[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


Is there actually a game that tried to have an adult story? No I dont mean sony exclusives, no I dont mean le deep spongebob roller coaster nintendo games, I dont even mean vagueposting loreslop either, I mean a story where the plot, characters, and dialogue could be placed into a real life book and people who read real books would consider it worthwhile rather than a "fun read" or some other popcorn flick equivalent
>>
File: Horses.png (476 KB, 1200x720)
476 KB PNG
>>751834527
>>
>>751834527
Devil May Cry 3.
>>
>>751834527
Has a recent book in the last 20 years?
>>
>>751834527
Silent Hill 2
>>
first one to say disco elysium gets beated to death
>>
Putting the stories in a book isn't the way to judge the quality of a video game's narrative. Are you stupid or what?
>>
>>751834527
Halo
>>
>>751834996
>generic heinleinian HOOAAH MUHREENS shit that's played completely straight
lol
>>
>>751834527
>people who read real books
don't give a shit about the story, they just wanna say that they read books because its a way for them to feel superior over the normies who do uncultured things like watch movies or play vidya
you ever been to /lit/?
>>
>>751835107
Your question is dumb as fuck OP
>>
File: gogo.jpg (179 KB, 721x1000)
179 KB JPG
I have two English degrees and you're a fucking idiot for trying to make this comparison.
>video game stories are bad because they don't work as books
VIDEO GAMES ARE MORE THAN JUST A STORY.
The reasons I like books and the reasons I like video games do not fully overlap, just as the reasons I like movies don't fully overlap with either.
Think about it like this. People bitch endlessly about how movie adaptations of books cut out stuff that they consider essential. It's not essential to the medium of film, there are visual elements and time constraints to consider. The same is true of video games, moreso because there are even MORE interconnected pieces.
Video games will never be considered art because these types of opinions get in the way of any substantial literary analysis.
Now, to be clear, video game writing is often subpar and many who write for games simply couldn't cut it as authors or script writers but that doesn't invalidate the medium as a whole, it simply needs more time to incubate.
That's all.
>>
wtf is an adult story nigga
>>
File: IMG_1883.jpg (172 KB, 1024x1024)
172 KB JPG
>>751834527
>I
>READ
>BOOOOOKKKKKSSSSSS
Hopefully 0 games, and 0 movies, and 0 books as well so snobby faggots who dont do anything but consoom while thinking highly of themselves dont feel ever so slightly higher than before for reading a book
>>
>>751834527
Word for word? Obviously not. But in terms of plot points and characters you could make a good novel out of many games.
>>
>>751835363
This. Far more of a red flag than thr book reading larp
>>
File: LOWOON-SK45.jpg (170 KB, 1001x745)
170 KB JPG
>I have been Roland, Beowulf, Achilles, Gilgamesh.
>I have been called a hundred names and will be called a thousand more before the world goes dim and cold.
>I am a hero.
>>
Undertale is nice, it's a nice fairy tale that uses the medium well
>>
>>751835320
>two English degrees
if anything, this detracts from your credibility (which is a shame because the opinion here is sensible)
>>
>>751835368
why are dudes using ai for what should be simple shitpost shoops. like just google "toradora volume 1 cover" and paste it over on paint instead of having claude make this ugly shit
>>
>>751834527
Does anyone have the meme of neon genesis but it's Bloom rising? I can't find it :(
>>
File: Stalin.jpg (571 KB, 555x831)
571 KB JPG
>>751835107
You know this is signifigant right? The only serious media produced these days is in regards to war and our military. Everything else is just distracting, time wasting, no commital, confusing nonsense that means nothing and just looks/sounds cool.

This is called the "Formalist Trend" and started all the way back in the 50s which led to rock and roll, the bikini etc. All these things were designed by top psychologists working with the CIA to be used as ideological propaganda weapons against the growing global communist movement. They serve to distract you from material reality and class struggle and entrance you in escapism by acting on your senses in a religious manner like gospel choirs or the music of the Shakers. The nihilism of the modern liberal world is no accident and it's why the only serious, ideologically driven media is shit that's designed to get young men to march off to war and die for capitalist profits. Stalin warned about this all the way back then.
>>
>>751834527
CRPGs tend to do that
>>
File: 5475467563544.png (436 KB, 435x655)
436 KB PNG
When someone says they like adult books I think of stuff like this
>>
>>751834527
Nier Automata. Philosophy chads would love it and women would love it even more.
>>
>>751834527
Just go read a book.
Games are about game design.
>>
>>751834527
No, but that's sort of a stupid way to judge the writing any game, or even a movie or TV show. I can't think of any that could be turned into a book good enough for Harold Bloom at least, not when stripped of all other elements unique to each medium for which the stories are written for.
