You may not like it, but it's time to admit that western games don't actually have any stories better than the best Jap narratives, every western story is just DEI shit and pseud politics. GTA6 won't be any exception.
>>751682703all mogged by new vegas
>>751682703This is probably bait but yeah most japanese games have significantly better stories. Their sincerity alone makes them superior. Not being propaganda pieces also helps.
Disco Elysium has better writing than anything in your image.
>>751682878>>751682980>every western story is just DEI shit and pseud politicsWhat do you think I was referring to in my post?
>>751682703Unironically true
Name one well written japanese RPG that's not FF7.
>>751682703There's only one good game in your image however.
>>751683423Dark Souls
>>751682703GTA6 will surpass all of that garbage
>>751682878>moggedYou are brown.
Persona, good story…mmm are you sure about that anon?
>>751682703>2 shit VNs>game with no real story>fucking PersonaYeah. I'm thinking Japs lost.
>>751682703Steins gate is just a shittier sword art online and sword art online was ruined by Asuna
>>751684121You are a massive retard if you think SAO is comparable to SG in any way.
>>751682703Elden ringSlopSlopSlop
One day /v/ will be forced to admit that Persona is kino.
>>751682703Video game stories peaked with Planetscape Torment, not any of that trash
>>751684121Considering that both Kurusu and Asuna are true Mary Sue self inserts in a science fiction story you're correct
>>751682703Too many people just hate japs by default, I like their games because even when there is "woke shit" it doesn't feel preachy and forced as it does in western media
>>751682703Japs can't write. We've been over this.
>>751685315They can only write romance
> One day /v/ will be forced to admit that Persona is kino.I like personal but the writing is shit.
I enjoy persona 4 because it’s a social life sim where you can date cute girls. The story good but it’s not why I play it.
>>751682703Elden Ring is the only half decent game there.
>>751685315Nobody who says this can read japanese. It's like expecting someone to take a chink's opinion on english writing seriously.
>>751685886And, i checked Xenogears japanese script, it's shit like the english one.
>>751682703Replace Persona and Shit;Gates with something actually good. I suggest Xenogears.
>>751682703>umineko have any of you niggas actually spent 100 hours reading this? I don't believe you, it has to be larp. most 19th century novels are unironically shorter and I don't believe the writing is anywhere close to them
>>751683057That "pseud politics" is about a magnitude more interesting and better written than the time travel and tranny slop in the OP.
I've been playing Reboot15 years ago I liked chuunibyou Okabe but he is just annoying now
Elden Ring's plot is the worst fromsoft has ever done in the base game and contradictorily incoherent once you include the DLC.
>>751686514You became dumber as you aged?
>>751682703this is still the best JRPG
>>751686514Yeah. Honestly after awhile you just realize that Okabe is a manchild and that he isn't actually witty or clever.
>>751682703P3 is the best Persona game.
>Anon mentions SAO and steins gate being the same>Scoff>Start thinking about it>Realize they're both the same shit>Anon mentions xenogears >Realizes that is also in the same shit bin>Realize xenosaga episode 3 and Xenoblade 3 are tremendous ass and basically the same gameI'm noticingIM NOTICING!!!!!!!!!!!
>>751686186>something actually good. I suggest Xenogears.Steins;gate unironically mogs that pretentious shit.Takahashi writes like a 14 year old
>>751687308elaborate
>>751682703Story for all these suck ass
>>751687308Xeno games are all the same: there's an oppressed world, an evil demiurge to destroy, and they all lived happily ever after. Add to that a sprinkle of shallow philosophical/religious quotes, the way a 14 year-old would use them, then write all the characters as caricatures and make them behave in the most unnatural way possible."Yes Billy, the church you've lived in all this time is actually a monstrous organization, you killed all those people without knowing it, and that same church killed your mother... But God exists inside you! Hahaha!"Then the game attacks religion like a kid would, but has Elly solemnly spout platitudes. What a mature and profound story...
>>751687318Steins;Gate is worse than pretentious, it's self indulgent manchild-core.
>>751682703>not a single good gameWow.
>>751682703>pseud politicsThis is fun you fag.
