[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


Is Pokémon a competently designed JRPG, or is the concept inherently flawed?
>>
>>751881384
The biggest flaw of the original game is dogshit encounter design and if anything they only got worse with that in later games.
>>
>>751881384
There's a lot of good in its design and mechanics but it's held back by the fact that the games are made for children to beat so you're never forced to properly engage with most it.
>>
it's just rock paper scissors with a dozen types, the only moves that matter are pure DPS with everything else being pointless
>>
early on, yes, but gen 3 pivoted dev focus to the battle system, and after gen 5 they pretty much gave up on the single player experience entirely
>>
>>751881384
The underlying gameplay loop is fantastic but unfortunately the games are developed by game freak who are profoundly retarded. Play a decent fan game/romhack if you want to see pokemon truly shine.
>>
>>751881671
It's really strange how Gamefreak has the intelligence to design one of the most intricate and granular combat systems in gaming yet has no idea how to actually implement it.
>>
>>751881643
Crystal has the first iteration of the Battle Tower. You can say that's when they "pivoted," but even then Stadium 1 exists.
>>
>>751882074
they don't want to implement it, they want you to be able to clear the game in a short amount of time so you can move on to multiplayer content as fast as possible
>>
>>751881384
It's been improved as it goes, but gamefreak clearly has a holier than thou attitude when it comes to feedback.
Some changes like splitting ATK and s.atk were great, but it took how long to add a
>repel has run out, do you want to use another?
Or the realization that move pokemon has always been better than deposit then withdraw?

Other than that, fluff like mega and fairy are just scraping the bottom of the barrel.
>>
For a game made for a handheld in the 90's, it was very competently designed (even if it was buggy)
>>
>>751882195
those were supplements to the rpg experience. the johto games are obviously trying to innovate on the single player experience with the various time of day things. in hoenn it's pretty obvious that they had no idea how to go further with that, which is why they just copied everything done in the first game and spent all their time creating things that would make the pvp more engaging
>>
>>751881556
>>751881623
Play BF

Emerald and Platinum are top tier JRPGs, i don't want to defend the rest
>>
>>751882473
and they did the right thing, Gen 3 is actually fun and it aged well.
Contests, BF, Trick House are better than one empty region as post game
>>
>>751882473
Gen 3 is also when they cared more about longevity of the game. In gen 1/2 cartridges if the internal battery died they notoriously deleted your save file. If a gen 3 game had day/night cycle and the battery died, you'd be locked into one time of day.
>>
>>751882620
if you enjoy it that's fine, but it's a shitty jrpg
>>
>>751882662
Name one JRPG with something deep like BF.
Most JRPG have boring post games with superbosses.
BF >>>>>>>>> Ozma, Weapons, etc any day
>>
>>751882803
i get it man, you don't like jrpgs
>>
>>751882829
I like great JRPGs, like Pokemon Emerald
>>
>>751882540
The postgame Battle Facilities are cool but they're only a small portion of the game. The stuff before it matters too.
>>
>>751881384
>JRPG
Tell me about the roleplaying part of pokémon please. I'm listening.
(Kill yourself)
>>
>>751882650
game freak went through dev hell to make gen 2 then couldn't replicate what they promised earlier from gb/gbc to gba due to technical limitations. it's entirely their fault.

then you got a bunch of angry retards who couldn't transfer their charizard from RB to RS despite not understanding the new nature or EV/IV system.
>>
>>751882932
i don't know why you're clinging to this when you have such obvious disdain for the genre
>>
>>751882803
The deathknell of BF was keeping EVs and IVs hidden for so long.
I'd say 80% of the players would only interact with the BF once, maybe outside of the Battle Factory, because without optimized mons it's a shitstomp. High level players knew how to optimize and minmax but the knowledge was extremely niche until about a decade ago. A BF exclusive postgame is in practice no postgame for the vast majority of players, there's a reason the most well received Pokemon postgame was Gen 2's.
>>
>>751883001
Of course, and Hoenn and Sinnoh are great to explore too, but the point is you end up with a game where there's always something to do thanks to BF. With the others, you just beat them and that's it. So they're both solid games in terms of the main story and also have a lot of replay value.
>>
>>751882803
isn't it just typical arena battles? that's like, bare minimum for every JRPG after the PS2.
>>
>>751881384
The single player is dogshit because single battle is a dogshit format. Playing a triple hack is eye opening. Even doubles is better
>>
>>751883191
you don't need to minmax BF to have fun with it. the whole point is to try new strategies with different pokemon and see what works best. gold symbols aren't exactly all that difficult.

>there's a reason the most well received Pokemon postgame was Gen 2's
pretty sad. kanto fucking sucks
>>
>>751883279
come on man, hoenn is notoriously unfun to explore
>>
>>751883424
According to who?
>>
>>751881384
Good concept that was never properly expanded upon and was afraid of introducing challenge due to the kid-appeal of the series.
The lack of a hard mode sincerely hurts the games. You don't have to engage with most of the game's mechanics or think much at all due to just how easy the game is. You don't need to consider XP curves, IVs and EVs are meaningless for the story, even team building is kind of a joke when your starter can solo 90% of the game, and forced XP share means you're not even punished for it.