>>
>>751834527
videogames are a medium for interactivity, the "story" of a videogame is emergent from how you interact with the world you're operating in. you don't understand the medium if all you want is movies and books pretending to be games.
>>
>>751834527
Why dont you say the same for books or movies? its because you feel you're inferior to them for consuming games.
>>
>>751834527
Disco Elysium
>>
>>751834527
super mario bros 2
>>
>>751835124
You just have an inferiority complex. Reading books isn't some big brain activity.
>>
>>751834895
disco elysium
>>
>>751836574
Yet you see performative readers everywhere. Curious.
>>
>>751834527
Planescape Torment, but that's cheating since there is so much fucking text it's been called "the best book you'll ever play".
>>
>>751836628
Fuck Arcanum, and Fuck Planescape, nobody has time for this nonsense and I will gang bang any unc that disagrees with me.
>>
>>751835363
story with naked boobies
>>
>>751836574
>Reading books isn't some big brain activity.
literature is taught as a PhD subject and people regularly do their thesis on a single author's works but ok
>>
Warren Spectre met the two johns doing Quake 2 and told them he was so disgusted with their childish storytelling he started making Deus Ex
>>
>>751836707
>>751835124
Readers like that can never be writers. Writing is best when revealed through vision and experience. You cannot teach that. You can teach to copy
>>
>>751836574
Explain why there’s an observably enormous difference in intellect between people who are well read and people who can barely read
>>
>>751835363
a story with depth compared to a childish story where the villain is evil because he is and the heroes win with the power of friendship at the last second
>>
>>751836707
devoting your whole life to studying another person is kinda cringe desu
>>
File: p2.jpg (33 KB, 616x353)
33 KB JPG
hey it's me, the thing you want
>>
File: 1794953003518720.webm (3.74 MB, 640x480)
3.74 MB
3.74 MB WEBM
>>751836221
>led to rock and roll, the bikini etc
thank you, formalist trend
>>
>>751836707
>>751836802
WTF are these retarded replies? I'm talking about the average normie reading a book. You don't need a high IQ for that, but anon is feeling inferior to people who read likely because he actually is an illiterate moron.
Fucking /v/.
>>
>>751836325
yea cuphead doesnt need a story but when niggas make you watch a 15 minute cutscene after hitting new game and before even controlling your character followed by 8 minute cutscenes every time you meet a new character, or meet an old character, or enter a place, or leave a place you have to wonder why nobody working on the game thought the story should actually be good if it was going to take up that much time
>>
>>751836802
The greater intellect training could be achieved by talking and listening, which is interactive like video games, see Socrates.
>>
File: planescape torment.png (293 KB, 499x358)
293 KB PNG
>>751834527
This post really updated my journal.
>>
>>751836476
disco elysium got me to read germinal and i'm glad it did, book's amazing
>>
>>751836707
There are different ways to read. TBK is a masterpiece with almost 150 years of critical analysis behind it, but you can still pick it up and get it. You don't need a PhD to feel Ivan's or Mitya's torment. The PhD is for studying how and why it works, not for being moved by it.
>>
>>751834527
No one's done that because a book isn't a video game you stupid faggot nigger.
>>
>>751836916
>because he actually is an illiterate moron.
Which makes the most sense if you factor in that notable, and very observable decreases in literacy all across western countries.

Which is depressing. And now I hate this thread for making me think about the how horrible the future will be.
>>
>>751834527
"Would [not a book] make a good book" is probably the stupidest possible way to judge a story. Why the hell would books be the standard by which stories are judged? What you're doing makes as little sense as judging movies based on whether they'd be good finger paintings.
>>
>>751834527
NieR Gestalt is the best vidya story of all time
>>
Yes, they made tons of FMV games in the 90s that were literally just books or movies with some token interactions
Nobody liked them so they stopped making them
>>
>>751836825
any examples of what you consider a adult story vs a childish story
>>
Story gamers are just pathetic pseuds i never listen to what they say.
>>
>>751837190
>Why the hell would books be the standard by which stories are judged?
Film and video games are hybrid media, so when they rely on words, through dialogue, plot and the way themes are developed, it's fair to judge that part by the standards of writing. And the problem isn't just the prose. Many video game stories, even acclaimed ones, are naive and heavy handed in their thinking. Compared even to an ordinary competent novelist, the level is just low.
>>
Red Dead Redemption easily. Especially the themes of the true ending where Jack travels to Blackwater to kill a certain somebody.
The true tragedy of RDR wasn't John, or his wife, or Arthur, or even Dutch getting dinged up the head.
It was Jack making to the same choices his father and mother and Arthur all gave their lives to prevent him from making.
The message is that redemption is both beautiful and sometimes futile and it is an elemental message that, once open contact with alien species happens, will no doubt be found in a myriad of countless other species' collective literary canons. It is insane that no-one has said RDR yet. It also comments on statism encroaching on the collective independence of the nation and the early formation of the FBI. The death of the independent west and the beginning of the domestication of America.
