[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/vrpg/ - Video Games/RPG

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1768372529201752.jpg (29 KB, 250x357)
29 KB JPG
tl;dr I'm remastering NWN2 OC and MotB from scratch.

Not sure that it's the right place to post, but what the hell.

I thought that NWN2:EE was lacklustre. It hardly fixed anything except for maybe Multiplayer and a few bugs. This doesn't look like $30 worth of work.
Then I started wondering: what would an actual decent remaster look like?
My first thought was using my modpack I created and debugged back in the day: better UI, custom portraits, better character sheet, better inventory, better companion AI, a bit of a facelift when it comes to textures and so on.
But that clearly isn't enough.
The big part of NWN2 is the original campaign, but it's buggy as hell and has a lot of cut content.
IMO the absolute minimum for the remaster is to fix all of the known bugs in the OC. And it wasn't done.
The next step is to fix some of the glaring campaign issues that are technically not bugs: for example, some of the influence gates are impossible to clear without the debug menu and your companion dialogue tree is static: you can ask one of your companions "Who are you?" in the final dungeon.
Then the AI should be reworked. In fact, there is a must-have AI mod that does just that: your companions and your enemies are no longer dumber than bricks and you have a DA:O-like tactical menu for fine-tuning your companions.
It should've been integrated into the main game, but alas.

Add all that and I see myself paying $30.

So I decided to remaster it myself. If I, one idiot with an LLM, can do it, then Aspyr is officially incompetent.
>>
File: 1765942736794382.png (320 KB, 1990x890)
320 KB PNG
So far I've gathered 300+ bugs, built a vision-based harness for automated testing and fixed a few bugs.
My goal is to make this number provably zero, at least all of the parts that don't require patching the engine. I've already decompiled it, but that would be the next big project.
>>
I think we need to coin terminology for a very peculiar variant of AI psychosis, one in which clueless people start thinking they're programming gods capable of tackling tasks far beyond their means. A type of inflated hubris.

I can guarantee that even with good harnesses, oversight, prompting and so on, you by yourself+Claude isn't enough to remaster this without also introducing quite a few new bugs and issues.
>>
>>4141740
It's okay to be confident.
>>
>>4141740
Thing is, this project has lived rent-free in my head for years at this point, predating generative AI.
It's just that now I have no excuse not to start it.
>you by yourself+Claude isn't enough to remaster this without also introducing quite a few new bugs and issues
We'll see. The first step is to create an automation framework for testing. I wouldn't say it's easy, but I'm making good progress.
Also I doubt I'll introduce many regression bugs until I start tinkering with the engine itself.
>>4141772
I'm not especially confident, but the worst-case scenario is that nothing comes of it.
>>
>>4141740
AI will do these things
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxMZyVn0y3k&t=75s
>>
>>4141845
AI indeed will, one day, but that day is absolutely not today. And if the tidal wave of slop has been any indication, even when AI can do all these things, taste (which most people seem to lack) will still be a barrier.
>>
>>4141859
This project requires almost no creativity from me.
Improving companion AI was already done via the mod, I just need to include is seamlessly.
Reworking dialogue trees into the MotB-style is also pretty straightforward. I probably need to think a bit more about the impossible influence gates, but that also looks doable.
The rest is just a mechanical work.
>>
>>4141157
So what are you exactly doing? A reimplementation of the engine to use all existing resources, no new data?
>>
>>4142222
First of all, I want to fix all of the non-engine bugs here: >>4141158
Needless to say, it's impossible to do in any reasonable amount of time without leaning on the automation really heavily, so I'm currently creating an auto testing framework. It's a pain in the ass, but I've made some progress: I can reliably fire up up to 10 NWN2 instances on demand and I can do some light automation with the limited vision to test end-to-end scenarios. It was funny to see that the 9070xt started actively cooling itself only after I'd shoved 10 NWN2 instances into it.
Then I'll apply some of the fixes that I mentioned in the OP-post.
Then I need my automation engine to play the whole game end-to-end.
At that point, I'll have a testing engine robust enough to catch a substantial number of regression bugs which will inevitably appear in the process of fixing the engine.
As for the assets, I assume that the NWN2:EE team upscaled them using AI(most likely), which drastically increased loading times and didn't improve their looks. I actually consider that to be a regression. Maybe I'll ship a small curated list of visual mods that provably don't collide with one another. I've seen some conflicts, the funniest was Safiya growing an ugly hairdo when I installed a floor tile mod or something like that.

