>Unrest in Cyrodiil City: "Uriel Septim is sick, and wizards say his heir, Geldall Septim, and the younger Septims, Enman and Ebel, are just doppelgangers placed in the household during Jagar Tharn's tenure as Imperial Battlemage. They say the Guard charged a mob demanding destruction of the false heirs... lots of folks were killed."Oh man I can't wait for Oblivion!!!! The political intrigue is going to be so juicy!!!! Imagine how Cyrodiil City will look like, with a Colovia/Nibenay cultural divide and fields of rice paddies along the city's canals guarded by Roman dragon riders and showing the heart of the Empire's technology teased in Battlespire and Redguard like a huge navy and even airships!!!! It's gonna be so fucking cool!!!!
I mostly remember 2006 as the year I stopped preordering after the disappointments that were Oblivion and Gothic 3.
Oblivion feels like it takes place in its own pocket dimension, or like it was the first sequel they made to the Arena/Daggerfall world with nothing in-between. You can look at Skyrim and sorta see how it could be the Morrowind world only after 200 years of post-apocalyptic decline in civilization, arts and culture, magic etc. but Oblivion was meant to be the Empire at its post-Simulacrum peak, at least in terms of the facade it presented the world (which is why the Morrowind rumor about the civil unrest and Uriel being ill sound foreboding, contrasting the image the Empire projects of itself). But this is never felt. Imperial Navy? There's no city in the entire fucking province with big enough docks to maintain a flotilla, nevermind the biggest armada in Tamriel. They could've had their cake and eaten it too with the airship shenanigans by saying Uriel's sons were killed specifically when their airships were taken over and ended up Flight 93'd. Something. Fucking anything outside of what should be the most technologically and culturally advanced province in the world being a worse High Rock.
>Holy shit Todd, have you seen this new movie??
>>751730960Why are Morrowboomer fans obsessed with Kirkbride's fanfiction? He retconned established lore because he thought he was more intelligent than the rest of the writers; yet when you read his own work that he wrote without the in-put of others you realise he is just a retarded pseud who has too high an opinion of himself.
>>751731287Project Cyrodiil in its limited Anvil release already shows a stupid amount of promise of what Cyrodiil is meant to actually be like. The kingdom of Anvil has several echelons of bureaucracy and old wounds it is dealing with, a failed coup a few years back orchestrated by the kingdom's original Shore-King now a vampire who believes the throne belongs to him by blood, the shores are raided by brigans and vampires the Navy is too busy with politics to do anything about, a bunch of the dungeons around the area are Reman-era forts that look and feel rightfully distinct from modern Imperial guardposts, and in the second to last main quest in the area, when one of the royal princes comes around, you can *feel* how big a fucking deal it is: he lands on top of the castle with an Imperial Airship, he is protected by two bodyguards both of which are seen wearing a mix of Imperial Ebony and Daedric equipment telling you they are not fucking around, and players aware of previous games lore are rewarded with the realization they are actually the protagonists of Battlespire which explains why they'd be given this position and just how much experience they have combating threats to the Empire.Oblivion is just... empty. Of anything even remotely interesting that ties to the broader TES universe. It's a self-contained LOTR LARP set in an empty world where every single Imperial fort is taken over by bandits and the music and visuals want to sell you on this idyllic fantasy adventure meanwhile narratively you're meant to be going through the single worst Oblivion invasion in human history yet nobody cares.
>>751731727petty bait aside, OP's topic is more of a Kuhlmann thing.
The only people that like Oblivion are those who were 7 when it came out and they grew up with it
Oblivion is more like sequel to Daggerfall than to Morrowind. Skyrim feels more like Morrowind than Oblivion does.
>>751731727>why do people prefer the media that is written better?gee i fucking wonder dipshit
>>751730960>fields of rice paddiesNah, Carnivore's paradise Oblivion is better
>>751731865>LOTROblivion was going to be Oblivion before any LotR influence
>>751731865I disagree, project Cyrodil/Tamriel Rebuilt/Skyrim HotN being based on Morrowind era lore doesn't change the fact that all of its content, world building, characters and aesthetic is inferior to Oblivion/Morrowind/Skyrim respectfully
>>751734806In that they had an idea for an Oblivion invasion marking the end of the Septim dynasty? Yes, it was teased as early as Redguard's intro and Eno Romari's dialogue in Tribunal. In that Oblivion the game was gonna look and feel like it did? Absolutely not.
