ITT:Bad Redesigns
>>59309185HGSS Misty & ZA Korrina
>>59309185Almost all the returning XY characters in ZA
>>59309196ZA Korrina yes.HGSS Misty are you on crack that's a great "aged up" design.
You will never have a loving wife if you can't accept her appearance changing over time. It's definitely alright to encourage her to grow her hair out long again though.
>>59309196Hgss misty is kino
>>59309185nah they did good. korrina on the other hand
>>59309216Love stroking it to her fat ass
>>59309185Literally everything in Let's Go
>>59309185OG Emma was cute, but I liked her mostly for her side-quest in XY rather than for her design.Now ZA Emma has a god-tier design.
>>59309185*Amazing redesigns
>>59309185i want to marry emma and then reenact the "where is my super suit" scene with her
>>59309201>>59309214HGSS Misty is trash. Thank god KANTOOO superiority keeps her original design as the main one
>>59309185any of the HGSS gym leaders
>>59309245Meh
>>59309185HGSS Sabrina
>>59309336Most are about the same with exception of Morty, Misty and Sabrina.Misty because animefags can't imagine her grown up, and Sabrina because it's a very daring redesign.>>59309363It's 3 years after Red/Green, I think it's fun to imagine what happened in her personal life to make her dress like that. You can imagine a sort of hidden character arc.
>>59309185It's actually pretty good as far as redesigns go.
completely fucking soulless
>>59309382The only notable difference is that the pose is less dynamic and they made the eyes feel less outdated.
>>59309185On one hand, XY Emma's hair was better.On the other hand, ZA Emma has a fat fucking ass, and she's legal.
>>59309185There hasn’t been a single good redesign of the protagonists.
>>59309400changing the nice blue for a shitty turquoise makes her HGSS design inferior.
>>59310086It's just light blue alongside the dark blue dude
>>59309185
>>59310113>DEI hirezamn we need more DEI hires like that.
>>59309185Is it a redesign? She grew up.
All of ZA
>>59309245She has fully modeled feet and Hideo Kojima was credited in the game
>>59309382The redesigns actually look good and give you impression's of the character. But the posing is worse.
ZA and ORAS has the worse redesigns
>>59310113>Character's sole existence is the sex appeal That's every woman ever
>>59310086Turquoise looks better imo. Really brings her outfit out.
>>59310148I haven't played ZA but only Korrina and the kimono girl looked bad, all the other girls looked good
>>59309185Karen. Talk about missing the point of your own character.
>>59310160Ehhhh not really
>it's not obvious enough to zoomers that he uses ice types!>give him BLUE clothes and a jacket and a scarf so he just looks like every other generic old man npc quick!!!
>>59310113>no personality besides 'me good and like pokeymon'
kek /vp/ might be the only place on the entire internet that I've seen doesn't like the HGSS redesigns
>>59310247Lewtwo hates them because he knows they're better
>>59310247/vp/ is always wrong so not surprised
>>59310247People on reddit and twitter aren't old enough to know what the original designs looked like.
>>59310247Honestly I can only get behind the male MC looking better in the original, all the other ones like >>59310206 feel like a stretch of wanting to hate something just because it's "le different from my childhood".
>>59310295They feel like a stretch because you’re a retarded zoomer who wasn’t around when gen 2 came out.
>>59310147>The redesigns actually look goodNo they don’t.
>>59310279And yet you see the old designs posted there way more?
>>59310301I started playing in gen 3 so I was definitively alive during gen 2, even if I wasn't a fan yet.
>>59310306We get it, you think your opinion is objective reality
I rarely ever see the old designs posted anymore anywhere after the HGSS designs came out, same can't be said about other redesigns in the series
>>59310326>the fanbase is full of zoomers who started in gen 4+wow no shit
>>59310350Hey even those who have played the originals prefer those designs
>>59310357Not me. All of the redesigns are downgrades.
>>59310393Can you explain why?All the 'original designs are better' guys can't explain. Usually they just say "i-it just is"
>>59309382>symbol on clair’s old suit looks like some kind of skull or head>gets replaced by orbgay
>>59310472>can you explain why it’s better that the character looks like a normal person and not a retarded lazy gijinka because zoomers are too retarded to figure out that clair uses dragon types without her wearing a literal scaly dragon cosplay?
>>59310472Can you explain why the new ones are better?