I've created a small one-pager to track the progress:

https://nwn2reassembled.fyi/
>>
I also want to restore some content, but that's so far off right now that it's not worth talking about.
>>
>>4142287
>Then I need my automation engine to play the whole game end-to-end.
>At that point, I'll have a testing engine robust enough to catch a substantial number of regression bugs
This is how you handle the elementary QA in anything more complex than a shoot'em up, at least when you aren't a braindead suit who thinks a bunch of monkeys can test everything million times a month for a handful of pennies.
Black Isle, Bethesda, Bioware, Troika and Obsidian were known for abysmal QA. The wtfs found in game resources by fans patching Planescape Torment and Fallout speak for themselves.
CRPGs, especially those with a lot of C&C, are not just "games" where clipping through the obstacles or inaccessible locations would be the worst thing that could happen. It's a complex logical system, a large finite state machine which can't be properly maintained without an automated system.
In the ideal world your automation wouldn't even start with actually "playing" the game to find a regression, it would be reserved for late stage testing, a very naive approach outside of it. It would start with grinding through the game at the level of scripts and data, or in a special dev mode.
>>
>>4142303
>Black Isle, Bethesda, Bioware, Troika and Obsidian were known for abysmal QA. The wtfs found in game resources by fans patching Planescape Torment and Fallout speak for themselves.
To their defence, everything was jank back in the day.
Also the hardware is an issue too: I have several supercomputers at home by the standards of 2004.
>In the ideal world your automation wouldn't even start with actually "playing" the game to find a regression, it would be reserved for late stage testing, a very naive approach outside of it. It would start with grinding through the game at the level of scripts and data, or in a special dev mode.
I do that too and I test everything that I can on a lowest level possible.
Issue is, an NWN2 save embeds a snapshot of the module - areas, object/instance state, local variables, globals - into its saves, so the area/module/creature changes don't apply to the existing ones.
So I need to actually "play" the game to do the robust A/B in many scenarios.
But loose script and dialog resources still load live, so override fixes to those apply immediately.
>>
>>4141845
We have iwd and nwn in bg, g in nwn 1 and 2 and is iwd in nwn? I know bg is planned as mod after path menzo in bg3 and some iwd2ee guys wanted iwd2 in bg3, are there other crossovers? Bg1, 2 and 4 are low key announced who will do it, cdpr, their bitch offspring or owlcucks? All three suck btw. >>4141157 I'd rather let him and Claude make bg4.
>>
File: 1777989798899409.png (1.73 MB, 1254x1254)
1.73 MB PNG
>>4142318
>I'd rather let him and Claude make bg4
>>
I set up the pipeline to post e2e A/B bug videos:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUmhlni8eAc

The default youtube recommendation feed is a horror show.
>>
File: 1785862376757334.png (82 KB, 1880x460)
82 KB PNG
Fixed some of the easier bugs and added counters.

https://nwn2reassembled.fyi/

It's still far from a whole bug corpus, but if I can't handle these, I 100% can't handle the trickier ones.
>>
>>4141158
I honestly don't give a fucking fuck about anything but Mystic Theurge prestige class. Get that implemented and working correctly.
Preferably by implementing it as a 20 level base class like the Kobold Press one for PF1e: https://www.d20pfsrd.com/classes/3rd-party-classes/kobold-press-open-design/theurge/
I do not fucking care about just about anything else because I'm not interested in playing any other class. And since Kaedrin is such a gaping yeasty cunt, the enhanced edition still doesn't have a functional MT and no one else has been updating still. There were like three different versions of the class created by mods for the old version of NWN2 and yet the enhanced edition remains unplayable not for any other reason but that the mods just don't work anymore.
If you get the item crafting / enchanting working with quality of life features, correct pricing and more enchantment variety, then that'd be nice, too.

