[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/x/ - Paranormal

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: shakyamuni-2-719x1024.jpg (331 KB, 719x1024)
331 KB JPG
can i archieve nirvana (ceasing of suffering) if i believe in an immortal self?
>>
No. You can't achieve nirvana while holding a false belief of that magnitude.
>>
>>43233243
is not a false believe though
>>
>>43232977
Not from a buddhist.
>>
File: lingpa.png (266 KB, 1079x1054)
266 KB PNG
>>43232977
Yes. Nirvana is just the mind snuffed out, which is the condition of the mind when one directly knows the Self. The issue is you keep fueling the mind. If you keep thinking this is real or that is unreal, you're going to keep fueling the mind. If you're meditating waiting to gain something wondering where this Self is, you're perpetuating samsara. Equally if you keep sitting there negating or believing there's nothing then you're perpetuating samsara. All beliefs, desires and aversions are given up when the mind is snuffed out.

>Yoga Sutras
>Yoga is the cessation of the modifications of the mind.
>Then the Seer abides in its own nature.
>At other times, the Seer identifies with the modifications of the mind.

>Katha Upanishad
>When the five organs of perception become still, together with the mind, and the intellect ceases to be active: that is called the highest state.

>Ariyapariyesana Sutta
>The stilling of all formations, the relinquishing of all acquisitions, the destruction of craving, dispassion, cessation, Nibbāna.

>Mūlamadhyamakakārikā
>Liberation is the cessation of all thought, the dissolution of all plurality.
>Emptiness is taught by the Buddhas as the relinquishing of all views. Those for whom emptiness itself is a view are said to be incurable.
>>
File: 1600020976212.jpg (538 KB, 750x941)
538 KB JPG
>>43232977
>what if I believe this, what if I believe that?
>what should I believe, I'm so concerned about beliefs?
Shut up and meditate, and practice compassion.
>>
>>43232977
At a certain point you will have to let go of all concepts and beliefs.
>>
Your true self is well hidden. Nirvana or blowing out is the removal of “blinders”.

You will have to let go of worldly concepts of what your self or true self is and once blinders are removed you will see and know without a doubt your true self. As it is, free from all earthly imposition and delusions.
>>
>>43233786
>>Yoga is the cessation of the modifications of the mind.
No it isnt. Yoga is union with the Supreme. There is no "cessation" in yoga, stop trying to merge buddhism back into what it left.
Nirodhah is better understood as stilling or controlling, not ceasing.
>>43232977
Just notice even as you say the truth, the buddhists will still just push and push and push for you to deny it.
>>
>>43233414
All beleif is false. Nirvana is literally accepting death in the materialist sense, and accepting the termination of consciousness and true obliviation.

If you cannot accept the concept of spiritual dissolution into true, everlasting, nonexistence, you will never reach nirvana(literally being ok with this)
>>
>>43234498
>everlasting
It cant be everlasting unless you are declaring this person already in what you said they can never reach.
>>
>>43234498
>All beleif is false
>ignores everything he believes
Let me guess, your beliefs like those you expressed after saying that aren't beliefs?
>>
>>43234787
>All beleif is false
Not that guy, but let me clarify.
Beliefs (especially the washy-washy metaphysical kind like the nature of the self) are irrelevant to the practice of dharma. Irrelevant at best, distracting at worst. They do you no harm, but won't do you any good either. The shiny red marble isn't any better than the shiny blue marble. They're just marbles. Thoughts in your head. And Nirvana isn't a marble. So stop playing with marbles and practice the dharma.
>>
>>43235555
>rambles off his beliefs
>>
>>43235616
You can accept them, you can reject them. You can take totally opposite beliefs. Just practice the dharma, and results will come. You don't have to believe this either.
>>
>>43232977
You know there are other systems which teach ways to enlightenment than Buddhism right. Not sure why you would cling to Buddhism specifically if you believe in an immortal self. Advaita, Neoplatonism, Hermeticism, etc would make more sense in that case.
>>
>>43233414
you're wrong
>>
>>43235555
based quads of truth

