https://boghog.itch.io/decogearDemo's out and playable on a browser Boghog, an incredibly vocal and outspoken "game design expert" and shmup obsessive, has finally put his money where his mouth is and made a game.It is...quite bad.And not just in terms of execution, it's bad in its fundamental design choices. Nearly all of them.Have you ever been playing Final Fight 1 on the hardest difficulty 1CC and said to yourself "I wish these enemies were more annoying to reach" and "I wish the fight would constantly stop for bullet hell patterns" or even "I wish jabbing and throws did no damage?" What about thinking "gee I wish all the characters were massively wide and constantly clipping with tiny animations you can't see?" No? No one but Boghog has ever thought that? Well that explains a lot!
I don't know who this guy is but he seems like he's remarkably elitist about old ass video games and he thinks he's hot shit and getting a reality check he's all knowledge, 0 experience.
you can tell the game is shit just by reading the features. he proved that he was a hack who doesn't get arcade design with caramel action. thankfully that game was free so props to him because I ain't paying 12 bucks for a shitty bmup
You keep posting this guy's retarded tweets and I don't think you'll ever manage to make /v/ care enough about it to hate him, OP, he's just that irrelevant.
>>751869736He's got pages and pages of tweets on arcade game design and how stupid everyone is except him.He has tens if not hundreds of hours of video on YouTube talking about game design in arcade and action games.This game just broadcasts that everything he ever said was incredibly wrong.
>>751870117Honestly I'm more interested in critiism of the beat em up, but we know /v/, people only reply to twitter post bullshit. If I just posted the game art it'd be page 10 zero replies
final fight good
>>751870325Final Fight indeed good!Decogear not Final Fight Not even close
>>751868774the twitter beatemup+shmup clique is beyond retarded and embarrassing and its no surprise at all that they dont even understand the two elementary schooler genres they autismally focus on.
>>751871492I'm surprised How do you basically make your job talking about game design and then put out a game that shows everything you believed is wrong?Like - this guy has a two hour video on how animations make movement feel good or bad and determine how impactful your hits are and in his game movement feels like shit and hits are anemic
>>751872790animation is a skill you have to hone for years.
>>751868774But Mork said it is the GOTY, maybe even GOTD!
>>751873047I mean, yeah, but there's two things going on here:1) His entire premise is simply wrong. He thinks your actual move speed on the screen doesn't matter and that things like acceleration and inertia make controls feel bad. ALL of that is wrong as proven by his game.2) His actual animations suck on top of that. Even if he were right that animations are what make movement feel good his animations are stilted and weird with lots of tiny pointless details you can't see and the models are massively wide and constantly shifting
>>751873438I saw a bunch of glowing reviews, but they were all from people that work directly with Boghog.
>>751873447Of course its a retarded premise.The craziest movement games look like your character is spasming out on the screen but they still feel amazing.Of course he and his retard friends dont know good movement games they play molasses shit like FF and SoR and shit their diaper when they experience the physics of something like Super Mario Bros.Animations are just part of the equation.For attacks generally its hitstop, special effects, camera movement, sound effects, enemy feedback and physics. Its not JUST raw character animations.
>start up demo>begin game on easiest available difficulty>first enemy enters screen>walk towards it and punch>it backsteps and runs away>chase it slowly because lol no dash dashes are bad>it just keeps running awayThis is the first enemy and it is doing the single most obnoxious and anti-fun thing any enemy in any game can do: outmaneuver the player based on inherent advantages and decide to do so indefinitelyThis failure in basic design, putting such an immediately and obviously frustrating experience in front of a brand new player, made me too curious. I had to know what the fuck was up.The best I can gather from reading his completely unorganized bullshit (I'm not watching his videos) is that he thinks it's boring when basic enemies close distance and set it up that enemies won't approach if you're looking at them and will run away if you whiff (because your jab is tiny and you can't move).
>>751874947The boghog way of killing the crab and similar enemies is when they try attack you the method to avoid it is to jump over and hit them and then jab combo or grab them. The thing is that this come from other beat 'em ups but the method you use to defeat such enemies is infinitely more varied and less annoying because the player is often actually playing under the same rules the enemies are instead of the enemies getting free privileges.
>>751868774The double jump, rapid punch and the uppercut attack are all basically useless moves too. If you get rid of them nothing about the game changes.
>>751868774Why are you responding to your own bluesky posts?
>>751875530>The boghog way of killing the crab and similar enemies is when they try attack you the method to avoid it is to jump over and hit them and then jab combo or grab themAnd while that is a kind of enemy design I am against as it is essentially just making your game reactive esoterica, it can work as an isolated enemy type in specific encounters.I can't imagine how empty one's head would have to be to think this should be the first enemy your players face.Then again this guy loudly and openly says shit like "difficulty curves are bad, the game's action should be 100% flat" so maybe I should have expected this.>>751875719The uppercut seems to have some utility in taking you off the ground while doing damage, and in a better game that would be neat, but this game is a total clusterfuck so it gets lost in all the bullshit.
>>751868774Shame the art direction is great
>>751875959Is it?The designs are fine in a vacuum, just generic kawaii animu bullshit, but as parts of a beat em up they're completely non-functional
>>751872790>>751873447Can I have a link to that video?
>>751876060Also, I'm sorry, I really need to get this outBoghog obviously had testers, he obviously knows that doing anything in his game is based purely around abusing i-frames, and he obviously realized that what gave you i-frames and how many was not intuitive.Writing SAFE on the character in tiny letters when they have i-frames is the dumbest fucking band-aid-on-a-bullet-wound fix I could possibly imagine.Forget for a moment the fundamental failures in design and animation that lead to this situation, how is a player even going to fucking notice the SAFE text popping up and disappearing constantly when the screen is always full of shit?
>>751875845>The uppercut seems to have some utility in taking you off the ground while doing damageActually the endlag completely negates this benefit so even in the best case scenario where you hit an enemy and two other enemies in the air whilde dodging a projectile the endlag ensures that an enemy is gonna hit you
>>751876351I'm not going to dig back through his catalog and patreon and all the podcasts he was onI'm sure if you google his name and stuff like "movement" "animations" "inertia" you'll find his opinion
>>751876437Something to keep in mind to that not all times where you have i-frames show that either. Like the final hit on neutral grabbing an enemy.
>>751876612So it's a shitty band-aid that doesn't even do its one jobShit like this is why I don't like when people praise difficult or uncompromising games for "just making what the creator wants." God Hand isn't -just- whatever bullshit Kamiya wanted, it's a fucking masterpiece of design.
>>751873438Mork and the rest of that ilk can't be trusted. They suck each other's cocks. Can't trust them objectively on their own product.
>>751868774I haven't played it but Boghog has that particular "guy you really hate & want to fail" writing style so I'll believe you even though i thought Gunvein was alrightBmups (beat em ups) are shit anyway and i don't care how much these guys shill the genre>>751873530Boghog giving Mork's praise as evidence the game is good is a lot like getting a quote from your mum to put on the box>>751874947Ok if there's a demo maybe I'll play it so i can shit on it myself
>>751877010>Ok if there's a demo maybe I'll play it so i can shit on it myselfDemo's literally in the link in OP and runs in a browser, you can see this shit in the next 10 seconds
>>751877171>you can see this shit in the next 10 secondsYou wouldn't be saying this if you knew how hungover and fucked-up i amBut okay I'll go try that, thanks
>>751868774Didn't he also make Gunvein? That was alright.
No decoupled UI/in-game controls? Fucking nice one Boghog the serious game designer, i love square being confirm you fucking hack
>>751877478He joined that project midway and it had a full team, this seems to have just been him.That was also a shmup while this is a bmupWell, I say it's a beat-em-up but clearly boghog can't differentiate the genres because half the enemies in this game turn it into a bullet hell
>>751876769Yea decogear feels like a troll game like i wanna be the guy but worse because even games like those are 100% consistant once you memorize all the traps but stuff like the items that spawn or even how enemies react, they can just decide to not participate and just block all of your attacks randomly
>>751877886The enemy projectiles wouldnt even be that bad if the player had actually good mobility but since boghog seems that good mobility in a bmup is demonic or some shit you can rarely ever avoid them without luck. If even the jump was half decent it would make the enemies fun while still being challenging but you'll still get hit even if you double jump
>>751868774>Why don't the enemies just let me walk up to them and hit them
>>751878208Hi BoghogYour game is badNobody played 80's jank bmups and thought "this needs to be slower with more shit on the screen"
>>751878208You often can't hit enemies at all unless the rng allows it. This type of post doesn't work for this game
Arcade devs>Let’s make a fun video game. Also, this game is too easy/fuck the players>This move is kind of bullshit sir>Who cares, we got a deadlineYoutube devs>I have inspected all the frame data and timings in the game. I see now what the masters were crafting.>Every single design was an intentional decision with a purpose that carefully balances the entire game. A master strokeArcade Devs>Did you know about the turn around jab exploit?>Brother, I'm already working on the next game. They got me on a puzzle game.
Okay I'm the last person who should be seriously criticising a beat-em-up but just the audiovisual feel of playing the game is a lot like being trapped in one of those dreams where you're being attacked and all your punches are just pathetic & ineffective. You're in a mech but all the sound effects are kind of pew noises and the animations don't have the kind of attention to detail or keyframing you might use if you want to really convey impact. I think the first enemy being one that retreats and is annoying is a deliberate troll and I'm a little sympathetic to that but i don't think Boghog has earned enough trust to troll the player, he isn't Kojima. I can't really criticise the game design because all of these games basically seem the same to me. You hit enemies and presumably learn the different ranged and area denial attacks so you can work around them. I don't know. But you can't tell me this guy hasn't played a Cave game and doesn't know that we, The Gamers, need keys jingled in our faces nonstop or we get bored and play something else
>>751868774it looks shit just from the screenshots and this guy is a retarded niggerclassic shmuphead desu
>>751875845>And while that is a kind of enemy design I am against as it is essentially just making your game reactive esoterica, it can work as an isolated enemy type in specific encounters.I can't imagine how empty one's head would have to be to think this should be the first enemy your players face.The thing is that sor4 does similar thing this does but better. You're not at the mercy of the enemy rng and can often react to what the enemy is doing. Most enemies often charge at you instead of spamming projectiles and the ones that do don't have as good mobility as the other enemies. The enemies that are faster than you can't also out poke you and the ones that do again also don't have as good mobility.
>>751868774The electric underground? If so, lol.
>>751869736He's a developer and he's talking about his recently release
>>751868774Decogear made me realize something, which is how much I dislike enemies that just let me effortlessly run right into their face and start wailing on them. Most "character" action games are like this which is definitely a big part of why I think they're shit.
>>751868774Hasn't he made multiple games before this
>>751879158>I hate enemies that fight meWeird take
>>751868774That's what happens when a person makes playing a specific genre or subgenre his identity. You end up with completely different ideas of fun from someone without the same level of autism.
>>751879158*i hate playing other video games on easy mode*Just go on hard difficulty, the enemies are better then.
>>751878725
>>751878725/thread
>>751868774I tried the demo and it wasn't fun. The enemies are very very annoying and it just made me boot up turtles in time instead. I guess I'm not the target audience for this game even though I like beat em ups
is yayshmups still here
>>751879705The target audience is people that suck their own dick for playing bmups instead of actually enjoying them. Not even classic bmup purists are this gay. So dar most of the 1cc gameplay videos of this are just on console mode (easy mode) because the game is actually decently fun on it
>>751879868So far*
>>751876603Blader also couldnt handle the inertia of Mario.NES games are too complex for these tards.