It would be trivial to translate RDR to a novel of worth
>>
>>751836913
What game is that? The combat style is cool
>>
>>751836176
PLEASE ANONS I NEED THIS MEME
>>
>>751837892
Bikini Karate Babes
>>
File: 1789657646761711.jpg (486 KB, 1920x1080)
486 KB JPG
>>751834527
I hesitate to post this since the remake just came out and I don't want to look like I'm trying to bandwagon here, but Ocarina's story could definitely be adapted into book form. It's a young boy suddenly being thrust into a metaphorical (and quite literal) adulthood, and has to confront the fact that the bright, lighthearted adventures he had as a child have been replaced with the serious, often bleak nature of the world that awaits him as a man.
And then Majora's Mask is about a man repeatedly trying (and failing) to recapture the magic of chlidhood that he's lost due to the passing of time and having mature experiences under his belt. By the end of it all he has to let go and realize that he can never return to that past, the Fierce Deity Mask is Link accepting his status as an adult and using this power to easily obliterate Majora, a godlike entity that's treated the world as its own personal playground like a kid playing with toys.
>>
File: 1666631083144337.gif (1.36 MB, 359x242)
1.36 MB GIF
>>751834643
Based.
>>
>>751834527
You can take a classic book, turn it into a video game and change all the names and faces so nobody realizes what you did, and guess what? No one's going to think the story is anything special. You can boil every lauded story down into just a few words, but that's not what makes people like them. It's the specific word choices, the pacing, the way the author manipulates the reader by picking and choosing what they can and can't see.

Video games are a different medium. Asking if any games have a good story is like asking if any films or albums have a good story. Maybe - who cares? They're different mediums and have different strengths.
>>
>>751834527
catherine full body i guess?
>>
File: 1791547285197660.png (236 KB, 666x681)
236 KB PNG
>>751834527
You're not asking for a good story. You're asking for a game you can hold up so other people will treat you like someone who reads real books. The whole post is a request for a status object. You already know the usual answers and you've ruled them out in advance so whatever gets recommended can be used to distinguish you from the people who like those games. That's the point of the exclusions.
Games are toys. Their job is to be fun. Some of them happen to have writing that isn't embarrassing. Almost none of them are literature, and the medium doesn't need to be. The fact that you need one to function as proof that you're not a casual is the actual subject of the post.

Alfred Adler spent a career describing exactly this move: people who feel inferior invent standards no one around them can meet, then treat meeting those standards as evidence they've overcome the inferiority. You're doing it with interactive fiction. The fear that other people will correctly clock you as someone who plays games for fun is running the whole thing.
>>
>>751838240
Screw all that
>>751834527
Start with the Greeks
>>
>>751838240
bodied that tranny
>>
>>751838384
>Start with the Greeks
Dead meme
>>
>>751838240
I view games as digital toys and prefer it when games have porn stories im mostly just wondering how we've been in the hellscape of every game having more cutscenes and dialogue than actual gameplay for close to 2 decades and yet seemingly none of the stories have ever actually tried to be good
>>
File: chizuru.jpg (531 KB, 1024x1024)
531 KB JPG
>>751834527
Max Payne 1 and 2 because the story is pretty much a pulp fiction seasoned with a solid inner drama from the protagonist.
SMT Strange Journey because it has a lot of scifi tropes mixed with religion's myths from around the world and the development of the plot has a lot of nuances easy to connect together for the satisfaction of faggots who look for d33p shit and stuff.
Silent Hill Downpour because the plot works better as a non-interactive media than as a videogame.
I took in consideration you mean this is for limp dicks faggots who like to smell their own farts to feel le supeior.
>>
File: 1767318770319799.gif (1.76 MB, 354x264)
1.76 MB GIF
>>751838240
Finally, a fellow intellectual
>>
>>751838447
People who dismiss the Greeks out of hand have no clue what they're missing. They were part of the western canon for 2 millennia for a reason, and the displacement of the classics from liberal arts education perfectly coincides with the debasement of the value of undergraduate degrees.
>>
>>751834527
No.
>>
>>751834742
>>
>>751834996
>action figure set
not literature, not art.
>>751835124
mad and insecure over wasting his adulthood playing with dolls kek
>>
>>751835719
It's nice for 10 year olds, OP is asking for adults
>>
>>751838240
Ace Combat chads always seem to be really good at btfos.
>>
>>751836309
>Nier Automata
>dude what if the old testament was post modern and had tiddies
action figure set for children. ever read schelling or hamann?
