[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/vst/ - Video Games/Strategy

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1791820153308106.jpg (47 KB, 1024x715)
47 KB JPG
I've wiped out every army and occupied every piece of land. I should be able to take the entire thing. Why am I blocked from taking the entire thing
>>
>>2518457
Because it's dificult to make unrest mechanics that punish you for expanding fast without feeling bad for the player. So they slow down your expansion rate instead.
>>
>>2518457
I think it would be fine to take everything if the game forced you to leave 1k soldiers as peacekeeping garrisons for every 5 dev or something
otherwise the province flips back immediately if you leave it
you wouldn't feel the need to take everything at once if it meant another war means your new territories flip back immediately because you have to gather your troops to fight
>>
Why should you need to make a peace deal at all?
>>
Nobody feels bad for blobbers.
>>
>>2518485
Based Major, just fight the entire world
>>
>>2518460
I'll be ok with the negative effects after the peace deal, that will still discourage blobbing. And antagonism / aggressive expansion / infamy etc is fine too. I just don't see why a country that has unconditionally surrended can't be completely annexed or puppeted.

>>2518477
Higher occupation costs, sure
>>
File: 1689806882177649.jpg (1.21 MB, 1000x1065)
1.21 MB JPG
>>2518544
>I'll be ok with the negative effects after the peace deal, that will still discourage blobbing. And antagonism / aggressive expansion / infamy etc is fine too. I just don't see why a country that has unconditionally surrended can't be completely annexed or puppeted.
Mods tried that and it never stopped anyone. War is beautiful.
>>
>>2518457
Paradox games are fundamentally based on boardgame mechanics, if you're going to ask for a deeper leap into the slippery slope of "realistically akshully I should be able to annex the whole country" you should prepare for a laundry list of incredibly boring and unfun bullshit to a ratio of 4 to 1 for everything you think it would improve

Naval play would cease to exist for 95% of nations, because they were historically prohibitively expensive in the extreme

No base tax income, no base forcelimit, trade in general would be extremely lopsided in favor of a handful of nations and everyone else would suffer greatly

all separatism would last 80-200 years minimum unless you were already within the same culture group, and even then it would be like 50 years for every fuck sucking pointless OPM in your region

unrest reduction and coring cost reduction would simply case to exist because the government simply doesn't have to capacity to directly control the populace so efficiently during the entire time the game exists

The entire game would be a tedious micromanagement simulator where you have to work 5+ hours of tanking events and unrest for some piddly +0.02 to autonomy reduction and estates would average a loyalty of 40% with all privileges granted

You would lose 40% of your income at minimum manpower in addition to the additional maintainence cost and wars would only be break a small profit margin if you sacked every other province and max out cash for peace

it is ultimately a contrivance to make the game predictable enough for repeated variable outcomes that don't brick a run because the dickhead AI lost a single war to the turks by running 80K crusaders across the straight in 10 8K stacks
>>
>>2518457
I got faced with this after occupying every system and planet from the empire i was targetting in Stellaris when my other rival joined the war and i had to take over much of their territory as well, despite the former being at 100% war score for half the war lmao.
>shitlaris
i know
>>
>>2518649
>Naval play would cease to exist for 95% of nations, because they were historically prohibitively expensive in the extreme
>No base tax income, no base forcelimit, trade in general would be extremely lopsided in favor of a handful of nations and everyone else would suffer greatly
>all separatism would last 80-200 years minimum unless you were already within the same culture group, and even then it would be like 50 years for every fuck sucking pointless OPM in your region
>unrest reduction and coring cost reduction would simply case to exist because the government simply doesn't have to capacity to directly control the populace so efficiently during the entire time the game exists
All of this would be good. Especially separatism, it'd basically act as a natural anti-blobbing mechanic, the bigger you get the more you have to devote your efforts towards inner policing, unless you're spreading over a population that's already naturally widespread.
>>
>>2518790
>it is ultimately a contrivance to make the game predictable enough for repeated variable outcomes that don't brick a run because the dickhead AI lost a single war to the turks by running 80K crusaders across the straight in 10 8K stacks

I notice you failed to address the crucial part of the post where having such a brittle system means the vast majority of the game would be played in exactly 5 provinces? Have you forgotten the literal years where the game was far more "anti-blob" and that the main issue was that it divides the game into a single dichotomy (which still exists now but is less burdensome)