>>751879868Btw you know a game designer is a real fuck head when they name their difficulty modes something cute to avoid offending the dirty moids who play on easy
>>751880059It's really funny how a lot of these types seems to think inertia is something that's always bad when a ton of great platformers have it and momentum as core mechanics.
>>751874947>>751875530>>751875845>have to play a pvre nitaku combat triangle spacing game with every minor enemy before you can move on>if you try to set up basic CC or use a get off me the enemies just jitter around and you miss half of themwhat was he THEENKINGi actually do like the game overall, haven't gotten past stage 2 with grabbler though
>>751879868>>751879705I think the target audience is just Boghog.The entire game feels like someone got bored of playing Final Fight and Streets of Rage 1CC hardest runs and decided the problem was that you're too fast, do too much damage, and there aren't enough enemies.For some reason the analogy that comes to mind is a crackhead going "cocaine just isn't strong enough for the average person, you barely shit yourself or bleed from your holes and that's the best part! Everyone needs intravenous meth."
>>751875845>difficulty curves are bad, the game's action should be 100% flatLMAO
>>751880187 (Me) Actually now i think about it I've seen these Electric Underground-adjacents make this point that Psikyo games having easy and baby and monkey (ermmm, yikes?) modes is evil because it hurts the feeliesFuck that. Unless you're Cave and you're making your seminal masterpiece, Mushihimesama or indeed its sequel, in which case I'll give you a pass because I'm a hypocrite and irl i look like a low quality animation cel of a rapist from a 1980s crime anime (not relevant but good to know)
so he spent years making final fight 1 kaizobravo retard
I was going to say that the smaller a genre is the more autistic the fanbase is, but point and click adventures don't really have this problem, the fanbase is pretty chill despite the genre being dead outside of indie games.
>>751880279It's not just making it harder than the avg beat 'em up it's also adding unneeded features that make the game unfun to play like the grey borders. The only real improvement to the classic beat 'em up gameplay is the faster paced gameplay but everything else good done has been done by another beat 'em up. Just make another sor fan game with the same pace as this and you have a better product than decogears
>>751876769God Hand is a Mikami game.
Didn't this guy make Gunvein, that was a good game
>>751880549/thread
>>751876769>>751877971this was my exact thought, it's like a kaizo beatemup. this game borrows mechanics from god hand and apparently NG2, but the enemies constantly barrage you in those games. the enemies dont backstep like a scripter every time you approach them, the point is that they are all jumping on your ass 24/7 and you have to find a way to deal with them. bog and mork seem to think that every encounter in NG2 and god hand are like a mini engagement in DOA and tekken respectively and this never made any sense.
>>751880729You are correct and I apologizeI got the two mixed up because I was thinking about how Kamiya puts bad shit in his games just because he wants itMikami almost explicitly made God Hand just based on his own feedback and the feedback of one tester but he's an actual good game designer that knows the difference between what he wants and good game design
>>751880758joined midway, game already had a team
>>751880646The actual reason for this is that gameplay-dense games appeal specifically to people with ADHD who also are more likely to have autism. Point-and-click adventure games generally appeal to women, pedophiles, dog fuckers and people who genuinely think the insult sword fighting is funny. They're completely different demographics
I find it fascinating to see game critics try to do something and generally fail at several basic things.This shows that:a) much of what they think is knowledge is merely rationalization; that is, creative thinking trying to explain why something is good and successful, often with no basis in realityb) knowledge without practice isn't worth much in game design, where the creative process is important and will ultimately reshape ideas, much like an engineer ends up simplifying what the architect designed to ensure the building standsMaybe if he keeps trying, he'll start doing good things. But if that happens, he'll have let go of many of the naive ideas he has today.
>>751879868That reminds me of a youtube autist who mainly does SoR 1CC runs saying that he explicitly doesn't want to have fun while playing a game. These people are a riot lmao.
>>751880221It honestly explains the absolute state of modern sidescrollers on average. Too many indie devs subscribe to this ideology, and it results in a lot of shitty flash-tier games where you don't ever have to think about building momentum.
>>751880868This, godhand is fun and challenging that isn't heavily rng dependant. In decogear if something a simple as an item not dropping when you meed it or and enemy decides to not play by the rules randomly the run can be over
>>751881068You're almost right.More involved games do more easily trigger hyperfocus and therefore do attract a significant amount of ADHD-autism spectrum people (they are different presentations of the same underlying problems in the production of estrogen-downstream neurotransmitters)Point and click adventure games don't do anything that makes ADHD-autism people deterred, but they are unappealing to those with low IQs and very appealing to people with high IQs, and in general people on the ADHD-Autism spectrum are below average in terms of IQ.T. High IQ with ADHD and I love both beat em ups and point and clicks
>>751881180Idk 1cc is a fun accomplishment to have but it's autists like these that make it seems like 1cc is a entry requirement for this cool kids club where they get to mock the normies or some shit like that. Arcade mode in sor1,2,3 and 4 is fun even if it's hard. But decogears is just meant to be some badge you wear to show that you're not a normie
>>751881180This is exactly why i will never do save state practice autism on shmups or even use a built-in practice mode. It's not fun. I just bash my head against the game and if i never win, that's fine too.
>>751880187It's not meant to be malicious to say that console players are bad. Console and arcade versions have traditionally had several differences in gameplay that anyone familiar with these games will immediately recognize.It's kind of like how racing games offer "arcade" and "simulator" modes, not because "arcade" is for people who are bad at the game, but because arcade modes typically focus more on pure gameplay than on the simulation itself.
>>751881691>It's not meant to be malicious to say that console players are bad.If you know mork and hog it's meant to say that you're a subhuman specimen if you pick this mode.
>>751881691I hadn't even considered the angle that he's trying to make console players feel ashamed and worthless. That's based. I'm actually on his side now.In all seriousness it's not like i don't get the logic of it, but it is fundamentally a difficulty setting, there's nothing special about it. The real actual issue (keeping in mind that most of what i post is completely disingenuous & lies) is that it obfuscates the 'intended' difficulty. Like, i want to know which version of the game the designer had in his head while making it, and which versions are derived from that, because that's the version i want to play, even if I'm not good enough for it.
Pure arcade design is only good for fighting games and puzzlers like Puyo Puyo desu. Basically just for VS games.Everything else should aim to leave those chains behind.
Has Mork ever been wrong about anything?
>>751882050When I first booted up the demo I picked Arcade because I had no idea what "Console or Arcade" was supposed to meanI also tried it on Console, assuming Arcade was just a very hard mode and the game wasn't that bad, but I was wrong and frankly I don't know why there is even a mode selection
>>751869736>elitistCan you kill yourself for being a newfag?
>>751882228Mork either says something retarded or something so clearly and plainly obvious it's been know for years like the you just posted
>>751880646>I was going to say that the smaller a genre is the more autistic the fanbase is, but point and click adventures don't really have this problem, the fanbase is pretty chill despite the genre being dead outside of indie games.It's a vocal minority for arcade genres. Most people who enjoy beat em ups and shmups are pretty chill too. But there's this weird subgroup that gets really smug and pretends playing a genre a lot, or understanding certain games well, makes them morally superior. I get the annoyance with people who don't understand you can play arcade games without credit feeding your way writing reviews about them and stuff. But you're not a better person than the kids messing around at an arcade. Insufferable to read if you're a normal person who enjoys these games. Good on the guy for making a game though, no ill will towards that.
It's funny to see that the thread about a semi-amateur game on itch.io has more genuine discussion from people who have clearly played the game and are clearly interested in talking about it and game design in general than all the GTA 6 threads combined.
>>751882095>chainsYes I agree. Every action game should be turned into a ~70 hours long aRPG with a generic button parry, empty worlds to "explore" and copy pasted fights with recolored dragons.
>>751882351If it's so obvious, how come he's the only one saying it
>>751882398Hi yayshmups.
>>751868774Why are you shilling for some random bluesky faggot and why should any of us care about his pet project?Judging by the way he posts he doesn't deserve the time of day, so no I won't even bother checking it out.
>>751882441Is memorizing exactly where to advance the screen better than that? I can make stupid reductions too
>>751882446Cause everyone already said it decades ago
>>751882228>wonder who the fuck this is>find channel>didn't like Pragmata>fellates NG2>fellates Spikeout>says improvements made to Final Fight are bad actually>God hand vi-OH SHIT I REMEMBER THIS GUY NOWHE MADE AN HOUR LONG VIDEO ABOUT GOD HAND'S DESIGN WHEN HE DIDN'T KNOW HOW THE DUCK WORKED OR ANY OF THE MANUAL MOVESAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>751882446
>>751882050 (Me) You know, to a large degree i think I'm just being contrarian here and my argument is retarded. I don't really care about the difficulty naming schemeThat said since i mentioned it before let's compare to Mushi. They get around this by calling the easiest difficulty 'Original', and the other difficulties are named in a way that makes it clear they're for real sick freaks. If you want people to play the easiest mode without making the player feel like overdosing on estrogen pills then that's a good way to do it. Calling the easiest mode 'Console' makes me not want to select it. I realise this is baaically the opposite of my original point but you have to forgive me, I'm abit hungover and my brain isn't working very well
Just play a fighting game.
>>751883006>you have to forgive me, I'm abit hungover and my brain isn't working very wellIt's all good, I'm posting weird too today because I haven't slept in 2 days
>>751883006From what i can despite calling the difficulty "console" it might made as a learning difficulty since it mostly just makes waves of enemies come out slower but mostly everything else is still the same besides bosses not have infinitely spawning enemies. It's clear the hog still thinks you're subhuman for playing it but atleast made it easier to "learn" the game from it
>>751882228Describing the multiple methods of turning in F-Zero GX and then saying some shit like "Nintendo would NEVER do anything like this" when everything he described sans the quick turn was in F-Zero X (Nintendo EAD) was profoundly embarrassing
>>751882441this beat em up nigger acting like his 20minute games arent filled to the brim with recolored punk enemies
>>751883390>>751882616I get the feeling actual experts at any of the games he "breaks down" would have similar complaints for every single videoThat kind of thing doesn't happen when you research properly instead of just farting out and recording a script.
>>751883502his fighting game opinions are "well I guess he isnt as awful as a game journo" tier at best.
I played the demo. I found it to be a pretty "unfun" game. I didn't quite understand how to handle the frequent gangbangs.
>>751883926>I didn't quite understand how to handle the frequent gangbangs.You don't you have to hope for ideal rng to get by
>>751880059>>751880221I get where they're coming from when it comes to shmups. With inertia the patterns become less interesting. You could never get cool shit you do in a CAVE game with movement inertia. But Mario is a completely different game. The appeal is how much fun it is to move a fat italian across an obstacle course, accounting for the physics. It's like saying a racing sim is bad because you can't do Mario Kart drifts.
>>751883926vertical movement (feels bad), jumping (feels bad), throw i-frames (feels bad), and stunlocking (feels bad)also just luck because it's a bad game lol
I understand wanting to sing the praises of arcade games and the finer points of their design, but I never understood people who think that's the only thing video games should do. I don't know enough about this pig to say what he thinks, but some people act like it's impossible to appreciate a variety of genres. Games shouldn't all be trying to do the same things, when video games are as broad as any form of entertainment on a screen.
>>751884053cave games are just memorization without the level of precision and execution needed for a fighting or rhythm gameshmups are the dad games of dad games
Reading this thread makes me feel more confident in making a bmup now. Before I was worried about being on bog's level and getting shit but now I realize I'm just appealing to trannies and people who play too many video games. Thanks /v/ros.
