compared to doom, i mean. previously i assumed i was purely a retarded zoomer since doom 1 & 2 never seemed fun regardless of effort. quake (especially given its remaster) is a game that i can sit down and play, forgetting it's 30 years old. has a nicer atmosphere too, melancholic instead of the capeshit power fantasy mood of doom. it's an fps where i feel like i'm on the "defensive" for once. i apologize
>>12943502Because Doom has had a bigger community around it, making maps, mods and keeping alive a game that conserves throughout these many iterations a feeling of simple, challenging and fast-paced gameplay.Quake also has its share of modding and groups that don't let it be forgotten, but a lot of it was built when the game was popular and online multiplayer was thriving, but it died out as newer games appeared and people moved on.With new maps and a second wind from the remaster that came some years ago, I'd say Q1 is not completely dead. True suffering is being a Q2 fan like myself, stuck with that game just because it was your first FPS. It's bland as all hell but I need to walk through those warehouses full of crates at least once a year.
>>12943502Honestly? I think it's because Doom (2) has a better roster of enemies and weapons, which are just generally more fun to play around with. The monsters especially are the stars of the show, and their designs and the sheer variety of enemy types makes possible much more varied gameplay. I also hate to bring up this old cliche chestnut again, but it needs to be said: Doom is bright and visually very sharp and distinct, and Quake is comparatively drab. Doom (2 moreso than 1) also has more up-tempo and generally, for want of a better word, "hyping-up" music, while Quake's soundtrack, while definitely one of its strong points, is more ambient and otherworldly.
>>12943502Doom is more iconic, easier to develop for, and has unique novelty in terms of the binary space partitioning engine compared to quake's low poly aesthetic which is a much larger pool of properties. That said I wouldn't be upset over it. Quake still has a pretty vibrant community(also just received a brand new expansion), it's just not omega popular like doom.
>>12943502Making maps for Quake was a lot more tedious, and most people flocked to the multiplayer of Quake 2 and 3. I think I might be the only person in existence who cares more about the singleplayer of an FPS than the multiplayer.
>>12943701>I think I might be the only person in existence who cares more about the singleplayer of an FPS than the multiplayerThat's pretty much everyone apart from CoD players
>>12943502Crappy weapons mostly, all the weapons are the same archetype as in Doom but a lot weaker because the game couldn't render as many enemies at the same time, so they nerfed weapons to make enemies take longer to kill.The modern Quake maps are amazing though. Check out Arcane Dimensions and like 300 other map packs on https://www.quaddicted.com/Some of the recent Ironwall exclusive maps are really mind blowing:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ShIjHA08EVo
>>12943715Not quite. There's no equivalent to the lightning gun in doom, or the grenade launcher.
the few iconic quake mods all moved to goldsrc
>>12943715I mean you're probably right but also doom would have very high monster density for a full 3d game, quake would basically be serious sam if it kept parity.
>>129435021. Worse controls, the default mouse lag is sluggish and the game needs sourceports to feel playable, whereas even vanilla Doom in DOSBox has an immediate fun to it2. Full third dimension makes modding/map building a lot more difficult, no shortage of great new Doom wads to this day, whereas great new Quake levels come maybe a few a year3. Much slower combat and more annoying enemy design4. Ugly brown
>>12943502The design doesn't lend itself as well to single player. You kind of just want to stop playing whereas with doom you want to keep going. I think making the levels less claustrophobic had something to do with it
quake was more popular as a multiplayer game than a singleplayer game and now it's deadthat's really all there is to itthere are way more multiplayer maps for quake than there singleplayer ones, and doom is the opposite. tons of singleplayer content and while there are some deathmatch maps it's not really the focus of the community like it was in quake
>>12943785If you're talking about Quake 1 alone, singleplayer maps outpaced deathmatch maps some time ago and are still being released.https://www.quaddicted.com/db/v2/?loadjstablefilter=true#%7B%22col_10%22%3A%7B%22flt%22%3A%22deathmatch%22%7D%7Dhttps://www.quaddicted.com/db/v2/?loadjstablefilter=true#%7B%22col_10%22%3A%7B%22flt%22%3A%22singleplayer%22%7D%7D
>>12943792yeah, NOWi'm talking about when this game was at its peakthe quake remaster brought interest in singleplayer maps in quake back
>>12943795One more aktcshually for you anon and I mean well: It was more of a steady buildup since the 2000s of mods and maps that just kept being released, the peak of which was between 2015 and 2020, when Arcane Dimensions was being developed and reached its zenith with version 1.81 in 2020. 2021 was when the remaster was released, no doubt spurred on by Quake's second wind from 2015-2020.