>>751836476
kek
>>
>>751838780
I'm not questioning that the Greeks are fundamental, I was only criticizing the idea that you have to start in chronological order. If I'm interested in Nietzsche right now, say, and I read in chronological order, I'd never get there, and maybe in the meantime I'd lose the passion too. You can start by just looking at the context notes (Plato talking about the true world, the difference with the Presocratics, etc.) and then go back and study them in depth
>>
File: 88333.png (295 KB, 322x591)
295 KB PNG
>>751836620
>>
>>751836628
>Planescape
7.5/10, I guess it has some scenes on par with Erikson or Bakker.
>>
>>751837425
based
>>
File: notavibe.mp4 (465 KB, 576x1024)
465 KB
465 KB MP4
>>751839165
this is not performative, its just a normal sensible individual reading in a normal sensible place
>>
>>751838157
>porn + anime
you're an addict.
>>
File: denzel-training-day.gif (3.8 MB, 498x273)
3.8 MB GIF
>>751838240
now THIS man reads
>>
File: file.png (1.07 MB, 1125x1122)
1.07 MB PNG
>>
>>751836221
And then they fucked up taking away the circus and next is the bread once the orange retard nukes Iran.
Everything is in place for a collapse and the elites are too stupid to sacrifice their wealth to keep the status quo.
>>
>>751839315
this is clearly staged, you walking jizzstain
>>
File: 2666-1327x2048.jpg (708 KB, 1327x2048)
708 KB JPG
>>751834742
I mean 2666 came out in 2004 so.
>>
File: 170479346923.png (535 KB, 858x716)
535 KB PNG
>>751839315
>>751839437
I'm scared to read paper books in public after seeing people humiliated for it online
>>
>>751839536
well don't go to a fucking rave to read it
>>
>>751839142
Fair enough, I didn't understand that's what you meant.

On an aside, Plato is a faggot and Thrasymachus was right.
>>
File: 908663.png (713 KB, 623x947)
713 KB PNG
>>751834742
>>
>>751834527
>mean a story where the plot, characters, and dialogue could be placed into a real life book
If you can do this to a game, that game has a bad story
>>
File: 1792982876355013.png (171 KB, 285x398)
171 KB PNG
>>751839363
>Sex is porn
Of course even the most enlightened anon see sex as porn and nothing else.
>>
>>751839445
is not that they are retarded, is just that the great majority of humans are going to be obsolete in the next 20 years with the boom of robotics and Ai (as shitty as it is now), so you either become millionaire by 2040 or you become a lability to be exterminated.
>>
>>751834527
>people who read real books would consider it worthwhile rather than a "fun read" or some other popcorn flick equivalent
This is a silly point to make since there are tons of popcorn flicks that were adapted into books and books adapted into popcorn flicks.
>>
>>751834996
Halo is the equivalent of Star Wars. Just action figures shooting at each other. The exact antithesis of OP's question.
>>
>>751834527
Lobotomy Corporation.
>>
File: Gamers.png (50 KB, 1226x197)
50 KB PNG
>>751839649
>>
File: 9798217405084.jpg (37 KB, 450x450)
37 KB JPG
>>751834742
>>
>>751838120
Only someone who hasn't read serious literature could post this.
>>
>>751839691
LMAO, that is so stupid.
The wealthy are the ones who will be exterminated.
>>
File: 1656186165678.jpg (24 KB, 576x436)
24 KB JPG
>>751839751
He probably means literary fiction specifically, as opposed to genre fiction, but it's obvious he barely reads if at all so he just fumbled and botched his own thread. You'd think a Harold Bloom poaster would know better.
>>
>>751834527
>Is there actually a game that tried to have an adult story? No I dont mean sony exclusives, no I dont mean le deep spongebob roller coaster nintendo games, I dont even mean vagueposting loreslop either, I mean a story where the plot, characters, and dialogue could be placed into a real life book and people who read real books would consider it worthwhile rather than a "fun read" or some other popcorn flick equivalent
Video games and books are two wildly different mediums. You cannot combine the two without pretentious results like those Sony games.
>>
>>751839827
>random seething about the "gamers"
>search for source
>reddit post
that should've been obvious from the beginning but i still looked it up. i have never known anyone who did this and wasn't a pretentious pseud faggot.
>>
File: 1794950492862762.jpg (19 KB, 343x343)
19 KB JPG
>>751838240
nice work anon, curbstomped that freak and also made him cry and call his mom to come pick him up early
>>
>>751834527
Harold Bloom was the Chris-Chan of the lit crit world.
>>
>>751839956
you lost
>>
>>751834527
The problem with video games is that their main influence is other video games. Sometimes anime, comics and Hollywood, but it's usually just other video games. Game writers are either too weak to go back and read literary Modernism or literary Symbolism, or their execs and producers and whatever refuse to allow them to write stories with more "artistic sensibilities" or however you want to phrase it. Games are meant to be entertainment and toys, first and foremost. We should be lucky that there even exists the occasional game with solid casts and narratives.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.