[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: character action.jpg (32 KB, 596x335)
32 KB JPG
Why does the genre suffer so hard from garbage boss design? Bayo and Nigga Gaiden would be so much better without 95% of the bossfights
>>
File: dogshit boss.webm (2.23 MB, 1280x720)
2.23 MB
2.23 MB WEBM
>>
>>751692680
I think it's genuinely that bosses aren't built into the combat system
At least with NG1 and NG2 but I never played the others
Look at Murai - he teaches you to space properly but like, most of the fucking enemies don't require that level of autism so it doesn't really work proeprly
Same with the horse rider or the armored dude in level 3 that they are mostly just 'dodge and space' where the main game is usually 'handle multiple enemies'
Even on Master Ninja it's still just down to 'kill enemies, use OLUTs if they drop essence, else just plya like on normal when regular enemies are dead'
>>
>>751693705
The horse boss is just a beefed up regular enemy though
>>
>>751694371
Doesn't he run the fuck around a lot on the horse at the start before going on foot?
>>
>>751694730
Yeah but you fight the regular horsemen just before him. And then never again lol
>>
>>751692680
DMC1 bosses are all good. DMC3 has shit bosses because the devs only care about epic combos and flashy attacks and don't care enough to design proper enemies.
>>
I'm on chapter 9 of NGII on Mentor in NGII on the Xbox 360. Ask me anything.
>>
>>751692680
>Bayo [...]would be so much better without 95% of the bossfights
KILL YOURSELF NOW
>>
>>751692680
Because for every humanoid winner, there are four giant monster stinkers. Giant monsters just seem to universally suck in action games, or at most are just harmless.
>>
>>751695367
Those epic combos that don't even work on the bosses and half the enemies?
>>751695517
Are you using falcon forward Y
>>
>>751698046
>Those epic combos that don't even work on the bosses and half the enemies?
Yes. It's flashy so who cares about actual game mechanics.
>>
>>751697236
There's an entire series specializing in giant monsters and until recently, even with nightmarishly bad hit detection, it was great.
>>
>>751695367
>DMC1 bosses are all good
Griffon 2 is just shooting your guns and all of nightmare boss fights are garbage. First phase of mundus is retarded too.
>>
>character action
Most retarded name ever. You should stop using that name
>>
bump
>>
>>751692680
I haven't played DMC 3 so I started a new game. FUCK MY RIGHT HAND, man. Do I need to finger exercises now?
>>751698578
What do you suggest? Cause my is just ultra jab n slashes.
>>
>>751698516
nightmare is good actually.
>>
>>751702051
>What do you suggest?
3d beat em up
>>
>>751702173
Like Yakuza, the fist of the North Star games, and the Batman Arkham games?
>>
>>751702383
Yakuza is an open world chore simulator/questslop
>>
>>751695367
DMC1 has two good bosses.
>>
>>751702796
>phantom
>gryphon
>nightmare
>nelo angelo
>all midbosses
really you could argue mundus sucks but that's about it
>>
Hey can someone explain to me why DMC 4(and by extension DMC 5) Dante doesn't have stuff like the rebellion combo II knock back swing(it just goes into million stab automatically), free ride, wild stomp, point blank, and wall running?
>>
>>751702383
SpikeOut, Urban Reign, God Hand, The Warriors, Die Hard Arcade
>>
>>751702894
The list of good bosses consists of Phantom and Nelo Angelo.
All Griffon fights suck ass - Griffon 2 just sucks the most ass, but platforming was never the strength of DMC, and a platforming boss is not a fun one to fight. That's why most players just shot the chicken down.
All Nightmare fights suck because it's not a proper boss to begin with.
Mundus fights suck because there's barely any actual fight - most of the "challenge" comes from gimmicks.
>midbosses
Who are you talking about? Shadows?
>>
>>751703006
>like the rebellion combo II knock back swing
Specifically omitting the Rebellion combo might've been a balancing decision. That specific combo had too good of an AoE coverage around Dante, so it was a very safe combo to spam.
The million stab variant only hits a narrow angle as the million stab happens, so it's not as safe.
>point blank
Probably to reduce redundancy between the weapon kits. Some Gunslinger moves in 3 existed primarily to help you cope with not picking Swordmaster and losing like half of your combat options because of that.
Gunslinger was still terrible at actually delivering on that idea, and in DMC4 you could always just switch to Swordmaster. So I'd assume they relegated Gunslinger to be more of a support/optimization style and stripped that parts of it that were trying to directly compete with Swordmaster.
>free ride, wild stomp, and wall running
My only guess is that those were too gimmicky and too impractical to justify spending the dev time on them.
Free ride is an entire interaction mechanic that's only ever used by itself.
Wild stomp is also a unique mechanic (as it directly locks Dante with an enemy) and it lacked a proper trigger, as the only Crazy Combo input in DMC4+ is Honeycomb Fire with Crazy Combos proper gone as a mechanic.
Now why did they remove Crazy Combos themselves I don't really know. Maybe they have decided that the combo system is already complicated enough as is, maybe they weren't too fond of mashing that was required to pull them off in 3, and reducing the input requirements made them too prone to getting triggered on accident. Maybe it was just dev time constraints, because realistically, having Crazy Combo just on Dante's weapons would require creating at least three more attacks for the mechanic to not look scuffed.