>>12943795lolwat, singleplayer maps were booming since FritzQuake in the 2000's, Nightdive's KEX engine can't even run most of them lolIt was roughly:GLQuake -> FritzQuake -> Quakespasm -> IronwailIronwail allows for yuge open maps with no stutter, so it really revolutionized things.
>>12943785Pretty much this.Some of the best selling games of all time might be multiplayer, but the games with the most staying power tend to be single player, since it grows more difficult to find someone else to play the older a game gets. Quake, BF1942, and Unreal Tournament were all popular for their multiplayer, and all are effectively dead now. Meanwhile singleplayer games like SMW, Zelda, Mega Man, Sonic, etc, still get plenty of new players and romhacks some 20+ years later.The issue is simple. Singleplayer games can be designed to provide a fun experience for the player and deliver consistently. Multiplayer games at best provide a fun experience for all players when they are more or less on the same skill level and all playing to have fun. If you get some dedicated trolls or try-hards, it makes it a shit experience for the other players. Getting new players into a game full of old die-hard players means the new players will just be cannon fodder for the people who've been playing for two decades. Meanwhile the new player you hand a singleplayer game will most likely get the same experience you got 20+ years ago when you first played it.
>>12943821i bailed on quakeworld when the NA scene became so dead i couldn't find ffas or duels anymoreseems like a singleplayer scene showed up in its place around the same timeline i quit quake for starcraft: brood war
>>12943821also what the hell are you talking abouti used ezquake and was the guy who would show up and shit stomp servers 50-3
uhh looks like someone got banned for some reason
>>12943836those are singleplayer forks, ezquake is quakeworldjust be honest and say you've never had any interest in SP Quake>>12943839I deleted and resubmitted my post because of a typo lol, didn't realize you guys were camping the thread
>>12943502It's just that Quake simply isn't as fun as Doom. Doom knows when to throw bullet sponges at you, in Quake everything takes so much ammo to kill it becomes a chore in later levels. It's a technological marvel and the multiplayer is top doge but Quake campaigns always missed the point.
>>12943715>the game couldn't render as many enemies at the same time, so they nerfed weapons to make enemies take longer to kill.This is the reason I never really have an urge to replay Quake but Doom is always fun. I always wanted a Doom "3" where it's an evolution of the Doom gameplay in the Quake 1 or 2 engine.
I've been marathoning through lots of mods for various FPS games, and Quake 1 has been my longest binge so far. What really opened it up for me is Ironwail with how crisp and responsive everything is (especially @250fps), with lightning fast loading times, only recently beaten by vkQuake with its fast load feature.In terms of gameplay, Quake has three things going for it - weapon combos, infights, and bhop. It's just so much fun, and Doom couldn't do it for me. Any map that lets me maintain basic rhythm with plenty of room to maneuver is almost always goated in my book. The weapons and the roster have so much depth, I really started to think that Quake is a thinking man's game, having to come up with a counterplay and tactics for any given situation on the fly, and maintain the most efficient way of playing. To me, Doom was always a methodical corner clearing game. In Quake, I rush in at breakneck speed, gunning down target from target in seconds, while dodging other enemies by pure feel and speed - it's exhilarating, and no other game comes close. HL is perhaps the only other game that lets you maneuver like that with bhops, but because it takes a realistic approach it often forces you to hunker down, and the most efficient play was always to either snipe or instagrenade enemies, which gets boring quick.Infights are incredible. This is perhaps the only game where infights are taken to the extreme. Let's say you get into a square room with 4 pillars, and you face against ogres, fiends, 1 shambler and a vore perched up, on top of scrags and DKs reinforcements. You'd be pretty fucked if it wasn't for infights. Get the ogres to hit the fiends, get the vore hit the shambler, take out anyone still targetting you, then it's mop up time. All that, under a minute.
