Which remake was the best?
>>59428143It's not lgpe or bdsp, I can tell you that much
>>59428143ORAS was the best, with HGSS and FRLG close second and third.
>>59428153>another ORAS fanTrue...
>>59428153HGGS is objectively the best remake the series has ever delivered
>>59428143I still try to pretend everything after HGSS (especially that piece of shit that ruined Emerald's legacy) don't exist.
>>59428174Faggot
Retard
>>59428159In terms of improvement over the original, yes. FRLG are better games though.
>>59428179>frlg better than hgss
>>59428143I consider orass the worst, not because it's technically the worst game, but because there are some people that actually like it, which makes its shittiness even more subversive and cancerous because it can lead to more shitty downgrades like it. The same risk doesn't apply to BDSP because most people rightfully recognize it as trash.
>>59428143>>59428179FRLG loses out to HGSS since it introduced a female playable character in Kanto. And I hate women.
>>59428190>I hate womenSame but it introduced a girl, not a woman.
>>59428190
HGSS is objectively the best Pokemon game in general, and those who say otherwise are retarded and don't know shit about game design.It's not even close.
>>59428159It's the best game in the series tied with PlatinumAhemHGSS >= Platinum > DP > Emerald = Crystal > Ruby/Sapphire >= Gold/Silver > Sword/Shield > Red/Blue = Black/White, Black 2, White 2 > FRLG > USUM = ORAS >= SM = BDSP > SV >= XY = Yellow
>>59428194Pokemon fans don't know the difference, anon
>>59428200pretty based ranking except why the fuck is swsh so high
>>59428200unovabort made this post
>>59428200>red and blue same level as black and whiteYeah do us all a favor and kys fag
>>59428204true, red and blue is better
>>59428200Also if I had to put in the legends games, Arceus Legends is next to SS =, ZA is either between FRLG and USUM/ORAS or together with USUM/ORAS
>>59428207
>>59428209bortseethe
>>59428143HGSS are the best hands down. ORAS are easily the worst though, they absolutely raped Gen III
>>59428202I think it's enjoyable enough, the lower half of the board is arguable for me for half of them. However I will comment on what I like about SWSH. I think it has a very acceptable level of visual clarity and an engaging art style and really unique and colorful and fun designs for the cities and routes, some of the Pokemon and NPCs are fun too, but it has a really nice vibe that I think just really hits right for me specifically with the Pokemon battles and dynamaxing and the stadiums. The battles in it feel nothing like any of the other games of the series in a very good way to me. I love the darkest day, the Rose fight especially, the gym battles and final tournament, it just feels really cool, I've never felt more like a pokemon trainer in those moments specifically. It has a lot of unique fun features like camping, Curry, etc, that feel like the culmination and epitome of the ds/3ds era (to me it just feels like a 3DS game, apparently it was designed as one originally). I think the wild area is okay, it feels like a decent compromise for open world. Last game with wild grass encounters. Last game with a lot of features. I think a lot of the DLC features are cute even if there's not a lot of depth. That's really my only issue with this game is that it lacks depth like Gen 4 and 3 and etc do. I like poke jobs as well, it feels like a rushed way to make you feel more connected to your Pokemon as more than battling machines but I like it regardless because I want just any features that do that. The DLC areas are pretty. I could go on but I don't want to write a YouTube video here. Also bede is cute.
>>59428204Red and Blue is really hard to rate for me because I'm biased, but I really enjoy how unique and focused it is.
>>59428228Cope and seethe
>>59428232Good essay. It's a shame pokefags can't read.
BDSP for teaching the remaketards an abject lesson on why demanding constant remakes of their childhood wasn't smart in the slightest (though they had already been given warning in ORAS and ignored that to push on)
>>59428203>unovabort>Gen 5 is literally in the lower half of the tierlistThey broke you.
>>59428143BDSP>HGSS>LGPE>FRLG>ORAS
>>59428368Amazing ragebait
>>59428318If this was true then people wouldn't be asking for gen 5 remakes.
>>59428382HGSS would be lower if it was.
>>59428396No, I'm talking about the dense cunts who assumed because ORAS was made as an XY2 replacement, that megas were the "remake" gimmick, especially when they got thrown into LGPE to make that not look a barebones re-do of Yellow. You know, the stupid cunts who threw a massive tantrum in '21 when it was revealed Game Freak were not remaking their childhood in the expected style, but some whos were porting it 1:1 to make money off kids like all the rest and there was no new Starter mega designs?There's always been people asking for remakes, both here and in the wider internet (it's why they even had ORAS as a concept to fall back on, the hoennbabs on the internet were squealing for one). Most however are just asking for a way to replay their childhood or an older game in the modern era (like BDSP selling 15m copies, despite r/veepee/ and r/pokemon both despising it for being "a slap in the face to "fans""). The spergtards thinking "remake" = "highly specifically developed video game curated to my exact wants" however were never a factor in the thing. Can't wait for the next round of meltdowns when they JUST remake BW1, offer no hint whatsoever to the events of BW2 and disregard the concept of BW3, due to them not actually believing the marketingspeak they shouted out in Gen 5, only to confirm it was horseshit 10 years later and Game Freak treated it like all the other rehashes they made, only paired to try and generate more sales by sticking to the game exclusivity theme (it's why XY's rehash was also planned to be two and why USM launched continuing to stick with SM's extreme opposites theme).
