[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/vp/ - Pokémon

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


A thread for the creation and discussion of fan fiction and other fanworks - anything that involves a story and/or reading. What've you been reading? What've you been writing? What would you like to see more of?

>Thread question:
What's your preferred way of having Pokemon make noise? Have them say their own name, generic animal onomatopoeia, etc?

>Previous thread:
>>59498208
>>
>>59515371
You mean like murim/jianghu stuff?
>>
>>59515372
Nah, high level cultivation too. Killing and eating others isn't the (only) way to progress, it depends on the story. Honestly it's not even the way forwards in actual taoism either, that's pretty much a genre convention to drive the stakes forward.
>>
>>59515382
I think the whole turtle's left gallbladder while it's peeing but not pregnant to improve your spleen's health thing would work quite well in pokemon
>>
>>59515392
That's probably the only way to make sense of poachers and hunters too, they take them to sell them as cultivation materials which Is illegal or something
>>
'ate female mc's
>>
>>59515392
The ice cream of a vanilluxe during mating season probably goes hard and helps with stamina.
>>
>>59515396
For me its the genderbending shit, like just write them as a girl you faggot, no need to hide your gayness by saying they're into girls even now that they have a V because even then you're still a faggot
>>
>>59515396
Yeah, i avoid them.

>>59515402
>genderbend SI
It's worrying how many there are.
>>
>>59515369
>TQ
I remember a fic where Pokemon said their japanese names as their cry, weird shit
>>
Does nen count as cultivation shit? Everyone having some unique technique sounds cool, I think JJK has the same with innate techniques
>>
>>59515419
anything but using pokemon, huh?
>>
>>59515419
Pokemon is closer to cultivation than JJK, all it's missing is a bigger emphasis on something like Bankai. The key word is "cultivation", as in something you sow and grow through your own efforts. Bankai are usually involved because that's the natural result when you grow your own superpower from the ground up. In JJK they're given their powers and don't really cultivate it any further themselves, they only enter the arena and see who got the better cards and who knows how to use those cards better.
>>
>>59515431
If you're gonna have a character throwing hands then everyone has to throw hands when needed, blame SI-LVER for triggering my autism about that.
>>
File: 50qz9awnhhhf1.gif (1.02 MB, 250x187)
1.02 MB GIF
Lmao, just steal from Digimon
>>
File: hsr5ouY.png (337 KB, 479x756)
337 KB PNG
>>59515444
then just do it, only wusses need power systems
>>
Kill pokemon for consumption. Villain teams exist off the grid so the grunt's pokemon are free food for your team. Pokemon have all the nutrition a pokemon will need.
>>
ESCALATION...
>>
>>59515369
Damn, May really got a big ass bush.
>TQ
I have Pokemon making animal sounds because then you get a chicken or the egg” dilemma of what came first, the word/pun that forces a Pokemon to say its own name on repeat, or the Pokemon picked up on human speech and began repeating it.

I don’t begrudge a fic where the Pokemon say their own names as it’s literally canon over 3 decades though.


makes them say their name over and over or
>>
>>59515536
Wasn't there huge backlash when Gamefreak made Pikachu say its name in the game, and they reverted it for the gens afterward?
>>
Forget nutrition, how would a MathGod fare in Pokémon
>>
File: images.jpg (44 KB, 495x404)
44 KB JPG
>>59515608
MathGod? What, like imgrelated?
>>
>>59515063
Vore fic where a dude's friend kept spamming in Super Smash Bros so he went back in time and ate his pregnant mom.
>>
>>59515787
There are some things that are best kept to oneself
>>
>>59515608
you mean nerds?
>>
File: Pikachu.jpg (51 KB, 530x396)
51 KB JPG
>>59515444
Might as well pull out the boom sticks.
>>
File: Gun.png (224 KB, 640x480)
224 KB PNG
>>59515466
The more complex a power system, the funnier it is when someone just pulls out a gun.
>>
File: League_Card_Avery.png (358 KB, 800x960)
358 KB PNG
>>59513378
>Avery comes from a long-standing family of psychics. Each Psychic-type Gym Leader of Galar has been from the same bloodline as Avery, and thus, Avery has been destined to bear the burden of Gym Leader since even before he was born. Ever since he was a child, Avery could freely move things with his mind but lacked other skills, such as teleportation or telepathy. This has caused the rest of his family to label him as a disappointment.
literal "banished from the family" story
>>
File: HC4mlK2asAAQ-QH.jpg (99 KB, 495x718)
99 KB JPG
>>59515900
it's even more funnier if it's a Pokemon who pulls out the gun
>>
>>59515998
>"Is that a Mankey?"
>"HE'S GOT A GUN!"
>>
>>59515951
How incestuous are Galarian psychics? Blackthorn Clan level?
>>
File: 1592647263276.png (460 KB, 640x480)
460 KB PNG
>>59515369
Should Frontier Brains be stronger than Gym Leaders but weaker than the Elite 4?
>>
>>59516158
Fr*ntier Brains are mercs that should be run out of the region by the League in order to uphold the region's dignity.
>>
File: 1092501925.jpg (77 KB, 800x1067)
77 KB JPG
>>59515369
I love my wife Green!
>>
File: 1298612985151.jpg (169 KB, 1024x1457)
169 KB JPG
>>59515895
>>59515900
Why are Gears of War Lancers canon in pokemon?

I love my wife Green btw.
>>
>>59516193
Shit.
He's back.
>>
>>59516208
>>
>>59516226
I think we need a Muk in that image.
>>
>>59515484
BETRAYAL...
>>
Like a bolt from the blue, it’s time for another Threadfic Review.

I suspect I make a lot of references in these reviews that others don’t really get. In turn, there are a lot of references I don’t really get. I’ve never read Spice and Wolf. I’ve never read Blood Meridian. I haven’t played a Pokémon game since the original Sun & Moon. I’ve never seen a full episode of the pokémon anime. I thought Miku was an original character the first time I read PokeNormal. One of those was a lie. And, of course, I’ve never played the original Final Fantasy. That’s right, it’s Pokémon Crystal Light time.

I’ll admit, a Pokémon Final Fantasy fic is not normally the sort of thing I would be interested in. In my eyes, pokémon is a series that poorly overlaps with worlds that already have human magic systems, because it either makes the pokémon kind of redundant, or the magic kind of redundant. I don’t know the setting of FF1 that well, so I can’t really say how much the author succeeded in avoiding this issue, but I can say that it mostly feels like a pokémon fic in a vaguely medieval fantasy setting. There’s still magic outside of pokémon, in the form of curses, elemental forces, and the like, but (with one notable exception) you don’t really get humans casting thundaga or whatever.
>>
>>59516336
Speaking of, the core human cast is pretty small. It’s basically just Jane and Wol, with Garland, Sarah, Hex-Matoya and Joy serving as the major side characters. Sarah seems to be joining the main cast on a more permanent basis, considering chapter 7. I think the fic sells the relationship between Wol and Garland pretty well, establishing their friendship and rivalry enough that you can really buy how much Garland’s betrayal messes Wol up. It helps that Garland’s presence (or absence) continues to be felt as the fic goes on, both through Wol and Jane.

