[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/vp/ - Pokémon

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1000001282.jpg (18 KB, 256x192)
18 KB JPG
>>
>>59735902
>Gimmicks are novel tricks, devices, or features used to attract attention, publicity, or sales, often with little real or lasting value
It’s the textbook definition of a gimmick
>>
>>59735907
I literally do not recall anyone actually ever talking about these. The teraleak also confirms initial plans to keep these long term, only being scrapped due to technical limitations. Mega Evolution was 'scrapped' in Gen 8 because they didn't want it to overshadow Dynamax and only came back due to fans popularity.
>>
>>59735932
Correct, Triple Battles are a gimmick.
>>
>>59735907
>Gimmicks are novel tricks, devices, or features used to attract attention, publicity, or sales, often with little real or lasting value
It's not really novel. If it was used to attract attention it'd be far bigger and would've received more advertising. It was intended as a series staple but testing during early SM made it seem implausible.
>>
>>59735902
I didn't even know triple battles were a thing. I probably would've known if it was actually advertised and shoved down my face like Mega Evolution or Dynamax. Where's the mandatory triple battle? Mandatory rotation battle? You can argue the same for inverse battles but no one ever brings that up, probably because only one guy does it.
>>
>>59735938
>explains how they aren't a gimmick
>Hurr durr they totally are gimmick
>>
>>59735941
>It's not really novel
How do I do Triple Battles in gen 4?

>If it was used to attract attention it'd be far bigger and would've received more advertising
It being a failed flop (like many of the things introduced in gen 5) doesn’t make it not a gimmick.

>It was intended as a series staple until it wasn’t
It’s a gimmick, yes.
>>
>>59735955
>How do I do Triple Battles in gen 4?
They most likely hadn't thought of it yet

>It being a failed flop (like many of the things introduced in gen 5) doesn’t make it not a gimmick.
It would've been advertised and we would've had multiple mandatory triple and rotation battles. Plus people actually liked them back then and thought it was cool, though most of the popularity has gone down.

>It’s a gimmick, yes.
It was never intended as such. In fact Mega Evolution isn't technically a gimmick because it wasn't intended as such. The first gimmick is technically Z-moves, because those were intended to be replaced one generation later.
>>
>>59735971
>They most likely hadn't thought of it yet
So it’s novel, and therefore a gimmick.

>It would've been advertised
You being too underaged to see the advertising doesn’t mean that it wasn’t advertised.

>It was never intended as such
And yet it didn’t have lasting value, and therefore, is a gimmick.
>>
File: 1562700217422.png (6 KB, 375x385)
6 KB PNG
>>59735902
I really liked Rotation battles
>>
>>59735975
>So it’s novel, and therefore a gimmick.
I guess that means auto renewing repels, battle facilities, following Pokémon and overworld encounters are gimmicks then

>You being too underaged to see the advertising doesn’t mean that it wasn’t advertised.
I was 15 when BW came out, and I was hyped for it, It was literally shown once in a magazine and briefly shown in a trailer. That's it. Megas, Z-moves etc were shown in every single trailer since the initial reveal.

>And yet it didn’t have lasting value, and therefore, is a gimmick.
Doesn't make something a gimmick. There has to be intent. Otherwise most features from most games are technically gimmicks because they have yet to return.
>>
>>59736068
>I guess that means [things that had lasting value] are gimmicks
Nope

>I was underaged when BW came out
We know

>Doesn't make something a gimmick
>>59735907
>>
>>59736073
>Nope
Most of those things only lasted for a couple generations before the direction of the series changed. Kinda like a gimmick.

>We know
I was 15. I'd remember if this shit happened. I'm now married with two kids, trying for a third.

>>59735907
False.
>>
>>59735902
The wonder launcher is right there.
>>
People treat Triple and Rotation Battles as "gimmicks" mostly in hindsight, not because they were designed as cheap tricks.

In Generation 5 (Pokémon Black & White), they were intended to be permanent evolutions of Double Battles—much like how Double Battles became a staple in Generation 3—rather than temporary novelties.
>>
>>59736106
>Most of those things only lasted for a couple generations
Auto renewing repels still exist because it has lasting value
Battle facilities still exist because they have lasting value
Following Pokemon still exist because they have lasting value
Overworld encounters still exist because they have lasting value

>I was 15
Yes, you were underaged, we know

>>59735907
True
>>
>>59736123
People treat Mega Evolutions and Z-moves as "gimmicks" mostly in hindsight, not because they were designed as cheap tricks.