>>12944194Words can't describe how it feels to rush down a corridor, induce an infight on your way there, grab a Quad and turn the entire room into giblets. I'm cumming every time. It's better than sex.The fundamentals, the simplicity and robustness of the core systems is what makes it great. I'd say the only real downside of Quake 1 is how 90% of the fun depends on the map itself, a poor map will ruin everything.>Quake levels come maybe a few a yearTry a month. We get a new map coming out nearly on a weekly basis, not to mention all the map jams. The tools and the tutorials got so good, there's no end in sight for the newcomers in the mapping scene. Besides that, there are over 1k maps to play, and many mods that spice up the old formula. I spent over half a year by now, and there's still so much to try, and I left AD for last btw.>Much slower combat and more annoying enemy designNot true. Combat is very skill based, and with basic DB+NG combo you can clear out any room within ten seconds. Any game will have annoying enemies, and it's mostly a (you) problem.>Ugly brownEh. Makkon, IKBlue/IKWhite, Koohoo, and so many other texture sets beg to differ.So no, Quake 1 is absolutely not overshadowed, and once it clicks it's incredible how well it holds up.
>>12943502The first 3D era of games has aged poorly in general. Yeah you are now getting indie devs who were kids then making games with jaggies etc to emulate early 3D but for the most part those early 3D games don't have the ageless appeal like sprite based stuff. They wear their age on their sleeve.
>>12943502The monsters in Quake are really boring compared to Doom
The aesthetics. People can nitpick about guns and monsters, yes Quake is a little disappointing in those aspects. But Foom looks a lot cleaner, has higher contrast, and is more colorful. There's lots of reds, blues, greens and pink to contrast with the browns and grays. Quale on the other hand is all brown and gray, it looks like rusty shit. Like you'd get tetanus just from playing the game. Its not just personal preference either, the lack of color and contrast make enemy identification more difficult. Quake 2/3/4 are better in this aspect but still ugly imo. Compare to the Unreal games which are generally more colorful and beautiful looking, and easy target identification.
>>12945003Meh. I want to disagree but I agree. I love Quake 1's aesthetic whether it's the scifi setting or more fantasy it just works for me. I always love when a major map pak gets released with vanilla textures but a grander scale (Deathmatch Dimension is 1 that comes to mind). To me, there's something strangely comfy about blasting away enemies to the color palette texture work with Reznor's OST in the background. A nice hit of alcohol or a buzz off DUDEWEED and for me it's an 11/10 experience. I think in my heart of hearts I will still always be the Midwest goth/rocker kid. Still holding out for a trashy yet attractive girl.
getting the music to work in sourceports using digital copies was always obtuse and often required dumb workarounds to make it think your have a redbook audio cd mounted, and sometimes the Quake version you downloaded didnt even have the music due to licensing
>>12944847>The first 3D era of games has aged poorly in generalNot true btw
>>12945003Blood also has that problem, really ugly color scheme. Heretic and Hexen were peak aesthetics in the genre. They're gorgeous to look at.
>>12943502Though modding still kept both alive I find Quake modding more robust going forward seeing those new quake levels done by actual dev teams in both quake 1 and 2, and all those indie low poly FPS games paying homage to ps1 graphics, just goes to show Quake is still lurking in the shadows of the FPS world even if DOOM if this generations' poster boy for the new wave boomer shooters.
The series in general was more well known for multiplayer which is why Q3 was a multiplayer (and simulated multiplayer with bots) only game. Q1 was played from 1996 to 2001 for the most part, with only small amounts of servers remaining online for things like Quakeworld Team Fortress and Rocket Arena (and its variant Clan Arena) afterwards
>>12945152It absolutely is. I know you were a kid then and are nostalgic for it but it's aged terribly.