Jane is not typically an archetype of character that I like. She’s reckless and naive, with a tendency to complain about situations she got herself into. Yet, as the story goes on, it’s revealed that the recklessness is (at least in part) due to her not valuing her own life that highly in comparison to Garland or her sister, which was basically enough for me to pivot back to liking her as a character. It helps recontextualise her earlier actions as less ‘naive’ and more ‘wanting to make her mark on the world, consequences be damned.’ In a meta sense I assume she’s based on Princess Mia, a character so unimportant that she didn’t even have a name in the original Final Fantasy, which feels fitting for how she’s characterised in this story. She certainly doesn’t seem to fit the role of any of the classic warriors of light.
>>
>>59516339
Wol, on the other hand, is so archetypically a Warrior of Light that his name is just an abbreviation of the moniker. This naming decision is so monumentally stupid I can only assume it was actually a name given to the protagonist of FF1 by Squenix at some point (lo and behold, google tells me the protagonist of FF Mobius is called Wol, so I was a little off the mark but not by much). He’s pretty straightforward as a John Heroman: wants to help people, avoids killing, kind, reserved and mostly humorless. The complexity he does have mostly comes from the conflict between him wanting to save people and the fact that doing so will sometimes require him to kill, or at least hurt, others. Killing Astos and accepting Garland’s sword as his own is a pretty big moment for him as a character, but unfortunately the ramifications of that are yet to really be explored since it only just happened. I do like how much he seems to respect the independence of others, both in the case of Jane and in the pokémon that follow him. It suits someone in a leadership role and makes it believable that he was once a beloved Knight commander.
>>
>>59516342
The pokémon who follow our hero probably fit the party roles of Final Fantasy better than any of the humans do, though they don’t quite slot in cleanly. Chansey and Vileplume are pretty clearly the White and Black Mage/Wizard respectively, while Blastiose and Wol tag team the role of the Warrior/Knight. Hitmonchan seems like a shoo-in for Monk/Master then, right? It punch. It’s literally the fist. But it specifically seems to be a rather versatile fighter that can hit a wide range of weaknesses, which feels more like a Red Mage, even if it can’t heal like a Red Mage can. Well, it actually feels more like a Tyrant than anything, but that class wasn’t in the original FF. Ultimately it probably fits Monk the best, which leaves us with a missing Thief and Red Mage. Meowth and Pikachu maybe? Meowth sure is a thief, but Absol is implied to be the “Shadow” of the Warriors of Light, even if it doesn’t immediately answer the call. Pikachu can do one thing, and that’s thunder. It’s pretty good at that one thing, but that’s not really Red Mage material, not to mention Vileplume dismisses the possibility basically immediately.

Regardless of the meta-discussion around party roles, I do like the pokémon in this fic. They all have distinctive personalities, personal objectives, and reasons for joining (or leaving) the team. Vileplume is a particular stand-out, being an arrogant, haughty, old witch who is more physically and seemingly emotionally fragile than she likes to think. Her initial interactions with Matoya are entertaining and give you a good impression of the sort of person you’re dealing with, especially considering Wol (and the reader) cannot understand a word she’s saying. The crystal eye being a sort of Unown is also cool and I like how its personality contrasts with Vileplume’s.
>>
>>59516344
Hitmonchan is also notable for being the party MVP. It’s consistently brave and willing to sacrifice itself for others, is basically the reason why the party can navigate the sea at all, and proves itself to be highly capable in combat. It’s obviously proud of its abilities, but insecure about its role as a hero considering its troubled past and rarely looks down on others. Honestly, I think it’s kind of too well-adjusted for an ex-pirate. There is an explicit mention in the text that it struggles with people and pokémon who aren’t hardened pirates, but it honestly seems to get along with everyone just fine. If anything, it just doesn’t seem to like it when others are fretting over it. Maybe that struggle would come across better if I knew what it was actually saying.

Now, I’m not a big fan of pokémon just saying their own names at the best of times, but with how much pokémon “speak” in this story it starts to feel really quite egregious. It (barely) works in the anime because saying the name can still efficiently carry useful information in the form of tone, but in text it's just repeating the same word over and over with the actually relevant info contained in the speech tag at the end, if any is even conveyed at all. It also just feels kinda stupid, I guess? Takes me out of the dramatic moment when the pokémon just starts yelling “HIT HIT HIT” like a bad jojo translation.
>>
>>59516346
Prose occasionally feels awkward and stilted, with some strange phrasing here and there. Post dialogue tags tend to link things together too often and too abruptly. For example: {“I will be fine. You and Chansey take good care of your mother for me, okay? Now that the pirates have been taken care of there's nothing to worry about.” Joy reassured her friend as she smiled.} The tag would be better shortened: {“-dialogue-” Joy reassured her friend.} Even better, something like: {“I will be fine,” Joy reassured her friend. A smile broke across her face as she continued, “-dialogue-”.} There also seems to be a particular dearth of commas and other rhythmic punctuation, giving many sentences a weirdly drawn-out feeling despite not actually being that long. I’m about to start using words like ‘cadence’ again, but I will try to learn from past mistakes — trying to teach English when I haven’t formally studied it for over a decade — and shut up about that. I will say that both these issues ease up a lot as the fic goes on, or I least got more used to it.
>>
>>59516348
In general I would say this fic improves noticeably as it goes on. The opening feels like a mildly confusing slog with all the flashbacks, to the point where I would have preferred if it just got all the past stuff done immediately before moving into the present. As it stands, it feels like the story keeps interrupting itself before it can get a good flow going. That clears up after the second chapter though, which leads the rest of the story into a plot that I can only really describe as “video-gamey.” Unsurprising, considering the whole premise of the fic. I get that the author’s hands are kinda tied, but I can’t say chasing macguffins is particularly compelling to me. That’s not to say the fic is devoid of intrigue. The anti-twist regarding Astos genuinely blindsided me, both because the characters actually discussed the possibility before it happened and because he’s sort-of a good guy in Stranger of Paradise.

Overall: I’m here to kill Chaos/10
Though you may forget the Threadfic Review, rest assured it DOESN’T GIVE A FUCK WHO YOU ARE.
Lali-ho for now.
>>
Did you guys know that people nowadays feed the stories they're reading to ChatGPT to get reviews? Not saying this is the case of course but I've seen that shit in few places, like nigga then what's the point of reading if you can't form your own opinion?
>>
>>59515369
I been working on this romhack:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CedcOzCpC_E
>>
>>59516346
>Takes me out of the dramatic moment when the pokémon just starts yelling “HIT HIT HIT” like a bad jojo translation.
Reminds me of the time IMOanon had a Geodude says "dude"
>>
>>59516357
the reviews are for the author itself and not potential readers, or at least that's what I think
>>
>>59516379
Disagree on that, as a reader I do tend to look at reviews to get a basic idea of the story
>>
>>59516402
I mean, I would do that too if readers weren't braindead lovers of power fantasy SI
>>
File: 1753185799357658.jpg (107 KB, 1080x1071)
107 KB JPG
>>59516357
ChatGPT is outdated and has Alzheimer anon.
it forgets basic shit it did like 2 minutes ago:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rITC6D-CyDg

So no. I just re-read what I write. I'm very creative I made a Final Fantasy-Pokemon RomHack demo and people liked it. I'm good at coming up with stories and I know how to world build. But I'm lazy as shit to I finish everything 1 year later.
>>
>>59516351
Nice review, please do "Crime Sometimes Pays" next.
>>
File: 1742286479491675.png (436 KB, 565x564)
436 KB PNG
>>59516351
>Stranger of Paradise.
I only just recently saw the trailer for this game that showed Astos and did a spit take when I saw Sqaure also turned him into a pretty boy. Have yet to play SoP yet, and undoubtedly two retellings of the same barebones story are going to have some things in common. And I mean barebones, they literally hadn't learned how to make NPCs say more than 2 boxes of dialogue, so when doing a big reveal halfway through they game they had 12 NPCs stand in a circle for you to talk to. They didn't even have cutscenes worked out yet so the big bad's monolog at the end has him teleport a step away every time you talk to him to let him talk more. So it's very funny to me that I'm writing a 'unlicensed D&D knock off' and people approach it with 'KILL CHAOS'.

