[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: FFXVI.jpg (333 KB, 1540x2259)
333 KB JPG
Why did Final Fantasy XVI kind of flop?

Not counting the online ones, it's the first Final Fantasy since X that didn't suffer from major development issues or get released incomplete.

The graphics and music are great, Clive is the best protagonist since Final Fantasy IX (fuck you Tidus), and the story is really engaging.

The combat system might be a bit too action-heavy for an RPG, sure, but it's super fun, especially the boss fights (Bahamut was peak).

It's not perfect, but it's easily the best Final Fantasy since X. I really loved it and played it nonstop until I beat it.
>>
>>751718130
>The graphics and music are great, Clive is the best protagonist
Stopped reading there. This thread has no value.
>>
The complaints I have seen from people who played it are that you barely get to play at all before yet another 40 minute series of cutscenes play.

I'm exaggerating but yeah that's what they complained about. I'm sure there's more criticism but those are the ones I heard from people I talked to.
>>
>>751718130
It had gay sex
>>
>>751718130
Because people for some reason can't get into action games. Even when they're not very complicated. And action enthusiast probably found it too easy because the game doesn't challenge you enough. It's a very odd balance to strike, but that's what happens when you want to please everyone instead of trying to commit to a choice.
Also the quest structure is a bit too simplistic, but I personally loved the game because I just like fucking around with system mechanics and Titan is also very fun to use.
>>
>>751718130
This game starts out really good, but gets boring later. It’s also too easy, even though it has a good combat system.
>>
They forgot to make a game for the cutscenes
>>
I don't think it flopped, square just kind of stopped disclosing sales numbers because people were fighting non-stop on the internet and couldn't decide if 3 million copies sold in a week was good or bad, even when square said it sold within expectations.
>>751718880
no it didn't, there's only hetero sex scenes
>>
I played it, probably the most mid FF ever gotten.
I finished it and I really can't remember much of it, also blatantly woke with the "loyal servant" shit.
>>
>>751719228
The games banned in several countries because of how much gay shit is in it
>>
>>751718130
It didnt flop. Turn based boomers are just loud. Youre not supposed to obsess over 1 thing for the rest of your life
>>
>>751719332
Its 1 kiss. Thats it. Saudis don't deserve rights so it doesnt matter that they cant buy ff. Theyre to busy getting zutted like mohammad
>>
>>751718273
You can see Jills bare bottom in the game and she turns into a giantess a few times.
>>
>>751718130
>Not counting the online ones, it's the first Final Fantasy since X that didn't suffer from major development issues or get released incomplete.
The game is 3 dirt roads (wood, mountain, desert) 2 hamlets and the same temple with almost every other big landmark from the map missing and the combat lacks status effects and cobditions that usually play a big role in lete game ff and most sidequests are autoback mmo filler.
It's unfinished as fuck - which is a shame since it probably would have been one of the best if it wasn't.
>>
it's like FF12, people weren't ready for it. Give it a few years.
>>
>>751718130
It sold three times as much on launch as turn-based messiah Metaphor while being exclusive to a single console
>>
>>751719282
>blatantly woke with the "loyal servant" shit
The fuck is that even supposed to mean?
>>
>>751719927
Having a servant is WOKE
>>
>>751718130
13 was the first one with modern graphics
15 was a butchered versus but that was still good enough to hype up
16 was kind of just there
>>
Actionslop isn't fun.
>>
>>751723098
It is though
That's a big part of why Jack's game is the best one in the entire franchise
>>
>>751719818
I would have loved it if it was more like 12 instead of a boring DMC clone.
>>
>>751718130
It flopped because it was a substantially inferior clone of Devil May Cry in terms of gameplay, the story is just horrible, and the main character is a crybaby incel
>>
>>751718130
Generic medieval setting riding off game of thrones looked terrible to me.
>>
>>751718130
The story is good until the Bahamut fight then it just starts fucking meandering and dragging itself out. They shoulda kept it on a smaller scale but everyone was on the Game of Thrones skooma at the time so the writers just had to indulge themselves way too much with all the politics shit
>>
Christ people really need to learn what the word flop actually means.
FF16 had a development budget around $60 million and it's sold to date based on Analyst data over 5 million+.
3 million of which was in the first week at full price only on PS5.
Sure it was hardly a resounding success but Square still got their ROI on it... Which is more than can be said for the numerous western flops these last couple of years like Wolverine recently and it's measly 2.4 million copies and $300 million budget. Or Gears Eday with 500k copies sold on a $400 million budget.
>>
>>751718130
If I wanted an ARPG equivalent of FF I’d just play Tales
>>
its boring as shit
>>
The least ambitious Final Fantasy...
>>
>>751725045
is III
>>
>>751719412
Well that one kiss caused it to flop not sure what to tell you. I was curious but when I heard there was ONE instance of faggots kissing, that was -$60 to SE from me. Enough people feel this way that it flopped
>>
15 minutes of 10/10 boss fights inbetween every 5 hours of the worst 1/10 filler in gaming that's so bad it makes me never want to boot it up again
it's impossible to recommend to anyone because of that
>>
It should be noted that the Steam release and DLC had essentially no motion, many people in this thread probably forgot there even was a DLC before this post. Regardless if it technically made its money back, this game threw away any good will the franchise had left for newer entries unless there’s some major changes.
>>
>I admire SE for doing new things, being creative and ambitious instead of doing the same thing all the time!
>what the fuck? where's cloud and tifa? I don't care about this game
>>
>>751719867
Rent free
>>
>>751718880
Anon, this isnt tour thread on /bant/. This one is about final fantasy. Wrong tab.
>>
>>751718130
Setpieces were kino, but overall mid game.