>>59428143FRLG and HGSS are the only ones that even had the right to exist. ORAS could've been fine but they fucked it up. Everything else is straight up shit that I don't even want to pirate.
>>59428143ORAS. Fixes a lot of problems with gen 3 and the new content like the delta episode is a nice addition. Graphically and content-wise it’s better than HGSS and LGPE. And it’s better than BDSP by default because that’s game sucks (as did the original diamond and pearl).
>>59428143HGSS towers over everything else
>>59428179>FRLG are better games thoughNahhhhh
>>59428446
>>59428176sōy cuck
>>59428470Kek
>>59428153ORAS was a fine game, but it felt like a downgrade from RS and a BIG step down from Emerald. Still, better than BDSP. HGSS felt like a step up and a full on replacement of GSC.
>>59428143ORAS > HGSS > FRLG > BDSP > LGPE
>>59428143Like how Megas were to ORAS, Dynamaxing should've been to BDSP. They hated him because he told the truth.
>>59428456this. its not even close tbqhwy
>>59428143HGSS is a fucking masterpiece, even if I've started to prefer Crystal after playing it.
>>59428143HGSS > FRLG > LGPE = ORAS > BDSP
HGSS is absolute kamige and only revisionist faggots think anything else even comes close
>>59428143Unrelated to the question but the appeal of them died after ORAS because you could no longer use new pokemon in the setting of the remake. You could bring your Blaziken to FRLG, your Garchomp to HGSS and your Greninja and megas in ORAS. It would act as your new hub game to do stuff when the remake came out. Compare that to BDSP there was no point in playing through it if you already played it. There's no out of region Pokemon you could bring in and no Dynamax.
>>59428143HGSS by far, anyone who tells you it's not has been infected by the xitter-virus illness of hotakeitis.
>>59428446>Shitty 3D graphics>Better than the sprite-3D model approach of the DS gamesI guess you really enjoy your themepark slop regions...
>>59428396I think we need XY remakes. BW and BW2 are already fine game on their own, I don't see anything much that could be improved about them, other than perhaps some minor adjustments. The bigger issues with the games, like the excessive linearity, would require a complete rework of the region, that might be better for a sequel or a Legends game than a remake. XY on the other hand got so obviously fucked over by gamefreak not giving them a third version they straight up feel like incomplete games to this day. It's hard to see how they could fuck up XY beyond what they already did to them, but if they actually do then there's no harm done as the games were already incomplete to begin with, and I am sure a group of fans could eventually make an actual Pokemon Z that does what Gamefreak can't.
>>59428940>RS>DSPick one please child. Can't have it both ways.
>>59428940The sprite-model approach was done well in gen 4 but overdone to the point of outright hideousness in gen 5, I would take 3D over that. Not to say the 3D is good in those games, mind you. It's just less bad.
>>59428146>He thinks ORASS is goodHoly dumbass
>>59428143HGSS, no question.
>>59428706Finally a correct ranking
>>59428848
FRLG and HGSS are the best remakes by far. They are also the best Pokémon games in general, together with Platinum.
>>59428143LGPE > HGSS > everything else
>FRLGMechanically better than Gen 1, but the already slightly scuffed Pokemon distribution being made worse by adding more version exclusives makes the campaign genuinely less fun to play than the game that only occasionally works in battle, and the post-game map design is borderline experimental which I like but isn't everyone's taste.>HGSSBasically a straight upgrade in every way that matters, and the few things that were changed or removed are replaced with something way better somewhere else.>ORASThe changes made make the campaign overall worse than RS, the post-game doesn't beat out Emerald, the overworld graphics are in the same tier of bad as the original, but the expansion on the connectivity features using Gen 6 and the 3DS's improvements are genuinely great. It's a bad Gen 3 remake but a easily the best Gen 6 title.>Let's GoMechanics have been dumbed down to arguably less than Gen 1 levels with very little to make up for it mechanically, it looks decent and has some charm so I guess it's good for children who can't read yet if you want to play something with them (it's unfortunate that this and BW's Entralink are the closest we've gotten to DQ9's multiplayer).>BDSPArguably worse than DP, which are arguably the worst Pokemon game. Sure the AI works now and teams have IVs and shit, but the mandatory Affection system means it won't matter. Following Pokemon is neat but it looks like ass. The game arguably looks as bad as DP or worse. The Pokemon pool isn't complete ass but it involves you going into a hell with no map design (which is arguably an upgrade for DP standards). The Battle Tower is solid but Platinum has more to do and mostly addresses the issues of DP in a more concise way.
>>59430170>FRLG>the post-game map design is borderline experimental which I like but isn't everyone's taste.What exactly is "borderline experimental" about the Sevii Islands map design, in your opinion?In my opinion, the Sevii Islands have some of the best maps in the franchise. It's not experimental, it's just how cool Islands are designed when you put in a lot of love and care in them
>>59430126Kek
>>59428143HGSS with FRLG a close second everything else sucksI don't even like Johto as much as Hoenn but ORAS was such an insult to the original games, so many unnecessary changes and dumbed down shit to make it baby mode easy like XY, the whole region being blocky shit also sucked ass, it should have looked like a region made for a 3ds game not a Gameboy advance region ported to 3d, the lack of emerald content when HGSS got the crystal content also shows the lack of love by the devs, no cool new areas like the sevii Islands either, just random nameless islands with random pokemon, the retarded oc everyone hates, etcAlso all the characters redesigns got so one sided too over the top they become stupid too>>59428153You don't like Hoenn