The series really needs to go to primarily double battles for trainers (wild pokemon can be single battles) and introduce a hard mode that forces set, raises gym leader levels, gives them an extra pokemon, and maybe changes the movesets a bit to be better. Pokemon has been build around double battles ever since they were introduced but they might as well not exist in the games for some reason.
>>
I totally agree with that, but it's about how the game was received, not its intrinsic quality, especially in hindsight. It's a design flaw, sure, but nowadays you can easily get around it with PKHeX, RNG manipulation or ACE, whereas it's much harder to get around a game that gives you every tool to breed quickly but lacks rich single player content.
>>
>>751883464
anybody who doesn't like surfing for twenty hours
>>
hold items should have stayed with berries.
status moves need to be more granular
end-game should not come down to who attacks first or sets up first
>>
>>751883397
hoenn is literally just copy paste kanto thobeit
>>
>>751883495
meant for >>751883191
>>
>>751881384
It's for children. It's good for children.
>>
>>751883658
>It's for children. It's good for children.
like every videogame?
>>
>>751883617
Weak bait
Leave it to the gen 2 tards to have the worst opinions
>>
>>751883397
You get your dick slapped if you go into the BF with Pokemon leveled normally.
Going into a BF postgame without super optimized mons is possible but you're still talking about having an encyclopedic knowledge of the intricacies of the game which is honestly a higher bar for a player than just rolling it with a 6IV EV minmaxed team.
The jump in difficulty from the main game to the postgame is absurd because it asks you to put into practice all the details and strategies the game never actually taught you and actually purposefully obscured.
>>
>>751883832
i don't get why you're so fragile about all this, you won. they make the games for you now. you can proudly gloat that all pokemon games are now made in hoenn's image
>>
>>751883994
they made a game for everyone relevant*
>>
>>751883331
The difference is that a typical JRPG arena is a fixed set of fights you beat by grinding and gearing up, and once it’s done, it’s done. BF normalizes levels and has restrictions, so overleveling doesn’t help, you face random opponents with competitive sets, you need long win streaks, and one loss resets you. Each facility has its own rules, so it’s really about team building and decision making, which is why it never gets old.
>>
>>751883397
Put aside the kanto stuff. Its the fact that you beat the game and expect at most an unknown dungeon, only to get an entire fucking continent, and said continent is the from the previous game and a bunch of shit has changed so you are automatically curious to explore. THEN you get an endgame dungeon anyway, and you expect this games mewtwo... only to kind some fag in a gold room that looks kinda similar to you but the cap is front facing and HOLY SHIT IS THAT YOU FROM LAST GAME WHY IS HIS POKEMON 20 LEVELS OVER YOURS OH SHIT NIGGER

You can not like Kanto and all that all you want, but it undeniably the best "post game" experience for any pokemon game to the casual audience, which is 99.9% of players. Because at its core, pokemon is supposed to be a monster collecting exploration adventure game with jrpg mechanics. BF is cool and we should have that sort of stuff in post games, but it itself cant sustain the post game. You need to have new places to explore and stuff, because its an adventure first and foremost.
>>
>>751884115
exactly, you are the median pokemon fan. the games are made the way they are now because you and your kind like it that way. congrats
>>
>>751884142
you've played like two jprgs, max
>>
>>751884115
Dumb nigga wants to larp as Ash again
>>
>>751884340
Gold Saucer is like that, FF9 is like that, in FF6 there's that tower where you can't use magic, FFX is like that
>>
>>751883424
Huh? Hoenn is great with all the secret base shit and trick bike stuff.
>>751883539
>this meme
You have a pretty expansive continent to explore. And why is surfing so bad when you can find dungeons and theres underwater shit? You replace it all with tall grass, what exactly changes?
>>
>>751884516
it's not a meme, hoenn sucks to travel through. it was your first pokemon game, though, so i can't blame you for being enamored with it
>>
>>751884516
Secretbases are such a fun idea that they did nothing with after, it pisses me off so much. Then they didnt even upgrade it in ORAS.
>>
>>751881384
its main problem is that the games never take advantage of the systems in place so 6 year olds can beat it with just the starter
USUM are the only games where enemy trainers are given proper kits and nobody played those because SM was so shit
>>
>>751884451
>I played Final Fantasy and Pokemon so I'm basically an expert on JRPGs
>>
>>751884628
Nice way to sidestep my question. You replace the water with tall grass, what changes? The only gripe would be that its a bit too "open world" compared to the rest of the continent, but theres plenty of secrets and things to break it up. At absolute worst, you spend maybe 15 minutes total travel time to get to the required areas to beat the game. Oh no.
>first game
Nigger I grew up during pokemania, I was 7 when the games hit the states. And I played every single one of them up till SwSh. Which I only played because farfetch'd finally got an evolution; I was the dumbass kid that didnt want a pidgey and didnt like spearow. I got the in gamr trade for farfetch'd and trained it up like 40 levels before finally figuring out it didnt evolve. Because the anime had just started and I didnt know shit. And I played even when it became "gay" to like pokemon and went to multiple tourneys. Lower your fucking tone when speaking to me.
>>
>>751884852
>I'm basically an expert on JRPGs
I never said that and you didn't provide any example of why i'm wrong
>>
>>751884628
NTA but my first pokemon game was BW and i hate it, nostalgia isn't exactly a good argument
>>
>>751881384
Despite what /v/ tryhards will say, Pokemon is objectively well-designed
>>
>>751881384
You have to consider the origins of the JRPG. JRPGs were designed to be the first game that anyone can legitimately beat. Before JRPGs, you had to earn your clears with skill through limited lives and often limited continues. The designer of the first JRPG wanted a game that even housewives and children who never touched a controller could clear. So in this context the game design of Pokemon is genius. Pokemon Yellow was my first clear as a young kid. Pokemon (and JRPGs in general) are games designed to show you the ropes of gaming, and it excels at that.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.