>>751868774>blueskynot playing your troonslop bud
>>751884219I'd actually say that decogear sort of shits on a decent amount of core arcade beat 'em up points in order to make the game more difficult. Making grabs as weak as they are in this while also making them essential for survival makes the risk reward for walking up so close to enemies pointless and just make the game frustrating. Especially when enemies can just decide they don't want to be and jusy ignore how close you are to them
>>751884710You're welcome, nobody other than said trannies is going to play your game, by the way.
>>751884710no the problem is exactly that they do not play enough videogames.
>>751884665The best way to play shmups is to learn on your own, not memorize every single bit of the game and just measure your progress in terms of actual progress, not 1ccs. Yes, improvising is the sign if a bad player but improvising is so much fun.
>>751884851I meant more that they get too into the weeds of specific games. Its like someone said, this is like kaizo Final Fight. And kaizo hacks are a sign you're into deep and need to go play/do something else. Its insanity, and not in a good way. Even Yagawa would play Mahjong and shit.>>751884772Harsh but fair
>>751882616>didn't like Pragmata>fellates NG2>fellates Spikeout>says improvements made to Final Fight are bad actuallywhy are you defending the guy?
>>751884851This. They autistically played the same thing for 30+ years and haven't moved on.
>>751884858Improvisation should be required to a degree otherwise it's just a memory rhythm game even in a fighting game you still have to wait/find or make an opening to attack and do your combo.
Boghog's game isn't fun>movement feels like shit>jab is weak and not fast enough to matter>all the enemies can do everything cool but you get fucked>awkward controls>no extendsIn final fight 1 it's difficult to 1cc but the game is well designed enough that you can do it with enough practice I don't see it for boghog's game. It's weird too because gunvein was fun it's like he forgot that most players ARN'T super arcade nuttersAlso >release spinoff before the main game is even done
>>751884710Beat 'em ups just need to be satisfying.Gameplay complexity is secondary. As long as the game doesn't have ridiculous flaws (like having to exploit the same shit the entire game that works on every enemy), you're good to go. The rest is visuals, art style, music, satisfying feedback on hits and moves, hot women, etc.This false notion that arcade games are complex and sophisticated is ridiculous. If you want something complex and sophisticated, you'll probably want a flight simulator or a military strategy game where you're managing spreadsheets, not arcade games.Guys like boghog and Mark would be talking about submarine simulators if they really cared about complex games.
>>751884665>cave games are just memorizationI wouldn't go that far. That's a big element but without reflexes you won't dodge through the unpredictable semi-random barrages and will instead get pushed to the wall and raped, for instance. On a good playthrough you need to have the reflexes of a fly and correct judgement of bullet paths to weave through without taking a hit. That's what makes the games exhilarating. Memo helps put you in the right position but i don't think I've ever 1CC'd and actually had conscious knowledge of all the patterns
i dont see how the game is bad. its really fun. caramel action was also really fun.
>>751868774Prolly the worst sprites in a bmup in a long time. And I don't mean visually but in terms of spacing/sizing, fucking everything is wide like a truck and everything starts overlapping if you attempt to CC. And the game has thick black outlines on everything, so it further fucks up visibility.Oh and the sound design is so shit it's embarrassing. But hey, at least he added le quirky announcer sound bites he recorded himself so we should excuse the combat sfx to sound like a wet trashbag.
>>751885708>Memo helps put you in the right position but i don't think I've ever 1CC'd and actually had conscious knowledge of all the patternsThat's encouraging to hear anon
>>751885181And given how decogears play you would think they hate other beat 'em ups like fight 'n rage because the player character is capable of doing stuff despite how diffocult the game still is but apparently they love it
>>751884665This. Watching replays is how you get better at them the quickest, but even then you don't know which ones are actually real plays and not savescummed on YouTube.
>>751885940>you don't know which ones are actually real plays and not savescummedyou kind of can. apart from shit like splicing you can tell if the player knows what they're doing or if they take huge risks for no reason. but honestly it's like half of them lmao
Just gonna leave this here.Generally players tend to get better at games than the developers themselves, but this feels like just putting a game out without playtesting.
>>751884757how are grabs weak? punching and then walking into the enemy and pummeling them is the single most consistent way to kill many of the simpler enemies.
>>751886081Oh it's an open secret the leaderboards are riddled with fake and unverified runs. When there's little to no interest the verification rules can literally just be "post a screenshot and type in your own score."
>>751886239Just plain unprofessional
>>751885787Boghog atleast fix the hutboxes or change the sprites to accurately convey how far your jabs go. Conveying information properly should be number one priority and even triple As get shit on for fucking this up
>>751886278Throws intentionally do very little damage in decogear as they are meant to be CC and i-frames not a way to get kills
>>751886390right i agree left/right throws dont do any damage, they're meant for grouping enemies together. i'm saying that just walking into the enemy and doing the neutral pummel into the neutral finisher is really good for damage.
>>751882398Why is that funny? That's the sad state of this board. Anonymous people trying to make other anonymous people mad and just participate in an endless rage bait shit fling fest l. I wish all threads could be more like this, but this whole website is infested with idiots who collude with onr another in secret discord calls to just ruin someone's day.
>>751885825I wouldn't of thought of punching an empty plastic bag for all the sound effects for my slow mecha beatemup, but it's hard for a simple man like me to grasp the sheer genius of a man like Bog Hog>>751886239To be fair i doubt the Cave developers did Mushi Ultra TLB before shitting it out onto an arcade cabinet and letting the real freaks have their way with it
Eh its bad but it doesn't seem particularly unfixable. Needs to spawn less enemies at once and make them far less absurdly aggresive. The yellow girl in particular can barely act without being hit then stunlocked because she's slow and the enemies are fast and spawn in groups of about 7. I don't like the designs, though. Its a weird thing where they know sex sells so they've gone waifu boobs, but then put them in robots so the girls do not matter and are doing nothing cool, but ALSO left the robots open so you can't just enjoy the robot aesthetic. Its the worst of every world. Fully closed robot or just girls on feet suplexing enemies with a horned helmet would have been much better
>>751886278There has to very little to be happening to use the grab consistantly, the only saving grace is that you sorta technically can grab more than one enemy but the enemies themselves can often just ignore you entirely even when you're in grab range so it's entirely rng dependant.>>751886390Even then you're often lucky if you manage to stun one enemy for longer than a millisecond in this game
>>751886239>boghog and mork jerk off arcade devs>but even arcade devs back then hired superplayers that could 1cc thier game and if they could do it (you) probably could >boghog couldn't even beat his own mode
>>751886481I mean arcade threads are the same thing but with a couple extremely autistic schizos condensed into one threadWhy do you think shmup threads are dead and riddled with obvious samefagging
>>751868774
>>751886485>To be fair i doubt the Cave developers did Mushi Ultra TLB before shitting it out onto an arcade cabinet and letting the real freaks have their way with itI'm not saying it doesn't happen, plenty of games have shipped without getting proper testing in various areas (often because dev time ran out). I just think he wasn't exactly under any time pressure, and skimped on playtesting, kind of using his itch.io audience as paid playtesters before putting the game on Steam.
>>751886239As someone who follows sites like alphabetagamer pretty often to see neat games tot ry, I don't really see the issue? He's clear its a demo. He just needs to reword it to "playtest". If he puts it on steam I'll write up the good parts, then autistically (actually I am autistic) list every bad part one after another and all the bugs I found and how and why they're bad Then he'd be free to disagree on those points, ignore feedback and wonder why his game has like 6 players peak (happens a lot) or try to fix what he agrees with
>>751887024This is the full game, he just hasn't released it on steam yet because i'm assuming he's adding a online leaderboard like devil daggers/hyper demon
>>751886867Shmup threads are in their current state because one tranny tried turning them into his personal Discord server.
>>751886918Shut up, bird!
>>751887003the arcade difficulty is already hard enough, it's ok that ultra is some extra thing for sickos.the fact the game isn't available on steam yet is not anything nefarious. it's just that he submitted the game to steam at the same time valve is dealing with unprecedented waves of ai slop games to go through and approve. you've seen the headlines that valve's approval process is backed up, right? itch.io doesn't have this issue so of course it can release there easier.
>>751887024The browser version is a demoThe game is done and 12 bucks on itch and steam
>>751886239>>751887003>I think I beat him once maybe so let's just ship the game
>>751887125>>751887245LMAOOOOOOOOOO
One thing that is weird with those bmup/stg cultists is that they never actually talk about other released arcade games from devs that aren't buddy buddy with them.Like Ashura the Striker was amazing, but no one from their side talked about it.Recently Shadow Gangs Zero came out, no one talks about it.It's like a complete echochamber, now this decogear game comes out and everyone says it's best bmup of the year before they even played it...
>>751887268General is in his own ball park.I find it amusing that even reaching him can be a bit of an ordeal, if you're not good at the game.
>>751887245no arcade game is worth more than $5
>>751887320do you really think they aren't playing it?
>>751868774I have boghog fatigue, terminally online twitter/bluesky troons post these vagueking posts all the time that make zero sense without your contexthat, boghog is so bad at communicating like a normal human being and his entire feed is retweeting transsexuals then he wonders why no one is playing his shitty itch io arcadeslop
I don't know how he designed that second character and did not notice this does not workHer gimmick is she can stand still and shootWhen in the actual fuck is standing still going to work in this game? Enemies spawn like 9 at once from every direction and overap on each other and all bumrush instantly
>>751887320>circle jerk group circle jerks each otherCrazy shit
>>751887536Apparently her melee has a billion i-frames so you're just supposed to play keepaway by shooting and then mash when approachedBut everything hits from fullscreen so lol
idk the game but pic related is my retort. it can't be that bad
>>751887654You can't see that in-game btw
>>751887654more>>751887718wtf
>>751887654Yes you are the low IQ coomer ruining 4chan grats>>751887637None of their kits feel designed for the game he made its so weird>First oneHer main thing is doing variety combos v enemies that tend to become to all but OTG's after every combo. NONE of them handle crowds>GrapplerHer basic combo is so slow its basically unuseable, enemies simply hit you while being grabbed
>>751874474alpha and sf4 feel better
>>751887003I'm not a bmup player at all but i feel like the real question is, is there forced damage or does every situation have some kind of solution? I can see your point if it's the former. I guess with a shmup it's a bit different, since so long as there are gaps at reachable distances you can technically avoid all damage>>751887245Okay finding out that he's charging 12 bucks for this has coloured my perception. I assumed this was like a small side project going for a fiver or something. Motherfucker bastard, if you're going to charge real money you'd better get the very basics right... fuck i could do better sound design in like an hour by just hitting a wall and making explosion noises with my mouth and shit.
>>751887746You should play the game, they're barely visible to non-existant. If you want beat 'em boobs sor4 is first thing that comes to mind
>>751887804you handle the crowds by grouping the enemies together manually and then doing the punch combo on them. are you not walking into enemies and then throwing them all to one side? i find it's often that one enemy is on one side and the other enemies are the other side so you throw the former guy over to the other side (hopefully stunning the other side's enemies as you do this), you go stomp them and punch combo them.
>>751887859>I'm not a bmup player at all but i feel like the real question is, is there forced damage or does every situation have some kind of solution?The solution in decogears is almost always juat ideal rng
>>751887536She's basically just how frank played in the punisher arcade game Of course Frank actually had a fucking moveset and enemies weren't gangbanging you so hard you can't even use use said character's gimmick without abusing iframes
I have one simple question: does it have the usual bmup grabs where you just walk into an enemy to start one?