>>12945003quake's style is dry but I wouldn't really call it ugly. it's not garish in the way visually incompetent games from that time were. the color palette makes makes sense and is consistent.
>>12945229It has a cohesive aesthetic, aye it's just that aesthetic is ugly.
Gonna have to try /vr/-made Violent Rumble and HUH jam sometime. Any contributors still lurking around? You guys actually reverse engineered Quoth for VR, or used AD as a base? Impressive. Wish the source code was available.
>>12943715>all the weapons are the same archetype as in Doom but a lot weaker because the game couldn't render as many enemies at the same time, so they nerfed weapons to make enemies take longer to kill.You're coming in at the wrong angle. Quake's shotguns hit softer but fire twice as fast as Doom equivalents. Super nailgun, the explosives, the lightning gun, these are comparatively powerful compared to Doom's plasma gun and rocket launcher. While the lightning gun isn't as strong as the BFG, the nailgun is much stronger than the chaingun and there's no peashooting pistol to worry about. There's also quad pickups to consider for when the game wants you to feel particularly deadly.The bigger difference is what you're put up against: Quake's main campaign is not filled with hundreds of small-healthed enemies like imps and zombies.
>>12943771The fuck are you talking about? Quake is MORE claustrophobic.
>>12943502Trannies have taken it over, probably because it's easier to mod.
>>12945547Debatable. No game is safe.
>>12945553>game where you fight devils>tranniesit checks out
It's not. People are playing the shit of Q1, even though it's worse than Doom 2."Capeshit power fantasy mood" is just true for modern Doom games that are shit anyway, OG Doom was a survival maze game, and by God we liked it that way.
>>12945472Violent Rumble used progs_dump 2 and the two official mission packs as a base. Various Quoth/AD/Drake stuff was added on top. >Wish the source code was available.It's literally in the Mega folder in the mod's readme.
>>12943502Doom came at a time when longterm competition was scarce, so it formed a strong community around making and sharing maps. Doom was huge in a time where pc gaming was still extremely niche, and that created some longtime fans.
>>12945670Whoops, I'm an actual dumbass, and I thought I scoured through the readme, thanks.It'll take a while before I get to it though, so no feedback for now. The only /vr/ map I've played so far was picrelated in qump, and I liked the cheeky style. Any more projects planned btw?
>>12945689Nothing is planned. We can hardly even get a Doom project going these days, and Quake is much harder.
>>12945694Sad state of affairs. The autism fueling all those mapping discords is probably the only source of fresh releases nowadays, which is even sadder.
>>12945003>lots of reds, blues, greens and pink>Quale on the other hand is all brown and gray
>>12945715Niggas play GLQuake on an LCD with filtering and default contrast and think it's supposed to look like that.
>>12945718>LCD with filtering and default contrastTo be fair, that's probably how >>12945003 is comparing the two - and Q1 is still not an "all brown and gray" game. Quake 2 fits that bill better but only if you're playing it "wrong" on software mode.
>>12943502Doom was a lightning in the bottle moment for the PC gaming industry. It was the combination of all the great minds of early ID, keeping themselves in check.>Romero - great maps, fast cars and bitches. >Throw in Sandy Peterson (1 & 2) and American McGee (2).>John Carmac - coding genius, albeit autistic and a control freak.>Tom Hall - Story nerd and wrote doom bible. Built the lore behind the games.Doom had a fleshed out back story that only somewhat shone through in the game. I remember as a child playing it and feeling like it was oozing a deeper lore that you could feel but it was just under the surface. This was Tom Hall's influence.Maps were amazing, fun and fair. This was Romero (and Peterson and later, McGee).And for the time, the game was graphically way ahead of it's time and still ran like a hot knife through butter (i.e. super smooth) on most PCs of the time. This was Carmac.Quake was a glorified tech demo. Apart from graphics, multiplayer, and maps (in that order), they didn't put much thought into anything else. They already had lost (fired) Hall, so there wasn't much of deeper story except the small influence Peterson had. After much back and forth they decided to just go with "spaces marines fighting evil" again but this time, lean more into their DnD campaigns and Sandy's Cthulhu fetish.Also at this time, Romero was on the way out and Carmac was becoming a tyrant. This shows as there is less an emphasis on story and design, and more on the tech.This being said, Quake was massive for multiplayer, so you could argue that it was the bigger game because it gave birth to competitive online. Also, Half-life was based of a heavily modified Quake engine, so you could argue in that sense it's also the bigger game.I prefer Doom and Doom 2. Something about the sprite work and engine just does it for me (probably nostalgia).