Oh, and thank you for the review! I am sitting in my car reading it all instead of going inside so I'll comment more in a second.
>>
>>59516462
Honestly it's WoL just wearing a t-shirt that gets me.
>>
File: 1555554328183.png (19 KB, 526x379)
19 KB PNG
>>59515369
Pokemon saying their own names was a marketing gimmick of the anime so dumb 5 year old kids could quickly associate Pokemon names with designs. Unless you're making a video or fan anime for 5 year olds, there's no reason for you to do what the anime does.
>>
>Only 800 words today
It's over.
>>
>>59516589
on what, on like.. some sexual pokemon fanfic or a setting based on pokemon you are developing or whut?
https://youtu.be/Pw4LPSEOMoA?si=5eTvhxYhx-Yi06ZQ&t=2013
>>
>>59516618
I'm not watching your channel little bro
>>
>>59516624
nobody forcing u to brother, enjoy your day however you please. Im chillin beating pkmn fire red today
>>
>>59516589
slow down fuggmann, I don't want your hand to cramp typing so much
>>
>>59515951
You'll never see this character in a fic because nobody played SWSH DLCs or they only care for Klara
>>
>>59516530
Counterpoint, I have created grammar rules for how a pokemon says its own name. Now I can feel superior while annoying my readers. And isn't that what writings all about?
>>
It's been ten years, did the frog ever recover? I barely see It in fanfics and its Mega is even more dead
>>
>>59516357
I’ve tried telling AI to review my own writing, but it seems very reluctant to give negative feedback and a lot of its feedback is just dumb.
>>
>>59515369
How do you write secondary characters? What traits do you give them? How long do they stay in the story?
>>
>>59516731
Better question is, do people even write Kalos or XY anime fics anymore?
>>
>>59516768
Does anyone even write about regions beyond Kanto? I think only Kanto, Hoenn and maybe Sinnoh get stories nowadays
>>
>>59516768
last one I cared about was the most evil trainer, and that was like 30 chapters before it ended.

Kalos has a lot of 'government conspiracy and oppression' potential
>>
>>59516778
>most evil trainer
The only thing I know about that Is that it proves spacebattles is just full of pedo faggots and that even the mods got involved

But yeah, I thought about using something like the Court of Owls from Batman but since even the Yakuza are dindu noffings there my idea just died.

Still hilarous how Silver got cucked by Corbeau as a son
>>
>>59516805
I dropped SI-LVER because of its meandering but if he and Corbeau meet I'll probably skim through the chapter. I'm very interested in what the author will do with the guy who cucked their SI
>>
>>59516772
>Does anyone even write about regions beyond Kanto?
>Lists some non-Kanto regions
Oh well I can't say I'm doing much on that front since I'm writing a Johto story.

>>59516768
From the Threadfic cataloge IMO, or In Mine Own starts in Kalos but then goes to Kanto. Prince of Po Town also takes place in Alola.
https://archiveofourown.org/collections/vpfanfictionthread/works
>>
>>59516816
Something edgy and "deep" I guess
>>
Is there any tabletop game that encompasses the spirit of this thread and series without the autistic crunching and archaic system of the mainline games? It would be fun to have a regular tt thread of Pokemon on here
>>
>>59516885
I've seen them here and there. No way something as big as pokemon wasn't getting its own tabletop. I couldn't tell you if they were shit or not though
>>
Omniring?
>>
>>59516948
A crutch for shitters. The real omniring is in your heart.
>>
>>59516731
Is it counter culture to have a team with Greninja in it now?
>>
>>59516948
give me an omniring that also works as a Pokédex, Pokéradar, Pokéblock maker and I'll buy it
>>
>>59516979
>He wants a RotomRing
That's probably one their future plans lmao
>>
>>59516948
Way cooler to have each individual transformation as a unique accessory
>>
>>59515396
>read story with female MC
>they’re inevitably gay
why does this happen so often
>>
>female MCs
gay.
But I do tell my readers I'm a girl so they lower their standards. Is hustling like this also gay?
>>
>>59517025
>But they were actually a guy in their past life so they're still straight
Do genderbending fags actually think that?
>>
>>59517075
I remember someone saying GB is just an excuse for authors to write a female main character but without the woman moments
>>
>>59516437
It's gonna be either that or Sellouts
>>
I'm not gay but if I were to write a girl version of me, I'd do a m/f romance.
>>
>>59517311
>SELLOUTS
Good choice as well, more SELLOUTS posting is always welcomed.

>>59516964
In other words, it's a tool for SELLOUTS!
>>
>>59517349
thas based anon and it is because thats hetero, more romantic and all that
>>
>>59517311
Should be CSP first. Sellouts drew inspiration from it and is a response to it among other things...
>>
>>59517417
Wait, really? That's kind of funny considering the comments CSPfag has left on SELLOUTS.
Still, now that you say it...
I still actually can't see where the inspiration came from, aside from the general Isekaijin trend.
>>
>>59516589
>mfw my most productive day ever is slightly more than 1k words
>mfw it's an ok day if i do 50
>>
>>59516885
Dnd?
>>
File: 78119033_p15.png (1.85 MB, 2291x1960)
1.85 MB PNG
>mfw I don't write
>>
>>59517461
>mfw i don't read
>>
File: et4nht7v42jg1.gif (1.03 MB, 540x266)
1.03 MB GIF
Any fighting type can do this btw because Pokémon humans are...FRAIL!!!
>>
>>59517499
>baby mienfoo and baby riolu play with worlds strongest man
>>
>>59517110
Why don’t they just not write woman moments?
>>
>>59517507
why did the world's strongest man chop the head off of riolu
>>
>>59517499
My hero would tank it no diff.
>>
What the fuck is a "story beat"? What is this term people are throwing around like everyone's supposed to just know what the fuck they're talking about
>>
>>59517589
It's when I impregnate your mom, that is an example of a story beat.
>>
>>59517589
>Beats are the smallest UNIT OF STORY that writers use to convey the details of the ALTERNATE WORLD, AVATARS, and story events to their readers. A beat is a micro interaction that must always have an input and usually has an output.
Ten gorillion years in google yielded this.
>>
>>59517594
bodied that freak.
>>
File: 1770600102882464.gif (1.13 MB, 640x460)
1.13 MB GIF
>>59516767
All my writing is seat of the pants bullshit that I then build a story out of the ramblings. I write the first chapter without a plan and then go 'Alrighty, where do I go from here?' At times it feels kind of like cheating, or like I'm some kind of fraud because I do all my planning and story creation starting with the second chapter. I have a few fun ideas planned out, but nothing too concrete.

It feels a little scandalous to say, but this is how I started both PokeNormal and Crystal Light. I've long ironed out the details of both fics at this point, but it seriously makes me feel like a crazy person to admit that I started writing a mystery fic without actually knowing what the mystery was. I just sicked a ghost girl on Tobio and Josalyn and ran with it. I didn't know who the detective was yet, who the villain was yet, or even who the doppelganger was. Same with Crystal Light, I just thought it would be cool for Wol, Sarah, and Garland to have the three Kanto starters. I made up a personality for Jane as a throwaway character and gave her a pikachu as an honorary Kanto starter.