>>751887926The issue is that every enemy has better range and mobility than you so it's next to impossible
>>751868774Who made bullet hell patterns acceptable game design outside shmups anyway? I want to kill that guy. Shit is everywhere now, can't have a boss physically attack me anymore.
>>751888074Yes but good luck at that when every enemy plays keep away and you have to bait hits while also watching out for a 100 other enemies
>>751888074Yea but enemies can just ignore you and not get grabbed if they don't feel like it
Itchio games are always badIf it has an itchio page, its bad
"full time"
>>751888190>>751888206I wish bmups would finally move away from that and just implement a separate grab button. I've played final fight adjacent bmups plenty enough times already.
>>751888229Nah, I've played some good onesBut this game is bad yes
>>751887956It seems obvious to me that you'd program the enemies to have some degree of consistency in how they behave with a constrained randomness, but I'm guessing he didn't do that and the enemies will either play nice or gangrape you based entirely on some seed? That's sick if true
>>751888114i dont get it. it sounds like you're just bad.take those little shrimp guys with the lance and the fin. it's true they have better range than you (they jump into the air and divebomb, or they poke directly in front of themselves, or they do a little spin attack on the ground when trying to attack into another row). but you have to see what they're doing and then respond with the right thing. the fact that those crab enemies in the very first encounter love to just run around and not attack you means they can be ignored until later. as they approach you can hit them and keep them still with the punch into suplex grab combo but focus your attention on the fish lance guys first, stepping out of the way as necessary and grouping them together when you can.i recommend just drilling the first encounter in practice mode until you understand the game before posting
>>751888229No, it's the bluesky presence. There are some okay games there, mainly from schizos who refuse to use other stores.
>>751888351Boghog the solution you just gave doesn't work most of the time. Even side stepping and enemies attack doesn't always work given how wide the player characters hotbox is and how narrow the actual space you have is. Your solutions is assuming this plays like a normal beat 'em up where this is a reasonable strategy.
>>751883502mork
>>751888680Hitbox*
>>751888680there are three rows for almost every encounter and you can move into them and out of them at will, this is the key. if moving normally is too slow and you need something snap-fast you can use the roll option. double tap up or down. again, go practice the first encounter. it sounds like you just got filtered and are seething with false statements.
Armed Decobot looked better. He should finish that instead.
>>751888746GAMEPLAY DENISTY
>>751887320>Shadow GangsI actually learned about that game from a member of Hog's gang.
>>751888164I'm the opposite. I'd put bullets in Final Fantasy if they let me. Expedition 33 would have been a lot better if it had bullet patterns instead of parrying>>751888746>Rule Bloati honestly love the idea of a game that has a billion stupid fucking rules and the challenge is entirely finding out which ones actually matter. Someone should make this
>>751888825He's currently trying to figure out how to make it the most unfair shump of all time.
>>751889064If I wanted that, I'd just play Battle Garegga.
how 2 fixremove mechs make the girls fight on foot jiggle physicsfuta sex mechanics for the grapplerall the enemies r cute girls who belong to the grappleradd thongs
>>751888805Again you're acting like this is a more normal beat 'em up. I'd say 50% of the screens actually have 3 rows. The roll is barely faster than normal walking speed so it doesn't mitigate the players wide hitbox. Focusing on one enemy at a time is also too risky because the majority of enemies can hit you regardless of distance.
I don't fully prescribe to the super strict philosophy of game design him and that side of Twitter/wherever pushes but I liked the demo a good amount so I got the full game. I like how basically every enemy has 2 or 3 things they do and how each playable character is wildly different from one another (though the gunner's controls really fucked with me). When he says it's inspired by Final Fight he's not lying, you can feel the exact same way in this game as you do when you're trying to deal with a simple mid-level room in FF1 and shit is just smacking your ass from all sides; I prefer Final Fight 3 personally.
>>751889436agree that focusing on one enemy at a time is generally risky, hence you have to group them. the roll can be hard to press fast enough in the moment but that's what the double tap assist hotkey is for, that's been helping me a lot. the player's hitbox is pretty reasonably sized. you are neglecting how many food drops there are in the game as well. he's giving you a banana in a majority of stages.
>>751889436https://x.com/johnnycookiedoe/status/2123076463381340252why aren't you playing like this guy. why not play correctly
How come some random uruguyan pervert can make a fun beat'em up but le hardcore arcade game essayist is unable to?
>>751889585Almost all the food drops are rng and your hp bar gets kneecapped the more dmg you take. And you're basically lying about the players hitbox, it's almost as wide as a whole tile.
>>751888351>I don't get itWe know you don't, Mr. Hog.Nobody wants to do the nitaku shuffle all game. Especially when your own movement is so slow and shitty.
>>751890023right. a tile is a reasonable size. most enemy's hitboxes are also a tile wide or bigger.
>>751889778He's fighting 1 v 1The game is bad v groups>>751889941Shit was mid. Far too many gimmick segments
>>751889778He's playing on console mode so boghog sees them as subhuman
>>751890071>right. a tile is a reasonable size. most enemy's hitboxes are also a tile wide or bigger.Except you're lying and enemies have bigger wider attacks and smaller hitboxes
>>751889585>the player's hitbox is pretty reasonably sizedThat's a good-ass joke nigga
>>751889778Notice how he's fighting 1v1, the actual game even on console mode has you getting jumped literally every angle
nooo mr enemies plz dont jump into my tight reasonable sized hitbox and stunlock me with your friends
I've got the game and it's a literal putrid piece of shit.> It's supposed to look like a PC doujin game made in 2005~2010, but the visual design of EVERYTHING is the mental equivalent of slapping Hello Kitty and MLP characters on a game> Like other anon mentioned, a handful of the designs are alright in a vacuum but horrid when placed together> Misses the mark of what made old cutesy doujin games so appealing> Enemies made with the sole intent of pissing you off> Fighting doesn't have the satisfying crunch for beating enemies> Vertical movement is restricted, what in the literal FUCK is this> Perfect exemple of an indie developer that talks the talk shitting on the whole industry, but can't walk the walk> Could had been a better game if the dev didn't wasted his time on Bluesky roleplaying as a 50 yo parroting the usual dribble of "back in my time TRUE games were HARD"> Wait for Electric Underground to shill this garbage as a new standart for beatnups and a must buyFight N' Rage completely mogs this despite of being nearly a decade old and made for furries. Gunvein was a better designed game than this, despite of being stiff and sterile as fuck
>>751889941Because that random BR was just trying to make something fun while BogHog is trying to make something "correct"Fight n Rage is packed full of stuff Hog and Mork despise. A big combo/juggle system, high damage throws, dashing/running, inertia/momentum, a clear ramp up in difficulty over time, basic shit people find fun and enjoyable.
I want to like beat em ups. I don’t care if they’re hard, the furthest I’ve gotten in Final Fight on one credit was the third stage with the two Andore guys. My issue is that I feel like they all feel like the same game more or less. Some are faster, some are slower, some have more objects to interact with, but nothing substantial. Like shmups feel distinctive to me because of bullet patterns and gimmicks and mechanics. To anyone who’s played this game, is there anything at all that makes you go “Wow, this feels novel to me”?
I'm still looking forward to WOON
He won.
>>751891053Based
>>751890929Play the demo and find out, my man. I'm basically of the same mind as you and i felt like this was basically just another boring bmup, but I'm not going to pretend I really engaged with the mechanics in the way a fan of the genre would.
>>751890296true. that's partly why im telling you to group the enemies. when you group the enemies in a beat-em-up and hitstun them all together, it's kind of like fighting 1 guy. you're progressing all of their health bars at once. it's even okay if you haven't grouped all of them but have grouped most of them, since that's still more efficient than going and fighting every guy one on one, which we both agree is a fools errand in this game cuz the enemies are so capable and strong. you need to be smart. you need to use your iframe moves like the burst and the grab finishers. you have to be proactive in a way that i'm guessing you're not being. you have to think "i'm going to deal with that guy there, and this other guy somewhere else is going to use that move, so i'll address that move by iframing or jumping at this point", and then you execute that plan.
>>751891053he's slowly turning into Mork by making up terms like "Aesthetic Deception"
I think it's pretty good. Maybe my brain's fucked from picking slow heavy-hitters in every game anyway but the movement doesn't bother me. In terms of beat-em-ups released this year I like it more than Takeover 2 and Scott Pilgrim EX but not as much as Blades & Battles. Excited for the Ninja Baseball Bat Man enhanced port next month, love that game.>>751889941>>751890705This is completely correct though. You'll often find the spirit of classics in dedicated creatives more than those who study them too closely.
>>751890929There's a vareity of unqiue beat 'em ups but a lot of the hardcore classic beat 'em.up purist tendies hate them and call them bad. Stuff like fight 'n rage, sor4 and even older one like alien vs predator https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=S5x9qDqfWWE&pp=ygUcYWxpZW4gdnMgcHJlZGF0b3IgYmVhdCBlbSB1cNIHCQnqBwGHKiGM7w%3D%3DAre good
>>751891053bro sounded so depressed in his recent streamsFrom what I gathered his game performed -well- but I imagine it's not enough to sustain him long term especially with how shit youtube has become
>>751869736Nailed it.
>>751875719lol he was asked what the rapid punch is for and he outright said it serves no practical purpose
>>751891146The problem is that you're thinking it's still a regular beat em up where hitstuning groups is a valid option, but when every enemy can just lmao break out stun/tech better than you we have issuesIt's bad enough that the only super move requires you to dizzy the enemy first and even then you can just botch the execution but even the other thing you move so fucking slow you can't do anything while every other enemy moves like a kid hopped up on sugar
>>751890929Try out some of the later Capcom arcade beat-em-ups, they got super creative with it. Alien vs Predator, Dungeons & Dragons, Armored Warriors. You could try 3D beat-em-ups like Dynamite Cop, Spikeout, God Hand & Urban Reign as well since they all went in different directions with their design. If you want something meatier content wise, Dragon's Crown and SoR4 have a lot to do (Absolum is also there if you just want a straight roguelite, it's the best mix of that structure with beat-em-ups so far even if I think there's inherent flaws in combining them).>To anyone who’s played this game, is there anything at all that makes you go “Wow, this feels novel to me”?The tiles being occasionally destructible to make pits is neat and few beat-em-ups make their characters play as wildly differently from each other as this one but it's ultimately just a game for people who love how much Final Fight 1 and Mania in SoR games swarm you.
>>751884851Literally just this, if 'hog tried playing Animal Crossing or Chrono Trigger he'd start convulsing and shit himselfPeople who don't expose themselves to a wide variety of stimulus and different beliefs develop this tunnel vision that causes them to think there is an objectively correct way to do everythingHe sees post FF bmups that neglect spacing for mechanical complexity and comes to the conclusion "mechanics are a crutch" when it is perfectly possible to have a game with both a good core AND good mechanics >>751890705So many of the things he preaches makes sense IN THEORY but not in practice, he extends the view of the screen to try and solve the problem of enemies hitting you from off-screen, but all this does is introduce the new problem of you not being able to hit enemies that are on-screen and capable of hitting you>>751875845>it can work as an isolated enemy type in specific encountersPretty sure it's based on the crabs that appear in stage 3 of Undercover Cops>"difficulty curves are bad, the game's action should be 100% flat"Again this makes sense in theory but not in practice. The best approach is something like Tetris the Grandmaster that has TA Death mode for people who already know how to play and the other modes for people who don't>>751876351I think it's this one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yb2woZX3jsQ
>>751891146You can do this in every other game except this one. Enemies that are stunned on the floor is completely random some just get up instantly and then jump to the other side of the screen. Forcing you to pick one enemy over the other individual enemies. And given how enemies easily out poke you or even just zone you out you're just fighting to get to them and hope they just dont jump away or lunge at you to hit you.