>>75168270380% of Japanese writing is just cargo culting gnosticism
>>751682703Umineko and S;G are just mid baby's first vns
>>751682980You can really tell this game was written by people addicted with social media. Measure Head literally being based on a twitter account made this obvious but the characters don't behave like real people. If you treat it like a playable Monty Python skit its alright, but for actual quality of writing isn't particularly good. The pacing is fucked, the characters exposition dump their ideological musings on a dime, the actual content of the ideological discussion is retreading social media arguments, and this isn't to mention the actual plot of the game is very weak. It sells itself as a detective mystery game then abandons its own premise after the first area so you can visit each faction and listen to them ramble about r/Iam14andthisisdeep political musings.Also the lead writer is a failed novelist with his book bombing so hard that he became an alcoholic to cope. Dude went from an MLB dropout to little league smurf by developing a VN lmao.
>>751682703None of those even come close to Expedition 33.
>>751684882I've always said that and will never believe otherwise.
>>751682878FPBP
>>751682703Based on this image I can conclude that the writing in Jap games is rancid dogshit
>>751682703Elden Ring’s story was written by GRRM so it doesn’t really count.
>>751691091>written by a western writer>only game in the OP with decent writing Really makes you think.
The universe is in limbo because of my trauma dump.I'm a very special woman.
>>751682703Is Umineko worth reading?
>>751686870My problem with Steins gate is every character is designed to appeal to young teens. When you grow up the characters stop being nearly as appealing as they used to be.
>>751682703Half of these aren't video games
>>751692280No, it's 100 hours of trannyshit
>>751682703>reddit's;gate and uminegro near actual videogames
>>751686796>JRPG>JAPANESE rpgNo.
>>751695275The French did it better.
>>751692280It's the only VN that aspires to be proper literature but it filters people hard because it doesn't really show its hand until halfway through. Also the western fanbase is full of trannies like this one >>751694465 who try to claim it for xerselves, meanwhile the japanese fanbase doesn't even know what a tranny is.
>>751689409All VN's have dogshit writing
>>751692280Umineko, Higurashi, everything from that hack is dogshit
>>751696169>It's the only VN that aspires to be proper literatureAhahahah
>>751696367What's the last book you've read and you liked?
>>751696662Brothers Karamazov
>>751696881Based. I don't get why you would hate Umineko in that case though. Obviously it's not Dostoevsky, but it tackles faith in an ontologically similar manner.
>>751696169>It's the only VN that aspires to be proper literaturelol, Steins;Gate is better than anything R07 ever made or ever will make.
>>751697015Actually, I was being a jerk, because I don't know the series. It was a knee jerk reaction, since I often hear any "okay" work naively hailed as literature. If anything, if some video game or VN ever truly reached the level of literature, I'd be the first to be happy about it. I'm just a bit disappointed by the superficiality. I'll probably give it a look anyway.
>>751697252Go into it as blind as you can, with only one semi-spoiler because this is what soured a lot of people: The novel is not what you think it is even after 10 hours of reading.
>>751697338thanks, will do
>>751682703Persona has shit writing
>>751696169>>751696367>>751696662>>751696881>>751697015>>751697252>>751697338>>751697537You should kiss.
Zanzibart...
>>751682703All of those are shit except Umineko
>>751698143Fromsoftfags will never recover from that tweet
>>751682703Elden Ring doesn't have a story either.
>>751682703>Steins;Gate50 hours of trash, dropped>Persona 4100 hours of mid, didn't drop but I wouldn't have played it knowing what I know now>Elden RingDecent but the story is a nothingburger>Umineko??? Haven't tried this and have no intention to
>>751682980Trvth Nvke
Elden Ring doesn't have a story. Zanzibart isn't a story.
>>751702147>lore isn't a storyTired of this meme.
>>751702263it isn't? also, lore isn't reading about zanzibart and then hearing a big guy in armor say "zanzibart, forgive me".Sekiro had a story you could follow. Elden Ring has no story.
>>751701340my all endings run of S:G was little over 20 hours
>>751682703Should I play original or Golden
>>751682703>Umineko>good storylol
>>751702549None of those have a good story really.
>>751702705Steins Gate is well written and the story actually makes sense
>>751703059>Steins Gate is well writtenEh, no. Not least of which is because the time travel is stupid as fuck sometimes.
