He will get his own game eventually
>>751716974no he won't.
Why would he? RDR ends in 1914, and by then cars were being manufactured en masse, so his game would just be a shitty old timey GTA if anything.
>>751716974>kill Ross's wife>kill Ross's brother>kill Rosswish he had a dog so I could kill that cunt too
>>751718372Nope. I've pitched this idea to one anon before. >Before he kills the guy he talks to some other guy that looks suspicious of him >Becomes wanted>Goes on the run >Hides out deep into Mexico >Mexico is still a shit hole piece of shit country >That means you can still be a bounty hunter in Mexico without modernizing shit That simple buddy
>>751718539Oh ok, that works.
>>751718372Jack goes to fight in ww1 comes back, two year timeskip and the prohibition era kicks off. Jack gets involved with boomshine running and the mafia.
>>751718714That would be pretty cool and all, but it would still just be old timey GTA.
>>751718372Cars weren't popular until the mid 20s, muddy roads that lead you to nowhere, this game could work.
>>751718714I'm so fucking tired of this dumbass theory,why the fuck would Jack Marston ever join the army and fight in World War One?and yeah a guy like him would easily avoid the draft
>>751718372RDR1 ends in Northern Mexico with him basically being on the run for killing Ross and northern Mexico was still lawless yeehaw cowboy country into like the 1920s.
>>751716974Yep, Jack is literally the natural conclusion of the themes of RDR and it would make it into a trilogy about the cycle of violence and the very closing years of the wild west.
>>751718714Why would he join the army?Why would he even live in the United States when he just murdered a federal agent?How is a game about bootlegging and the mafia not 1920s GTA?
>>751716974would be no point, his story is over. despite his father's actions Jack too goes down the path of the outlaw, and likely is gunned down like a dog as well. Jack's fate is set the second he goes for revenge.
>i dont understand cowboy movies
>>751718372Idk a post WW1 mafia game would be good
>>751719837youre not gonna believe this
>>751716974I hope not. RDR's ending is perfect tragedy kino
>>751716974no he wont, you didn't buy enough gold bars in rdr2 to keep the series going so now all you get is one (1) gta every 15 years.
>>751718539>Mexican Revolution and Cristero War gameKino setting
>>751718372>Old Timey GTA with horsesThat's exactly what the industry needs. Something original.
>>751719948>Cristero War gamebut which side is the protagonist is on?
>>751716974>cowboy game>but not in the cowboy eraI don't get why they keep doing this shit. What's so fun about making a game around a premise that it'll never be met. It's like making a game about knights but in the 16th century. There aren't any wild west games. all of them are about its end.
>>751716974Does anyone really want another one of these?
>>751721608That's why I think they should go back and make it about young Hosea.
>>751721608>but not in the cowboy erathe problem is the cowboy era goes too far into cowboys and indians killing each other and that's verboten. for some reason nobody wants to make egyptian games (that aren't city builders) that are set in the early new kingdom, or even earlier. its always right at the end in the ptolemaic period long after all the good stuff happens.
>>751719634>his story is over>*proceeds to describe a story with an arc that happens after the events of the first game*Doomed outlaws who ultimately get gunned down like a dog is literally what RDR is about.
>>751716974A WW1 shooter?
They should reimagine Red Dead Revolver where it turns out actually Uncle was Red Harlow all along because the original game was basically just a penny dreadful story loosely based on a legend about a real guy. His tall tales about once being known as the one shot kid were actually totally true.
>>751723647Red Dead Lumbago
>>751723647>Rockstar was so unoriginal they used the face someone else created for 2 more games
>>751716974No it's gonna be another prequel about the good ol' days. You'll play as one of the people who died in the riverboat heist that goes bad.
>>751723765A sequel about Jack would better continue the themes of the series about the end of the west and the pursuit of redemption/revenge whereas a prequel would just be a normal western.
>>751716974WORK YA DAMN NAG
It's hard to make something with him. He's not like Artur or even John. He doesn't have a crew, or even a family as it matters. He would be a complete lone wolf living in isolation from the world. Not just because he's wanted but also because despite what others tried, he only managed to follow the cowboy lifestyle, a lifestyle that already has ended by 1914.He pretty much is living completely outside of the world and his generation. He can't find anyone like him. He's a very sad character.A third game probably would be a prequel with Dutch anyway, or a game with one of the early members who died prior to RDR2>>751723848The west already has ended by 1914. John already was living it's final days.
I want to experience all the stranger missions as Jack but I don't like playing as Jack. youtube just isn't the same as playing it yourself. I'll just do what I do every time things get difficult: nothing
>>751723918>The west already has ended by 1914.But not in Mexico.RDR1 ends with Jack in Mexico.
>>751723960I feels like it would be a bit of a departure since RDR is specifically about the American west. It would just retread the themes of the first game about the world changing and living behind many people
>>751723647That’s too playful and fun for modern rockstar
>>7517240231/3rd of RDR1 is already set in Mexico.Imo there's good potential for a story about Jack as despite the name being Red Dead Redemption, everyone is pursuing freedom moreso than redemption (except Arthur in the latter half of RDR2). The gang life, Dutch's whole philosophy, John's attempts to transition into farming and his compliance with the FIB, the carrot on the stick is that freedom is always around the corner after this one next thing. With Jack there's a potential for the logical conclusion of that, running from the law in the last possible pocket of the old cowboy lifestyle.
>Jack Marston becomes a dirty cop during Prohibition era>hates the government for what happened to his father>you play an actual bad guy for once>There's all sorts of old timey cars, majority of game takes place in the city, classic GTA gameplay>towards the end of the game you have done way more bad than John or Arthur>Jack Marston becomes tired of the killing, smuggling and payoffs>You join up with a an Elliot Ness "Untouchables" task force and become a real cop, marry a cutie and raise a family>Hence the Redemption in Red Dead Redemption
>>751716974GTA 6 is secretly Red Dead Redemption 3. It's about Jason's redemption for dating a psychopathic and manipulative Latina.
>>751719878one that wasn’t written by an eastern european
>>751718372It could be good but not with Nu kikestar
RDR4 will not be Redemption 3
>>751721608What's wrong with that
>>751716974>"Mexico ain't a good place for you Jack. What do you think you're just going to get you're Red Dead Redemption free?">"Say that again"