>>751735281this was sourced by kirkbride but everyone who worked for bethesda who was asked about this says otherwise, ergo kirkbride was probably speaking metaphorically
>>751731727>retconned established loreBasically the only lore Cyrodiil had in Arena & Daggerfall was "it's where the capital is" and "it's inhabited by the main races and their mutts and has no native race of its own", which you know it's not as if modern post-kirkbride TES does the latter either
>>751735281>In that Oblivion the game was gonna look and feel like it did? Absolutely not.It absolutely was, the LotR inspirations came much later but the initial expectation was Oblivion. Kirkbride lied
>>751731069>Gothic 3 comes out>Play it>Upset at this fucking shit that barely runs and is dumbed down and stupid and breaks with the lore and reeeeee>Keep coming back to it over the years hoping to find the good parts of it they promised on the box>Keep coming back to it>I now know it basically by heart up until Nordmar, and I feel intense nostalgia towards it, despite never having liked it>It's the Gothic game I've replayed the most times>I no longer find the orcs cringe as fuck>In my heart of hearts I think of Xardas ending as canon>If asked why I like it all I can say is "I like the world and the music.">That's allWhat did I do to myself?
>>751730960i sure hope todd will finally give us horsesand i know this is a bit out there, but it would be cool to have an armored horse, idk about you guys but i would literally pay money to have that
>>751731865oblivion wasnt chasing lotr hype as kirkbride saidkirkbride said it was because he was really fucking mad at bethesda for not sticking to him, not as a cultural basis but rather as an insultin part because kirkbride doesnt like classical fantasy at all and sees it as an insultsimilar to saying a modern game like nuGOW is aping marvel movies, even if its not taking after them
>>751735716Oblivion was unironically a return to Daggerfall. Not in terms of lore, since it ultimately still uses the PGE1's world as basis, but more in the way the world is portrayed to work. Each city having a "count", the scrapped concept of a "Duke of Colovia", the general fact that the Imperials just look like medieval europeans with a very light Roman theming, it's likely meant to harken back to Daggerfall days, when ALL of Tamriel was supposed to be a feudal medieval europe ruled by scheming backstabbing noblemen ruling small city-state/kingdoms, something that Redguard & Morrowind-era lore confined to just High Rock as its main gimmick. Though ironically that politics aspect still ends up in the backseat because they wanted the game to focus 100% on the Daedra InvasionIt was probably a collective decision but i can't help but think Nesmith was heavily involved since that guy clearly preferred the simpler way things worked in Daggerfall, most infamously shown by what he did to the Nordic Pantheon in Skyrim
>>751731727>hating on kirkbrideDon't know about his writings outside of the games but even in Oblivion the only interesting piece of lore (Alessia rebellion/Pelinal Whitestrake) were written by him, so...
>>751730960I give Oblivion a pass for being the first RPG to make playing a thief fun. Its just a shame that everything mechanically that isn't vestigial from morrowind or thieving related is absolute dogshit
>>7517310692005-2009 were the real turning points of gaming becoming dogshit. Zoomers like to pretend otherwise, because there were still shit games being marketed to masculine normalfags at the time, but everything that made games fun suddenly became "bad game design" around 2006.
>>751736004dzien dobry pidor kurwa
>>751735716>everyone who worked for bethesda who was asked about this says otherwiseSource? And I mean actual source by actual devs years after Oblivion shipped, not pre-release or immediately after release in a "it's totally not LOTR pls Peter Jackson don't sue us" kinda way.>>751735775>LotR inspirations came much later but the initial expectation was OblivionLearn how to read because you said literally the same thing I did.
>>751736032I bought horse armor and spell tomes on day 1
>>751736334Shivering Isles lore was better and that wasn't Kirkbride, but it also filtered everyone (including autismos like PatricianTV) who isn't into literature because it was still too esoteric for a video game at the time.