>>12943502Doom is easier to mod for, so Doom's mod scene just never died out. Meanwhile Quake expects you to both 3D model and vertex animate (but maybe the tools for fans are now better than the base game's)
>>12945993>vertex animateLiterally nobody has ever 'vertex animated' a Quake model. The final format used by the game stored vertex positions per frame for animation, but those animations were very much made with rigged models.
>>12943715idk about that, i played quake for the first time recently and the weapons are much more satisfying to use than the ones in doom. its just that the game is clearly balanced around you using the grenade and rocket launcher as your main weapons, while in doom the rocket launcher was an "ultimate" weapon with very limited ammo drops overall
>>12943502The enemies move too much in quake and aiming at them is annoying.
>>12943502I’m 42 and I’ll never understand feeling like you have to pick doom over quake or vice versa. I’ve been going back to these games for decades.
Never into Doom too much.Love me QuakeLove me expansion packs Love me Hexen 2Love me Quake community maps Simple as.
>>12946663There is exactly ONE (1) enemy in Quake that is annoying to aim at, and even then that's pretty overblown.
>>12945983>not mentioning based Adrian's art direction
>>12946729>overblownHaha, I see what you did there. I bet it was Sandy or Timmy who thought, "hey, what if we add an enemy that bhops all over the room and explodes in your face like a mega rocket when you kill it?! Sounds sick, let's do it!"In my experience, nowadays modders use Spawns as these trolls that either appear in your face right after getting a power up or camping behind it, which made them very predictable - I even changed its alert sound to that meme "hello" voice cue, very fitting.And if you don't instantly rocket or nailgun it on the spot, depending on their amount and the room layout, it can very quickly get out of hand, so you might as well reload. The best thing I like to do is to make it infight with the others.
>>12946657I agree rockets are a core element in Quake's gunplay, especially the GL, which is a part of the trifecta "DB+NG+GL" basic gun gear loadout that lets you beat pretty much any map in existence. But I disagree about the rocket launcher, it's still an ultimate weapon in Quake, and the map is pretty much over as soon as you get it, it's a cakewalk from here on out. That's why majority of the custom maps never let you have one, or you only get it by the end. Not to mention the very real possibility of breaking the map with rocket jumps, not that grenade jumps don't exist, but it's much easier to perform. And don't get me started on GL+RL boost, many mappers to this day never protect their important areas from that.
>>12944194>>12944201This guy Quakes.
>>12943502ayyy...i love quake too but have you considered Quake 2???https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALBKFB28E0M
I fucking love single player quake and the fan maps are awesome, the new expansion is good, and I've started mapping myself. Game is good, if you don't like it it's not for you. And also you're gay.
>>12945983>Quake was a glorified tech demoThis dude is gay
Was there ever a mod or a source port that tracked detailed stats for each map? The only similar thing in my experience was Qonquer from Jam5, but it's waveshit so wasn't really applicable anywhere else.I kinda went full 'tismo on this thing for a few months now, and sometimes there's a lot unexpected things you end up seeing there. Picrel is only the top portion of it, it's a long ass list. Didn't find a better way than to just dump it in the console on impulse command or when entering the intermission screen.
Behold the absolute horror of an ogre who can aim down
Aieeeeeee admins, they're doing it in 0g!!!