But still. I have zero interest in NWN2 because I can use toybox to gestalt in Kingmaker or Wrath instead.
>>
>>4143522
Thanks for the feedback.
I'll file Mystic Theurge, but restoring this class isn't the first priority right now.
>NWN2 and yet the enhanced edition remains unplayable not for any other reason but that the mods just don't work anymore.
I'm basing my version on

https://www.gog.com/en/game/neverwinter_nights_2_complete

because, frankly, fuck the EE. I do not consider putting in this much effort and then having the gall to ask $30 for it to be acceptable.
>>
>>4143522
>>4143533
https://nwn2reassembled.fyi/#download
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NulQhS6IpNc

but that's still that needs to be properly play-tested, which is very far-off.
I cannot ever recommend using it as it is right now.
>>
>>4143508
Are you saying you'll be finished with a remaster in like 80h or so? This means gen8 ai will bury gaming studios, good, fuck them. Imbeciles.
>>
>>4143508
You are going to end up like Cleve Blakemoore "polishing" his Grimoire in 2014.
>only 123 issues and 4134 microissues left!
>>
>>4143730
>like 80h or so
lol. lmao.
My optimistic estimate is two months *before* fixing the engine.
I only posted a fraction of the bugs. The main issue is robust automation, and it's hard.
Also keep in mind that a lot of work was done for me by the community, I just compiled the data.
>>4143756
Could be. Again, the worst case scenario is that nothing comes of it.
>>
>>4143820
That makes much more sense
>>
File: 1767708969967586.png (1.94 MB, 1920x1080)
1.94 MB PNG
tl;dr reworked Khelgar's dialogue tree to behave more like its MotB counterparts.
The only question mark is "Why are you going to Neverwinter?". It was gated by the Helm priest convo and I made it a one-off.

____________________

#38 Hlam / Khelgar's Trials — completion line ("you've learned what you need")
checked for EXACTLY 10 influence instead of 10-or-more. =10 >9
Files: 10_hlam.dlg, 3063_hlam.dlg [v0.1]

#659 Khelgar greeting cleanup — removed a duplicate "I need to know more about
you…" option; "Who are you AGAIN?" retires after one ask; the Weeping-Willow
and "creatures pursuing us" questions retire once asked.
File: gl_khelgar.DLG [v0.2]

#660 "Were they wizards?" was offered before Khelgar describes the fight. Moved to
follow the line where he says the brawlers "were moving too fast."
File: gl_khelgar.DLG [v0.3]

#661 Getting-to-know-you topics now retire once heard (MotB idiom): "Tell me about
yourself", the "Kalach-Cha" question, "How did the meeting with monks go?",
and the eager-to-fight story (only on a passed + fully-heard telling — a failed
influence check keeps it so you can retry).
File: gl_khelgar.DLG [v0.3]
>>
>>4145953
2/2
#662 Eager-to-fight influence check was written "== 5", so ONLY exactly 5 influence
failed it (4 or 6 passed). ==5 <5
File: gl_khelgar.DLG [v0.3]

#663 Khelgar's three Trial quests (Maimed / Even-Handed / Justice) dropped into the
journal all at once during Khelgar's outburst, before the priest explained
anything. Each now enters the journal when Hlam describes that trial.
File: 10_hlam.dlg [v0.3]

#664 "Why are you going to Neverwinter?" is now a one-off — retires after you ask it
once instead of lingering until you meet Hlam.
File: gl_khelgar.DLG [v0.3]

(Also: #614 restores Khelgar's loyalty-defence line at Traitors' End, alongside the
other companions — part of the shared Act-3 finale fix.)

