What's your honest opinion of the Nintendo 64 controller?
soul
It needed a better analog stick. Everything else about it was great.
Too fragile.
>>752107972I don't think I ever used the left part
Mogged by the PS1 controller
>>752107972absolute retard shit, I wish I had a PS1 instead>>752108146
Dual shock PSX controller made sense, this did not.
>>752107972It's shaped like a 3.
>>752107972kino design but the dpad always felt superfluous. I don't think I ever used it.
>>752108079virgin n64 stick was peak, but yes, games like mario kart ground it's working parts to dust until it was blown out like a roastie's wizard sleevethey didn't know what they were doing and ended up with something that mostly workedhowever, without a second stick, it was ultimately a blunder design-wisethe cube almost fixed things, but the shitty stiff d-pad was a major regression from the company that invented the damn thing
It’s alright. I think the analog stick would’ve benefit from a more cushy design, the hard plastic really wores down your finger. It’s maintenance-heavy but also extremely reliable if maintained, much like all old mechanical gadgets. The accuracy and sensitivity of the stick is superb, the best I’ve used from first party offerings.
>>752108380I don’t remember ever using my right analog stick on my Dualshock 1. Even camera controls, if any, were relegated to shoulder buttons.
>>752107972i liked it. killed one playing mario party 1 though.
>>752108380Mario Party 1 too, with its dumb "rotate the stick as fast as you can" minigames.
>>752107972I liked the Z button
>>752107972the D-pad wasnt necessary, the analog stick wore out too easily.
>>752107972it's a phenomenal prototype for modern controllers. most of its "issues" are things that are only obvious in hindsight thanks to the lessons we specifically learned from it.
>>752107972It's weird but was fineL button was useless
surprisingly smart for its intended purpose of nintendo not knowing whether 3D games were gonna pan out or not (dimwitted in hindsight as 3D games were already proliferating when nintendo was designing the thing, but it was a product of the time) with being holdable as either a six-button SNES pad or a single-stick 3D pad with two main action buttons, four supplementary buttons largely working in place of a right analog stick, and a Z trigger to replace the inaccessible L button
>>752107972the ultimate brainlet filter. You'd have to be literally retarded to misunderstand its control scheme
Z-Targeting
>>752109436>four supplementary buttons largely working in place of a right analog stickat the time the concept of a "right analog stick" wasn't really that widespread. most 3D games used fixed camera angles that the player had no control over (honestly devs should bring this back, genres like horror games are way better with it).
Great grappling hook
>>752109553it is if anything proof that nintendo was thinking forward a bit, super mario 64 as their prototype, launch, and flagship game for the system had already cottoned on that some kind of camera control was needed
>>752107972Probably the worst controller ever designed, by far the worst mainstream/first party controller ever designed
>>752107972PerfectAnd there are retards that still don't even know how to use it
>>752108079The stick lasted 10x longer if you didn't have Mario Party but yes you're right
>>752110252what games required you to use anything else than the one on the leftHaven't played them
>>752110252If you need to make a pictogram manual showing how to hold the controller you've already failed
>>752108380I broke several sticks playing Smash. I was then stuck with a drifting Stingray until the Gamecube.
>>752110319single-digit number of games required holding it like a SNES controller, mischief makers and kirby 64 are the only ones i recall off the top of my headi think goldeneye 007 has a control scheme using the d-pad and analog stick like that middle position
>>752110319Mischief Makers
it was meh, i gripped like a retard but the games were fun enough where i didn't really think of holding it in a consistent way. i would alternate between the center for the stick or the left like it was a normal bumper to bumper grip, and just stretched my thumb out to get the analog stick. idk which was better, honestly.
>>752110328That's the manual, I'm sorry that you're a retard anon, get better soon>>752110319All shooters and most other aiming games use the middle one, and sidescrollers usually use the one on the right
>>752110328Given how many people who didn't own an N64 assumed it was impossible to hold without 3 hands shows people really did need an instructions
>>752110319Mortal Kombat games come to mind. only lunatics would try playing those using the stick.
>>752110546>they didn't hold the middle prong in their foreskincasuals
>>752107972Got mogged by Sega
>>752111015designed by andre the giant
>>752111015Worse in every way
>>752110319Some games barely used the control stick at all. You'd use the D-Pad for those games. The pro wrestling games were like that.
>>752109295Modern controllers all stem from the Saturn/PlayStation ones. Nobody took anything from the 64's controller.
>>752111326>stem from the Saturn/PlayStation onesretardbro... those controllers were made after the N64 controller using it as a reference. PS1 and Saturn controllers from before the N64 release were just SNES/Genesis controllers all over again.
>>752108038fpbp
>>752108038/thread
>>752111501The Saturn's analog pad released less than 2 weeks after the 64 came out, it wasn't based on it at all.
>>752108146I've used it in Pokemon Stadium to navigate in the menus. But that's pretty much it.