The entire cast was boring and not even remotely interesting amd I kind of agree with that guy who said Clive is an incel. He is really cringe and creepy.
>>
>>751718130
I never played this but this looks like the most boring game ever made.
>>
>>751718130
Even a good action game wouldn't be able to sustain itself for 50-60 hours. I was bored out of my mind by kupka.
>>
>>751724926
comparing tales to ff16 is an insult to the former
>>
>>751725045
makes perfect sense considering who is behind it
>>
>>751718130
It wasnt fun
>>
>Make a 30 hour adventure
>Add most side content at the end
>All side content must be stumbled upon organically and there are no markers for it
>Each character gets an arc with a nice bow on it in the side content
>Make a few harder end game dungeons with a gimmick
Wallah! FF is fixed and will now sell like hotcakes again. Too many RPGs overstay their welcome, like a 900 page book that could have been 300
Just do exactly what FF6 and Chrono trigger did. That's people want out of their RPG.
>>
>>751725981
Wow just like Resonance.
>>
>>751725789
>to the former
Tales of Anime Faggotry are budget bin JRPGs. Both Tales and Trials are just awful series that only continue to exist because anime fans are not exactly hard to please.
>>
>>751726109
yes and those budget jrpg have more entertainment value than ff16 could ever hope to. grim.
>>
>>751726042
Yeah I've been playing it and liking it, it's really good. I wish the 3D movies in battle could be turned off because they're gay as fuck but that's a small concession. I was going to say a mainline game could be more ambitious on characters and story but desu I like big tittied black veil lady well enough so maybe not
>>
I despise Square Enix so much. They botched 15 to create 16.
>>
>>751726273
16 flopped and 15 succeeded. Gay may cry is not FF, party action road trip kino with bros is.
>>
>>751718130

So, speaking as someone who has LOVED Final Fantasy XVI, and played it, the DLCs and did most of the side content.

1) Chief complaint, it is not in any way, shape or form an RPG and, as such, should not have been a mainline title. I genuinely feel if they called it Final Fantasy: War of the Eikons or some shit it would've received a quarter of the complaints.

2) It's DMC-lite. The combat is really nice and snappy but lacks depth, and for the most part enemies are damage sponges for no reason other than to inflate combat times artificially. I love inflation as much as any other anon, but that is not the right way to do this. It makes no sense for random animals or normal humans to resist the onslaught of the power of several fucking gods for that long, especially when you show them get instantly fucking pulverized by those very same powers on several occasions.

3) It has some REALLY fucking bad pacing issues. It hits incredibly high highs, especially during the Titan and (OH MY FUCKING GOD) Bahamut (THAT FUCKING BOSSFIGHT HOLY SHIT) segments which are followed by A COMPLETE FUCKING STOP IN NARRATION, ACTION AND RYTHM. It's like someone's given you a tuned sports car, let you loose on a circuit, then once you were done with a couple laps a magical brick wall spawned right in front of you while you were going a million miles an hour. It is VERY bad storytelling and pacing.

4) Bossfights lack substance and difficulty. They're just spectacle. Really good spectacle, but there is nothing more to them really. They're fun but not in the slightest challenging.

Basically, XVI lacks 99% of what makes (made) mainline FFs (pre XIII) what they were. It lacks freedom, it lacks RPG elements, it lacks difficult content (that isn't artificially made so and that forces you to replay the same stuff again but tuned different).

Idk, I give XVI a 2.5/10 as a mainline FF, but a 7/10 as a game in general. It's fun, I don't regret actually buying it but I wanted an RPG lol
>>
>>751726385
>it is not in any way, shape or form an RPG
Quite honestly this is a stupid complaints because FF's rpg elements has always been extremely superficial. Look at the underlying damage/defense calculations in older FF titles, they are pathetic.
Now, 16 does have an issue with itemization and DLCs solve it somewhat, but i always chuckle when i see this complaint, especially if people praise FF4 or 9 in the same breath.
>>
>>751726531

Previous FFs, even XV which is breakdancing on the line between RPGs and anything else, had:

Buffs, debuffs, elemental weaknesses and strengths, offensive/defensive item usage, a plethora of spells, stats which were actually influenced by gear in a more or less meaningful manner, but at the very least minimally meaningful unlike XVI's COMPLETELY illusory one, possibility of a certain degree of customization by choosing your job / which skills to learn / which abilities to turn on or off / what kind of combat style to adopt.