>>751736582>>LotR inspirations came much latermuch later as in 2003-2004 after Oblivion was half finished. The few examples of that include Mithril
>>751730960Skyrim felt like that too. The thalmor invaded and outlawed a god and we got some weird save the world thing about dragons.
>>751736582https://www.reddit.com/r/oblivion/comments/1wmasom/actual_influence_lord_of_the_rings_had_on/inb4 reddit
>>751736212>oblivion wasnt chasing lotr hypeme when I lie
>>751736750Internally it wasn't an objective or even a major factor. People just repeat it because they LISTEN and BELIEVE to 6 hour youtube videos (the people who made those videos are just ranting occasionally citing an article)
>>751736742>reddit
Considering Kirkbride leaked Sentinels name for literally no reason I think its true he's still salty at Bethesda
>>751730960It is funny just how thoroughly Oblivion shat the bed
>>751736913The Xbox pajeeta went out of her to drum up discussion about it through that tweet and all he did was agree with some random redditor who guessed it first, probably while knowing that half of all people would refuse to believe him due to the "noooo Kirkbride stopped working Bethesda 40 years ago he knows literally nothing and his opinions don't matter!!!" section of the fanbase
>>751736634Yes I'm sure fucking Oblivion features "writing too esoteric for a video game at the time" and not just retardedly written content some schizos get themselves attached to and try to see more than is there. Like Mankar Camoran getting the basic ass Daedric Realms wrong because Kirkbride wrote them wrong but people try and cope about it. Jesus Christ.
>>751737292>probably while knowing that half of all people would refuse to believe him due to the "noooo Kirkbride stopped working Bethesda 40 years ago he knows literally nothing and his opinions don't matter!!!" section of the fanbase???
>>751736742>male feminist redditorNot a good look for kirkbride hipsters.
>>751737401As in, for every person who wanks Kirkbride too much there's one who downplays his contributions to the franchise by bringing up the fact that he hasn't been an actual Bethesda employee since before Morrowind released, despite the fact he still worked with them as a contractor and advisor all the way until Skyrim's early development. You've probably seen that type around. The 40 years is just hyperbole, if that's your hangup
>>751737591>You've probably seen that type aroundThey're in this very thread kek
>>751737339>>Yes I'm sure fucking Oblivion features "writing too esoteric for a video game at the time"It does though. Its a pretty commonly accepted facet of Oblivion that its MQs (Oblivion, KotN and especially SI) are all overtly esoteric and the well written parts of the setting especially as related to the lore/setting, while the side quests tend to have the basic degree of tonal verticality people associate with Oblivion, in part because most people skip the Main Quests. Everything related to Sheogorath, Mehrunes Dagon and Pelinal is x10000 more interesting than Bloodmoon and Tribunal and is still discussed often in autistic lore circles
>>751736690>2003>three years before release>"after Oblivion was half finished"
>>751737940Work on Oblivion began shortly after the release of Morrowind in 2002.[23] By mid-September 2004, Oblivion had been officially announced, and its title revealed.[23][24]Oblivion went gold in 2005
>>751730960>>751731287>>751731865They couldn't reference past lore because they wanted to appeal to console kids. No Tharn reference, no Dagon invasion of the Battlespire reference, no General Warhaft appearance, nothing that'd cause kids playing Oblivion on the 360 to be even remotely confused about anything.
>>751738185you say that but almost none of the TES games were very referential of their previous installments until Skyrim and ESO barring single digit counts of obscure text blurbs
>>751738104>Oblivion went gold in 2005But it didn't? It went gold on March 2, 2006https://www.gamespot.com/articles/elder-scrolls-unrolls-this-month/1100-6145290/So again: 2003, less than a year after Morrowind, three fucking years before release, "after Oblivion was half finished". Right.
