>zelda games are great except for the dungeon>dark souls comes out which is literally zelda without dungeonsITT we thank Miyazaki for fixing zelda
>>751722003idk what you are talking about but1. Zelda doesn't need dungeons2. Dark Souls is roll slop
>>751722581Zelda IS dungeons you ubislop fuck. What a deranged post.
>>751722581>>751722581>zelda games are great except for the dungeonI completely agree with this and don't understand how people think otherwise. There exist Zelda dungeons that are good, but they are the exception. The 'formula' of:-Go through a bunch of rooms and do whatever simple task is in those rooms-Get map, then go to parts where there are rooms that you haven't entered yet and do more tasks there-Get compass, and go and collect keys in the chests that you hadn't opened yet-Finally, after getting 2/3s of the way through the dungeon, actually get the fucking item that dungeon is supposed to be based around-Use item to activate things around the dungeon that use it-Trigger something that changes part of the dungeon-Go back through the dungeon to get the boss key-Get to the boss, and use the item to smash the bosses weakpoint open when it get revealedIs absolutely colossally boring garbage. I can't believe a series as otherwise creative and often delightfully unhinged as Zelda is shackled to such a lame convention, especially when most of them contain 2-3 actual puzzles or challenges at most, and otherwise are mainly navigation problems. Good 'dungeons', like BotW's Hyrule castle, the final dungeons of both NES games, OoT's Gerudo Training Grounds, OoS's Sword and Shield dungeon, and maybe LA's Eagle Tower exist, but they are the exception.
>>751722003The dungeons are the only good part of Zelda albeit
>>751727579I genuinely want to know how someone could possibly have this opinion. Please explain.
>>751722003Nintendo let Capcon to make Zelda games, its now fromsoft time do it
>>751722003If you played the trannymaster version, you didn't beat the game
>>751722003the dungeons are the only reason to play zelda games. Its why BOTW and TOTK are garbage.
Both of these series have dogshit gameplay and are only popular because of their brands
Did I accidentally fall into bizzaro land? The dungeons are the only good thing about Zelda games. The world sections are shit.
>>751727579this. got bored by BOTW after 10 hours because it had no proper dungeons.
Zelda dungeons are the literal reason the franchise exists. Without dungeons zelda is just open world slop. Look at BOTW and TOTK. They are both forgettable trash.
PLAY THE ORACLE GAMES, BOTH OF YOU.
>no dungeons>Sens fortresslmol
>elden ring is dark souls with dungeons and it sucks ass
>>751722003Most retarded post I've read all day. Congratulations.
Zelda should be built around dungeons, and the best "overworlds" are ones with dungeon-like progression as opposed to being open zones. Oracles, TMC, and SS are peak in that regard.We just need a Zelda game that wholly integrates dungeons with the environment itself. Kind of like Tears' Spirit Temple. Just, not shit.
>>751727661Dungeons are where most of the new combat encounters happen, and where you get new tools to explore withStrip those away and you just run around and talk to npcs and in rare cases get an npc quest started or explore mini dungeons that exist in random caves in the overworld
>>751728237Contrarianism this thread is I'm afraidOr it's unironic zoomers that have botw as their first Zelda
>>751728593>Dungeons are where most of the new combat encounters happen, and where you get new tools to explore withThese are both perfectly good reason to like dungeons that I agree with, at the same time they're the only things that are actually good about the dungeons, and a huge proportion of the game's dungeons only minimally use either. Most of the games have piss easy combat, and most of the dungeons lock you out of getting their items until the final parts, and hence make minimal use of the thing, so you may as well have more ways of getting new items outside of dungeons.
>>751728139>>751728336>>751728376>>751728625>Two of the best received and best selling games ever made>"They're trash"I love you guys
>>751722003>>zelda games are great except for the dungeonThe fuck are you talking about you drooling retard
>>751722003>Only good soulsslop games are the ones like DeS and DaS1 which include dungeoncrawling and puzzle bossesWhat did he mean by this?>>751727661The remnant of Zelda without dungeons is just fetchquests, minigames and trying to find environment secrets.>>751728559SS has 3D Mario progression, just with a character that doesn't feel fun to control. Trying to describe its overworld as dungeon-like is just misunderstanding what dungeons in the games even are. Not even the dungeons in Zelda games are just one puzzle or optimized environment challenge after another with no breaks.
>>751729516>fetchquests, minigames and trying to find environment secrets.Even if you try to reduce it to this, all of this is far more interesting than what you actually do in most dungeons. Zelda has some of the best quest design in all gaming, the actual environments are highly dynamic, responding to day/night cycles, time travel, changing dimensions/seasons etc. and problems can involve using items in close to arbitrary ways, NPCs are often some of the best in the medium and the solution to a given problem could involve anything in the entire overworld, while it's almost never the case that what happens in a dungeon matters to another.At best a dungeon might have some things randomly tucked away in some of its corners, but very few things will be hidden in actually interesting or elaborate ways, and rarely will the dungeon format actually be taken advantage of to provide real challenge. BotW's Eventide Island does a far better job of this, for example, than any of any of the game's actual dungeons, so actual dungeon offers a genuinely unique challenge where every single resource you might find potentially matters and in something you are incentivized to use in creative ways.