Wait, I didn't even answer the question properly. I started writing this, got distracted by videogames, and then finished this without even remembering what I was replying to. Whoopsy.
>>
>>59516767
For secondary characters I know they aren't going to be as big as a focus so I tend to give them one trait that emphasized by the narrative. Like being precious and brave, or being lazy and quick to make excuses. And for how long they stay, that depends on their purpose.
Some are heroes of their own story, others just exist so I can have a cute PoV of a certain event.
>>
>>59516885
I actually love some of the fanmade pokemon tabletop rpgs, but I have no experience with them beyond making fetish fuel character sheets. There are some non-pokemon specific monster taming rpgs out there that allow pokemon to be statted in them but I can't speak on any specifics.
>>
File: 1753468429487781.png (307 KB, 953x960)
307 KB PNG
>>59517631
Just realized I forgot to take my meds and revealed myself as a hack.
>>
>>59517780
ash trapped and betrayed story when?
>>
>>59517782
Like the anon in the past thread said, cultivation would be a bigger fish nowadays
>>
>>59517796
ash trapped and betrayed but he finds the inheritance of an ancient ascended immortal whom is trapped in a ring and teaches him his type matchups and the dao of the secret heavenly demonic otherworldly beast core consumer when
>>
>>59517797
This is how a lot of cultivation novels actually start. The chinese truly are ahead of the west in ways we cannot even fathom...
>>
>>59517807
junior... this elder is well aware
>>
Hmmm I think I will write a story about a guy travelling with young trainers except I won't reveal to the audience he's actually a 30 year old gay neckbeard until after the first arc. Surely there won't be any backlash over this.
>>
File: ancient Pokéball.jpg (495 KB, 1400x2800)
495 KB JPG
>>59517797
Hahahahaha
>>
>”Archie's teeth grind audibly even over the storm”
Is Fuggman really just trolling at this point?
>>
>>59517025
>>59517075
I haven't even written any romance yet
I'm not even sure if I intend to. I had ideas for it but now I'm not so sure about the whole section of the story where it would be in. Anyway, f/f SUCKS! It would be m/f in my plan.
>>
>>59517939
Aura infused teeth make the grinding louder.
>>
>>59517422
CSPfag has left comments on Sellouts? I only see Mahoganyfag. Is it on a fifferent site other than Ao3 and Spacebattles?
>>
>>59517888
Only if you make him act as mature as a 30 yo so the smart ones can see the guy being odd and sticking out like a sore thumb
>>
>>59518239
No, I think I'll make him act like a an early teenager at most instead. It'd be quite evil of me as a writer, I know, but...
>>
>>59518053
Mahoganyfag here, SELLOUTS is also on Spacebattles under the title:
>SELLOUTS DBA LOCAL 548, IGWU
But CSPfag has only commented on it in this thread. Basically he said it wasn't for him >>59341305
There was another occasion where he commented on Andrew (SELLOUTS) and John (CSP) being entirely different beasts, I can't remember the comment exactly, maybe this one was on ao3 (authors can delete comments), but he said that Andrew was "like a mad dog that has to be put down," which I think is apt.
>>
>>59518291
I'm also writing a manchild MC
>>
File: Cry.gif (33 KB, 220x165)
33 KB GIF
>>59518291
No! How can you?
>>
>Author asks for feedback
>It's mid, here's why:
>Come on guys I didn't put in much effort don't get all cinema sins on me!
Well then why did you ask for feedback! And if you don't want people to get all 'cinema sins' on you at least have the decency to be consistent with if you're using past, present. or future tense.
>>
>>59518658
i hate when they cant take / ignore criticism
basedciety is filled with pussy ass faggots
>>
File: 1779610067072500.gif (1.59 MB, 400x267)
1.59 MB GIF
>>59518658
>at least have the decency to be consistent with if you're using past, present. or future tense.
hrgkk
>>
>>59518658
>author asks for feedback
>some autist posts "I don't like it" followed by personal attacks and empty ad hominem because listing actual examples and being specific requires just a bit more effort than they're willing to put in, but their pride insists to them they know what they're talking about
there's good feedback out there, but generally unless you have a large audience, 1 or 2 random posters are probably going to be worthless. People love to post hate/'im better than you" reviews on content that doesn't have a lot of reviews, like being the first person to shit in a new toilet.
>>
>>59518658
>author asks for feedback
>give them the most tepid feedback possible
>they block me
lmao
>>
>>59518895
>>some autist posts "I don't like it" followed by personal attacks and empty ad hominem because listing actual examples and being specific requires just a bit more effort than they're willing to put in, but their pride insists to them they know what they're talking about
Holy projection Batman. He's the one that asked for feedback, some feedback is useful some is not, no matter who's saying it. It's a skill to parse out if there's anything useful in there.
I wasn't even mean, and I used specific examples, mixture of Japanese and English honorifics, inconsistent usage of past/present/future tense, some scenes being under described while others are over described or have redundant exposition, inconsistent pov, and occasional grimmer and spelling mistakes (although that last thing was a very minor point and I didn't focus on it).
In each instance I quoted the text to use as an example.
>>
File: MobiusFF_Wol.png (318 KB, 326x712)
318 KB PNG
>>59516339
Okay, gonna actually try and reply more indepth now.

>Princess Mia
Oh, did she get a name in Stranger? Neat. I would have used that name if I had known, but I'm glad Jane gets to be her own character. I named her Jane II because the queen DID get named Jane in one of the versions despite the king not getting a name. And I actively built her personality of struggling with feeling unimportant based on her unimportance as an NPC.

Wol's stupid name and the in story lore behind it is straight up taken from Mobius. In that game there is a prophecy that <playername> (defaults to Wol) will become the warrior of light. So literally thousands of men named Wol have been isekai'd into the setting and thrown into destiny's meat grinder to fulfill the prophecy. The majority of NPC's you meet have the same name as the MC.

Wol's personality is actually a relfection and exploration of my own struggles with confidence and kindness. Pulling the Squirtle out of the stone, so to speak, has given him more opportunity and responsibility than he feels he deserves. He has trouble recognizing his talent both because Garland always outpaced him so he has always seen himself as second rate. This made him not see how far he outpaced everyone else, and consequently made him treat those around him as equals.

The sword thing is actually something that is going to get explored more. Especially because, as I have been told I mention too much, the true sword is Charizard. Which is a big part of the pokemon's arch, the impact being born as 'a weapon' might have on one.
>>
>>59518916
>grimmer
I hate it when a Grimer gets into my fic.
>>
>>59518938
Those filthy poison types need to be snuffed out.
>>
Mmm, what if Ansha Is actually a clone made by Lyssandre because he was obssessed with eternal beauty and after killing everyone he planned to use the clones of the ones he thought of as beautiful to repopulate the world?

I don't know, just a silly idea because every evil team plan is stupid as fuck
>>
>>59518916
Every writer needs the feedback like this that kicks their ass into shape because usually first time writers will be fucking something up and not realizing it. Specificity and good reasoning that is actively constructive with the intent of helping the author improve is the best feedback to give a writer.

The other side of the coin is writing is an inherently persoonal thing, so the “how” this is all delivered matters far more than what’s being said, ironically enough. Because there’s plenty of just mean-spirited feedback that’s more just trying to dunk on the author than anything else. Feedback of this sort usually ends up being subjective, vague, or a repeat of criticism that’s been addressed. The more critical feedback you get, the easier this becomes to spot when you get it. As far as the fanfic commmunity goes, you’ll notice it’s incredibly rare that writers give this kind of feedback. Partially because lots of fanfic writers don’t fucking read, but that’s another thing. If they are going to be critical, it’s handled with kid gloves, done for very specific moments, and usually has positive notes sprinkled in with it to soften the blow with because they’ve been on the receiving end.
>>
>TFTC
>Is this harem?
>Is "X" part of the harem?
>What legendary will "X" get?
It's not Pikachu its pikachu because it's not a proper name
>>
>>59518990
Bad news man, clones are also stupid as fuck. The reason evil teams are stupid is because evil is inherently stupid. The motivators of evil boil down to cowardice and anger at lack of power.
>>
>>59519012
Naming the MC of my next fic Human.
>>
>>59518916
>Holy projection Batman.
anon, the post wasn't about anyone in particular, just losers who post reviews on stories that have no comments and no reviews and act like asses.

If you decided that was you, that's on you

>>59518992
> Because there’s plenty of just mean-spirited feedback that’s more just trying to dunk on the author than anything else.
Criticizing something gives you power over it and establishes dominance, people like to cause pain in others for entertainment too. On the other hand, being positive to something is a sign of weakness and appeasement.