>>751737570They all are. Just a little while ago Todd talked about how much he loves Reddit and how Bethesda takes the criticism and ideas from it to heart lol
>>751737847
>>751738242Daggerfall references what little it can of Arena during its character creator and uses factions that were merely wordplay in TES1 like the Blades and the Underking. Battlespire's whole main plot revolves around Tharn from Arena and expands the Daedric Princes from Daggerfall. Morrowind has OP's quote and all the weird Battlespire items associated with Divayth Fyr. And Skyrim is easily the game that calls back to the past the most.
>>751738242>none of the TES games were very referential of their previous installments until Skyrim and ESO barring single digit counts of obscure text blurbsBiggest load of horseshit uttered in this entire thread so far. Have you ever wondered why Orcs suddenly became a playable race in Morrowind? There's a reason for it.
>>7517379402003-2004 implies late 2003/early 2004 which you can trace by the tech adoption, so 2 years into development (if I'm remembering correctly), and they released 2 years later (early 2006) ergo halfway into development
>>751737847>Its a pretty commonly accepted facet that its MQs are all overtly esoteric and the well writtenBest part is you unironically believe this.
>>751730960Oblivion's shit and water's wet what else is new what's the point of this thread
>4E 206>Elves on the verge on conquering all of Tamriel and using an Elder Scroll to go back in time to the origin of creation and preventing Man from being born>Suddenly Talos descends from the heavens in a Numidium>TOTAL MER GENOCIDE commences
>>751731727Ken Rolston wrote the main quest dipshit not Kirkbride
>>751738104>By mid-September 2004, Oblivion had been officially announced, and its title revealedMorrowind and Oblivion's titles were revealed during the intro sequence to TESA:Redguard in 1998. The 5th game was titled "Romanelli" so Skyrim is the first game to break the sequence.
>>751738410>Morrowind has OP's quote and all the weird Battlespire items associated with Divayth Fyrand nothing else because Morrowind was a Tabula Rasa. Even your statement that Daggerfall featured any Arena lore is mostly wrong, I don't know about Battlespire but neither Shadowkey nor Redguard had a lot of other TES lore>>751738421Because they were adding more content? Outside of books explaining Daggerfalls time paradox ending there isn't weight given to the setting, Morrowind tried to facelift the entire thing>>751738587Kirkbride wrote the 36LoV which is what most people cite as being important to the MQ and worldbuilding
>>751738473There's pics in this thread proving you wrong, can you cite a contradiction to them?
>751738640>Kirkbride wrote the 36LoV which is what most people cite as being important to the MQ and worldbuildingExcept this thread wasnt about the lessons of vivec. Low effort troll not even worth a (you)
>>751738640>Because they were adding more content? Outside of books explaining Daggerfalls time paradox endingOne of Daggerfall's endings allows you to empower Orsinium and turn it into a mega civilization spanning the Illiac Bay. Each of the kingdoms have an ending like this so they had all become large empires and not at the same time. The result of the non-linear time fuckery is that Orcs are considered a civilized, respectable race when they hadn't been previously. This event is the reason why Orcs became playable. It's also why Mannimarco is simultaneously The Necromancer's Moon and a random necromancer in Oblivion's Mages Guild questline.
>>751739363i know
>>751739404Okay so how is that not a fucking reference?
>>751738640>and nothing elseWait until you figure out the first game King Helseth and his mom showed up in and what Tribunal directly continues from.
>>751739363Because those are more features of the setting being TES than reference to the plot, as the method by which those 2 endings are used in games is almost entirely divorced from them as objects in the game, as well as the info mentioned. Contrast this with Dragonborn in Skyrim which does have references to Morrowind (that weren't even in Bloodmoon)to compare, I can count about 50 direct references to previous games (1/2) in New Vegas direct to character events etc just in a minute off the top of my head, and this is without mentioning the fact that half of the plot and setting in New Vegas is dependent on stuff that happens in FO1/2. TES 1/2/3/4/5 could all exist in isolation from each other with all related context between them scrubbed out without changing a major amount. You can't say that about Mass Effect, Fallout, Dark Souls or Final Fantasy
Oblivion could never
>>751739961Where are those ships stationed in game? Besides Anvil, wouldn't the Empires Navy be outside the Cyrodil province which could only have Bravil/Leyawin/Anvil using meaningful amounts of ships (and Bravil is a poor swampy distant minor colony)This seems like a bigger picture issue
>>751740121>"The Far East Fleet, also known as the Sea Serpent Fleet, is headquartered at the docks of Old Ebonheart"
>>751740247It doesn't say if that's the entire Imperial Navy. If so isn't that's just Morrowinds Navy that the Empire is taking? What's their Navy before that.