>>59310486That's the Rising Badge.
>>59310494Well for starters, they look less generic and actually look to have personality.
>>59310487I never really saw them as gijinkas. Though tell me what about Pryce's original design suggests he uses ice types aside from the tiny badge that I can barely see.
ZA redesigns suck
>>59310506>they just are!Riveting.
>>59310521Where is that stated in my message?
>>59310549It's right where you inserted the buzzwords.
>>59310509>how could this frail, fragile old man with spiky white hair communicate that uses the frail fragile type associated the color white? this is too subtle for my zoomer brain, I need him to wear le heckin winter clothes even though he lives next to a fucking lake and would be so used to the presence of ice types that he he wouldn't need to wear winter clothes!!!
>>59309185That fat fuck TabithaWhat the hell were they thinking?
>>59310113>leh DEI Your entirely identity is a farce built on the lies of a dead pedophile
>>59310578When I was a kid I assumed Dragon because he's old and dragons require lots of time and patience to train. It wasn't until I actually got to the gym and realized he used ice.
>>59310568What buzzwords?
>>59310614Hmm. Good point.
>>59309185she was literally homeless
>>59310167They're not ready for this convo
her perfect ass and gap are made to be worshiped
>>59310614>>59310621samefag
>>59309185>soul vs 67-tier meme design Damn we were robbed.
>>59310669Homeless and had more personality than be retarded and shove her ass in the camera
>>59309382agree especially jasmine, i hate her redesign so much
>>59309382Claire's redesign boots and Jasmine's original dress are great.
>>59311067That's just the devs glazing Corbeau until he gets forgotten by the new fujobait
>>59309185HGSS SabrinaZA Korrina
>>59311062You know that why exactly?
>>59311067It's not a matter of personality, it's just a matter of having a plotline in XY.Some characters need a story to work, for example, Liko post-timeskip in the anime compared to pre-timeskip.
It's not a redesign, it's a time skip and character development.
>>59309382>Original comics vs mcu
every redesign from oraz and hgss glad diamond pearl remakes didnt get redesign
SM RedThe lack of front bangs under the cap makes him look bald and he just doesn't look good in general
>>59310113>No backstory You can literally play it in XY
>>59311621People deify some of the oldschool designs too much, some RSE human designs were kinda bland, like Courtney and Shelly are way more memorable in ORAS, etc. There's an argument for certain characters but not all of them, some are just objective upgrades.>>59311640It's supposed to look like a tourist outfit, he's in Alola as vacation, not like the mount silver encounter where he was training.
>>59309245a redesign?it's a new character
>>59310247I've seen a lot of people who don't like the Misty/Sabrina HGSS redesign outside of /vp/.I, for one, do like Misty's design.
>>59309382What made Sugimori obsessed with drawing noses like that, makes every character look like Voldemort
>>59312344Sugimori was always one to chase trends of the time.Back in the mid 90s he would draw kinda Toriyama-like, but by the 2000s his style was getting outdated, so he felt pressured to change again.
>>59311621Most of the designs in the originals are generic and boring as fuck. The redesigns add character and actually fit them thematically. Though some redesigns are over the top. Sinnoh has so many mediocre or terrible designs. I'm saddened we didn't get redesigns.
>>59311705She was in XY, though she barely had any 'character' back then. So you're technically right.
>>59311812Both of those designs are great, and are thematically appropriate. Most of the complaints are simply 'I liked the old design more' with no explanation as to why.
>>59309382a full translucent dress? holy shit we were robbed
>>59312767Most of the redesigns completely miss the point of the original.
>>59309185HGSS Sabrina for getting rid of the himecut, her unique outfit and turning her into a second Karen
>>59309382digital was a mistake
>>59312828Provide the point of the design and explain how or why the redesign doesn't do that. Also provide evidence that it is indeed the point.
>>59311640FRLG Red is garbage too.
>>59313862>FRLG Red sux.Absolutely based. The OG design for him has never been topped.Pokemon Adventures comes close, though.
>>59309382Jasmines redesign is fine but the original is definitely superior. The simple plain white dress just fits her better. Clair got it pretty badly though. Losing that sharp expression for something proud is disappointing.
>>59310206Nah fuck you. Pryce is wearing that shit.
>>59309185God redesign in picrel
>>59313862Postin Ariga art is cheating, he's doing the heavy-lifting in the left side.