>>751682703The japanese are so bad at writing I don't know how anyone can take them seriously
>>751682703>every western story is just DEI shit and pseud politics
>>751702263Lore was never good.Even Tolkien isn't defended for the lore
>>751703059>Steins Garbage>well writtenI won't pretend Umineko is good either but come on.
>>751682878flippy bippy
>>751682703>Gave everything in OP's image a shot>Hated all of themWhat does that make me?
>>751687358I think he's noticing that the most interesting concepts and plots are getting knee capped by ship shit and that the ship shit is basically all the same.
>>751702482The definitive version, Revival.
>>751696169>It's the only VN that aspires to be proper literature
>>751705667>not out yethmm....
>>751682703S;G was so bad, the fanbase really oversold how good it was all these years.
>>751707346SG fans are incredibly pretentious and think their VN is clearly the best thing ever made, while most of them haven't watched or read a single other time travel story.
>>751682703Post better games next time you're trying to shill Japan to everyone.
>>751682703>trying to sneak in elden shart in there like we wouldn't noticelmao
>>751683423>FF7>well writtenLMFAO
>>751682703I dropped Steins;Gate and Umineko after like 5 hours, they're trash.
>>751712443S;G's ending was a retarded asspull and I also dropped Umineko after chapter 4, I don't think you're missing out on anything.
>>751686870The point is that he is a manchild. That's the whole point.
>>751713150NTA but Okabe just did a good job of making me not like him. Mission accomplished I guess?
>>751713408Read 0 and Okabe sulking through 90% of it and you'll beg for the manchild behaviour to return then
>this thread again
>>751713080If I recall Umineko even warns the player to not read the answer arcs if they want to keep their own theories. It's fine to leave it at chapter 4
>>751713480>Read [more slop]No, I don't think I will.
>>751713480S;G 0 is awful, what a bad suggestion
>>751714432It's good for characterization
>>751682980This
Persona 6 will be good, trust
>>751686448I dropped it in part 7. It has some cool moments and decent closed room riddles, but it also has dogshit moment-to-moment writing.
>>751682703western games are lacking in the PLOT department
>>751686796Brown RPG
>>751696662The Sot-Weed Factor. Well, like is a strong word here, the author is witty but has not a whit of poetic sensibility. At least it was funny. I have no idea why people compare him to Tommy.“All that made the day attractive to me, for it were otherwise malodourous enow, was, that Burlingames bowells did seem to commence troubling him, for that he did still wander hither to yon in the barge, his face shewing ever more discomfort, and crost & recrost his leggs, and his want of composure was a tastie thing to watch. When that he shd finallie let flie, I guess’d it wd prove a spectacle in sooth, by reason of his greate corpulencie, and the lengthie space he had held fast his reins…”[...]“The tugg-o’-war that then insued had been a sporting match, wch methinks we had won, were it that naught had interfear’d with the murtherous game. But the Salvages giving out with terrible whoops & hollowings, did so smite with fear this Burlingame, that at last he forewent entire the hold of his reins, and standing yet in our prowe like unto an uglie figure-head, he did let flie the treasure he had been those daies a-hoarding. It was my ill fortune to be hard behind him, and moreover, crowch’d down beneath his mightie bumme, so as to better brace my feet for pulling, and looking up at that instant of time, to see whether Burlingame was yet with us, I was in a trice beshitt, so much so, that I cd by no meanes see out of my eyes, or speake out of my mowth. Then the Salvages gave a great pull on the pendant, and the deck all bemir’d, I did loose the purchase of my feet, and sayling betwixt Burlingames legs, did end face downe in the mud of the shoar. This same Burlingame thus knock’d from off his ballance, he fell after, and sat him square upon my head.
>>751711549>Xenogears >Well writtenLMFAO
>>751714573It's not even really good at that and it's shit and just about everything else.
>>751719992>translation never>New World never>final LN never
>>751682703The umineko and steins gate writers are among the biggest hacks in the whole visual novel industry.
>>751682703>When They Cry UminekoELO make me sick
>>751682703>Reddit;Gate>Rollslop>good storieslmao
>>751682703i haven't cared about western crap in over 20 years.
