What game was indisputable peak of Super Mario Bros series?
Super Mario World
3
3D: Odyssey > 64 > 3D World > Sunshine > Galaxy 2 > Galaxy (both galaxies are garbage though)2D: World > 3 > 1 > NSMB > Wonder > NSMBWii > Lost Levels > NSMBU > NSMB2Mario USA or Mario 2 for amerimutts is not a real mario game
>>752198043Fpbp not even gonna lie fr fr no cap
>>752198272>Sunshine >anythingopinion discarded
>>752198272>Odyssey is Peak>The Galaxy Series is garbage
>>752198384To be fair, Odyssey wasn't very good either. Generally speaking, open-world Mario games don't tend to be as good as the linear ones.
>>752198603People bought switch for OdysseyI actually adore 3D World, and switch dlc for it was interesting, but unfortunately it couldn't convice people buy WiiU
>>752198043Always the canned answer. It was a step down from 3 in every way except art/graphics. SMW gets glazed so hard, and it is great, but the only classic mario it really beats is the American version of SMB2.
Galaxy
>>752198696People buying a console for a single game doesn't really determine its quality in my eyes. Many bought a PS5 just to play GTA 6 only to regret it. I understand the appeal of Odyssey as I also played it quite a lot, but it might be the worst to second worst Mario game. I haven't played a lot of Sunshine, but I think I might prefer that one. I'd rather prefer the side collectable to be the thing you find everywhere over the main one.
>>752199395When I say "worst Mario game", I meant in the 3D series and not in general. There are way worse Mario games than that.
>>752197986New Super Mario Bros DS
>>752197986Wonder unironically
>>752198603Odyssey still is amazing. The worst part is that it's too long
>>752199798Nah Odyssey is perfect. I love that it has so much content, especially post-game. Bananza should've been as long as Odyssey.
>>752199929The amount of content is fine on a first playthrough but I recently 100%ed it again and some of just feels like filler
>>752199798The worst part is that 80% of its content is repetitive filler that never encourages you to use the entire moveset it has. I still enjoy playing it, but it is far from being any sort of masterpiece.
>>752197986
>>752199798>>752199929Half the zones or whatever theyre called are empty half complete shitThe ice world is empty as shit. The beach is pretty empty. Even the lost world is bland if you take out the gimmick dinosaurLunch, Forest, Desert, that racist oriental one and Moon are all good to great. But its like they ran out of time and just went with it
>>752200260I'd say 20% is repetitive at most but that's part of the charm. It's a like a running gag you're just waiting to see implemented in a new world>>752200357The space is great for bing bing wahooing
>>752197986NSMB wii was the only sovl new 2d Mario platformer
>>752199987Even when I didn't go for 100%, a lot of the content felt like filler. Either I only go for what's necessary and the experience is too basic or I do every and the experience is too repetitive, collecting "some more than required" is a very specific middle-ground. If I'm already collecting more than what I need, then why don't I just simply collect everything there is before moving on? there's also issues regarding the conflicts at each world. Why do I have to kill the Sand Kingdom's boss instead of simply defeating Bowser and recover his ring? everyone gets to enjoy watching it be brought back except the guy who owned it and was killed because he thought you stole it from him.
>>752197986Galaxy 2, according to metacritics
>>752200414>It's a like a running gag you're just waiting to see implemented in a new worldWell then that gag isn't funny. I want proper content in my Mario game. If I wanted a map filled with useless main objectives, I'd simply play a Ubisoft games. People throw shit at BotW for the korok seeds, but those were an inoffensive minor part of the overall experience. The shrines are another story, but I don't think they're as offensive as haters claim they are, I'm actually fine with most of them but that's because I prefer the overall exploration over dungeon crawling in Zelda games.
>>752200780I love Galaxy 2, but no decent person should ever consider the opinions of game journalists as trust-worthy. They aren't game curators, they're just barely-disguised advertisers.
>>752201152I know, it's my point, the whole metacritics thing is hilariously dumb once you actually look at the list.
>>752198852>hating on SMB2That game is a certified classic. Sorry you got filtered.
>>752202161>but it's NOT REAL MARIO>its designed by shigeru miyamoto, published by nintendo, and several of it's elements appeared on later mario games but ITS DOKI DOKI PANIC
>>752202053Generally speaking, using ad populums as a genuine argument says more about the person's arguing capacities than it does about the quality of whatever they're discussing.I'd love it if people realized that there are good reasons to dislike any of the top 20 highest-rated Metacritic games. It only creates stagnant discussions not accepting that there are ways to improve upon most games with a considerable level of complexity, which is why whenever I think about games that I'd deem as "with little to no flaws" are simpler retro titles like Ms. Pac-Man, Tetris and Puyo Puyo. And even then you could come up with reasons why they're not "your type of game"
>>752202779Scores end up just being shitflinging on the end of the day.But i wanted to meta a bit and shit fling at the thing for a change.
>>752197986If only Wonder spent more time adding some challenge instead of making everything feel like an amusement park.
>>752203867Wonder is basically style over substance, But I'm not sure if that's completely bad when I remember how bland New Super Mario Bros U felt to play. The New Super Mario Bros did had more challenge to them, but they were very artistically conservative in terms of design.At least each level in Wonder is memorable in some capacity by the amount of gimmicks they add, yet I can't remember a single level in NSMBU, only general themes.
Forced Soul: the franchise
>>752203867Had fun with challenge levels, ones of the best in mario franchiseDunno what's your problem
>>752198384Sunshine is the best 3d Mario by a large margin and anyone who disagrees does so because they were hard filtered by the precise controls/physics
>>7521979863 was by far the biggest leap and best mario game.