>>752111691The 64 pad was known well before it released anon
I remember playing Mario Party 3 (?) and playing the minigame where you have to spin the joystick to beat the shyguy.It was an incredibly hard thing to do, and I used the entirety of my palm to do so.I spin so fast and hard that the entire epidermis of my palm peeled off and got stuck in the joystick. Hurt like a motherfucker. The worst part is that my mother grounded me because she thought that in order for that to happen I had to be playing for hours non-stop.There's an old /v/ comic about a Jesus copycat using stigmata and then the priest finds his N64 controller and I always get a good chuckle because it reminds me of that moment.9/10 one of the best controllers ever behind the Gamecube
>>752111691yeah, and it fucking sucked because they rushed it out when they saw the N64 controller and realized how limited their original controller was.
>>752111880Classic
>>752111848The controller was made in tandem with Nights which started way before the 64's pad was revealed.
>>752107972only really suitable for comfy games. the analog stick feels great for the first few days before it inevitably goes floppy
>>752112085Ahh, it was the game itself and not the controller.Still a good one.
>>752111119They're the same size
>>752107972I think even giving them the benefit of saying it was one of the first 3d controllers they fumbled it by always locking a bunch of buttons away from your hands. That heavily limited games.
>>752107972overrated
>>752112228I was talking about the comically unwieldy disc shape but you already knew that and were being disingenuous
>>752107972Iconic
>>752107972It's baffling to me that they didn't think of a two-stick design even back then. The C-Buttons obviously show that they knew controlling the camera was going to be an issue. You control movement with your left thumb, you operate the camera with your right thumb... yet they settled on buttons instead of a stick? It just shows how little thought really went into it. The awkward design is proof of that. Sony came swinging with the dual-stick controller around the same timeframe, because it's just such an obvious thing.
>>752112228If you've used them you'd know that the size when holding is very different
>>752112330>two-stick design even back thenIt doesn't really matter that much, left hand on the DPAD and right hand on the stick did the same thing as modern dual analogue control
>>752112397It matters a lot actually, which is why every modern controller has it, but sure, pretend to be a retard for no reason.
>>752112330Most games didn't actually use it for the camera at the time. Kingdom Hearts on the PS2 was still using shoulder buttons.
>>752112462Yes, some games were still made by retards at the time.
>>752112502Name 10 PSX games that used it as a camera.
>>752112425If you didn't understand what I said then you definitely aren’t any pretence of retardation
>>752112536>people were retards so nothing should ever improveThe real retard was the /v/ posters I met along the way.Just accept that Nintendo was short-sighted and stupid, as were a lot of game designers back then.
>>752112602>can't do it>spits out word salad insteadBot or jeet, but concession accepted either way.
>>752108380Second stick is just waggle for gimmicks like Ape Escape, it's not good enough to handle camera controls better than camera/shoulder buttons anyway.If you need constant fine adjustment, then gyro does that better on modern controllers.>>752111326You can just say that modern controllers are all based on the SNES, you don't have to pretend that Playstation had any influence. Your modern controllers are just bottom surgery SNES or Futa Amazon SNES.>>752112330Why would they? If you're not getting any benefit from rotating the stick in a circle, then the analog stick is pointless. The analog stick without assist features does not have enough fidelity to babysit the camera 24/7, you get equal benefit out of having buttons to pan left/right and a button to snap the camera behind the player. There's a reason that nobody did this until they started backporting PC games or licensed engines started prepackaging it as a solution.
>>752107972Galanga
>>752107972Ambitious to say the least.
>>752112085I finally understand this stupid fucking comic after like 20 years
N64 controller only had one stick because the retards at nintendo picked a hilariously expensive for the time laser-light optical position detector.While it didnt have the problem of potentiometer wearout/failure/sensitivity the rest of the design fails from the spring metal being garbage and weakening and the ball of the stick grinding into dust.It's a controller and its purpose is for playing N64 games that just dont feel right on other controllers.But dont glaze the thing. It was one very good tech decision that due to cost limits ruined the rest of it.
>>752110319It's middle that I'm concerned about. Literally unnecessary.
>>752107972It deserves credit for experimentation, but the Dualshock was simply a better design.
>>752111880>>752112216It was mario party 1, they removed those in future games because of the problem. Also they gave out free gloves or something like that because how bad it was, they really fucked up.
>>752113124It's literally modern FPS controls, movement with DPAD and aiming with the stick
>>752108146It was good for puzzle games like Pokemon Puzzle League, but seemingly every dev was too excited to make 3D games to even consider making anything 2D. Nintendo probably thought there'd be more interest in 2D, so they did that just in case.
>>752113568And modern FPS games control like shit without boatloads of assist features that games didn't have ironed out yet.
>>752113568You can just use the C buttons instead of the dpad
>>752113738Analog inputs are even more important for aiming than they are for movement.
>>752113738And DPAD is better than buttons and on left and right hand is better at aiming