For a LOT of people, it's really that simple: Getting actual feedback means getting through piles of this filth until you find people who aren't brown in body or spirit
>>
>>59519065
Farla and her simps would kill you lmao
>>
>>59518992
Delivering and parsing what people say are skills of their own. Even with the best of intentions and efforts there's no guarantee criticism you give will be useful, and even when asking for it there's no guarantee that you'll get good feedback.
The only thing you can do is try your best and treat others the way you want to be treated.

>>59519071
Yeah, at least the mods on THP are fairly honest about it. They want reposes, positive ones, and ones that enjoy their story in the correct way.
The honesty is refreshing.
>>
>>59519060
Mewtwo is kinda smart
>>
>>59519101
You can be smart while also stupid
>>
>>59515951
>family of psychics
So you need a special bloodline to be a psychic? No wonder everyone goes for the aurafag build, just meditate for a day or so and you will learn to use it
>>
File: images.jpg (39 KB, 640x480)
39 KB JPG
>>59519267
Japanese love their bloodline stories
>>
>>59519282
And destiny, Kiki was right and you really can't fight againts the heavens or the child of destiny
>>
>>59519267
just drink sabrina's blood like a vampire
>>
File: 1594513754197.jpg (1.33 MB, 2048x2048)
1.33 MB JPG
>>59516344
For the record, the original FF1 classes were Warrior (Fighter/Knight/Paladin depending on version), Monk, Thief, Black Mage, Red Mage, and White Mage. And yes, all of Wol's final team is going to be one from each class. Hitmonchan is indeed the Monk, because Hitmonchan is my favorite Gen 1 fighting type (woe is me). All of the Pokemon of Light are going to be Gen 1 mons with the intention being 'first FF = first Gen'. This led to some world building with each nation having its own Gen population associated with it. So the neighboring kingdom of Melmond has Johto, Elfland has Hoenn, etc.

Back to Hitmonchan, it's moveset is actually based on it being a pirate more than it being a monk. Thunder Punch to fight off wild water pokemon, Close Combat for pure damage, Ice Punch for coverage, and Sunny Day to clear storms + Weaken water attacks. Fire Punch makes more sense with Sunny Day, but... Eh. As for how well adjusted it is for a former pirate there is a reason for that but that's spoilers.

And yes, who the Pokemon of Light end up being is part of the mystery. Along with who the Warriors of Light will be, as the only one with a guaranteed spot right now is Wol.
>>
>>59519072
I don't know who Farla is but I could take at least 6 simps.
>>
>>59519350
Funny story, both Sabrina and a Vampire are going to be relevant to my fics soon.
>>
>>59519350
Well it's either that or eat her eyeballs
>>
>>59516346
>>59516348
>>59516351
>Flashbacks
I'm conceding that I would alter the flashbacks of the first chapter if I were to rewrite it to be less confusing. Just slightly though. They are the #1 complaint I get. The #2 is the prose feeling awkward. I just straight up have been too lazy to relearn the rules of grammar. So I just write what best feels in my head, which isn't always great because you miss things when you write. My brain just sort of fogs over sometimes when it comes to stuff like that. So its definitely a flaw with my writing that I for the most part just try to not think about for now.

As for the video-gamey plot of the story, yeah. I've added a LOT of extra stuff to the original story, but if you know the plot of FF1 you know the broad strokes of the story and it is very McGuffin based. But I'm glad the Astos thing came out as a surprise. In the original him being a villain is actually a small plot twist as he originally pretends to be a good king before betraying you. I wanted to play with that concept because he is obviously sketchy, but I tried to portray him as charismatic enough that he could very well still trick somebody despite how sketchy he is.

Anyways, thanks again for the review! Also, I love my wife Selphie.
>>
What happens when a woman is in the middle of a Pokémon battle and gets her period?
>>
>>59517948
Erika/Sabrina or no balls. Even better have Erika groom a younger female trainer like Green but don't present it like Erika is a groomer, put all the responsibility on the younger girl to make it 'her fault.'
>>
>>59519424
Ursaluna hunt her down and attack her. Bonus points to any writefag who writes a Legends Arceus fic where the Ursaluna keeps sniffing out women on their period.
>>
i had an interesting idea for a guy- a guy who goes around catching interesting or exotic pokemon for clients who he then trades to them. interesting being like, the 1% encounter wild dodrio in pokemon yellow or a yanma outside of goldenrod city or an underleveled evolved pokemon. not even necessarily like shiny legendaries or something huge just the weird little encounters that no one really thinks about
>>
>>59519433
I'm stealing this to make Absolblogs Canon to my fic
>>
File: J_anime.png (392 KB, 640x603)
392 KB PNG
>>59519433
so just J?
>>
>>59519437
>Absol tries to warn town of impending disaster
>Rare (Pokemon) Hunter captures it
>Goes to town to sell it
>Disaster ensues, destroying most of the town
>>
>>59519437
lol
>>
>>59519443
similar but not evil
>>
>>59519433
River Monsters + the for hire part
>>
>>59519452
yeah maybe that's a good angle, he's a jeremy wade type older guy who's already had his fun being the best trainer he cane be, now he's just in it for the fun of catching stuff
>>
>>59519433
>>59519443
Minor spoiler for IMO There's a reason Brock's wife Jay just happened to possess a shiny Kleavor
>>
>>59519459
Fake and gay.
>>
>>59519459
The best way to end a crime streak is to just domesticate and impregnate the criminal so much they can't do crime anymore
5D chess right there.
>>
>>59519466
Brock was the one who was impregnated.
>>
>>59519466
Oh if anybody is whipped there it's Brock. Besides that, this version isn't evil she's almost exactly what anon described, a mercenary Pokemon catcher that tracks down oddities of the Pokemon world and trades them, usually with a generous finder's fee attached. She just has more scruples how and when she hunts.
>>
>>59519471
>>59519476
I guess I will have to write out my Zinnia fantasies another way.
>>
File: 1761509439600.png (2.73 MB, 1231x1389)
2.73 MB PNG
>>59519476
>whipped
It's hard to forget you're a woman sometimes but when the connotation of "I want to fuck an evil woman pregnant and have all the children with her" translates into her being whipped it's kind of obvious.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zr8j_u25Jro
>>
>>59519494
I mean anon the word domesticated was used, I don't think I really took the connotations that far out. I was just saying the resident simpgod isn't domesticating anybody.
>>
>>59519515
True, Brock is 100-percent the abused not the abuser. He seems like someone a strong woman could walk all over.
It's fairly obvious that Oberon is controlling him through his wife.
>>
>>59519466
Pretty sure SI-lver tormented Domino to the point she begged on her knees to be spared while crying, he then gaslighted her into being his secretary
>>
>>59519544
It's been years but I'm pretty sure she didn't use Pokémon but martial arts iirc, so even that wasn't enough to play the ESCALATION game with SI-LVER?
>>
>>59519544
>Makes her his secretary
>Doesn't breed the shit out of her
What's the point of having a secretary then?
>>
>>59519773
she isn't a blown out hag so the author hasn't turned her into a love interest
>>
File: architect delia.png (1.21 MB, 1483x2038)
1.21 MB PNG
>>59519779
Mmmm... blown out hag love interests...
>>
>>59519433
There's a similar fic called The Dragon King's Conquest but he does it for money and sells the pokemon to Team Rocket
>>
>>59519815
Hey, hey, I’m supposed to be the only architect in this thread!
>>
>>59519815
Cute tummy.
>>
>>59519849
I wonder why he added the whole horse thing
unnecessary if you ask me
>>
What's this I hear about Wattpad users migrating to AO3? What even happened?
>>
>>59520028
Can't write smut anymore
>>
>>59520154
So they're going to a place that allows it to complain about it?
>>
>>59520215
Well they're underaged, so yes.
>>
>>59520355
There's an irony of the underaged complaining about a lack of restrictions before proceeding to ignore every existing one.
>>
I'm trying to write a brushing the pokemon's teeth scene and no matter how I rewrite it it keeps coming across as somewhat fetishy.
>>
>>59520403
Don't worry, brushing someone elses' teeth is hot, but who knows? I had a similar problem recently but luckily I was able to tone down the rapey-ness of a scene.
>>
>>59520403
Lean all the way into instead. Make it real uncomfortable for everyone involved. Then never even hint at anything lewd for the rest of the fic.
>>
>>59518922
I'm definitely curious to see more with Charizard. Always had a soft spot for the living weapon trope.
>>59519381
Didn't really notice the gen 1 thing, that's neat. Hitmonchan's moveset makes sense, I'm just being a schizo contrarian I think.
>>59519419
Look, you can study prose writing and shit, but actually learning grammar rules is mostly for academics. Just reading aloud and adding punctuation when you naturally pause within a sentence is generally good enough. Same deal for word choice. If it sounds bad when you say it, or doesn't flow properly, just change it. Read aloud, always, even if people give you weird looks on the bus.
Also, I don't really remember it being a problem in Pokenormal or towards the back half of Crystal Light, so you've probably gotten naturally better at it anyway.
>So its definitely a flaw with my writing that I for the most part just try to not think about for now
Should add some commas to this one tho :P

