[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/vr/ - Retro Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor applications are now open. Apply here!


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1780322855433174.jpg (195 KB, 1024x1008)
195 KB JPG
Could Doom be ported to the Neo Geo?
>>
>>12608091
MVG please go away
>>
666 doalrrinos edishion?
>>
>>12608091
Not PC perfect at all

Doom is very CPU heavy

What made Neo geo great is it's GPU and gigantic rom cartridge

The NEO Geo CPU is pretty underpowered even for an arcade board of 1990,it use the same CPU as the Genesis but overclocked
>>
It was ported to weaker hardware.
>>
>>12608091
Vanilla Neo Geo? No.
Doom requires lots of 32-bit calculations. It was tailor made for 486 CPUs which are far more advanced than the 1970s MC68000 CPU that Neo Geo has.

Additional chip? Probably yes, but in case of these chips, questions like OP make no sense.
>>
File: 1767188081650470.jpg (129 KB, 1241x1240)
129 KB JPG
Could Doom be ported to the SNES?
>>
>>12608125
no, it requires an extra chip to run a still extremely downgraded version
>>
certainly not as-is, idk how you'd even do it.
neo-geo's cpu isn't anything special (12MHz 68k). it also has a pretty boring 64k of main ram and doesn't even have DMA.

what neo-geo has was fuckhuge cartridges (not just in physical size) and a graphics chip that could handle as many sprites as you could want, even backgrounds are just made of sprites

doom doesn't use sprites, it's an entirely software-rendered engine, as it is it'd run like a slideshow, and that's assuming you can even run it with so little work ram (can't really compare memory requirements directly since PC games practically needed levels loaded into memory, which cartridge games don't need to do, still doom has a lot more variables than your typical arcade game)
>>
probably one of those meme ports that arent even ports they just look like doom
>>
>>12608125
not a port
>>
>>12608095
/thread
>>
Doesn't Neo Turf Masters use some sort of pseudo-3D rendering?
>>
>>12608091
It could be ported to neogeo but we're on a subject initiated by MVG, who is a bit of a dullard and a wanker. Ideally what you want to do is lots of cheating by rendering various surfaces as tilemaps. since neogeo can have everything as a sprite, you can separate out the surfaces (walls, floor, ceiling etc). to repeat as often as you like and use sprite scaling to change the perspective as you walk. same thing applied to walls, doors and other 3d objects. you only need part of the animation for a 360 degree rotation. the rest you can cheat using animations, sprite scaling and line scrolling. The second solution is to have a custom DSP on the cart that draws 3d objects and can spit out neogeo tiles (superfx like)
>>
>>12608091
>Could zoom be ported to the Neo /v/?
Happened long ago, my silly little child.
>>
>>12608095
Naur
>>
File: Neo-Geo_Pocket_Color.jpg (3.38 MB, 4608x3456)
3.38 MB JPG
Could Doom be ported to the Neo Geo Pocket Color?
>>
>>12608386
Sure, Doom RPG
>>
Could Doom be ported to Doom?
>>
File: 1780335598699.png (2.94 MB, 2178x1594)
2.94 MB PNG
>>12608387
If I hack into the Matrix and spawn a General Motors Geo for Thomas Anderson, could Doom be ported to Neo's Geo?
>>
>>12608390
>>
>>12608395
heh
>>
>>12608390
yes, someone has already done that
https://youtu.be/c6hnQ1RKhbo
>>
>>12608487
i like how MVG calls doom's code "elegant", while doom hackers call it a mess
>>
>>12608091
>Could X be Y to Z?

Tranny Smith gotta Tranny Smith.
>>
>>12608091
Yes. The same way it was ported to the SNES: via an enhancement chip in the cartridge.
>>
>>12608542
also known as "no"
>>
>>12608582
but also yes
>>
Now we has not even l and r trickers and broughted the gaem for hundreds of shekels?
>>
>>12608126
>no, it requires an extra chip
Many SNES games (and not just this one) used enhancement chips. They're still SNES games regardless.

Maybe someone with more technical knowledge than I do could explain why I'm wrong, but seeing that the Neo Geo is also a cartridge based system I don't see why similar enhancement chips couldn't be put into the cartridges to make DOOM work on that system also.