Wall running specifically was a complete gimmick in DMC3 already. There's only a few locations where wall running has any practical use, and that game happens inside of a building.
>>
>>751704046
Gryphon doesn't have a lot of platforming. What little it has is well implemented.
Nightmare is a proper boss, I have no clue what you're getting at
Mundus is the hardest boss in the game but phase 1 is annoying to get through so I could understand the feeling of tediousness. Phase 2 on its own would be fine
Yes shadows are pretty good, actually feel more like proper bosses than almost anything in dmc32 outside of vergil
>>
There's literally nothing wrong with the enemies in DMC games.
>>
>>751693543
....What the fuck are you suppose to do here
>>
>>751705381
Gryphon's core distinctive mechanic is the platforming. It has a lot of it and it's implemented horribly.
Nightmare is not a proper boss fight, you are indeed clueless.
Mundus is not particularly hard, and part 2 is mediocre with the core challenge, again, coming from the platforming.
Shadows don't feel like proper bosses as they are gimmick enemies. DMC4's Blitz did Shadow's gimmick much better than Shadows themselves did.
>>
>>751705702
They are somewhat fodder in the grand scheme of things if you commit to the genre but to the average idiot who just goes triangle triangle triangle with no thought of spacing, they're usually enough.
>>
>>751705998
You're just going "no" to whatever I say, whatever nerd. Fuck off.
>>
>>751695367
Not being able to juggle Vergil is a crime. They figured it out for 5, at least. And yeah, none of the enemies outside the Sins are fun to fight.
>>
>>751702051
>>751698578
Action Games Incorporating Totally Ambiguous Terribly Explained Depth For Autistic Gamers
or
AGITATEDFAG
>>
>>751706030
Cope, faggot.
Your entire response to my initial post was a "no" - you don't deserve a better reply.
>>
>>751705070
>Specifically omitting the Rebellion combo might've been a balancing decision.
Gay
> Probably to reduce redundancy between the weapon kits. Some Gunslinger moves in 3 existed primarily to help you cope with not picking Swordmaster and losing like half of your combat options because of that.
Gunslinger was still terrible at actually delivering on that idea, and in DMC4 you could always just switch to Swordmaster. So I'd assume they relegated Gunslinger to be more of a support/optimization style and stripped that parts of it that were trying to directly compete with Swordmaster.
Makes me wish gunslinger was cooler
>Wild stomp is also a unique mechanic (as it directly locks Dante with an enemy) and it lacked a proper trigger, as the only Crazy Combo input in DMC4+ is Honeycomb Fire with Crazy Combos proper gone as a mechanic.
I guess that kind of makes sense
>Now why did they remove Crazy Combos themselves I don't really know. Maybe they have decided that the combo system is already complicated enough as is, maybe they weren't too fond of mashing that was required to pull them off in 3, and reducing the input requirements made them too prone to getting triggered on accident. Maybe it was just dev time constraints, because realistically, having Crazy Combo just on Dante's weapons would require creating at least three more attacks for the mechanic to not look scuffed.
They should bring crazy combos back
>Wall running specifically was a complete gimmick in DMC3 already. There's only a few locations where wall running has any practical use, and that game happens inside of a building.
It should have been improved upon to make it not a gimmick. Like me do melee attacks and shoot guns while wall running, ya know
>>
>>751703006
I always had the feeling that DMC4 sort of split what DMC3 had going into two separate characters with Nero and Dante.

More visceral, situational or execution heavy mechanics like crazy combos were removed from Dante and he was turned into a much more technical character that was focused on weapon and style switching. Meanwhile Nero is all about hitting the right exceed times and has grab mechanics that directly tie into enemy types but he doesn't have to deal with the hoop of switching things.

I think it's just a result of trying to find ways to innovate while keeping things relatively concise. When Dante is this Swiss army knife character with so many options you still can't have him do absolutely everything and have the player engage with completely different philosophies to how he plays. That's how you end up seeing some of his abilities like Doppelganger and Quicksilver being used by other characters.