/thread
>>
>>43235818
because OP is a dumb underaged nigger who is too young to even be posting here and doesn't know what you're talking about/has never heard of those things before now
>>
>>43232977
The Buddha has taught of the existence of self as well as of the non-existence of self; He has also taught of neither self nor no self.
>>
File: Eye_of_Horus_bw.svg.png (72 KB, 2560x1970)
72 KB PNG
You possess your soul and your power – so says the Self-created to me. My soul cannot be grasped by the talons of the falcons, my soul cannot be seized by swine, my soul cannot be strangled by the serpents, my soul shall not be repelled by magic, my soul shall pass quietly by them until it enters into the shrine. My soul has taken possession of what is mine because I came into being in front of it; my soul grants me power over my foes, and I have expelled them from their tombs, I have overthrown them in their mansions, I have expelled those who are yonder from their seats, I have caused their dignities to pass away, I have destroyed their magic, I have cut off their powers.
>>
>>43235875
Don't knock OP too hard. If he actually is a young guy genuinelly interested in esoteric topics I'm happy to help (though he probablyhas abandoned the thread).
>>
>>43235778
>It wont be me adhering to a belief any more if I say it again
>>
File: s-l1200.jpg (129 KB, 787x1024)
129 KB JPG
>>43235875
>>43235935
i have been posting in /x/ the last 9 years
>>
>>43237726
Youve been here the last nine years and dont have an answer to that question?
>>
File: chakrasamvara-1M.jpg (1.46 MB, 798x1000)
1.46 MB JPG
>>43237747
i want to know /x/ opinion. i truly truly believe in an inmortal self and i believe that someone can overcome suffering but i don't think that is what we are supposed to do
>>
>>43235818
advaita is for niggers, neoplatonism is a bit more my thing, hermeticism doesn't mean anything. the reason why i choose asking this in regards to buddhism is because i find buddhism practice helpful. there is no neoplatonic practice or vedanta practice, it is mostly intelectual
>>
File: buddha on belief.jpg (78 KB, 509x570)
78 KB JPG
>>43236325
Do you believe the sky is blue? No? Then perhaps you should look up. Just like a vegetable grows from a seed and soil, so should belief be grown from practice and direct experience. Believe nothing. Practice.
>>
File: 14028_13of16.jpg (1.3 MB, 3200x4000)
1.3 MB JPG
>>43235870
no, you're wrong
>>
>>43237828
Believing in an immortal self is incompatible with Buddhist thought, regardless of whether you believe 'advaita is for niggers' or not that's probably what you want to research.
>>
>>43237828
>i want to know /x/ opinion.
Youve been here NINE YEARS and you couldnt say what /x/'s opinion on this was?
>i truly truly believe in an inmortal self and i believe that someone can overcome suffering
And again - NINE YEARS and you didnt realize the first thing someone would say by putting buddha as the image and that question would simply start an argument?


What you can do to sound like a rational person at this point is acknowledge how stupid that was, and how little you have progressed in NINE YEARS.
>>
>>43237847
>Do you believe the sky is blue?
Is the sky blue at night?
Is the sky blue at sunset?
Is the sky blue at sunrise?
Is the sky blue when overcast or raining?

The sky is more often NOT blue than blue.
Who told you otherwise, and you ignored your senses?
>>
>>43239371
obsessed
>>
File: one hand clapping.jpg (44 KB, 468x543)
44 KB JPG
>>43239376
>The sky is more often NOT blue than blue.
Technically correct, and deliberately misapprehensive.
>>
>>43239650
>tries to use a bit of dogmatic belief to show another person is buried in dogma
>gets mad when his example only shows that he is stuck in dogmatic thinking
>>
>>43237847
>Do you believe the sky is blue? No? Then perhaps you should look up. Just like a vegetable grows from a seed and soil, so should belief be grown from practice and direct experience. Believe nothing. Practice.
Nta, but my senses are measurably pretty bad at their job. Pretend I eat a spicy pepper, and my senses tell my mouth it is smoldering hot. If I stick a thermometer into my mouth, we can measure the temperature inside my mouth and find out my mouth is not on fire and is still as hot as anybody else's mouth.