>>12945983>glorified tech demofuck you arrogant piece of shit
>>12947601Just fork Ironwail and AI a stats screen for each map, and one for consecutive maps ala Doom.>>12947826Which mod?
>>12947859>which modMy own. I'm cooking a spiced up copper with stuff I'd like to see.
Block quake is a silly mod
>>12947861Based same but Drake and Violent Rumble 2. Finished up a monster randomizer recently based on Arcane Dimensions' Chaos Mode. VR2 has a monster randomizer, but it's pretty ball ripping in terms of difficulty. Good luck with your stuff.
>>12947863Thanks man, u2.>Violent Rumble 2They made a second one?!
>>12947865Yeah and it's a really great mod, but not enough mappers came around when he was running a mapjam for it. He has since moved on to other things.
>>12947867Link? Or you mean it's like the new Drake version situation, mod base is out but no one made the maps? RIP Tronyn btw.
Also wow, I just checked the Chaos mode for AD in id1's ep1, and it was something. I always dismissed it, thinking it'd be like Doom's shitpost mash up of randomized monsters from mods, but it stays within its own class, and occasionally spices up the gameplay with extra power ups and armor pick ups, not bad at all. Gotta admire how playable AD is compared to other mods with how sane its monsters are.
>>12947887https://mega.nz/folder/LVlWVK5D#H5iqeD61bSItMIVeGqymTQThat's VRanon's link for VR2, including QC.https://mega.nz/file/jJMFiBRS#ULvcNZ5mUMfGtJ7CFfaYEESrXwgsZkl8v3zycaTg-soThat's my VR2 and Drake merge, but it's already outdated in the last two weeks with a new weapon, new shield item, new monster, and the new monster randomizer. I'll update the link in the next few days.>>12947908It's a ball, ain't it? AD is getting an update before the year's out. Can't wait.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=icWh2szIzYk&>>12947984Thanks m8
The most insane map you've ever beaten? Mine's picrelated from QBJ3.
>>12948006Whew! Nothing even close to that.
I Remember When Quake Came OutMy Uncle Had It On His Computer And He Told Me It Was The Future Of GamingI Asked Him If It Was Better Than Doom And He Said They Were Two Different ExperiencesI Thought That Was A Very Mature Way Of Looking At ThingsAnyway I Played Quake For A While And I Have To Say The Brown Buildings Reminded Me Of A Warehouse I Used To Work AtThere Was A Woman There Named Linda Who Had A Very Nice Figure And She Smoked Inside The Loading BayI Never Really Understood Why They Made The Shotgun So WeakHad To Look It Up But Apparently The Game Has A Multiplayer CommunityI Don't Know Why You Would Want To Play A Game With Other People When You Could Just Walk Around A Warehouse By Yourself
>>12943502Gameplay was worse, enemy animations and damage feedback were jank.
>>12948065Why is this in stanzas and why is the first letter of every word capitalized
>>12948096HAHAHAHAHAHA THIS YOUTUBE NIGGA NEVER PLAYED THE GAME
>>12943624Which OST did Reznor do again?
>>12948138https://letmegooglethat.com/?q=Which+OST+did+Reznor+do+between+the+Doom+and+Quake+games%3F
>>12948138quake 1 and doom 3
>>12948143i thought they closed that site because it sadly turned into a malware vector
>>12948145Akshually they scrapped his stuff for doom 3 but you can still get it as a sound pack. And chris vrenna did the theme(off/on nin touring drummer)
>>12948156i thought he did the title screen and ambiet track during the pathetic excuse for what the game considers "boss fights"only the cyberdemon truly felt like a boss fight in that game
>>12948143Thanks for googling that for me :)
I love my Quake mappers being so stunning and brave, ohh you go gurrl
>>12947908The 666 chaos mode was more of that pepega shitpost vibe I was looking for, still highly playable, but it gets a bit predictable with how high tier monsters tend to camp Quads and etc.
>>12948487queer blow job 3 was a disaster for the human race
>>12948627It do be like that, they went really blatant there. What's crazy to me is how czg just lost it to the mass psychosis and full trooned out, wtf happened