Hell I fucking hate XIII with a passion and that too is a FAR better Final Fantasy title than XVI is if we're talking it being an RPG.

Now mind you, I love XVI, I loved the story, really loved the characters, my only real complaint is with the pacing of it: they've rushed certain moments / characters and decided to entirely break the momentum at other points which I found infuriating, but it's also a REALLY well developed and written world (the ingame codex is bonkers) and the characters are written and acted out beautifully, imho.

The previous titles, at least pre XII, had A LOT more depth (like, a LOT LOT) to them and sure, some titles (VIII I'm looking at you in particular) are arguably pretty much half assed but they at least fucking TRIED and the average person is EXTREMELY unlikely to find the many ways to break the games very early on anyway.

It always was the beautiful mixture of RPG elements, whether they were super well developed or not, and amazing stories that made me love FF, and each title, including XIII and, hell, even XIV which is online, had all that. XV's story was horribly, horribly butchered and rushed and the trailers had more plot than the game itself did in the end so yeah, that one is what it is too, but still.

So yes, I'll praise 4, 8, 9, even XIII over XVI when it comes to the RPG department. They tried, some failed. XVI didn't even try being an RPG, the devs tried calling it one, but it isn't, at ALL
>>
>>751725301
this
>>
>>751718130
>Thinks Zidane is a good protagonist
>Hates Tidus
This made me wince
>>
When is it coming to Switch2?
>>
>>751718130
an absolute nothingburger of a mainline entry, they could call the next one xvi and no one would notice
>>
>>751718130
Not RPG. XIII and XV were bad, but RPGs
>>
>singleplayer game
>cooldown based
How fucking lazy are these old fart devs?
>>
>>751718130
Its the combat. People dont like the DMC esque gameplay. Also the story starts strong but it devolved into the typical "must kill god" route JRPGs take and thats boring as fuck
>>
At least it was better than Flopbirth.
>>
File: 1794823071891536m.jpg (83 KB, 806x1024)
83 KB JPG
>>751733052
Rebirth is a masterpiece.
>>
>>751733382
Said noone ever. That's why it flopped
>>
>>751735085
>flopped
>part 3 coming next year
I don't think you understand the meaning of the words you are saying.
>>
>>751733382
in the same way the sky is green
>>
It's just not a good game. They tried to make medieval asian, and attack is a face button.

Looks good sometimes, and is a kind of grindan like diablo, instead of a select attack jrpg. The dialogue and story is to be skipped though, it's so bad it's infectious, would lower standards. There is a lot os stupid asian shit in it. And no it is not impressive. Grounded physics and actions would be. Being a big monster pressing a button repeatedly when you can, flying around is just shit. Takes the gravity away from the subtle.

It's ok. Better than most FFs. Just not good enough. I haven't finished it though, maybe it gets better.

Sometimes it looks very good.

Except Clive, he looks like a fucking animu character.
>>
>>751735085
>game gets sequel
>ITS A FLOP!
i wish saying flop would get you a instant ban for being a shill
fucking shithole
>>
>>751726330
15 commercially succeeded but critically and culturally flopped which is why they got punished with 16. how many people regretted buying? a lot i'd wager.
>>
16 is a masterpiece, people are just retarded
>>
It's boring.
>Clive we need to destroy another crystal
>Woops the way is blocked
>Clive we MUST do menial bullshit to unblock the way
>Talk to this NPC
>Now talk to this NPC
>OK go back and talk to this NPC
>This NPC now
>ENEMIES
>Use your blue AoE, red AoE, or brown AoE attack it doesn't matter
>Wew good job Clive, ok let's go talk to the NPC
>Good job Clive here's a badge/pin/medal to get to the next bland area
>Oh shi! Clive the way is blocked!
>IFFRIIIIITTTTTTTT
>Shitty gameplay intensifies
50 hours of this shit.
>>
File: 1.jpg (94 KB, 736x822)
94 KB JPG
>>751718130
This game's story completely runs out of steam right after you kill Hugo. No relevant characters left, hyper focus on Clive. The story literally turns into Naruto and not even the good part but the Ninja War final arc.

The combat while you can style ala DMC it is not necessary and actually makes fights take too long, so most of the time you'll just be spamming the most powerful abilities without a care in the world, bored and whishing for the game to fucking end already.

The only good FF games Square has made since the PS2 era are FF7R and FF7RE. FF16 barely even passes for a FF game. They should have called it something it.
>>
>PS5 exclusive when not many owned a PS5
>Year later for unoptimized PC port
>Did nothing to address all of the fixable complaints from the original release in the time to do the DLC/PC port
>>
>>751725301
Basically
>>
>>751735164
>>751735673
Sales numbers? Don't lie or inflate them.
Oh, you can't.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.