>>751891525Le game design expert boghog at work
>>751891525>hey boghog how do you use rapid punch?>idk lol I just threw it inMASTER ARCADE GAME DESIGNER
>>751890929I adore beat em ups. I've loved them ever since I was a kid feeding quarters into TMNT and Simpsons Arcade. Got MAME up and running back in like 2012 so my friends and I could have a multiarcade setup.This game is wild to me because it looks at all the hundreds of ways people have improved on the formula, all the innovations since the ancient Final Fight 1 days where games had severe technical limitations and nobody knew what felt good yet, and goes "actually fun sucks just make Final Fight harder"I have hundreds of hours in games like Shadow over Mystara and Dragon's Crown, 1CC hard clears in games like Turtles in Time and various Streets of Rage games and Fight n Rage and such BogHog's game is not fun
>>751873438mork is a shitter who's been exposed as a casual fraud time and time again
>>751891146You're giving generalized bmup tactics and ignoring the fact that this game is literally incompetent It's impossible to see attacks to react to them in the clusterfuck, made worse by the massively wide models and thick outlines and weird "breathing" all the moels doJabs are stubby and movement is slow adding unnecessary jank and risk to the basic tactics you're mentioningEven Boghog admits he didn't actually design the game to allow you to avoid damage, he literally hasn't cleared ultra and nobody has 1CCd arcade
>>751890705Holy shit, this. Just like Gunvein, Decogear felt sterile as fuck because it was clearly made by a guy that wanted to make a game as correct as possible, but forgot of the simplicity of fun. It's not a a bad game, but not fun or interesting either.This nigga got a clear case tunnel vision for only playing the same games on a unending loop while claiming that everything else is bad, no flexibility in his tran of thought.
All the effort put into all those enemies and and yet he (and to be fair a large majority of devs) have never topped the depth of encounter design provided by these niggas.Shit you could cut this down to just Galsia/Donovan/Signal and it's still stronger than the enemy lineups of most action games.
>>751892175>That time when people found his xbox account and he basically only played MW2 and none of the STGs or action games he claimed to be an expert onIt's insane how those pseud always never actually played vidya back then. Even Bladder is some 20yo gen alpha kiddy that, despite being european (I think) never fucking played half-life or max payne and goes on some crusade to review le heckin proto-uncharted games (that's the only comparison he can have to games he experienced during his prime).
can someone upload the full game already since there's no DRM
>>751891776there's only one enemy that techs out of being grounded, and it's the ballerina enemy with the pincer legs who appears in the first encounter. no other enemy in the game works that way. the player themselves can tech out of being grounded by pressing jump at the right time, too.
>>751892402Sor is just better final fight. When they realize FF should be more like a base or a blueprint to what a good game should be rather than this thousand folded nippon steel of game design they can make an actually good beat 'em up game that can also be really difficult but fun. While not a beat 'em up nuclear throne is a decent example made with arcade design and hard but still a blast
>>751892527here you gohttps://files.catbox.moe/5r6f3d.zip
>>751868774still a better game than troon hand
>>751891750>He sees post FF bmups that neglect spacing for mechanical complexity and comes to the conclusion "mechanics are a crutch" when it is perfectly possible to have a game with both a good core AND good mechanicsI think I've never understood this better than I do right now after marathoning Castlevania games. You can feel the core of what makes good and fun combat design from Classicvanias in the better Igavanias despite what the RPG systems afford you in terms of leniency. You can tune it outright wrong like Dissonance letting you carry dozens potions and dash dance like a Smash player against bosses who walk towards you and swing their arms every 3 seconds but by Portrait & Ecclesia they had everything locked down (except healing only being in the pause menu but that's why Ecclesia added the boss medals).
>>751892793>Look this game is bad when I turn on invinc cheats
>>751892402Fixed those enemies for you-bog
>>751892971Those still aren't good enough You need them to randomly inflate and deflate like a balloon
>>751892927are you retarded
>>751892971WIDER
>>751892971>Thin Ben
>>751892927?game doesnt look bad in that webm and theres no invul cheat in it hes jsut ducking
>>751892535Any enemy can get up nearly instantly without teching anyway especially the more difficult ones the only exception i can think of is the mech bears. The enemies that can tech just means you risk getting hit anyway right after hitting them.
>>751892971>big-benkek
>>751892420The only game Mark is sure to have played is DOJ, you can drink yourself to death whenever he mentions it even when he's not talking about shmups. Doubt he ever played Ninja Gaiden as much as he claims, and he never bothered to clear some other games like Hellsinker.His most laughable vid was by the one defending FFXVI, he spent half of the time saying that garbage was great just because it got cancels.
>>751893051>>751893027You two are fake as Mork and this clown used AR to make moves have i-frames
>>751892971VISUAL CLARITY
>morktoday I will remind them
>>751893210you know he and most shmupfags only wank it because it's on the top of the japanese meme difficulty ranking
>>751893368Kek
>>751892793>hog trying to damage control by calling a good game trooncore so his game looks good by comparison
>>751893210I haven't watched most of his videosA friend sent me his God Hand video In it he said the duck dodge, the safest and most spammable defense tool in the game that you're meant to use preemptively as opposed to on reaction, was the highest risk option that required the most timing.It literally requires no timing at all. It cancels into itself. You are 100% upper body invincible until you stop spamming up on the right stick.Making an hour long video about the game design of God Hand and getting such a basic fundamental part of the design so wrong is embarrassing and I have to assume all of his videos are equally wrong.
>>751893210I'm sick of the DOJ wanking. It's fine, I'd probably put it roughly in line with Daifukkatsu and the original DDP but Futari rapes them all. You know what fuck it, Espgaluda 2 rapes them also. There, i said it.
>memo traps are good design because... it just is, ok?
>>751892971The biker needs to be bigger
>>751893210>>751893970I prefer Mushi because I think beetles are cool
>>751886239Untested difficulty is something that many developers intentionally include in their games so that the community can figure out ways to overcome it. It's not a problem.
>>751892790Thank you anon, for once this wasn't dolphin porn
>>751893970Yeah DOJ is cool and all but I've put more playtime into AK and Espgaluda 2. Shit is just too fun, especially the arrange modes.
>>751893354How intelligent do you think mork/hog defenders are?
>>751894241My issue has more to do with bog's talking and delivery. Walk the walk, if he thinks he's so right about things.
>>751894127then play geometry dash
My Issue with Decogear playing it in normal for a bit is that you feel weak, your jump is short yet the enemy jumps like a power ranger entering the scene, a somehow normal enemy is a motherfucker with an area attack when the game is not that flexible to have this enemy and don't be a restrictive annoying shit, contact enemy spawns, my last death happened because a bulldozer spawned in front of me while walking and somehow I feel like I playing a beat em in a gba. Maybe I should play on easy because fighting one quadrillion enemies as the same time when my attacks don't have much range and splash it feels not fun.I suppose is one of those games that are only fun once you become GOOD at it but the issue is reaching that level, if you have no fun how are you going to get good?>>751892793>This good thing is bad *points at the coolest shit ever*
>>751894867I agree entirely but I find the grappler fun just because every successful grab feels super satisfying. The jumping dunk perfectly spaced to take out enemies on landing feels amazing even if I whiff it 90% of the time. If not for that I'd probably not be having fun since the main mech is just okay and the gunner feels weird.
Predict the amount of reviews on the eventual Steam release, and the total review score.
>>751894867The point of the genuinely isnt about fun. It's about beating it and being in the le arcade game design cool kids club.
>>751895152Mixed with 45% with 119 reviews total
>>751894792Ew, Geometry Dash is for kids. Unlike arcades, which weren't for kids in 1990... oh wait...
>>751894127This is more retarded than anything I've posted in this thread and I've posted a lot of retarded shitThe player should feel like a fucking king if they're good at the game. Video games to a degree are a sort of power fantasy where the power is made meaningful by adversity. You can challenge the player without relying on forced memo bullshitHe really does just hate the player doesn't he>>751894231That too. Btw anyone who uses Ab Palm because he's stronger instead of Reco is gayAll shmups are improved by the presence of sexy anime babes with heaving breasts ready to receive my gamer seed. This is also why i like SDOJ despite it being clearly the worst DDP
>>751894127Memo traps being memorization traps? So like a bunch of invisible pitfalls?
>>751895352You see people who are unskilled at games don't like memo traps so I have to defend it so they understand that I'm better than them.
>>751895352>He really does just hate the player doesn't heAnd what's amusing is that he doesn't even seem to play the genre that despised the player the most. That is, roguelikes (in the traditional sense). Those can be so full of gotcha moments, or scenarios where you just get fucked sideways to sunday, but you just have to roll with them odds at times.
>>751895352A game doesn't have to make the player be op to feel good it just has to be fair enough where winning feels rewarding
>>751895274Gunvein at least had a bit of appeal and got 227 reviews, Decogear is something I would hid from my friends and parents because it looks like a hello kitty game.73 reviews with 65% at maximum.
>>75189574355% at most. If mork and hog defenders flood the reviews
>>751868774>has finally put his money where his mouth is and made a game.this isn't his first game, bud
>>751893970>Futanari rapes them allHot.
how many posts has geewoody made in this thread?
>>751894364To be honest i don't like Akai Katana that much but i might just be racist against horizontal shmups. I cleared Zetsu but i didn't feel like going for Shin or the original arcadeEspgaluda 2 is great because it feels like the design philosophy was "you think you're hot shit because you 1CC'd the original? Think again bitch". I love how the secret extend is ridiculously specific nonsense as a response to the first game having the easiest one possible. And having six stages instead of five to fuck with the player's expectation.
>>751895152Less than 100 reviewsMixed
>>751895152100 at most, mostly positive, depends on how many people outside of bog's circles even find the game and try playing it
>>751895884>0.3 on record (0.2 hours at review time)ahhhh game so ahhhh fire its everything i needed thank you boghog(Currently playing FIFA and Fortnite)>0.4 on record (0.1 hours at review time)Listen well, kids. AS SOMEONE WHO grew up playing arcade games [wall of text, nostalgia related a dim lit joint with a single FF1 machine] so, like I'm saying AS SOMEONE WHO [games aren't real games anymore][essay about eating a bowl of kellogs while playing TMNT on Snes)so, as SOMEONE WHO, in my opinion you should buy Decogear right now!(Currently playing Civilization VII, 634 hours recorded
>>751896262Shin has different scoring mechanics and the ninja mode is different too.Basically you now gain energy from laser shot or blades from rapid shot. Energy, just like in Zetsu, give you the Ninja mode, and blades is a new meter that spawn huge fucking katanas. The more katanas you get, the more you can cancel, then you release the katanas and follow the trail of scoring items, which depending on the situation can fuck you over.It's a really really fun mode and plays very different from arcade/zetsu.Zetsu is basically like having the bullet patterns from Shin but with the scoring and mechanics from Original arcade + new stage 5 added from Shin. So og Arcade is still a bit different because some of the bullet patterns, especially during boss fights are different, and personally some of them are much harder, but that's mainly because you are invulnerable during ninja mode unlike in Shin.
>>751869736You just described every single arcade game youtuber. Turns out that autistic people are not very likeable. >>751886239Kek it's NG3RE Ultimate Ninja all over again.