No dialogue text is added or changed in any of these — gates, quest triggers and
retirement flags only.
>>
File: 1762613242975485.png (2.06 MB, 1920x1080)
2.06 MB PNG
>>4145953
I've done roughly the same thing for Neeshka

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0UHvf0wnPQ

I still can't believe that I've spent two hours debugging the automation and it turned out to be an obscure low-priority engine bug.
>>
Looking at the file structure, it's quite possible that Light of Heavens and Guyven were intended to be at least temporary companions at some point.

https://nwn2.fandom.com/wiki/Light_of_Heavens
https://nwn2.fandom.com/wiki/Guyven_of_the_road
>>
A none jank storm of zehir with reworked random encounter layouts would be cash.
>>
>>4146960
Can you work out a sex scene with Elanee
>>
>>4147859
>he didn’t get the true ending
>>
Currently working on the Elanee dialogue tree. Fixing it took some time, but it's doable.
NWN2 GUI fights every step of the way when it comes to automation. The cursor in particular is a real son of a bitch, but I'm making progress.
>>4147859
Electron is pretty jank, so probably not. Alas.
No creepy stalker elf-on-PC action for you, I'm afraid.
>>4147817
I'll start working on SoZ right after the OC and MotB.
I'm focused on bugfixing first, though.
>>
>>4146960
>>4147859
Still no graphic sex scene, I've made the first fix for Elanee's dialogue tree.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-laswpxpYsg

Almost failed my Will save after this:

1. Clicking on a PC's portrait
2. Right-clicking on Elanee's portrait
3. Starting a conversation.

Took a 10+ hour debugging session to implement.
I also realised that the old-save compatibility should be tested extensively.
>>
>>4147985
>stoneskin
lfmao
>>
>>4147859
Why a sex scene is considered the best reward for "romancing" a virtual bitch? I want her begging to be allowed to give pleasure to my mighty MC. I want rare artifacts. Permanent power ups. New powers to bring destruction over my enemies.
Not an awkward dialog followed by a fade to black.
All romances in BG and NWN were written by faggots. Except Aerie in BG2. Aerie was so awkward it worked well by accident.
>>
>>4146960
>an obscure low-priority engine bug
Games flop when the number of ignored low priority bugs gets high enough.
>>
>>4148070
Losing your virginity is a permanent power up
>>
>>4148070
>All romances in BG and NWN were written by faggots. Except Aerie in BG2
Name one romance in BG.
>>
>>4148072
This one is harmless. Or at least it looks harmless.
When you load NWN2, the right-click-on-a-portrait menu doesn't work.
You need to left-click on one of the portraits, and then it works.
>>4148070
>All romances in BG and NWN were written by faggots
I consider Gann's romance to be decent.
>>
>>4147875
>NWN2 GUI fights every step of the way
The game engine is so bad on its own that I would write the whole thing off as unplayable. The campaign being boring and generic doesn't help.
>>
why dont you just fix the terrible fucking camera fag

like literally all they had to do was make it zoom out and control from further out like an rts or isometric.

they're retarded and so are you
>>
>>4148262
The plot of the original NWN2 campaign was anything but boring and generic. It was a gameplay problem. Too many repetitive encounters, certain parts felt like a pointless chore (everything about Sandra Jerro)
>>4148262
>The game engine is so bad on its own that I would write the whole thing off as unplayable
>>4148549
>the terrible fucking camera
The camera of NWN2 was so fucked it's legendary. The worst "isometric" 3D game I have ever seen, it got me traumatized for life. I finished the game in 2007 only because I messed really long with camera settings in the debug console. It was painful, in a physical way, in locations featuring large differences in the terrain elevation.
IRC it was very easy to modify the camera in Skyrim, yes, the fucking Skyrim, in order get an high altitude "isometric" view in outdoor locations. But in the NWN2, where the entire engine should be optimized exactly for it? Oh boy.
>>
>>4148262
>I would write the whole thing off as unplayable
Well, I obviously wouldn't.
It has two major issues:

