumable Esunas instead of needing to forage for items necessary to make Remedies?If you can cast Curaga why not just sell the equivalent of X-Potions for a significantly lower cost of production?Unless getting the magic into a usable form for non-mages is wildly expensive (Like, the materials are as complicated as making a semiconductor or something) technology would in general replace mages for the most part. That's doubly true if it can be done as a scientific process instead of how mages do it.
>>751673652Or even worse>game setting has access to firearms and magic>there are also many different magical artifacts and enchantments>DESPITE this, every army in the game (minus big bad evil empire) uses exclusively shitty iron swords and nothing else>cant even have them also use swords with better materials or basic enchantments or anythingIf the tools are there, then why the hell do they never let the characters use them? Putting them into the world exclusively for the main character is retarded.
>>751685660keri sable iirc
>>751674475Real answer is that if magic existed in the middle ages technology would have developed far differently than what we made with muskets, trains and boats. It's just laziness to have "lol gunz lmao" when real technological development didn't have to take magic into account.
>>751673652>game has a medieval setting>women are inexplicably placed in positions of power or in physical occupations or as soldiers/fighters of some sort>browns are inexplicably present and tolerated without questionits all so tiresome
>>751673652>Game has medieval fantasy setting>Actually there are hostile, autonomous, sci-fi mechs that guard the ruins of destroyed ancient civilizations using nuclear weapons, and you defeat them in honorable melee combat because you are just that badass
>>751686070Looks like it is, thanks!
>>751673652>fantasy setting with magic>somehow no industrial revolution or plumbing infrastructurethis always gets me. magic should make gathering fossil fuels easier, no outright ignored. and i refuse to believe a world where people can shoot lightning out of their hands still can't invent a lightbulb or a basic toilet.
>>751683818Legend of Galactic Heroes did that because of the danger of hull breaching and because most ship have defense system that deploys reactive gas that instantly explode when any energy/gunpowder weapons is fired.
>>751686240innovation and invention are the direct results of necessity or greed. there are no exceptions.firearms were invented to solve the problem of high quality armor making the kingdom with enough knights and knight-level armored soldiers unbeatableif magic existed, no stressor would be present to cause this. therefore, guns are practically incompatible with any setting that has magic, because magic is the guns of the setting
>>751673652Yeah, I hate Nasu. Everything has mechas or AY Lmaos. >The greek goods? Mechas!>Odysseus? He's a kamen rider and the horse of troy transform into a mecha>Hercules and Lu Bu? They may be robotsI'm really tired of his bullshit, I just want a normal myth character. Stop giving M4 to a guy who was famous for using crossbows or bows, fuck modern shit
>>751686373it's kino.always was and will be
>>751674475Magic is capped at individual ability. Tech is not. In the long run, magic can't compete.
>>751684081The reveal that you're actually on a spaceship in Firmament was one of the few good parts of the game
>>751673971Shhh, you'll upset the tardies.
>>751679710Yeah you can do whatever you want butDo you have the LOICENSE to do that?
>>751683051Imagine taking Zelda stories and lore seriously
>high tech setting>melee weapons are widely used and do more damage than ranged ones somehow
>>751683051>ancient technology is fucking everywhere>is literally just garbage at this point>half the NPCs in the game have the occupation of "ancient technology researcher">No one understands how any of it works despite this>Also the creators of the ancient technology are still alive over in some village that anyone can go to whenever>they don't understand their own technology eitherI genuinely cannot stand the world building of BOTW
>>751677129how valuable is heated seating?
>techbros literally can't conceive of magic that doesn't involve studies and formulaeMagic that uses science already exists, it's called science. Stop ripping mystique out of the mystical.
>>751683261Why is that a bad thing ?
>>751688819Soiboi non-feature. Ooooh, you can now not be slightly cold for those 2 minutes before the seat would warm up naturally from YOU SITTING ON IT