>>75189670110/10 precision
Derek Yu vindicatedMovement inertia is GOOD Console design is GOOD Low difficulty is GOOD Breadth CAN compensate for depth This nigga already outplayed these posers in 2008
>>751896894I love Spelunky physics. My brother and I have been referring to any game where you get bounced around the screen and eventually lose all your HP as getting Spelunky'd for decades now.
>>751895152People who don't like this game aren't going to care enough to leave a negative reviewVery Positive with 95% 200 reviews maxMatthew won
>>751896701Best post in the thread
>>751872790it's way easier to notice flaws than it is to figure out how to fix them
>>751895560At no point did I say the player has to be OP though. I just think pure memo traps are an uninteresting, 'flat' kind of challenge where the solution is entirely one-dimension. It's like you're playing a real video game and then suddenly it's fucking Dragon's Lair>>751895743You have to understand when coming up with these review scores that the people who played the demo then purchased it is going to be entirely the people who are positive on the game. It'll be like 73 reviews but 95% positive. Maybe up to low 100s in reviews if the Bog is particularly lucky and the word of god-king Mork has a big effect >>751896735I've heard Shin is the most fun version and I did have a go but I was kinda burned out already from Zetsu. Thank you for the description. Maybe I'll give it a go some time but i need to 1CC Esp 2 first, I've gotten to the last boss... I feel like it's just a matter of optimising my run and saving resources at this point
>>751897168Hey well atleast i'm gonna care enough
>>751897406>At no point did I say the player has to be OP though. I just think pure memo traps are an uninteresting, 'flat' kind of challenge where the solution is entirely one-dimension. It's like you're playing a real video game and then suddenly it's fucking Dragon's LairDidn't say you were, i agree with you. I was just saying the doesn't even have to go fully into the giga power fantasy it just doesn't need memo traps
>>751897168People love writing negative reviews and shitting on things though. They just aren't going to pay 12 bucks for the privilege with a shit game attached
>>751896701kek
>>751897556Okok, I wasn't sure, I thought maybe you'd misread my 'power fantasy' comment as a suggestion that the player character should be OP. I do think the Boggers could have taken a little something from shmups and made the player character actually feel powerful, even if they aren't. The presentation is really undercooked to the point I'd feel a bit embarrassed charging 12 dollars for it. You just can't make a game where the player controls a mech and have the player feel weak.
>>751897967Yea, even in FF the playable characters are atleast comparable to the enemies. In this the playable characters are weaker than the basic ones
My guess is that this thread is mostly just one schizo who's really really obsessed with this one youtube personality. The absolute state of modern /v/.
>>751897967I think the presentation is correct. The mech legitimely looks like something taken straight from an old 500 yen mobile game made exclusively for japan, plays remarkably bad just like one of those old games, and in a matter of years someone will excavate it to turn into a hidden gem essay for youtube.
>>751897406>You have to understand when coming up with these review scores that the people who played the demo then purchased it is going to be entirely the people who are positive on the game.For total reviews, yeah, but keys acquired from outside of Steam are not counted in the total score as displayed on the top of the Steam page. A game has to be bought directly from Steam for its review to be counted in that tally.
>>751882616Pragmata is bad that piece of shit makes you do a normal playthrough before you can play lunatic
>>751895057It could feel more snappy, is normal to get tickled from behind when grabbing an enemy. That character is pure control, there are two states, you either make a deathball with the enemies or they simple tickle you to death like a loser.>>751895402Or that contact enemy that respawned in top of you because lol lmao.
>>751898543That's actually an incredibly shitty feature from steam. Odd from how good steam usually is
Why is everything so garishly colored?Why is everything so aliased?Why is the background so flat and featureless? The lack of parallax or color variety in particular makes it look like a flat billboard one inch away from the action.
>>751895352>The player should feel like a fucking king if they're good at the game>You can challenge the player without relying on forced memo bullshit>All shmups are improved by the presence of sexy anime babes with heaving breaststhere must be something wrong with my joints because I suddenly fucking kneeled
>>751898539This is easily the best thread on /v/
>>751898539>youtube personality.He made a game, the thread is about the game, if that's not video games then I don't know what is
>>751898847dunnobecause lol pixel art is when you render a model at literally 16:9 pixels amiritebecause those are things that aren't immediately gameplay related so he doesn't care
>>751895352>>751898851
>>751898817It's basically there to avoid abuse, with developer distributing Steam keys in exchange for reviews or the like. Any time you see something like this on Steam, it's because there was a bad actor in the past, abusing the system.
https://steamcommunity.com/app/5088910/discussions/0/574932244729505660/these "people" are so miserable.
>>751882616It's insulting that this guy made a video about Rain World and I doubt he played for more than 30 minutes before going to watch other creators explaining the game.I would be stunned if he somehow had managed to last long enough to reach Five Pebbles before unninstalling it.
>>751898847>Why is everything so garishly colored?>Why is everything so aliased?>Why is everything so aliased?3D models turned into sprites with posterize filter slapped on. None of the visuals were manually retouched, so you have ugly aliasing because of downscaling to make it look like pixelated sprite.
>>751899141It's a damn shame, i would say this could probably an intentional decision from boghog so his steam reviews is only people that are going to defend him but i doubt he's thinking that hard about this.
>>751899198>developer on a twitter splinter site has a small clique of retarded troons who think bad game design is goodNot surprising really.
>>751892351>nobody has 1CCd arcadeSomeone just did 30 minutes agohttps://youtu.be/vRCS178V3vw
>>751899198>But Boghog is one mean . HIdeki Kamiya likes to block people, this pigbird likes to flip plain old birds, so he ain't changing a thing unless Mark or Spiders brings up valid complaints.peak parasocial behavior kek
>>751898543It doesn't matter. One, he'll probably put the demo on Steam as well. Two, nobody is stumbling upon the Decogear Steam page and going "oh, this looks good!" and buying it until at least a 50% off sale. Purchasers will almost entirely be Bog's Hog riders on Bluesky or whatever shit Discord server these fuckwits inhabit>>751898847Making your game take place in a kind of abstract void is a good way of not having to spend quite as much on art. I mean, he could just use AI, but that would get him a digital lynching
>>751899214Keep in mind that he's a shmup junkie first and foremost, and the only reason he's even checking out other games is because people pay him to do so. I doubt he'd even play Ninja Gaiden 2 on his own.
>>751899956Mark has been making NG tutorials long before NG 2 became popular amongst arcade enthusiasts.
>>751899826>Deaths: 1Pack it up
Lol AGP 6 is so jeeted people are talking about this instead?
>>751899826>Actual literal playtester had to spam runs for days to get lucky enough for a 1ccThat's not the slam dunk response you seem to think it is
>>751899945>Making your game take place in a kind of abstract void is a good way of not having to spend quite as much on artTrue, AI is off the table for him since he's on Troonsky. He could at least use some parallax and darker colors so it looks like it has some depth. I realize this is probably peak shit nobody cares about, but I have autism about backgrounds in games.
>>751899826>Arcade 1CC the best player right now!>Start video>First crab enemy avoids them for a full fifteen seconds
>>751899826>Even the youtuber who 1cc it admits ultra is too muchThis isn't the W you think it is champ...
>>751899826Those hits have no impact. How does this guy worship Final Fight and fuck that up? Enemies in that game cut to their hurt frame instantly and shake in place, attacks only have one wind up and one keyframe. This is like fighting underwater in comparison.
>>751900137No, i actually do get it. To some degree you want to be sold on some sort of fantasy when you play a game, so in Streets of Rage you're walking down a rough street beating guys up. Then developers use things like parallax to convey depth and give an illusion of being in a bigger, real world. Decogear doesn't concern itself with any of that and just slaps abstract floating platforms in a void. It reminds me of when a JRPG gets lazy and sets the final dungeon in a void with corridors just kind of floating in it, but executed a little worse than that
>>751899826I'm watching this, skipping around a bit, and I mostly see that you just get fucked at times. Making health a resource you have to manage (as opposed to designing the game with damageless attempts in mind) is fine, but some of these situations seem annoying.
>>751900310>sips monsterahhh... just like final fight
>>751899826>Literally the first enemy you fight moves off the screen before you can even get to it
Why are arcade gamers such faggots?
>>751900137Oh and yeah, obviously making the platforms and the background be the same colour and shade is fucking insane. I don't know how he looked at that and thought it was okay>>751900601Seriously play the demo, it really is like being trapped in one of those nightmares where you're trying to defend yourself but you're completely weak & ineffectual
>>751898847>lack of background color varietyI'll defend low contrast backgrounds to the death. This just isn't a great execution of it. The whole point is making the foreground clearly pop, but the FG here is roughly the same palette so it defeats the purpose. Also could have picked better than saturated toothpaste green.The background buildings also have the same thick outlines as the foreground. Sprite outlines work like traditional animation cels, great for making important moving stuff stand out but if your background elements have them too everything looks muddy and poorly lit
>>751869736Suck a dick His vid on beat em ups is VR good Don't care about the shmup stuff though
>become autismally good at a certain video game>reach the top 0.1% of best players which is like 5 people>make a game inspired by that game you're good at that appeals to players like you>it ends up appealing to 5 people and most normal people hate itThis is why you don't consult pros about anything.
>>751900857>>751900310GAME DESIGN MASTERPIECEBRAPHOG IS A GENIUSI'LL TAKE EIGHT
>>751900920They always have been.
>>751899826copymonkey time
>>751899826You just shot yourself in the foot by posting this boghog
Feels good to be a racism enjoyer, arcade racism games don't have any of this faggotry near it.
>>751899826Why does the screen freezing ground slam move not have any sound effect when you activate it? Makes it feel like it's lacking any impact.
>>751901231Based racist
>>751897158I got all the achievements except the two player one in 897 attempts total over about 75 hours or so. It’s an amazing fucking game.
>>751901231I love both
>>751900601This is why I've enjoyed Fight N' Rage. Beating enemies has a satisfying SFX, then they explode into bones like you are crunching a ceral bar and you feel like a god.
>>751901369Fight N' Rage was made by a guy who genuinely loves the genre, not in a performative fake way. I love the hit stop and other graphical effects in it.
>>751901480>>751901369I think FNR can get a bit carried away with some of its effects, but you can thankfully turn a lot of the fluff off. The sound design in it is good though, definitely leagues better than Decogear.
>>751901480What's funny is mork has praised sor4 and fight 'n rage which are antithesis to decogearhttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BHmKAgsfQ1Y&pp=ygUZZWxlY3RyaWMgdW5kZXJncm91bmQgc29yNA%3D%3D
>>751885181Fk you man. Shifting around spreadsheets is not the complexity that gamers are looking for that are actually there for the gameplay systems. Victoria and hearts of iron is for physics and history students that are actually maladapted in the brain. Gameplay system complexity is a different category.
>>751900857Could this be genius auteur Boghog making a reference to the classic 'Giant Enemy Crab' meme? Hit the weak point for massive damage! Gahaha. That little scoundrel.
>>751899826>>751900857>>751900310
>>751901231What are the best arcade racers? I've only really played Outrun 2.
>>751868774>Link to game at start of post>OP appears to be salty AF>All comments on the page are overwhelmingly positiveMethinks this might just be a false flag / guerrilla marketing thread...
>>751901786I like Daytona USA 2 and Scud Race.
>>751901865See>>751900857
Reminder that Mark and Boghog have a series of schizos that track their every post/video and are dedicated to shitting on them at every opportunity because the arcade scene is full of a bunch of autists and they're likely samefagging in this thread right now.