>>751740328>"The West Navy is one of the Cardinal Fleets of the Imperial Navy, tasked with securing the waters of western Tamriel. It is divided into three fleets: the Home Fleet, the Iliac Fleet, and the Far West Fleet. Of these fleets, only the Home Fleet has a presence in Cyrodiil. This fleet is headquartered at Anvil's Fort Telodrach and is comprised of five squadrons each led by a commodore. It is responsible for patrolling the Abecean Sea, the Blue Divide, and the Sea of Torinaan"
>>751730960>WHY IS NONE OF THE ACID TRIP LORE REPRESENTED IN GAME???This is by far the most disingenuous talking point that Morrowboomers try to make when criticizing Skyrim or Oblivion. Morrowind is almost completely devoid of any cool shit in game. 90% of the cool shit in Morrowind only exists in the lore books and never appears physically in the game. Your game is a barren desert with some repeating mushroom props and a stationary big insect model in each city. It doesn't come close to properly showcasing the outlandish parts of TES lore.
>>751740827>when criticizing SkyrimBut we're not criticizing Skyrim.
>>751741249>instant disingenuous replyMorrowboomers just can't help themselves
>ten minutes later>pro-Skyrim pic and post>INSTANT MORROWBOOMER REPLY REEEEwhat did anon mean by this
>>751740827still infinitely closer than oblivion and skyrim
>>751740827giga trvke
>>751740827actually truethe wacky stuff you DO see (Hiricine, Almalexia, Vivec, the last Dwemer, Dagoth Ur) in Morrowind are not that out of left field in the actual gamethe rest are no name NPCs (except the meme'd caius or bridgeskeleton guy or that one khajit)Davyth Fyr is actually the best NPC simply because he has an interesting premise and high level gear, but he has almost no quest relevance
>>751740827>hey why doesn't the n°1 Imperial province in the world feature Imperial things like the Navy>"WHY IS NONE OF THE ACID TRIP LORE REPRESENTED IN GAME"Disingenuous 'tard
>>751738185The King of Worms was in it but unless you bother with the mages guild hes the only pre oblivion reference i recall
>>751745247literally discussed in the thread, the empires navy is not in Cyrodil because the geography doesnt allow for it. Bravil can't have a Navy due to its position, Anvil has boats but is to small, even with it being ridiculously over expanded in Tamriel Rebuilt it still cant have many boats, paradoxically leading to the same conclusion as in Oblivion.
>>751746186>literally discussed in the threadYou do realize I'm the one that posted >>751739961, right.You do realize what was "discussed in the thread" was in regards to TR/PC, right.>Anvil has boats but is to smallWhose fault is that.>paradoxically leading to the same conclusion as in OblivionBut it doesn't, because it represents the Navy, its people, its ranks, its job and its effect in the local politics. By being ingrained in the world, it doesn't matter if there's three boats or three hundred to the average player the same way you're to assume Whiterun is bigger in the lore: the intent of existence is made clear. The Empire quite literally has no Navy in Oblivion. It doesn't exist. It's not talked about. It doesn't play a part in the local goings on at sea in the wake of the Oblivion Crisis. And that's because Oblivion didn't care.
>>751746629>It doesn't exist. It's not talked about. It doesn't play a part in the local goings on at sea in the wake of the Oblivion Crisis. And that's because Oblivion didn't care.Because Cyrodils Navy was always in other provinces due to terrain (as its outsourced to other races)to contrast, Morrowind (Vvardenfell) has like 5 ships and its on an Island
>>751747546Damn if only we were told the Empire recalled all its forces back home...