- wonky camera in one of the modes that I never use
- brain-dead AI, especially your companion AI

The second one is far, far, far more serious than the first and it can be straight-up fixed by the mod, which I suspect will be the only rebalance mod that I'll include in an eventual repack.
The tactical mode camera is a bit jank, but it's not even remotely a showstopper. Top-down hovering is mostly fine.
>>4148549
>why dont you just fix the terrible fucking camera fag
I already addressed this point here >>4142287
tl;dr I'll try, but I need a regression testing suite and I currently have maybe 1% of what's required.
>>4148584
Do you know a place where someone enumerated the exact NWN2 camera problems?
It will be extremely helpful further down the line.
>>
>>4148584
>>4148604
Horrid engine and AI leads directly into frustration as your allies trigger 10 million attacks of opportunity because they felt like dying, yes.
The game also has that hideous Everquest 2 style "Poser" aesthetic. And it doesn't support custom portraits unless you have the final expansion pack.
>>
>>4148968
AI can be vastly improved by this(iirc) mod:

https://neverwintervault.org/project/nwn2/script/companion-and-monster-ai-213

This is the only mod that I consider an absolute must have.
>>
Still working on proper OCR.
Little by little, I'm getting there. Fixed Grobnar's dialogue tree, the rest are on their way.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6uCX214GZ34
>>
Started working on a really big and complicated one: an unattended end-to-end playthrough. This one makes or breaks the whole project. If anyone else saves every five minutes to a new slot like an autist just like me, your save pack will help me a lot.
Meanwhile, I refreshed the sample fix videos to include sound and made small fixes to the dialogue.

Grobnar - "What do you do?"
https://youtu.be/6uCX214GZ34

Khelgar - "Who are you again?"
https://youtu.be/S0JwVrOKJ34

Elanee - "Who are you again?"
https://youtu.be/2NBMwsrySl8

Neeshka - "So you're a tiefling?" / "Do you have any useful skills?"
https://youtu.be/Wz-A_87-4Q4

Qara - "Tell me about yourself."
https://youtu.be/8H5bDgek4M4

Casavir - "What is your concern with Neverwinter?"
https://youtu.be/1seBUZ_xRZw
>>
Experimenting with voice generation. I'm still not 100% sure that I'll use it in any capacity. Maybe I'll generate some of the unvoiced Ammon Jerro lines from MotB and add it to a separate pack.

https://filebin.net/0o62h8xdwkh9ev8s Catbox is currently down
>>
>>4150350
>Started working on a really big and complicated one: an unattended end-to-end playthrough
I've got the first footage:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qeQCYTJILA
>>
>>4150517
I continue working on the automation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5cXkHXJZt-g
>>
>>4141157
Wow, based beyond belief. I hope it goes well.
>>
>>4151684
Thank you. It's not easy, but I'm making progress.
Currently working on an automated run >>4150923
Already fixed over-reliance on autosaves to get the current world state.
Next milestone - New Game, Village, Ruins, Fort Locke with side-quests, arriving at Highcliff.
>>
>>4150923
Still grinding away at the automation. Fixed a small bug in the process:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HiZj-UXhxC4

My bot is a bit retarded like father, like son , but it's making progress.
Next milestone - from zero to Neverwinter, while doing most of the side-quests along the way.
>>
>>4152829
>like father, like son ,
I wonder why spoiler didn't work.
test
>>
File: 1788801047459072.png (2.52 MB, 1920x1080)
2.52 MB PNG
>>4150923
>>4152829
YES. The first segmented automation from zero to Neverwinter is done.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j8xGdSzZR88

The next milestone is a clean zero to Neverwinter run and my bot finishing Act 1.

I'm also working on a cosmetic change.
OC displays influence shifts only in a combat log.
I want all of them to be immediately visible, MotB-style.
>>
What you should be doing is decompiling the engine byte for byte first.

