[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


sometimes people wonder why did turn based tactics die out or at least become less popular? well i think a major reason is that most of them are RPGs. so instead of each mission being its own thing, instead you have to care about the progression/skills/stats of your characters for the whole game. i dont think this mechanic meshes very well with turn based tactics. it puts too much emphasis on the RPG mechanics and progression and not enough on the fun strategy and tactics. RPG elements are not necessary
>>
>>751698962
That's why Advance Wars is dead as fuck while Fire Emblem continues to sell millions and make mad profits, right?
>>
>>751698962
>more fun
for (you)
>>
>>751698962
It can be pretty boring without stats. They basically put a half-completed chess board in front of you and tell you to solve the victory condition.

I will say I hate hit percentages though
>>
Wrong, Gold Box games are fun with TRPG battles. It just depends on what you're looking for. Some people like Ogre Battle, I find it boring as hell because it's just a stat roll with no chance for the player to be clever.
>>
>>751699716
You're shitposting but if we take the chess comparison at face value:
In chess there is only one winning sequence. You have to sit in front of the puzzle until you find the correct move. Usually found by process of elimiation because there aren't that many possible moves.
In advance wars there are too many possible game states. You don't play by predicting or eliminating possible moves but more by instinct and heuristics. It is fun in a different way from chess.
Personally I find srpgs tedious at this point, they are either too easy or they require you to know what's coming ahead of time so you can pick the "correct" skills with no prior knowledge.
>>
>>751698962
This is why I couldn't get into the homeworld games. It's obvious highly thematic and well setup to need to do so, but managing my fleet between missions is obnoxious. It makes me want to just restart if anything goes wrong.
>>
>>751698962
I like both :)
>>
>>751699219
Not OP but the comparison is unfair. FE is a dating sim.
>>
>>751698962
i love advance wars, fire emblem, final fantasy tactics, into the breach, and mewgenics
>>
>>751698962
I love advance wars too anon, but it’s time to let go.
>>
>>751700169
Ogre battle was he first autobattler, once you understand that it all makes sense.
>>
>>751698962
I like both; they have a bit different appeal. I do wish Advance Wars had survived instead of Fire Emblem, though.
>>
>>751698962
> turn based tactics games are more fun when they AREN'T RPGs

True.

>sometimes people wonder why did turn based tactics die out or at least become less popular? well i think a major reason is that most of them are RPGs.

False. I love AW, but even I have to admit its a guilty pleasure. The core gameplay simply is impossible to balance, simply because you can move all your units at the same time.

Assume you have to identical symetrical armies. The one that moves/attacks first will always have a massive advantage over the other. This is a well known issue even with Chess, but at least with Chess you only move only one unit at a time. With AW, you can potentially completely destroy the enemy army in one turn. And unlike 4x games like Civ, that also allow you to move and attack with all your units, there aren't any extra mechanics to make up for the disadvantage.

This is fine for turbo casuals, but most people genuinelly interested in strategy will eventually drop the game. And that's ignoring all the other balancing issues.
>>
>>751701409
Why would I let go when Im playing on AWBW every day and people are still making mods?
>>
>>751701976
Nah AWBW has proven the game is really deep and can be made balanced by giving the second player an extra property
>>
>>751698962
Agreed. Strategy and RPGs don't mix well because the RPG playerbase just wants their overpowered juggernaut main characters to effortlessly cut through the entire enemy army by themselves. There's next to no strategy, just have better stats.