Anyone tried Wendigo Blue? It's got like one or two good aspects, but it's mixed with roguelite aspects like a mandatory pit stop after every zone that force you to deal with a dogshit gear system and distributing skills points.It also added a forced parry gimmick to make the bosses vulnerable on a later patch. The combo system tries to be complex and frame perfect like Blazblue.
>>751901865Anon this entire thread is people shitting on the game and basking in the schadenfreude of a highly opinionated dickhead blasting his incompetence out into the worldIf that makes you want to spend 12bux that's a you problem
>>751901728>five years agoI think this is before Bognog started remote controlling him. Also SoR4 despite looking very modern still has the keyframing of old beat em ups because they knew that was important.
>>751899826Game looked okay in screenshots. But in motion holy fuck!
>All these extremely autistic niggers hating on this game and honestly mostly just hate on bog on the hog as a person or his association with morkI can't take you niggers here seriously when this guy you're trashing on is way better at video games than you and at least uses his autism to make said video games. He's honestly based for making you morons this mad and you being filtered by his game.
>>751901967>waaaaaaa it's the dirty trolls trying to shit on us reeeeeeeeee!!!!Make a better game boghog
>>751888853Absolute cinema. If you aren't inventing your own terms for established concepts you aren't even thinking. Stop being a golem and take the mork pill
>>751901982I bought it ages ago but I've been waiting for it to get finished. Looks like it might end up being one of those "forever early access" indies so I might just bite the bullet and install it. I have a pretty high tolerance for beat-em-ups so I doubt I'll hate it. I even bought Streets of Red: Devils Dare Deluxe.
>>751901967OP hereAs someone unfamiliar with this person's particular autismo circle but knowing about it:I was counting on that.>>751902052>H-He's better at games!I'm sure he's better at specific 1CC clears of ancient arcade games.There's a lot more video games than that.
>>751901786Seconding scud race
>>751902018I also think it's partly elitism talking. FNR and SOR4 come around and show how to make a good bmup, and start dominating any modern discussions, so people like bog go back to the basics that it's FF1 or bust.
geewoody isn't even in stg rev anymore why is he still spamming the board about this cunt
>>751902052Being good at games doesn't not make you a good game designer. The two are not related at all.
>>751902018Sor4 is still opposed to decogear design. Every aspect of this game that exists in deco is done better in sor4
No but for real why do the robots inflate and deflateIs it supposed to look like they're breathing? Robots don't breathe.Is it an artifact from the low-rez renders before the outline was applied?
luv net beef
>>751902158>There's a lot more video games than that.Okay, so why are you playing an ancient arcade inspired video game if you don't like that shit to begin with, retard? I bet if the developer was a Japanese all of you would be sucking his dick.
>>751902270The game's ending suggests it's a dream world or simulation, so it's just a thing.
>>751902286>so why are you playing it?Because I love beat em ups and it was compared to God Hand in reviews.It's a bad beat em up.
>>751902216it absolutely helps to be good at games when designing a game. becoming good at something generally means comprehending it which pays dividends when thinking about what one wants for their own work. it's like saying reading a lot doesn't help one become a better writer even a little bit. pure retardation.
>>751902286japanese are the faggots that memed westniggers into caring about arcade games
>>751890929You might be autistic The decision making can vary substantially depending on beat em up design. Then God hand and urban reign stick completely out bcs they are their own version of a 3d system.
>>751901925The enemy is clearly just not inside the hitbox of the attack.>>751902004Remember: this board is anonymous. One person can pretend to be many.If it makes lurkers want to check out the game for themselves to form their own opinion it is still successful marketing.
>>751902478>The enemy is clearly just not inside the hitbox of the attack.Yeah, that's the problem there. Sure. Not the enemy literally avoiding the player for 15 seconds. That's not bad game design, no sir. Skill issue. Skill issue on the part of the single best player this game has at the moment.You have brain problems.
How much do you wanna bet this thread dies immediately at 500 posts
>>751902216Before the schizophrenics latched on to mork and bog, people praised bog's previous game. The point is that people REALLY hate how opinionated he is and that's why people shit on him because how dare he has his own opinion on what a beat em up should be like? >>751902368>I love beat em upsClearly you don't. If anything you're using that as an excuse to seethe about other beat em ups, doesn't help that this thread reeks of people that hate arcade style games anyway
>>751902380If you're an avid reader you're going to write a piece of shit, just like how if you're an avid Final Fight 1 fan you're going to make a really shitty beat em up. You're limiting yourself in ways you don't understand because you're a fan of something specific.
>>751902380The issue with being a gamer and a game designer is that as a game designer, you generally need to design something new. A pro gamer could very well tell you what makes a given game fun to play, but then task them with designing a new game, and that's where issues might crop up. Sure, they could just make a clone, but even clones do tend to need more of a hook than being a replica.
>>751902591>thread dies when it reached bump limit
>>751902639>nuh uh you don't like beat em ups!I do, which is why I'm critical of this one.Hog seems to think Final Fight 1 is the pinnacle of game design and that's fucking retardedNow if you'll excuse me I need to beat Fight N Rage again
>>751902582Surprise surprise, this is most often how fist fights work in real life.
>>751902052Could you perchance, the sole honest & ingenuous poster here, explain for us why Decogear Dimensions is good and not bad? Have you got any specific refutations? Because this is probably the only thread on /v/ where people are making actual gameplay (and presentational) criticisms in good faith and it seems unfair for you to come in and shit it up while crying and seething about how Boghog is actually better at games than us and actually we're the ones coping>>751902270That kind of sprite stretching effect just makes me think of old Flash games. It gives the game a 'cheap' kind of look>>751902356I hate this trope just about every time, it's so overdone
>>751902639>people praised bog's previous gameWhat do you mean by that?If you mean Caramel Action that game was absolute trash and nobody liked it. If you mean Gunvein that's not his game, he worked on the tutorial.
>>751880545What if it's a game with soldiers and the difficulty levels are likeCadetMajorGeneralis that kosher?
>>751902412>the decision making can vary substantiallyGo on, then. It seems like the depth is in crowd control. Jump in attack, a throw, combo canceling to stun lock an enemy. What else is there?
>>751902646You are a pretentious double nigger that doesn't know what he's talking about. Crimzon Clover was made by a guy that lived and breathed shmups so hard that he made one of the best shmups that people liked and can't find faults with. The same retards here praising fight n' rage was because the developer loved played beat em ups and fighting games so much. You just want people to be on the same level as you: worthless and nothing to show for by giving shitty advice.
>>751899826This game looks fucking horrible. I'll stick to playing Ninja Warriors remake, a game made by people who actually know how to make something fun.
>>751889941FnR is so good. Played it yesterday after not touching it for a while and I was still able to 1cc hardest by the skin of my teeth.
>>751902847Hey cool yeah I love the realism it's just like when I pilot my own robot to fight giant dream crabs that's what makes for good game design you stupid twat
>>751902380It takes skill and experience to have the ideas born from your head validated not only by yourself, but by others.Real artists are capable of alchemizing even shit into solid gold and boghog is just a pretentious dickhead that got his ass blasted after spending most of his time babblering about his supposed knowledge.
geewoody stream doko
>>751868774>pig thread
>>751902847The issue is in like a boxing match one isn't arbitrarily slowed down ny weight and the other get to dodge as he pleases. Each one is capable of having free movement unlike in decogear where the player is slower than everything else.
This thread just makes me want to go and beat FnR again. Thanks hog!
>>751902639>that this thread reeks of people that hate arcade style games anywayHi boghog. I've done plenty of 1ccs of actual arcade games. Your game sucks
>>751902958>You are a pretentious double nigger that doesn't know what he's talking about.New writers creating a rip-off of the book they like the most is an extremely well known phenomenon.
>>751902639>people praised bog's previous game.Hardly anyone played Carmel action and gunvein was already made by the time boghog joined the group. For all intents and purposes this IS his first real game.
>>751898613I would argue with you because I think Pragmata is good but you posted based Tojima so we're cool. Kunitsu-Gami is the best modern Capcom game anyway.
>>751869736FPBP
>>751902639>arcade style gamesWhy do I get the feeling you've loaded this term with a million conditions no one else would agree withIs a game arcade style if you can runIs a game arcade style if you have defensive optionsIs a game arcade style if you can juggle enemiesOr is a game only arcade style if the only consideration whatsoever is spacing
>>751903263Kunitsu does look cool but I keep missing the sales for it
>>751892793
>>751903375This, anytime you hear their terms the chances are there's dozens of highly lauded arcade games that break thosw rules
>>751901036>This is why you don't consult pros about anythingSome have good taste, it's just not something you can tell from a leaderboard. Some are autisically married to a company, genre, character, or game mechanic and eat up anything with it, no matter how bad. Others are reasonable dudes.When X-Fusion came out totally fucked, I assumed it was pandering to kaizo Super Metroid bullshit speedrunners. So I looked up the WR holders to see if they were creaming themselves over it, but they had X-Fusion pegged as the mess it was
>>751902956There is resource management and enemy priority. Manipulating enemy ai with your own string cancels and saving items/pick ups for bosses. What more do you want ? That's way more than the average souls game has in its core gameplay. Its all about getting UT into a nice presentation like Situ did. Though that game was not very deep. But still it had compelling crowd control scenarios.
>>751896894reminder morkhog shat on ufo50
>an actual thread for a change Mist be bcs all the groids are occupied with GTA 7
>>751903420It's genuinely worth what they're charging and I say that as someone that waits for sales all the time. The genre mix does appeal to me as an individual perfectly but I think it's just a great game top to bottom. Whenever people talk about games not having little touches that actually matter these days I remember Kunitsu-Gami's entire OST was recorded outdoors in forests so it sounded more diegetic in-game.
>>751901036>>751903802As with all things there is a balance.Obviously a pro/speedrunner/1CCer/whatever the fuck is going to have insights on the genre that the average person won't have and will be an asset to playtesting as they will quickly sniff out optimal play.That said their input MUST go through an intermediary, they cannot have direct control, because by virtue of being so deeply involved in the genre they bring two massive problems:1) Complete blindness to how inexperienced players will interact with the game or how they will feel about the game2) A constant need for greater stimulation, making them want the devs to push the systems far past the breaking point because they as 10,000-hour players are bored
>>751868774This game is unfair bullshit, there are no continues, the enemies attack nonstop with no telegraphing. The player has no defensive options. There are no upgrades, the coins are useless, you go back to the beginning so what's the point of playing runs?I enjoy a challange, I'm a Souls veteran, this is just badly designed. Does not respect the player's time. Artificially difficult.
>>751904445Anon someone already posted the steam thread where bog's latcher-on posted thisYou're embarrassing yourself.
>>751902052I genuinely really like Boghog, I think Decogear has so much potential but the current version just isn't that good of a game, definitely not as good as his circlejerk is hyping it up to beA lot of the hate in this thread feels forced but there is still some actual valid critique here that he will hopefully take into considerationDude still mogs absolutely everyone ITT for being able to actually create things, programming and art are fucking hard, finishing a game is an achievement regardless if it's actually good or not
>>751904528kek fuck
>reddit filenamesup geewoody
>>751904227From personal experience, as a developer listening to "pro player" feedback can be really exhausting. They will often ask for changes that'd make a game more to their taste, completely disregarding the average players. I'm not opposed to difficult games, or games having some meme difficulty mode that's unbalanced or not recommended for casual players, but you got to keep your average playerbase in mind. I guess in bmup circles you can sort of just coast by appealing to more hardcore players because bmups are pretty niche anyway, but good luck if you try that with some other genres, and want your game to sell.
