Has time redeemed it?
No, it's shit on a fundamental level because it broke with the formula that made the first two games good. Small handcrafted worlds, factions you can actually join and so on. It's one of the first devs that fell for the open world meme - big world, but no depth to it.And the pajeet made expansion pack doesn't even need discussion, it was so hilariously bad.
>>751727438playing a mage is somewhat fun but overall it sucks, not the music thoughhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a6pfstI4A2A
Man, I remember I got a new PC specifically for gothic 3 and the load times, especially when teleporting were still abysmalit's somewhat more enjoyable nowadays, but it's still a very flawed game
Despite all the flaws I still like it, doesn't have the depth of first two games obviously but it's still a comfy large world to explore with shitloads of enemies to kill.What I find amusing is that there are numerous modpacks and "fixes" but they somehow all make the game even worse. AB is full retard too.
I had my fun with it, but it's not the one I keep coming back to every couple of years.That being said, any Gothic 2 mod recommendations while I'm still waiting for Archolos 2.0?
>>751727438One of the biggests disappointments in my life
>>751727438No. It is truly a horrible game in every sense.
>try the gothic remake demo>everyone hates me>i don't have any weapons>everything kills me in 3 hitsamazing
>>751729084sounds like it's faithful to the original
>>751729084haven't played the remake, but I was pretty surprised that it was apparently positively received
>>751729187its time of remakes and any game that doesnt hold your hand a lot still apreciated more if its rpg
>>751727438No, it's still as terrible as it was 20 years ago, even with community "fixes". This is the only PB game I never finished, even the shitty Risen sequels were more bearable.
Gothic 3 would be the best Elder Scrolls game if it was part of that series but Gothic had much higher standards, thankfully Archolos exists.
>was just a youngin, nya>it happened quick, nya>wanted to become a melee paladin, nya>just had to clear out the wild boars, nya>UNF UNF AHHHH>a loud moan as they stunlocked and raped me, nya>killed my old pc too, nya
>>751727438it was the cyberpunk 2077 of its time, but thankfully it released in an age when games didn't get "engoodened" so it hasn't redeemed itself.they abandoned the superior open world design of 1 & 2 because bethesda's sold better, then tried competing directly with bethesda. it was a recipe for disaster.most of the game is the chapter 1 experience from the first game, where you go to a settlement and do side quests so they let you in the upper quarter, pasted over 20 towns where most of those quests are the usual mmo fare. it still tickles the dopamine sensors which makes it a guilty pleasure, but I don't replay it nearly as often as the first two.
>>751727438No, it's still dreadful. You can use mods to fix some bugs and iron out some kinks, but when the game's design is fundamentally broken, there's only so far you can go without remaking it from the scratch.
>>751727438why are half the NPCs in this game legitimately obese?
>>751728693I really like using Nostalgia mod though some german streamer made a fun little mod that randomizes items and enemies diablo style.
>>751729187It has plenty of flaws but for once the devs tried to be faithful to the spirit of the original and you can even tell they had fun making the game.
>>751728693If you want a vanilla mod that rebalances the original game without bloating it with weird content made by drunk Russians, I can recommend Gothic 2 Minus, also called Other Balance. It makes the game more difficult, but it also adds QoL stuff like early teleportation runes, no need for hoarding stat bonuses (most abilities just cost flat 2 LPs), mana regen ability, faster magic progression. It does have some issues though, magic is a bit OP, while tankier enemies make archery much less viable, since it hinges on ability to one- or two-shot monsters. Some escorting NPCs typically used for farming early exp like Bartok or Lares got nerfed too much and WILL die without your help (especially Bartok vs Shadowbeast, he gets absolutely DESTROYED and it took me fucking ages to pull a win off), but at the same time Diego is still immortal and can still clear half of the map for you. Also you have to keep in mind that monsters are more aggressive and give you less time to back off before attacking.
>>751727438There are many mods trying to fix the game and none succeeds. The game is just flawed.
>>751733618No amount of mods can fix the fact that the game has no plot, no direction and all you do is going from one town to another doing same fetch quests and same liberation/extermination battles. Add to that awful, floaty combat and very weak character progression, and you get something that is simply unsalvageable. Gothic 3 just has no strong points other than the music to use as the foundation for fixes.They really should've just improved on the G2 formula instead of reinventing the wheel.
why are the Archolos devs teasing us for like two years alreadyjust fucking release the update, I want to replay
>>751734503only slavshits care about that shitty ''fan'' modgo die in a trench Ivan
>>751734503Lying faggots
>>751734723There's still December...
>>751729187People forgot how old games were played beforeAnd now they're as difficult as soulslikes to current gen gamers
I liked the magic in 3 more than 2 and 1. Mana was more plentiful, easier to recover, and most spells weren't gated behind progression. Melee sucked dick though.
>>751729084>everyone hates me>i don't have any weapons>everything kills me in 3 hitsthe average Germany experience
>>751731813does it have new content past act 1? In the original game the game becomes an action adventure game from act 2 onwards and I missed the RPG stuff from act 1, so I wonder if the remake fixes that
>>751734503>>751734723December 10th
Who the fuck thought it was a good idea to remove a proper faction system for this annoying reputation shit?
>>751727438its the best one in the franchise lolI also truly appreciate Arcania for being the first game to get console ports, something that took PB 15 years to do after the fact
>>751727438Absolutely fucking not. For the record I played it for the first time about 3 years ago.
>>751727582/thread
It was way shittier than Gothic 2 and 1 and yet it still wasn't as shit as Gothic 4, Elex or even Risen
>>751727438This game unironically uses comic sans, it's a joke
>>751737576To some degree yes, not as much as I might've wanted but the drawback from sticking close to the first game is how frontloaded it is/was. But there are some extra things to do.
>>751727438The thing is, it lies in the shadow of one of the greatest RPGs ever, so you can't fully trust people shitting on it. Overall though it definitely went in the wrong direction. It's a gothic game that went open-world (or rather unfocused) and the Gothic games was always focused games story driven games, even though you might technically call them open world or open ended.Not sure if it deserves to be forgotten though. I was too young to have a critical sense, but I actually remember enjoying the game. Problem with revisiting open world games is that it's just a slog, and they definitely pad the game like most open worlds, which makes it excruciating returning to it as an adult.The OST is great though. Vista point can hit you right in the feels without any nostalgia.
>>751739681I don't think anyone thought it was a good idea, the game looks like something you get when proper development suddenly stops in the middle and then the team rushes to create something playable out of what they have at that point.