>>751699219
Fire Emblem sells more because RPGs sell more than strategy games. RPGs are more palatable to a casual mass audience and this is why Fire Emblem, which was never a particularly challenging series, is increasingly becoming a Personalike dating sim with a lot of talking and chores and the occasional (easy) battle.
>>
>>751698962
I agree but it's hard to get right
If you turn up the difficulty too high it turns into a puzzle game but if it's too easy it's not satisfying and you don't get the RPG fake accomplishment feeling up making numbers go up.
>>
>>751701542
>was he first autobattler
No, Gold Box games had it first. It was ass, but it was there.
>>
Speaking of Advance Wars I just finished playing an AW clone called Warside. The story was shit, the characters and CO powers were shit, the music was shit, but gameplay-wise it really scratched that AW itch and that was enough for me. I think that alone is testament to the enduring appeal of the AW formula.
>>
>>751701976
Youve never played AW competitively and it really shows
>>
File: 1793126858977598.jpg (64 KB, 739x415)
64 KB JPG
>>751698962
Cool, now go support them then.
https://store.steampowered.com/app/4951260/Banana_Kingdom/
>>
>>751704838
>jap dev
I will now buy your game
>>
>>751704838
>banana kingdom
this is a sex thing isnt it
>>
>>751704838
Came to this thread expecting only shitposts and here you are posting a game that actually looks good.
Thanks anon. I will buy your game so you can buy an ad.
>>
>>751698962
>sometimes people wonder why did turn based tactics die out or at least become less popular? well i think a major reason is that most of them are RPGs.
No, anon, that's fucking stupid. The ones that are more RPGs wouldn't have had half the appeal that they did to a broader audience without the RPG stuff. It used to be that everyone instantly knew adding RPG mechanics was casualizing your game in the 90s. RPG mechanics only exist to let you statcheck enemies. The purer the gameplay, the less RPG bullshit matters.
>>
I like pretty much every niggas in a chessboard game Ive ever played
RPG elements or not
Both AW and Disgaea are goat
>>
>>751699716
1. How exactly do stats change that?
2.while that might be true for pre-deployed maps, it's not true for anything where you build units.
>>
there's no strategy if you just apm the enemy to death. It becomes less of a game and more of an exercise
>>
>>751707306
forgot about disgaea
only played 4 but it was really fun
>>
>>751698962
They're still popular on PCs, you're just a consolefag.
>>
>>751703808
Apes Warfare is in a similar bucket. Characters and CO Powers were shit, but the core gameplay of AW is strong enough to carry it. Only AW-like I've played and not enjoyed was Wargroove 2. On top of messing with the formula a bit too much it also added a bunch of units that made matchups really unintuitive.
>>
>>751707572
>apm
>advance wars

how have people as stupid as you not died from your own follies, yet?
>>
>>751698962
thats the last map of AW1 campaign IIRC but why would you build 4 infantry
>>
>>751707832
ask the op on his dumb statement about turn-based games
>>
>>751707878
To maximize unit count.
>>
>>751707803
Name 5 good ones from the past year.
>>
Advance Wars is a special game; most strategy games don't have the same charm. RPGs ooze charm. Strategy games do well when they make the person feel smart but most people just aren't smart and don't try to be.
>>
>>751704838
soulmaxxing game
>>
>>751708145
It's something about the GBA.
>>
>>751700183
>In chess there is only one winning sequence
lol what a retard
>>
File: sophia custom FE6.webm (3.82 MB, 500x332)
3.82 MB
3.82 MB WEBM
Why doesn't IS treat FE like a roguelike? The game being replayable makes it so that feel less brutal to iron man
>>
>>751700183
A good strategy game is replayable because a good strategy game has many different ways to solve the puzzle. I don't see the point in romanticizing your first playthrough that much. If it's that exceptional of a game, it's a drop in the bucket. Many strategy games are hard enough that you won't even beat them on your first playthrough anyway.
>>
>>751700183
>only one winning sequence
holy midwit
>>
>>751704838
Looks fun, I'll probably buy it tonight.
>>
>>751699219
Eat shit. Millions of flies can't be wrong!
>>
File: 1764219325957828.png (657 KB, 640x480)
657 KB PNG
>>751698962
I wouldn't say the RPG aspect are or aren't necessary, but I fully agree with everything else. FE is so haphazard in how it statically throws random troops at you with little regard if you desperately need them or you're swimming in options.
Not to mention getting bogged down in all the unit maintenance, leveling them all up, changing gear and spells -- it's why I never finished Brigandine with the 40+ units.
Why aren't there more skirmish and mission based games that aren't military?
>>
>>751708510
FE is tactics for babies and slow adults.
>>
Besides AW what are some other streamlined strategy games let you build units mid match?
>>
>>751709326
Any 4x really.
Id say age of wonders series is the closest that i know of.
>>
>>751709545
Most 4x aren't really streamlined, they've generally for a half dozen systems that are all fairly opaque to a new player. I've tried AoW, it was okay, Gladius is the closest in the genre to what I'm looking for though.
>>
>>751698962
Advance wars is good because it just lets you play the fucking game.

Tactics """rpgs""" don't let you play the game. They make you grind to unlock points which you can then use to unlock microscopic parts of the game, one tiny piece at a time.
>>
>>751698962
Normals (the people who actually pay for video games) prefer things that generate discussion such as story cutscenes or decision paths/routes and builds. They are very enamored with presentation as well since that tends to be universal and not particular, or said in other words, everyone has the same intended experience from cutscenes and art and dialogue.
"fun" is hardly a consideration to the normal. If they are still playing a video game instead of turning their tv/pc off, they will consider a game fun with no particular reason behind it.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.