>>751722149I don't hate Jap shit but OP was really scraping the bottom of the barrel when he put that image together.
>>751682703>Steins Gateretarded time travel plot>Persona 4 glorified high school life simulator and only so liked here because people here relate to being as big of a loser as Adachi >Elden RingFromslop games don't have real stories just youtube essay bait >Uminekohonestly know nothing about other than a few memes
>>751682878I'm not even a big New Vegas fan but this is obviously true.
>>751682703Elden Ring's world and lore was written by a westerner. The actual story was ass.
>>751683612pic unrelated
>>751696662I'M READING SALT: A WORLD HISTORY AND I LOVE ALL THE FACTS I'M LEARNING ABOUT THE HISTORY OF SALT AND SALT MAKING AND SALT USED IN COOKING!!!
>>751722149Never understood why people like that time travel slop.
>>751723694It just makes them feel smart. I agree though the writing in S;G was mid at best, I prefer All You Need is Kill.
>>751698842
>>751682980>Disco Elysium has better writing
>>751682703embarrassingly millennial list
>>751692280It's LITERALLY a book, not even a VN as it does not have routes, so you literally just read shit with no decision at all
>>751686796Not even the plot is original as it was done in FFTA and P5R
>>751689639That's what makes it fun and entertaining. When you take internet-level discourse and make the words come out of caricatures it exposes the ridiculousness of the extreme views. Making an RPG out of it was genius.
>>751727868this nigga didn't finish the game, likely couldn't solve bernkastel's game as well.
>>751707346At the end SG is just a basic time travel story, the end was unique though compared to others
>>751682878And how old is that game anon?
>>751728023>the better game is old as fuckdoesn't that make it 100x more embarrassing that it hasn't been beaten yet?
>>751728047The fact still stands that the west can't write for shit anymore and everything from them in the past 15 years is handily bested by games from the east.The west has fallen. Veilguard is considered the gold standard by western writers and they will continue to deliver slop while the east continues to capitalize on their retardation. They even do woke better in Metaphor.
>>751727979>UNO decision at the end of the gamefvvaaaaaaaark, it's just like those "if x then flip to page y" books!
>>751682703All of these are kind of mediocre though
>>751682703>Visual novels Not video games.
>>751731502without love it cannot be seen
>>751728017The end of S;G isn't unique at all, I was rolling my eyes at the beginning of the story because I knew exactly what it was trying to set up
>>751682703Planescape Torment clears any game written
>>751682703playing video games for the stories
>>751733540And it doesn't even do that foreshadowing part well. Zero subtlety, with the finesse of throwing a rock like a caveman. But I shouldn't be surprised after s;g 0 was even worse.
>>751682703Bait, there isn't a single good story in that whole image. Elden Ring is arguably a god game but definitely not a good story.
>>751728023exactly the same age as 2 of the games in the OP
>>751682703>Jap writinglol, just lol
>>751682703>bro thinks he's on the team
>>751682703>You may not like itYou're right I do not like any of those games.
>>751682703>P3Haven't played P3 but 4s gameplay was mid and the story didnt grip me. Can't evaluate it. >ERER has trash writing. At best you could say there's some cool world building but like most souls games there really isn't much going on in terms of character, character arcs, and plot. All of it is implied or happens offscreen which isn't really good writing. Also Dark Souls did most of that better.>Only watched the anime for Steins;Gate. Chaos;Child was decent though.>UminekoI malded the fuck out in part 3 about the author wasting my time with magic fantasy bs padding only to see Battler (the main character) do the same in part 4. Actually goated vn would recommend.
>>751728023
>>751733540It's was predictable but being predictable just means you evaluate the story based on its execution instead of the novelty. Same with Expedition 33. The story made everything obvious before they tried to 'surprise' the viewer. Novelty is also hard to evaluate in terms of timelessness. If e everyone starts doing time travel stories they're boring and predictable, but even the first novel time travel story feels trite and predictable once everyone's done a few.
>>751682703If /v/ wasn't contrarian they would be able to admit that none of those games even come close to disco elysium
>>751682703Mayuri sex
>>751682980>Disco Elysium
>>751682878This.
>>751682703I like rollslop but not for story.