Copy this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ff8su9nY4os
>>
>>4153519
Before watching the video: he used Ghidra, didn't he? It's not exactly rocket science. The NWN2Toolset is a bit easier because it's C#, so ilspycmd actually produces something readable.
I've already done that. This was extremely helpful when I was creating good "vision" for a bot.
Thing is, I suspect that this engine will start falling apart when I start fixing it. Hence my efforts to create the bot. I want to play the whole game, all of the branches, end-to-end, and I don't scale well.
>>
>>4153519
>>4153586
Ok, I watched the video.
We're doing roughly the same thing, but we approaching it differently.
I genuinely want to do this project alone. Having help is nice, but it shouldn't be requirement.
Hence my focus on testing first.
He is more of a type to throw shit at the wall to see what sticks. The unspoken assumption here is that the community will do QA for him.
I don't like this idea. I want to release something actually polished for the Reassembled 1.0.
>>
>>4153586
He didn't mention ghidra, i don't know if he used it.

https://fnvdecomp.com/how
>>
>>4153603
It should be the same as the vanilla exe when you build it, so it should have all the same bugs as vanilla game. you wouldn't need any extra QA.
>>
>>4153603
Also there is reverse engineering project that has been abandoned. Might be useful to you as well.

https://xoreos.org/
>>
>>4153623
He used that or something similar. It doesn't really matter that much. I was going to build a similar thing anyway.
Again, we have different objectives in mind.
He obviously wants to do the decompile so he (and others) can mould the game like clay. This is admirable, but this is not my main objective.
My main objective is a bug-free NWN2, specifically the OC and MotB.
>>4153626
I'd need extra QA when I start fixing it.
The camera in particular will be a bitch to fix and validate. Yes, I can build an obstacle course that will contain all of the known edge cases, but an actual test would essentially involve fuzzing all of the distinct paths in all of the modules and reviewing the footage for the anomalies.
>>4153631
Thanks. I know about this one too. It's extremely useful as a reference.
>>
Anyway, the campaign is still in a sorry state, and I want to do this low-hanging fruit first. Fixing the engine is a phase 2.
>>
Not much to talk about: I'm still working on the automation.
Also started decomp/recomp in parallel, currently experimenting with local models to save tokens.
>>
Added a recomp section to the site.
It's a low-effort on my part right now, but I think you were right: it doesn't make sense to hold off on it until I'm done with the campaign.

https://nwn2reassembled.fyi/#reconstruction
>>
For all that's worth, recomp now has its own github page:

https://github.com/nwn2reassembled/nwn2-matching-rebuild
>>
would this remaster affect the editor in any way?
>>
>>4157698
I currently don't have any plans to touch it, but that could change.

Phase 1: all of the non-engine bugs.
Phase 2: some of the engine bugs, hopefully including the camera

Do you have something specific in mind?
>>
>>4157700
nah, just wondering if the work is extensive enough to affect how the editor works or how things work in the editor
>>
>>4157711
NWN2 is a clusterfuck even before you get to the engine.
As for the editor: changes most likely wouldn't affect it at all, because, say, camerawork belongs to a presentation layer and it shouldn't affect anything inside the editor (except the camera) unless Obsidian's programmers were utterly incompetent.
There is evidence of separate gameplay-camera and editor-input paths. A patch confined to nwn2main.exe does not automatically propagate into the editor.
>>
add an RSS feed to the website.
>>
>>4157975
To track the progress? Ok, but why?
>>
>>4157975
>>4157982
https://nwn2reassembled.fyi/rss.xml
>>
>>4157982
because im just interested in it.
>>
File: 1775333066887494.png (60 KB, 1220x298)
60 KB PNG
Unfortunately, not much to talk about.
I'm still working on an end-to-end run and it keeps breaking in a new fun and interesting ways.
I'm also doing the decomp, bit by bit.

I have no intention of quitting.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.