>>59518992
Might as well chime in on this. I've been trying to do the specific feedback thing a bit more, since I know a lot of authors are starved for any sort of meaningful outside input. Still, even writing reviews is a form of writing. I worry that I'm misremembering basic facts, giving too-vague suggestions, misidentifying character traits and so on. It's a hell of a lot easier (and less vulnerable) to just say "this is shit" or even "nice, I like this" than opening yourself up to meaningful criticism in turn. Not that I really think anyone is taking random 4chan reviews seriously enough to make some takedown essay or some shit, but it still hurts to realize when I've been wrong or lazy.
>>
File: Pokemon-school.jpg (157 KB, 1600x900)
157 KB JPG
>"I can't go on a journey because it's too expensive and I don't have a sponsorship"
What if there were trainer loans the League could give you, so you could be in debt for half your life?
>>
File: rawdogging, get it.png (4 KB, 345x401)
4 KB PNG
>>59520514
>mfw he's not rawdogging it
ngmi
>>
>>59520514
you get money by winning battles, so being poor is literally skill issue
>>
>>59520516
Eevee line are felines and I'm dying on this hill
>>
>>59520621
Then die, because they're cat dog bunnies.
>>
>>59520621
Eevee are eevee. That's like calling a bike a car because bikes have wheels and sometimes also have horns and engines.
>>
>>59520454
>Still, even writing reviews is a form of writing. I worry that I'm misremembering basic facts, giving too-vague suggestions, misidentifying character traits and so on.
Honestly, getting things confused is actually good feedback for a writer to receive. If someone who's clearly invested in the story is having a hard time keeping details straight, maybe the writer needs to throw readers a bone as a refresher more often, especially if it involves a sprawling cast and a deep world with lots of details to get invested in. As writers it's really hard to get out of our own heads and get in the mind of a reader seeing this thing for the first time that the writer's been replaying in their head ad nauseum for weeks/months/longer.

I also usually keep notes a la CCbro as I'm reading along if I'm going to drop a comment for something. If the writer's setting things up a certain way and the reader thinks they've sniffed it out and the expectation gets subverted (in a non-retarded way mind you), it's really cool to see that genuine reaction from both sides.
>>
>>59520656
Yeah but Growlithe is the Puppy Pokémon and Sandshrew is the Mouse Pokemon so there are clearly suborders in the Pokémon species
>>
>>59520699
Eevee and its evolutions are their own suborder, Evoformia
>>
>>59520621
Does that mean they can give you toxoplasmosis?
>>
>>59520621
They're felanines
>>
>write 1000 words for the climax of the first arc
>immediately move all of it to the cut content section
YUP... another hard day of making absolutely no progress.
>>
>>59520976
Wrong, you're writing exp increased. Keep cultivating in and soon your writer aura will let you punch harder.
>>
File: Gs9VetuXoAAxZYW.jpg (53 KB, 543x304)
53 KB JPG
Reminder that Superman has aura too so you can do more than punching harder
>>
>>59521021
Just be careful, once you become too powerful your keystrokes will destroy the keyboard. The only way to stop your keyboard's imminent destruction is to get a gay keyboard that has Fairy Type Aura.
>>
File: thing, Japan.jpg (891 KB, 2856x2152)
891 KB JPG
>>59515369
what pokefic reads and feels very Japanese?
>>
>>59521145
Fics on jp sites.
30 years worth of fics that may be cringe or kino. I wonder what's their BoC.
>>
That one elf isekai story is updating again.
>>
File: future pokeballs.png (43 KB, 544x205)
43 KB PNG
Is the pokeball design complete, perfect and timeless? Or will there be future versions with drastic changes?

Will those versions also stick with the current pokeball geometry (double hemisphere), or are there other designs of superior quality?
>>
>>59521307
Any elf in Pokémon story? I think they would fit since the setting is supposed to be a balance between nature and urbanization
>>
Are there any cyberpunk fics anyone can recommend? I mean the genre in general but the IP Cyberpunk is fine as well, really I just want something cyber publish to chew on.
Also SELLOUTSFAG, reference the Pokestars studio movie Timegate Traveler in your next chapter since your doing the creepy fetish thing with the pokeballs anyway. I really didn't expect Sellouts to become a TF fic but I'm okay with it. I guess that's why it was rated E for smut, either way I'm excited for what comes next.
>>
>>59521325
It needs 5G internet
>>
>>59521334
Gardevoir and Gallade are elves in Pokemon form already
>>
>>59521325
Streaming Ball, it's not even a PokeBall but a mini-PC that stores the Pokemon on the Storage System automatically
>>
>>59521362
>you will own nothing, not even your Pokemon
>>
>>59520403
>>59520439
This is the only way to do it.
>>
>>59520403
hygiene is important
>>
>>59521362
That seems sensible as a development honestly, rather than a Ball for every mon you have a single capturing tool that directly sends them to the digital storage and can recall them as desired. That could also shake up the competitive scene since you could call on your entire Pokemon collection for any given battle.
>>
>>59521445
Sounds like something the Rotom conspiracy from Pokenormal would come up with so they can get a hold of people's pokemon. Also something Oberon or another conspiracy-type villain would do.
>>
>>59521334
I’m sure there are some LoTR crossovers. There has to be.
>>
>>59521339
Death and Taxes on SB
SI (you can ignore this, it doesn't matter) is a tax accountant in Night City. Gets fired and becomes the tax accountant for the Animals

Cyberpunk: Another Daybreak
Edgerunner and Kamen Rider 01 crossover
David becomes KR Ichigata and fights Ark while supported by an isekai'd Hiden Intelligence.
Personally not a fan of the expies though