You have a handful of tags that can WC because they either start out so big or become so big in most playthroughs that anti-blob ceases to matter

the sheer weight of their blob knocks the whole map over and the game collapses under the weight and you end up with beyliks bordering denmark

and then you get everyone else, impotently treading water in the shallow end of the gene pool throwing the next 80 years down the shitter to win a war because losing is a death sentence that you can't recover from, all country play hyper conservatively and "nothing ever happens"-itis sets in immediately as borders change by one province in a 200 year window
>>
>>2518800
nta but the solution is really simple.
instead of making peace deals extremely limited, make it so wars are incredibly costly.
you should only see a full 100% warscore in late game hyperwars. most wars should be extremely limited in scope with the initial engagement between the two main armies being enough to settle for a limited peace if one side won heavily, with stacking harsh modifiers for the attacker and stacking buffs for the defender if the required warscore for the initial cb is met but the war continues.
>>
>>2518649
this is simply untrue on many occasions and none of your supposed bureaucratic mess really happened historically

case in point would be the angevin empire, rise of ottomans, rise of lithuania, new spain, and so on. people didn't just comically rebel at every chance they get or magically feel the strong inclination to not pay taxes back then, they collaborated with the new conquerors in town and in return the local elites kept the status quo if not benefiting from the new development. meanwhile the people of the countryside aka the majority of the population went on with their life like nothing happened unless there's a famine or war in vicinity, in any case they were not politically influential at all to the fabric of pre victorian society
>>
>>2518800
>I notice you failed to address the crucial part of the post where having such a brittle system means the vast majority of the game would be played in exactly 5 provinces? Have you forgotten the literal years where the game was far more "anti-blob" and that the main issue was that it divides the game into a single dichotomy (which still exists now but is less burdensome)
Ideally it wouldn't be done on a per-tile basis but a per-culture basis, Vicky 2 style, just with cultures having more agency and ability to stir shit up.
>>
>>2518477
>Take territory
>Kill everyone there

Problem solved
>>
>>2519147
OK but you get 0 dev and therefore the moment you leave the province it becomes neutral no mans land
>>
>>2519150
>Send fertile fat titted milksow settler from own people
>Send 10 good men
>Re-populate neutral no mans land

Problem solved
>>
>>2519150
>They make it a desert, and call it peace.
>>
>>2519152
>Pic related
>>
>>2518526
I do :(
>>
>>2519152
OK no problem but you wait 50 years for 1 dev.
All of these mechanics combined would deter people from annexing everything at once
>>
>>2518649
civitas and pax historia has made paradox obsolete
>>
>>2518457
trvke
>>
The real truth nuke is that warscore limits in paradox games aren't restrictive enough and most gsgs would be funner if warscore limits were lower
eu4 and stellaris being the prime examples of too much leniency

>Why am I blocked from taking the entire thing
to compensate for retarded ai not being smart enough to gang up on blobbers as much as they need to

someone NEEDS to reverse engineer paradox games and implement ai agents to larp as each country so they can team up and rape blobbers ai or human
>>
Alright, my solution to this problem is to just handle peace agentially, similar to an expanded CK2/Vicky III system. So ultimately, you can reject any peace, but if you do, your generals can coup you and try to enforce the peace, or some asshole can start a peace movement. Also peace talks are an ongoing thing you give agents orders to work on, having delegates try and offer peace or convince an enemy general to turncoat. Another thing means you can have independent agents pulling a Rudolf Hess and trying to make peace illegally by flying to the enemy nation, which you can use as propaganda to try and get an early war end or cause chaos in both nations or whatever.

The bones are in, I'm working on implementing the systems for agents right now, but I got pops and markets working somewhat. Unlike vicky II the markets don't crash after 100 years. I've already one up'd vicky III and most PDOX slop. Release is unknown, cause this is a hobby project. TL;DR, just don't load in everything at once if you can't run it, and load things in when you are looking at them/need them and then unload them into hard files, and you can get the ram requirements down a metric ton, and the game is just a bunch of math and seed based random/procedural rolls, so it literally flies with loading and unloading to and from ram. The entire universe is deterministic, and in my stress test on my shitbox, I can support ~200 billion star systems all moving and blowing up, and changing easy off this architecture, though I decided to cut scope to just the solar system for the demo. Also, PDOX literally triggers events month by month, and days are tactical subpulses. I'm just having the game be turn based and have all the subpulses calculated each turn. It's way less a headache this way and passing time x years is really fast.
>>
>>2520496
I said that terribly, but I just did a long coding session and it's 3:40 AM. Also expect the worst 2D graphics known to man (well, not space empires bad, but yeah), but I am trying to make the UI clean.
>>
>>2520497
I'll clarify that you can send the delegation with your demands, and the AI can respond and say sure or offer counter demands and they're received every month long turn. You can accept any time you feel like. The AI agents will probably not accept unless they feel like accepting, depends on who they are. In the Nazi genocidal empire example, they can adopt the no surrender type shit, but ocuppying everything will either cause them to sepuku, someone shoots them, a coup, or you capture them and ultimately your win condition here is to cause everyone to stop resisting. If you don't do it right, then yeah the dumbass chud genocidal folks can start a terrorist group and can literally attempt to produce weapons of mass destruction or whatever.
>>
>>2520498
Can you guess what famous mecha anime I'm pulling from for inspiration? Yeah it's gundam.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.