>>751904536>there is still some actual valid critique here that he will hopefully take into considerationFor his own sake I hope you're right, but in the itch/steam/bsky forums you can already see people around him shitting on other games for accepting criticism from bad reviews.I don't know that the community he has cultivated would accept him making serious changes. It would be an admission he or they were wrong.
>>751904536>programming and art are fucking hardLiterally the easiest part of making a game. The hard part is designing it and making it fun.
Boghog won
What are some actually good beat em ups you guys recommend? I've played most of the Capcom beat em ups (DnD, Punisher, AvP, tried Cadillac's and Dinosaurs but didn't like it much), Panzer Bandit, SOR 1-4, and the Ninja Warriors remake. Fight n Rage is on my to play list since I always see it jerked off here.
>>751905027I like battle circuit
>>751905027Guardian Heroes, Bognog and his clique hate it because Treasure always made their games centered around unique gimmicks instead of making them "correctly" like his autism demands.
>>751905027With those games you listed, feels like the next obvious step is Fight n Rage
>>751904765>you can already see people around him shitting on other games for accepting criticism from bad reviews.He's based for shitting on people that wanted continues in fucking takeover 2.
>>751905027Denji makai 2/Guardians
>>751905027SOM which you postedDragon's CrownNinja Baseballbat ManAbsolum (warning: roguelite)Castle CrashersGuardian HeroesShredder's Revenge and Marvel Cosmic Invasion have problems but they're still pretty good
>>751904852>Boghog: "Heh... Boghog won...">proceeds to go back to bluesky circlejerk
>>751905206>Takeover 2just looked it up and holy shit that game looks hideouslike, seems decently fun, but I want to vomit watching this videoI don't give a fuck if casuals want continues so they can see the end screen and I can't imagine what kind of enormous faggot would
>>751905257>Not a single good best em up>Games made for people that hate beat em upsAmazing thread so far. Boghog vindicated, as usual
>/v/ is actually discussing game designIt feels like I have entered bizarro world.
>>751904639I'm way above the average since I've been playing shit since the 80's and have also got paid work as a tester multiple times, I can agree that listening to the average NPC "as someone who played dark souls" can be fucking infuriating, but developers can also be absolutely retarded, indie devs being the worst examples of tunnel vision. Won't listen to the average players, won't listen to pros, won't listen to paid testers, won't listen to their mother dying of terminal cancer. As result, "i'm an indie developer" becomes a synonym for starving shithead.
>>751905441Anon it really just sounds like you and braphog hate beat em ups
>>751905454>>751882398>>751898971why does geewoody keep making posts like this?
>>751905027Double Dragon Neon is underrated
>>751904639>From personal experience, as a developer listening to "pro player" feedback can be really exhaustingExamples? I'm not doubting you, I'm just curious.I did a lil' dev and I think my favorite axiom is listening closely when players feel there's a problem but barely to what they think you need to do to fix it, because the root cause is often way off
>>751905441>every beat em up that isn't final fight 1 sucks>also final fight sucks too it should be HARDERT. Boghog
>>751905136I should've mentioned I've played every game in the Capcom beat em up collection but none of them really connected with me like DnD or AvP, but that's probably my fault for playing DnD first since it feels like an evolution of a lot of those games. It's been a few years though so maybe I should give the games in that collection another shot.>>751905176I have tried Guardian Heroes, I got decently far but some later levels had some really damage sponge enemies so I assume I must've been playing wrong or something. I found Panzer Bandit more fun.>>751905257Ninja Baseball Batman is on to play, especially when the new version comes out. Absolum's character design and artstyle is genuinely so horrible I'm never touching it because of that, sorry.>>751905221Never heard of this one, noted.
>>751905382It looks way better than the first game, you guys have impossible standards.
>sneed em updogshit genre for people who can't play fighting games
After hours of research and careful consideration I have come to a conclusion.Boghog only really likes bullet hells, they do not like beat em ups. At all.This game is a freakish attempt to make Final Fight 1 more like a bullet hellIt appeals to precisely 10 people in the entire world
>>751905709>I have tried Guardian Heroes, I got decently far but some later levels had some really damage sponge enemies so I assume I must've been playing wrong or something.You need to make use of your AI companion. The right commands for the right enemies and spacing with him is important, and so is using his screen clearing rage mode.
>calling trannies "people"kekaroo!
>>751905206>He's based for shitting on people that wanted continues in fucking takeover 2.I will never get this. Like... just don't press continue? All of his favorite games have built-in continue system, even console ports had usually 3 continues. Final Fight had it, SoR had it.Not just that but that game only added continue system to the casual mode, so what's the issue exactly?It's always a weird discussion, because those cultists have their own cult approvedTM cheats like auto-fire, save states or advanced training modes, but they draw this arbitrary line over something that effectively still acts the same as it did in the arcades.Oh, and of course those cultists never actually bought or played The Takeover 2, funny how they bitch about arcade games dying but they never ever purchase any of those games.
>>751898847
>>751905745I didn't play or hear of Takeover 1The animations are good but the shading and texturing is fucking gross. I feel physically ill looking at the game. It's like everyone is covered in mold.
>>751905903Because if the plebs can see the win screen at the end it cheapens their "hard work" and """"""achievement""""""
>>751905913video games???????????????????????????????????????
>>751900857
>>751905621The usual suspects I've had to deal with it's stuff like "okay, make this thing harder, but make sure it's harder in a way I like it!". That is to say, effectively redesign enemies, encounters and scenarios for some higher difficulty mode, which in turn could effectively double up the required amount of work. Just to please someone who's expert at the game, when I've had issues to address that'd help or benefit everyone (tightening up hitboxes, fixing bugs, patching obvious exploits that could drain the fun out of a game).Again, I'm not opposed to making something hard, but time constraints and budget don't always allow for crazy redesigns that only a minority of players would actually play.
uhoh troonoid meltoid
>>751906118Like I saidBraphog doesn't actually like beat em ups
>>751906118Quick, somebody pirate and vibecode a continue feature in five minutes.
>>751905868Which character would you recommend for a first playthrough?
>samefags thread all day>gee how is this thread is the only good one on /v/lol
>>751906118Ow the edge.jpg
>>751906118Damn, all of the best jap Cave superplayers need to kill themselves right now because they dumped 700 coins to learn the game... oh wait, it's different because they "trained".
>>751905027I enjoyed Lost Castle. Need to try Lost Castle 2.
>>751905027Street Of Rage serie, Splatterhouse 3, Crime Fight 2 and 3 (Vendetta and Violent Storm), Final Fight serie (2 and 3 are for Super Nintendo) and King's Blade (Played the with my brother and we loved the game.)
>>751903063Says who?I'm lightweight but fast as fuck; most fights I've been in have been more like that webm than any GTA 6 "realistic" fight.
>>751906118I don't think he should have to change his vision for the game to please people. But curious, does it at least include a way to practice later stages? Like a stage select practice mode or something?
>>75190636910 year olds playing easy demons in GD are better at video games than Cave trannies
>>751906118HOLY BASED
>>751906265Han has the simplest gameplay and is fun. You get full i-frames from jumping between lanes, enemies can be grabbed from frame one when either you enter a new lane or they enter yours. You can do some good throw cheesing using this.
>>751899826
>>751906502See>>751906369
>>751906426You can practice in different stages yeah
https://www.furaffinity.net/user/boghog
>>751906598VGH... the density!
>>751906118Why are indie game devs always unhinged?Starting to think that Alex Kierkegaard was right about these people.
>>751906653That's not the same boghog...
>>751906118retarded niggers replying to this calling this edgy or too far or whatever like they aren't calling people retarded niggers that need to hang on a daily basis on this site
>>751906607Good that he included that.
>>751906673GAMEPLAY DENTISY UGHHHHH
>>751906653Unironically prefer this guy
>>751906835Shut up nigger.
How long until mork makes a video gushing over the game?
>>751907000He'll call it his goty
>>751906684People with balanced, healthy lives aren't going to be regularly posting on social media.
you hate boghog for retarded reasons i hate him because he hates my fetish, we are not the same
>>751907000After he's done with his 3 hour OOT remake review that will come out in 6 months
Yeah I was in a discord with this guy and he was a dickhead. Not surprised
>>751907153I wonder what he'd even say about it. Even the Star Fox video felt like just yapping. Yeah yeah, another sf64 remake, but you know.
>>751907105I'm guess it was "cute and funny"
>>751907304>wants to desperately prove that flat is justice >makes a game with cute and funny characters >yet supposedly isn't a loliconI don't know...
>>751907105>includes loilconBog is a hypocrite
>>751907105Never forget that Mork review of Deathsmiles where he made a dedicated section over "loli's smile back" line (which mind you was only in promotional artwork of US version specifically, nothing in-game or such) like that was some evil fucked up thing.Those people are genuinely insane, I don't know where this belief came from that normalfags think word "loli" is associated with porn or anything like that. Much less when the game is about gothic lolita fashion.Oh, and he picked a 17 year old girl in a dominatrix outfit with a whip and refused to pick any other one because apparently having normal gothic dresses up to your ankles is pedo coded or something.
who the fuck is this
>>751907258what server
>>751906603see:
>>751907864>i have no argument! I consneed saar!I redeem your concession
>>751906653>>751906860If nobody else is gonna make a furry slob fetish arcade game, then I'm gonna be the first.
>>751907105>>751907665I didn't know they were antis until this thread, I thought they didn't give a fuck about culture war shit one way or the other.
>>751906039>soitranny detected>ERRM THIS ISNT VIDEO GAMES ON THE VIDEO GAMES BOARD WE WERE LISTING COMMON BMUPS THAT EVERYONE PLAYS
>>751907105Now all the hate makes sense
>>751868774>Everything is fuckhuge and take over half of the screen>every attack has a range of 1/3 of the screen>can't run or dash>hold jab to win or jump+jab, no complexity in the gameplay>terrible sound effects and busy visuals from someone that supposedly loves shmupsWtf is this I thought faghog was actually a shmup and bmup fan, but he isn't any different from those trannie devs that like to LARP being a shmup/bmup fan.
>>751882228Considering he has almost zero understanding of game design outside of shmups, yes is usually wrong. This faggot thinks ninja gaiden 2 uses the fighting game triangle kek>>751883390It’s especially embarrassing because the f zero x staff ghosts are actually fucking brutal and use tech, Nintendo knew what they were doing with that game
>>751898847Jesus Christ, that looks awful. What were they thinking?
>>751906118I actually do agree with him and i do think we need to treat joe retard the average consumer with a level of contempt normally reserved for kiddy-diddlers, and i think preventing them from experiencing a gimp version of your game by withholding continues and forcing them to engage is basedOn the other hand, he is a seething faggot and I'd like to see him made into pork chops
>>751908638>NG2Reminder mork never beaten master ninja kek
>>751900857Is this a phone game? Why is everything so large?
>>751868774I thought we liked bog hog
it's funny that you guys call these guys sjw retard lefties because twitter and bluesky think they're nazis because Electric Underground made fun of game journalists and the last of us part 2
>>751908269Anon Battletoads Arcade was made 32 years ago
>>751909256would
>>751909256Sex
See you guys next time
>>751899826I wish this board still had IP counters because there's no way THIS many people care about braphog's game, and this isn't just the deranged lunatics from the shmup general samefagging.
>>751909108
Play Hyper Bun Buster