In Generation 6 (Pokémon X & Y), they were intended to be permanent evolutions of evolutions—much like how evolutions became a staple in Generation 1—rather than temporary novelties.
>>
>>59736156
Slightly better ragebait than normal. I give it a 3/10, champ.
>>
>>59736156
Triple battles and Rotation battles have lasting value as well. They're fun and add extra layers of strategy. People loved them when we had them. The only main problem was the fact that battles could take awhile. I would not be surprised if they (and Inverse battles) are eventually brought back in Champions.
>>
>>59736156
>Yes, you were underaged, we know
And I was likely older than you. Heck, I'm older than most of the Pokémon community. I grew up with Gen 1 and Gen 2. I was only a baby when they came out, but I sure as hell played them.
>>
>>59736192
>Triple battles and Rotation battles have lasting value as well
Cool, so how do I do them in Gen 7+?

>They're fun and add extra layers of strategy
"Doubles except you auto lose if you lost the coin flip of putting your Pokemon on the wrong side of the field" isn't fun
"Singles except switching doesn't cost anything so every turn is pure coin flips" isn't fun

>People loved them when we had them
No they didn't, the ranked ladders for them were fucking dead lmao
>>
>>59735902
This is just a bog-standard JRPG fight.
>>
>>59736200
>Cool, so how do I do them in Gen 7+?
They were cut for causing performance issues.

>"Doubles except you auto lose if you lost the coin flip of putting your Pokemon on the wrong side of the field" isn't fun
>"Singles except switching doesn't cost anything so every turn is pure coin flips" isn't fun
Looks like someone has never played either format. It's nothing like that.

>No they didn't, the ranked ladders for them were fucking dead lmao
They fucking loved them. They were forgotten about by the time Gen 7 rolled around due to being cut and having new formats to play with. You'd know this if you weren't underage.
>>
>>59736224
>They were cut for causing performance issues.
So why weren’t they added back in Gen 8? Could it be that they were gimmicks that didn’t have lasting value?

>It's nothing like that
It’s plenty like that

>They fucking loved them
Then why were the ladders dead?
>>
>>59736232
>So why weren’t they added back in Gen 8? Could it be that they were gimmicks that didn’t have lasting value?
Didn't think of it I'm assuming. I guess with dynamax it'd be difficult to implement. Gen 8 lagged a bit when there was one dynamaxed Pokémon on screen, and actually noticably when there's two, so I guess they didn't wanna risk it. By then I'd assume they forgot about it.

>It’s plenty like that
It's not though. Competetive triple battles relied heavily on a handful of moves that could hit regardless of placement, as well as the usual shenanigans you'd expect from doubles. Rotation was somewhat less popular, but it was basically just singles but with 6v6.

>Then why were the ladders dead?
They weren't. Nowadays they are, but back then triples was quite popular. Rotation not so much.
>>
>>59735932
>initial plans to keep these long term
As they should have, they should have been standard features of Pokémon games going forward.
>only being scrapped due to technical limitations
That's a stupid excuse for them to have. Up until gen 9, the Pokémon main games had battles take place in battle backgrounds like many other RPGs. Because of that, they can adjust every battle animation and battle background to each other.
>>
3v3 is cooler than Doubles.
Attacks like Wide Guard and Ally Switch were built around the idea of using 3 mons on a larger field.
Weather War was insane because you have 1 weather setting mon + 2 mons taking advantage of it at once.
>>
stop feeding the troll
>>
>>59736268
>Didn't think of it I'm assuming
Yes, because it was a gimmick, that had no real or lasting value

>It's not though
It is though

>Competetive triple battles relied heavily on a handful of moves that could hit regardless of placement
It also relied heavily on all the usual moves that don't hit regardless of placement, making it just a more coin flippy doubles.

>Rotation was somewhat less popular, but it was basically just singles but with 6v6
It's singles except switching is completely broken.

>They weren't
They were though.
>>
>>59736366
Okay champ, doubling down on the ragebait brings it down to a 2/10. When trolling you gotta learn when to quit.
>>
>>59735902
No, it's just bad game design.
>>
>>59735902
it's as much a gimmick as double battles
which is why they both only appear a few times, and not all the time.
it's not the intended way to battle, or all battles would be like it
>>
>>59736326
I think the technical limitation is that the performance, as in the games framerate. would be too bad with 6 pokemon on screen at once.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.