Those are the two that come to mind.
>>
>>59521334
There is an elf kingdom in Crystal Light.
>>
Do pokemon really JOB to cavities?
>>
>>59521736
Not trainer ones, they put flouride in their kibble
>>
>>59521768
Doesn't work, you need extensive mouth-to-mouth saliva exchange between pokemon and trainer. You need at least five minutes of making out per Pokemon to ensure healthy teeth.
>>
>>59521736
Any HP restoring berry also heals tooth decay.
>>
>>59520403
Pokemonogatari?
>>
>>59521855
You eat food to prevent tooth decay?
>>
>>59521982
In a world without high fructose corn syrup...
>>
File: IMG_9451.png (1.6 MB, 828x1792)
1.6 MB PNG
Idk who this is but I’ll take it.
>>
>>59522010
I'm pretty sure that's a schizobot Pofag, somebots just try to weird you out.
>>
>>59522023
Fair. It makes more sense. Just hilariously timed that this was directly before a sex scene
>>
>sex
I sleep
>>
>rape
I WAKE
>>
>>59522023
Did some quick sleuthing, it shares the name of an actual writer on the site and looks like how they comment.
So either it's an elaborate bot made to mimic how one specific user talks or it's just the writer using the same name under a guest comment.
>>
>>59522064
>it shares the name of an actual writer on the site and looks like how they comment.
Yeah bots do that too. I've run into bots using the names of authors and copying their commenting style.
And non-author commentors as well. I have no idea who's wasting money on these bots but it's stupid.
>>
>>59522068
Wack
>>
What DO the Japanese side of the fandom read? Is their top fic a litrpg slowlife haremfic?
>>
>>59522118
>top fic a litrpg slowlife haremfic?
That's already oficial material bro, btw chinks are obssessed with
>Bocchi
>Yukino
>Bang Dream
And funnily enough JJK, every fic that isn't a Douluo Dalu has them, also their MC is always the strongest thanks to the system giving them the strongest cheat without training, are obssessed with harems and sex and their MCs are psychos
>>
>>59522010
"askjbw4ktbj" holy hell why can't people comment normally
>>
>>59522145
>and their MCs are psychos
you'd turn into a psycho too if you lived in ancient china but with superpowers
>>
>>59522194
In the chinese fanfics I've read they're psychos in current japan
>>
>>59522209
The Japanese deserve it!
Short Emperor 短い皇帝 Bataan death march バターン死の行進 Jungun ianfu ジュガンイアンフ unit 731 ユニット731 Kanto Massacre 関東大虐殺 Hiroshima Atomic Bombing 広島原爆 6 August 1945 1945年8月6日 USS Missouri USSミズーリ Postdam Conference ポツダム会議 Manchurian Strategic Offensive 満州戦略攻勢 Operation Downfall オペレーションの没落 Kuril Island クリル列島 Article 9 第9条 American puppet アメリカの人形 High suicide rate 高い自殺率 Low birth rate 低出生率 Tokaimura nuclear accident 東海村原発事故 Fukushima nuclear accident 福島原発事故 High sexual harassment 高いセクハラ Overworking until dead 死ぬまで働き過ぎ Lost decade 失われた十年 Logan Paul ローガン・ポール Aokigahara 青木ヶ原
>>
File: 1757474976739094.png (203 KB, 814x1907)
203 KB PNG
>>59522118
>>59521156
Top 6 Pokemon fics on Syosetu, sorted by most favs
>>
>>59522298
>Memeta knowledge
>Humblebrag
>Basically Bocchi
Huh, somehow I expected that now where's the systemshit
>Last one
Lmao, that one sounds like almost every "soldier dragon god war king emperor returns to the city" that chinks love
Hahaha
>>
>>59522298
>reincarnation redslop
>humiliation ritual
>isekai
>edgeslop misunderstandings
>silly fun fic
>redslop
They're literally us.
>>
>>59522324
>>humiliation ritual
Truly, no matter the place there will always be cuck obssessed faggots
>>
>>59522322
>systemshit
Didn't find any in the first five pages
>>
>>59522387
Weird given how common that shit is used in isekai
>>
>>59522404
Well, I didn't look through every single fic and just judged it by its title and summary. But given there weren't any titles specifically like "I was given the skill analysis", I just assumed there wasn't any of that stuff going on.
A lot of people pretending to be streamers though.

The status window and other similar tropes aren't common in eng pokemon fics either. It's like people collectively agreed that seeing pokemon through numbers just invites headaches.
No one wants to comment or read something like:
>252 SpA Tera Water Kyogre Water Spout (150 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Eviolite Fomantis in Rain: 232-274 (81.6 - 96.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
>>
>>59521736
yeah
>>
>>59515369
How would a bank robbery work in the Pokémon world? Which Pokémon would the robbers use? What Pokémon are used as security guards?
>>
>>59522739
Security? I thought everyone just hoped a 10 year old child gets their stuff back?
>>
>>59522739
High trust society, the robber just walks in and asks nicely for the money, then the police catches him and they ask nicely for the money back.
The robber then gets off the hook with a sorry
>>
File: hqdefault.jpg (37 KB, 480x360)
37 KB JPG
>>59522758
Police should pull up weapons just in case of a escalation situation occurrs
>>
File: FEQpt1bWQAkrmIo.jpg (35 KB, 635x635)
35 KB JPG
if you don't get drunk along with your Pokemon, then you aren't real partners
>>
>>59522837
The only drugs you and your pokemon should be abusing are the drugs called training, battle, and victory.
>>
>>59522145
>>Bang Dream
How would Viola make Arale lose her League license?
>>
>>59522298
>meta knowledge edgeslop
>Humiliation ritual humble brag
>Generic reincernation waifu fic
>Bocchi phofic
>phofic
>More Red.
As expected,
>>
>>59522404
Is there all that much pokemon systemslop?
Most I can think of are a couple stories with the summary screen from the games
>>
>>59522840
what about aura cultivation pills (rare candies) are those okay
>>
File: EmcCPhLXMAItk2s.jpg (793 KB, 1075x1075)
793 KB JPG
>Gym Leader Fraud: Indigo Plateau
My sleep has been fucked for the past week, so I've not been writing as much as I should have. Also my document says 40k words but AO3 only says 39k, what the hell is up with that? Am I being taxed of my story or something?
Lance (obviously) gets an appearance next chapter, despite its many faults, I actually really like SI-lver's depiction of him. I don't know how much he'll show up in the fic, but he'll be there.
https://archiveofourown.org/works/88650066/chapters/242231976
>>
>>59523153
no pills, only Energy Roots
>>
>>59523181
How is Lance in SI-lver, I haven't read it and I don't want to because it's ridiculously too long.
>>
>>59523184
I'd say competent and trying his best, with a strong sense of justice and the balls to commit to it. Which honestly sounds like most depictions of Lance which aren't EVIL Lance stories.
>>
>>59523190
>which aren't EVIL Lance stories
People actually use pokespe Lance?
>>
>>59523184
A total pushover that says nothing when Silver calls him Flying Master
>>
>>59523184
an actually respectful rendition beyond the mary sue protagonist halo
>>
File: fczds1rand7g1.jpg (201 KB, 1280x2160)
201 KB JPG
No matter how edgy and deep and cool tries SI-LVER, he will always be known as the cucked son lmao
>>
>>59523283
Yes, but the uncuckec son is a Aunt Vi rape victim. Although if you follow the power scaling logic then Silver is even weaker and more rape-weak than Corbeau.
>>
>>59523283
he's talking about Mr. Fuji here btw
>>
File: 17395775.png (1.17 MB, 1280x906)
1.17 MB PNG
>>59522423
I think you've got it right. Pokemon is one of the few fandoms that can neatly be divided between people who care about number shit like that, and people who don't. And the people who DO care about it can easily go experience the real deal with showdown or champions or whatever. They don't need to read fanfiction for it because they can theory craft actual teams.