I think ultimately Dante gets more than he gives this way though, since he's only ever gone up in terms of complexity as the series went on.
>>
>>751710235
>he's only ever gone up in terms of complexity as the series went on.
yes but hes not necessarily gone up in satisfaction or fun
if you played DMC3 Crimson recently, youd know that outside of Devil Sword Dante, Quad S and maybe a few QoL changes that DMC3 dante feels better on a technical level, as well as in general game feel, AND can do more complex stuff than 5s can
the biggest issue is most of 3s enemy roster is bad
>>
Legitimately bayonetta is an improvement to the DMC formula and future DMC games should incorporate Dantes styles into his base kit.
DMC 5 is already pushing it with everything Dante can do to a stupid degree.
>>
>>751710385
I mean you can't really understate how much DSD and Quad S do for the character though. Quad S specially closes his gameplay loop by making the style meter have a tangible reward. It essentially completes the project DMC3 started.

But personally I don't fully disagree with you. I never particularly "got" DMC4 Dante and have preferred Nero both for that game and the next one, but some people absolutely love what they did with the character.
>>
>>751710235
>That's how you end up seeing some of his abilities like Doppelganger and Quicksilver being used by other characters.
>I think ultimately Dante gets more than he gives this way though, since he's only ever gone up in terms of complexity as the series went on.
I guess but it just feels weird piece mealing Dante. I feel like there is still a lot more to do with Dante gameplay wise.
Also unrelated, it feels weird that Dante and other DMC characters(outside of 2 and 2013) don't have a forward/omnidirectional dodge roll, only side to side. Like yeah there is stuff like table hopper, trick, and trickster but the lack of a simple lock forward dodge roll in 3&4&5 seems a bit backwards.
>>
>>751710923
I wish Nero had more weapons. Feels like a waste of the d pad for him in 4&5
>>
>>751710989
>I wish Nero had more weapons
why? so he can be a lesser dante?
let him keep his gimmick but make maxacting easier
>>
File: 1659104953293458.jpg (11 KB, 232x315)
11 KB JPG
>>751705947
If you kill your enemies, they win.
>>
>>751711086
It's pretty easy in 5 to max act.
>so he can be a lesser dante?
I just think it would be cool/fun to have a moveset where you dual wield red queen and Yamato outside of dt.
Also I wish Nero could use the devil bringer to throw explosive barrels.
>>
>>751710734
>Legitimately bayonetta is an improvement to the DMC formula and future DMC games should incorporate Dantes styles into his base kit.
I think you don't understand what makes DMC special at all.

Every other game out there has a dedicated dodge or block button. DMC is the outlier where it's just you, your moves and how they affect the enemies that matters.
>>
>>751710734
DMC fanboys will never admit that of the 6 styles darkslayer lmao get the fuck out of here with that shit only 1 is a real style which is Swordmaster.
Gunslinger is superfluous as fuck. Most of its moves could be tied to movement inputs and nobody would care. Shooting guns throughout the franchise was every antonym of fun even in DMC1 where it had the best sound effects that made them very punchy.
Royalguard is boring as sin. Trickster is purely dodge utility.
Quicksilver and Doppleganger are better off tied to the DT system itself. Every player used them in conjunction with DT because DT drain in 3 was fixed not additive last I checked.
>>
File: 1787442630914556.jpg (63 KB, 897x897)
63 KB JPG
>>751711295
trve morality for trve geniuses
>>
>>751710734
Bayonetta shares close to nothing with DMC's formula combat-wise.
It's a Ninja Gaiden-like with a focus on dodging over blocking.
>>
File: bendyrivers.png (46 KB, 261x215)
46 KB PNG
Finally got around to playing Bayo 3 thanks to the Witch Time recomp
Holy shit I knew it was going to be bad when I heard it shared DNA with the cancelled Scalebound and the last-minute-rebuild Astral Chain but I had no idea how bad it could be.

Mix and match weapons gone, all the weapons are handed to you instead of hidden to reward exploration, the demon slave mechanic is slow and boring and utterly dominates the combat in these massive empty arenas, the camera is dogshit, Viola is way too simple, and it's obvious from the word go that no one on the team gave a flying fuck about any kind of pacing or consistent tone.