>>751748264>Damn if only we were told the Empire recalled all its forces back home...>allthat's not truealso>I wonder where they're docking those hundreds of ships back home, since back home their only real docks are in AnvilEvery Dock in Vvardenfell is 100% on ship capacity anyway
>that's not true Oh, I wasn't aware I was speaking with a lorelet. Nevermind then.(You)
>>751748534Almost all of the Imperial Forts are fully staffed and manned, there's more Imperial Soldiers on Vvardenfell than there are Dunmer ones, wtf are you on?
>>751730960When I play Morrowind/Skyrim I just pretend that events similar to Oblivion are about to happen/happened but not the game we play, because it feels wholly disconnected from the other games.
The Kirkbride haters must be overjoyed that with no Kuhlmann to bring him in, he's not involved with TES 6.You'll get the perfect Pagliarulo and Chapin-penned narratives you've always wanted!
>>751735739Incorrecthttps://youtu.be/MgqtgzlMue4?t=471
>>751752191>watch my e-celeb videoSlice your wrists
>>751752191>Old Knight lmfao you gotta be kidding
>>751752230>>751752536https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Daggerfall:King_Edward>The journey through Valenwood was pleasant. The weather held fair for the most part, with sunny days and cool nights. Bright leaves of scarlet, crimson, gold and green drifted down to form a carpet beneath their horses' feet. Valenwood was very different from the somber, steep forests of High Rock. When they reached the northern border, Edward, looking back, saw that the trees were mostly bare, shorn of their glory. Before them lay a wide green land of rolling hills with only a few stands of trees. It seemed to spread on forever.>"This is Wilderland, Edward," Moraelyn said. "Be on your guard. It seems a pleasant land, but no king's writ runs here. Each man's hand is against every other's -- and there are worse than men. All the races of Tamriel meet here, and clash, save thine, perhaps." Daggerfall calls Cyrodiil "a wide green land of rolling hills", not a jungle. Oblivion simply undid Kirkbride's retcon. Cope all you want, it's the truth.
>>751752783I'm not watching your video, Old Knight. Suck my nuts.
>>751752848I accept your concession.
>>751752783>whataboutism Hey fuckface: retcons that make something more interesting GOOD. Retcons that make something less interesting BAD. First lesson's free.
>>751753197I was responding to>Basically the only lore Cyrodiil had in Arena & Daggerfall was "it's where the capital is" and "it's inhabited by the main races and their mutts and has no native race of its own"Which is false.I don't really care if the place looks like rural England or the Amazon, just don't try to defend your preference with "there was nothing there before" when it's not true.
>>751752783>>751753647I'm aware. It quite simply doesn't matter, though. There was a whole lot more to Kirkbride's (& Kuhlmann's) Cyrodiil than just its biome, and Daggerfall did indeed have basically nothing beyond those two things I mentioned. Cyrodiil in Arena & Daggerfall was in fact just a big grassland inhabited by mutts without a native culture of its own. The point was, If Bethesda (or you) cared that much about rolling back things to what they were in Daggerfall, they would have went further than just turning it back into England, erasing the Imperial race from the game, removing the name "Cyrodiil" itself, etc. But instead, you act like the type of tree is the thing that people lament and not the lack of a Colovia-Nibenay divide, moth worship, ercThat being said, now that I think about it, they did kinda do that in a way by stripping the Imperials of all their culture. Oblivion Cyrodiil is basically a big grassland without a culture of its own now that the Imperials are just Bretons who put skirts on their armor sometimes
>>751731069If you ever started preordering you are retarded. The only reason to ever do it is if the preorder nets you a ton of bonuses or a fat discount, if you're just paying full price in advance for the base product you are an idiot.
>>751730960Are the leaks true?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4qzGLw_2Baw
>>751756601Kek
>>751730960hey we're finally gonna tie up this storyline in The Elder Scrolls 6: Sentinel it only took literally 25 years. (they just started working on it, it won't be out for half a decade)
>>751731727hello Emil
>>751756601Damn that Boromir guy does a pretty good Martin Septim impression.
>>751731727holy shit /v/ is really compromised by the morrowind discord, what the fuck are those replies
>>751761589Cope
>>751761589this guy is weeping over his keyboard rn