Meanwhile the people who are more likely to be into fanfiction also more likely to hate it when pokemon are reduced to numbers. They get enough of that shit in the fandom already so they probably don't want it in their fanfiction. The appeal of pokemon for a lot of people are the magical world and pokemon being treated like real creatures. So reducing them to numbers becomes antithetical to the appeal.
>>
>>59522882
>>Bocchi phofic
I don't get this. I watched some of Bocchi, but I don't understand the implications here.
>>
>>59523283
It's Koga.
He's a poison type master, boss of a ninja clan, and is much more likely to know about the mythology of surrounding regions due to being a practitioner of an old traditional art.
>>
>>59523348
>Bocchi
As in it's about a powerful or skilled person who's anxious, beat down, or humiliated learning to come out of their shell. Basically the fantasy of not being a NEET.
>PHO
A message board from WORM and WARD. Basically if a fic is in a message or bulletin board style, which it's tagged as.
>>
>>59523363
Ah, I see. So it's like me in these threads.
>>
File: 1781961368015380.png (130 KB, 1303x1326)
130 KB PNG
>>59523363
There is almost no difference between this, a 掲示板形式 bulletin board format, and a script fic.
But then again, PHO fic/chapters are just scripts with a fancier dressing.
>>
>>59523363
I loathe chatfics with all my might
>>
>>59523348
WEAKEST but STRONGEST or in simple terms some neet is the best of the best in their field and everyone is in awe so now they will stop being shy introverted neets.

They're also super cute/handsome/beautiful
>>
>>59523420
Ah. It's like that old stereotype of the nerdy girl who gets the boy at prom once she takes off the glasses.
>>
>>59523283
Being fatherless makes you stronger, just read shonen manga for proof
>>
>>59523444
Meanwhile, being motherless turns you into a psychopath
>>
>>59523509
So when's Kuzey popping off?
>>
Chapter 63 of Prince of Po Town is up for those who partake and like a Ceruledge fight.

https://archiveofourown.org/works/66210784/chapters/242282641
>>
File: mdgl12o60b271.jpg (222 KB, 737x1200)
222 KB JPG
Every time I read a fic and MC says they have to train hard to be the strongest or whatever, I get reminded of pic related
>>
>>59523746
>Enjoys himself
>And has the strongest genes
It's always hilarous, also a trainer can't train with their Pokémon because that would be ESCALATION
>>
>>59523779
Bruno has been fighting his team since the 90s
>>
>>59515396
luv to give them an infl fetish.
>>
File: 1787342406861491.png (2.44 MB, 2679x1392)
2.44 MB PNG
What's your explanation for the military being absent when terror organizations / mega-corporations and legendary monsters nearly cause the end of the world every three years?

Did the pokéworld turn turbopacifist after a no-further-elaborated and memory-holed war took place?

Or are governments absolutely toothless and corrupted to the point of criminals running the show?
>>
>>59523807
Hack writing. I’m down with protags getting the big victory against the evil team leader, just they should be part of some sort of volunteer militia or something of that sort.
>>
>>59523807
They can't do shit because of bureaucracy and diplomatic reasons
>>
>>59523807
There is no explanation. Everyone should ignore that retarded part of canon entirely.
>>
>>59523807
They have even bigger fish to fry
>>
File: 55881970_p23.jpg (1.58 MB, 1110x1553)
1.58 MB JPG
>>59523779
if there's escalation in my way, I'll smash it down!
>>
>>59523798
Traveler does this and nobody complains about it
>>
>>59523850
Traveler is way too fucking long, who trains like that?
>>
File: G8eoEk6bMAA5LSz.jpg (226 KB, 800x1200)
226 KB JPG
>>59523807
They're busy fighting and dying to keep back the endless hordes of wild pokemon outside the known world
>>
>>59523807
In my world there's no standing military in MOST regions, though some very remote or estranged ones have armed forces either to keep their populace in checks or repel threats from wild Pokemon. Instead most regions have pooled their collective strength into the International Police, which is very well-funded but also heavily regulated to prevent favoritism to one group or another. Every region that accepts its jurisdiction is expected to supply a certain amount of volunteers, and acknowledge their authority over local police activity.

Their strength has actually swelled over recent years specifically caused by the activity of criminal organizations like Team Rocket, Flare, etc. and are meant to curb such groups as they form.
>>
>>59523807
The captain general is a really old dude who's extremely old and whenever he decides to act, the threat has already passed
>>
>>59523807
garchomp flying is so retarded

>military being absent
They're fighting super underground dwarf wars with mining kits because Lt. Surge, the Lightning American, can't go underground due to his extreme Electric type energy aura.
>>
>>59524080
The garchomp ate a balloon
>>
>>59523807
Surge is actually an Isekaijin from real life americs.
>>
>>59524082
does rough skin not apply to it's innards as well or do only sand veil garchomp learn how to fly
>>
I'm coming up with a scene for much later from the perspective of what it's like when a pokemon uses Transform to turn into Arceus.
>>
>>59524170
>. . . Why do I suddenly want human dick so much?
>>
>>59524170
>wait a second, Arceus isn't a creator god, they're just opening portals and pulling things from them!
>>
>>59524170
By becoming Arceus, they lose their individuality and become merged with the deity, and immediately abandon their trainer and all ties to their previous life. Some strong willed pokemon may be able to mantain a transformation into Arceus for very short periods of time, capable of utilizing only a simple fraction of the deity's true abilities before succumbing to their own power.
>>
File: 1779474794226012.png (189 KB, 554x554)
189 KB PNG
>>59523984
Oh boy, I can't wait for him to job when he does show up in time
>>
I have a question for the thread
>What's your favorite pokemon movie
>What would you change to improve it
Feel free to answer least favorite too, but even the best pokemon movie is basically an extended episode.

For me
>Mystery of the Unown
>Keep the parents dead. That weird "oh actually they're still alive" was a bizarre choice given what the story actually was
>>
>>59524231
That's actually part of the angle I'm going with.
It's like becoming infinity, but upon self reflection you see that you are no more than a drop of oil floating on top of the ocean, and it is only by the grace of the waves that you haven't dissipated yet.
>>
File: 1000108578.png (306 KB, 284x585)
306 KB PNG
So where are we supposed to store our aura? Must of us won't be part of ancient psychic family if reincarnated so we must have a back up plan
>I will just use my Pokémon
You will die to ESCALATION
>>
>>59524391
Aura is a meme made up by Lucario to trick gullible humans into giving them food for fake guidance.
>>
File: 1757655323895329.png (150 KB, 430x438)
150 KB PNG
>>59524391
Abra cells
>>
>>59524391
Your core, obviously.
>>
>>59523807
Military and special forces take time to operate. Its all about making sure they have all the intel for a flawless operation. But the protagonists happen to be at the right place at the right time. Most of the villain's keep their crimes low scale enough that they fly under the radar for major government intervention and then jump to major crisis.
>>
bump limit reached, new thread
>>59524718
>>
>>59523821
Could be one reason. People coming to the conclusion that manmade weapons were too cruel to use after what went down in that one particular war, deciding to only use pokemon to handle conflicts. Although they didn't dispose of all the tech and military structures, as they could still be used as a last resort for a future threat (thinking of how nukes in DUNE are still a thing - despite all factions considering their use a horrible crime - in case something alien might threaten mankind (even though alien basically don't exist in their lore)).

>>59523830
Then you might also ignore the ugly part about weaponized Infinity Energy posing a potential and serious proliferation threat (picrel).

>>59523831
>>59523895
What's a bigger existential threat than having one's universe wiped out? Maybe the Reds, considering no region so far is set in the Eastern Bloc?

>>59523919
It's possible there's a global world government which employs the IP to keep criminal activities in check, parallel to regional police forces. Considering the "National Pokédex" and how regions based on national states like Kalos, Galar and Paldea are named regions, not nations, implying there's a bigger unifying structure in place ("United States of Europe"?)
>Flare
This case however shows that the IP is either weak, incompetent or hindered by corruption. Flare is repeatedly shown to officially perform hostile acts, like raiding the Pokéball factory with their agents in action. The PokéSpe version even outright states a significant amount of the Kalosian population is aware of Flare's cause and even supports them. There's no other way to explain how a megacorpo can plan and perform actions leading to genocide other than the government being corrupt or large parts of the population being implicit, which in turns prevents armed forces to engage the issues.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.