What a fucking mess.
>>
>>751705947
>>751693543
Hold block.
>>
>>751711910
>all the weapons are handed to you instead of hidden to reward exploration
That's a good thing though?
>>
File: ng3re tonfa.png (338 KB, 661x595)
338 KB PNG
Fiend busa is adding Tonfa to NG3RE.

https://youtu.be/z4ggQDJ-LfU?si=YkRkzMx--CD9PEGn
>>
>>751710385
I feel that DMC4 is a major improvement over DMC3 in general terms of combat feel.
There are a few mechanics 3 has I think would've benefited 4 a lot - like Crazy Combos - but overall gameplay of 4 is much smoother, but to be fair a part of the reason might be that the enemy roster in it is great.
DMC5 is a very major improvement over 4, and I'm convinced that all the issues people have with DMC5's mechanics are down to the force of a habit and refusing to change.
I think the most major change DMC5 offers is its improvement to ground combos as well as JC-less combos.
JC spam of DMC4 is very impressive mechanically, but the process itself quickly becomes stale, as all you're really doing is repeating a select few attacks that control your aerial positioning.
The most impressive combos virtually always rely on something else but JC spam being the presentation piece.
>>
>>751711910
https://youtu.be/2ySpIsqwZPI?si=McurEYU_2KV9MBh2

looks pretty fun tho
>>
>>751712160
>COMBO MAD
instant opinion disqualification.
>>
File: 1789687048724571.png (619 KB, 1200x1200)
619 KB PNG
>>751712207
why tho
>>
>>751692680
Seriously anon, just stop it with this nonsense.
>>
>>751696721
Jeanne is the only good boss in that game
>>
>>751712246
I could be a twat about it but I'll give you a genuine answer
Outside of DMC none of the games anyone puts in this category are about le ebic combos. Bayonetta in particular rewards sticking to the pre-built strings and reacting with dodge offset as opposed to big juggles (and will typically prevent you from doing them in the first place).

Combo Mad videos are generally not a reflection of actual play at any level. They're novelties.
>>
>>751712148
in combat feel in DMC3 is better
but DMC3 jumping and collision boxes are awful, gravity timing is nonsensical and a lot of animations get stuck for longer than they should
>>
>>751712063
>Tonfa
He should have added the Nunchaku(Flails) first.
>>
>>751692680
I watch this channel
>>
File: 1785784139497.webm (3.9 MB, 640x360)
3.9 MB
3.9 MB WEBM
>>
>>751712835
>Nier Automata
>>
File: balenciaga.png (904 KB, 902x847)
904 KB PNG
>>751712898
ponching robots is fun
>>
>>751712604
I feel that DMC3 has a lot of very cool moves, however it's not well-balanced.
Specifically, JC was an accident and not an intentional mechanic - they kept it in with DMC4 and 5 being clearly balanced around it, but in 3 it simply breaks some encounters with JC The Hammer and to a lesser extent Aerial Cross being the worst offenders.
I'm also personally not a fan of DMC3's DMD, but that's more of a me problem - I don't like playing around the DT explosion and I think it actively detracts from the reward mechanic that is DT itself.
DMC5 has the best DMD IMO.
>>
>>751692680
The problem with the genre isn't the boss designs. It's the overabundance of filler that has nothing to do with the core gameplay.
I'm talking about stuff like:
1. Backtracking
2. Just simply spending a lot of time walking/running/dashing to the next combat encounter with nothing happening in between.
3. Gimmick sections like puzzles or ride sections.

Beat-em-ups are just better as a genre for melee weapons/hand-to-hand action combat. For example, Streets of Rage 4 has all the good things about character action games (or stylish action games or DMC-likes or cuhrayzee or whatever the fuck the actual name of this genre is) minus all the bullshit.
>>
>>751692680
Don't know why you'd put Nier Automata in that image
>>
File: 1769503623769944.mp4 (3.87 MB, 500x280)
3.87 MB
3.87 MB MP4
>>751712476
I would say Nioh MADs qualify because of how status effects and yokai ki work, plus death dancer and versatility as incentives, though that's far from a comprehensive representation of its gameplay (webm related for RPG cheese).
>>
>>751712959
I really hated how spongy some enemies in DMC5's DMD were, especially ones with hyper armor like the Proto Angelos, it made killing them as tedious as DMC3's without DT explosion. I don't like DT explosion much either, so DMC4's ended up my favorite, at least in terms of balance.
>>
>>751714765
DMC5's sponginess sits somewhere between DMC3 and 4.
4, I think did DMD very well, but it erred on the side of making the enemies too fragile.
DMC5 has some of its enemies become very fat after they DT, but that tends to only apply to a select few enemies, and those are usually a good target for you higher-damage tools.
I like this approach because unlike the DT explosion, those tools are not a universal BiS answer to every problem, so when an Angelo or a Behemoth give you a very credible reason to finally use Cavalier, Balrog, or Faust for specifically their damage output, which is a property that takes a complete backseat on the lower difficulties.