But even if it can't for some sort of reason, the stock Neo Geo hardware is much more powerful than a stock SNES. Maybe not as powerful as an SNES with enhancement chips, but considering that watered down ports of DOOM have been made to run on graphic calculators and printer controllers and things like that, I see no reason the Neo Geo even without enhancement chips couldn't be made to run some really cut down version of it.
>>
File: 2uz2aqvatbza1.png (2.67 MB, 2048x1728)
2.67 MB PNG
>>12608091
>Could Doom be ported to the Neo Geo?
Could Doom be ported to a Tiger LCD handheld?
>>
>>12608768
Could Doom be ported to a live tiger?
>>
You could probably program a pseudo-3d FPS engine tailored to the Neo Geo’s capabilities and then adapt Doom’s assets to fit in it, but that’s not really Doom anymore.
>>
>>12608763
Historically enhancement chips were quite limited because of the price so they did something like math or scaling. Today people just stuff in a modern general CPU in a cart that does all the heavy lifting. You could literary stream GTA6 to NES. It's not really a NES game at that point.
>but considering that watered down ports of DOOM have been made to run on graphic calculators and printer controllers
Not really, it's a meme. They are Doom in the name only, more like cut down Wolfenstein,
>>
>>12608091
Youtube and gaming are the worst duo ever made
>>
>>12609306
Gaming and social media in general are the worst combination. Remember where you are.
>>
>>12608164
>doom doesnt use sprites
arent all of the enemies sprites?
>>
File: Screenshot_1345.jpg (299 KB, 2560x1350)
299 KB JPG
>>12609346
No.
>>
>>12608395
yes.
>>
>>12608454
could Super Turbo Turkey Puncher 3 be ported to VMU?
>>
can you run doom on /vr/
>>
>>12608091
A cut down version like Dread on Amiga, possibly.
>>
>>12609417
If I amputate the part of Dio Brando's leg between his shin and thigh, could Doom be ported to the Knee o' Dio?
>>
>>12608176
Definitely a port.
>>
>>12609429
Amiga at least has a planar framebuffer (not ideal for Doom, which is designed for a packed a.k.a "chunky" framebuffer). NeoGeo doesn't even have that. It's impossible without an enhancement chip pretending to be C ROM (sprite data).
>>
>>12609574
yea, neo-geo's cpu can't write to video memory at all.
maybe it could do something like what playstation doom did, playstation doom renders the environment much like the pc version, only instead of drawing columns and rows a pixel at a time to a framebuffer, it draws the columns/rows as 1px wide quads for the GTE to render. could potentially do the same with neo-geo sprites... maybe. the resolution would be limited since the neo-geo can only do 96 sprites per scanline, not 320, even with a reduction in resolution it'd be a ton of work for a 12MHz 68000, not only is it nearly 3x slower in clock speed, but the ALUs and memory bus are all 16bit compared to the playstation's 32bit
>>
>>12608117
This is probably the most retarded thing I've seen all day.
>>
>>12608095
This. Hate that washed up faggot.
>>
>>12609574
Neo Geo can scale down sprite and has a ton of fast access graphics data capacity. I'm sure a quirky version of Doom could work, somehow, with a lot of ingenuity.
>>
>>12609437
how many bits?
>>
Could Doom be ported to the FM Towns Marty?
>>
>MVG
fuck off dude
>>
>>12608203
I don't think so:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4f1-7c6WX10
>>
>>12608203
It uses static screens with some scrolling, sprite scalling and warping. The golfer doesn't move at all. There are some pseudo 3D game on Neo Geo, like The Super Spy or Riding Hero, but first one is mostly 2D with sone very awkward 3D level transitions and the other is a very basic Hang-On clone. Neo Geo is a sysytem without any polygonal capabilities, so the only way to simulate depth is to use sprite scaling, which is a big limitation.
>>
has doom ever been faithfully reproduced on a system older than itself? i don't count the snes version since that has a hard requirement on the superfx2, which while i don't know when that chip was made, no game older than 1995 used it.

i think the only time it has was, surprisingly, was the atari jaguar version. the jaguar came out a couple WEEKS before doom did, and it got a pretty decent port. practically it's the same age however and i want to know about older systems.

i'm not sure there is, doom was a high end game, and even something as stupendously high end as neo-geo only a few years prior stands little a chance of running doom as-is
>>
>>12612092
The NEO-GEO is high-end, but its designed for a very different task. Comparing the power of two very different machines, is like trying to compare the power of a car and an elevator. A super-car is very powerful, but if you want to go up, that power is irrelevant.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.