Conversely, it would indeed feel pretty tedious if you simply don't want to use those weapons against them, but I appreciate the choice and the guidance.
A somewhat similar case is Ifrit vs Frosts in DMC1, but that one was way too ham-fisted for my taste. DMC5 achieves similar goals while leaving you more options to pick from and without completely gimping the alternatives.
>>
>>751711910
my personal BIGGEST problem with Bayo 3 is that it utterly feels slow and bogged down.
Compared to the fluidity of 1 and 2 you can feel that 3 is slow due to trying to do too much on the switch
>>
>>751715336
I can't say I really agree, the damage is still completely insufficient, at least outside Dante and Vergil. Like I once landed 4 Overture detonations on a Proto Angelo and it still wasn't close to dead.
>>
I saw some anon post that an offline version of Babylons Fall was created
https://arch.b4k.dev/v/thread/751349390/
https://gitlab.com/babfal-group/babylons-fall-offline
I remember the demo and it sucking ASS. But for archival reasons I do think it's important to keep a game like this from completely disappearing.

Man I played that TMNT game platinum put out and that was below average. Not actually entirely shit but meh ,Babylons Fall was WAY worse than that.

I specifically remember the 2019 trailer actually looked like a fine game
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PckcAblyGB4
and then when they reshowed it later it looked like they retooled everything to be much slower, less dynamic, and MUCH more stiff. When I played the demo it unfortunately confirmed by suspicions
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Wmno7aB0t0
>>
>>751716445
Yeah, that's fair.
I can't name the proper solution for Nero off the top of my head. I think that's where he needs to use Showdown for damage, and if it's his only answer I can see it becoming repetitive.
>>
>>751712476
>Combo Mad videos are generally not a reflection of actual play at any level.
My dream is that people will realize that this also applies to things like speedrunners and professional gamers too, their gameplay is so far removed from the regular experience that you might as well ignore them outside of the context of their respective competitions.
Also that people who reduce games down to buzzwords like parryslop because they're either too stupid to actually engage with the game mechanics or they barely even like the games that they play be placed inside a woodchipper/incinerator combination that's stuck inside a time looping anomaly.
>>
>>751712018
Why have the alt-forms that give different traversal moves though.
>>
>>751692680
I feel like we're heading to a revolution on the boss front with all the action games lately and coming in the future taking the boss approach of DS3/Elden Ring, but changing the gameplay to be far more character action orientated. People don't really like to speak about this because it makes old games look bad, but there's a massive problem with boss design in older games whether we're talking about rpgs or action games.
>>
>>751718967
I'm a bit behind on new releases, which games are you talking about?
>>
>>751719025
For starters similar to Nioh many of the recent and upcoming souls-likes (dreadful and useless genre name) have had the basic set up of Dark Souls, but significantly expanded upon the player and enemy movesets. That's not quite Character Action game really, but it speaks to a desire in the consumers for more action orientated games.

Lately there's also a lot more that feel like typical action games being announced like Tides of Annihilation, Genigods Nezha, Rhapsody in Scarlet, any of the like 30 wuxia action games, etc. Now I'm not sure if they're good or going to be quite the same as things like DMC, but developers are absolutely putting way more effort into regular action games lately. It just feels like we're moving past the Dark Souls era finally, I mean even Phantom Blade Zero is loved by normalfags and those guys fucking hate action games.
>>
Is this the thread?
>>
Any tips for Vanquish god hard? I'm getting my ass kicked
>>
File: ygs88b1jizqc1.jpg (419 KB, 2746x1358)
419 KB JPG
>>751697236
>Because for every humanoid winner, there are four giant monster stinkers
Which is why kh2 and even 3 are the best since they give you 13+ humanoid winners to play with.
You might not like it, but this is what peak character action performance looks like.
>>
>>751718082
>Combo Mad videos are generally not a reflection of actual play at any level.
>My dream is that people will realize that this also applies to things like speedrunners and professional gamers too, their gameplay is so far removed from the regular experience that you might as well ignore them outside of the context of their respective competitions.

Niggas, even on /v/, often don't understand combat systems (or games in general) and can't get through their heads that shutting down opponents and not letting them play is the best option(unless you want to use a specific enemy as a crowd control tool) that usually requires some deep game knowledge. But on the videos it's not "flashy" enough and seemingly lacks "back and forth" actions between the player and foes.
>parryslop
Blame Sekiro and its copycats, lol. And parries are often overpowered and 1 dimensional. But that's because of their implementations. Nobody calls DMC 1 or NG(without an intercept) parryslops.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.