So, which do I trust? My lying senses? Or the thermometer?

I can learn to juggle. I can explain how it's done, to a degree. But I do not really know how it is done. I, most likely, am incorrect if I think I do. I may know how to get the result of juggling in my instance. But that does not mean I have any idea what's going on. I could not sit you down and explain to you how to juggle and then have you be able to do it without any practice of your own. You might reach enlightenment, nirvana, whatever it is, but the silence of the yogis and sages of the past comes not from wisdom, but from ignorance. Enlightenment was, and still is, too complex a process to know well enough to teach it. They were excellent guides, and had much to say that's helpful, but that was all. We are, each of us, alone. From accepting that fact, practice makes sense. Knowledge and truth are a shared thing. They do not change depending on the observer. We are alone, so practice is all we have. Before you can get somebody to figure it out themselves, you need to stop pretending any of what you're asking them to do comes from fact. Science has not yet caught up. They are, actually, still in uncharted territory. As are you.
>>
>>43237828
Belief is the enemy of knowing. If you don't know your mind is creating fiction based on your desire. You "believe" in an immortal self because you're craving continuation to experience, to satisfy your desire, hoping there's an end to this suffering. Yet, you say the goal is not to end suffering.
Dukkha, ie "suffering", have a deeper meaning. It's more like a state of agitation, dissatisfaction, a constant chase. Just like we call ghosts restless spirits, because they're mentally stuck in their state of mind, perhaps not even knowing that they're dead.
Which is why a human birth is considered a rare gift that gives you the opportunity to think, learn and understand the mind.
And wasting that opportunity perusing material gains you won't carry with you beyond the grave. Indulging in hedonism and sense gratification that only give temporary relief and satisfaction, and more often than not will you get bored and seek new thrills to satisfy the endless hunger. Is but a fools errand, like a dog running in circles chasing its own tail.
>>
>>43241021
>Belief is the enemy of knowing.
Nonsense. Knowing is simply determination of the validity of a belief. You cannot even begin to know things without a prior belief.
>>
>>43232977
>still thinks having opinions matters
Leave the midwit realm and just practice daily
>>
>>43237851
its not even a belief
you're just autistic and have no self control or awareness
because you don't care and don't want to care
like every other low functioning "neurodivergent" faggot
you are incapable of masking it
this thread is not about your beliefs
it's about your autism and you coping with it
>>
>>43241021
>no immortal self

>won't carry things beyond the grave
>life is opportunity to learn

seems a bit like a contradiction here, as if one can take their knowledge or memories with them, but there is no such carrier of memories to be found

whatever individual progress you make here turns to dust, that's why >>43233787 seems to make the most sense in the end
>>
>>43245495
>"shut up" makes the most sense
Sure, once you give up.
>>
>>43245495
That depends on how we define an (unchanging independent) "immortal self". Based on things like near death experiences, ghosts etc. I think the evidence is supporting a continuation of existence after this physical life.

Does that mean it's what we define as Self lives on, or simply another layer of our body, like the astral, subtle and causal body? When we peel the layers of an onion do we eventually find a true independent onion?
>>
Words! Words!
The Way is beyond language,
Words never could, can not now, and never will describe the Way.
>>
>>43247610
Skill issue.
But why does it bother you that other people dont give up in describing it?
>>
>>43239776
Based answer, exactly this. All concepts and beliefs only have meaning because there is a reference point to compare themselves to. Spicy or hot only have meaning because they are compared to a baseline, in truth this is arbitrary, what is cold to one is hot to another.

Enlightenment is just a word, a label, but enlightenment is not enlightenment. At some point, terms fail, distinctions cease to matter. Buddhists who argue that there is no-self misquote the Buddha. Buddha simply stated that the truth was beyond category. All four views, whether there is self, where there is no-self, whether there is neither self nor no-self, where there is self and no-self, are all wrong. Eternal self and non-eternal self all make assumptions of the self, self being a product of space and time.

>>43237885
>Believing in an immortal self is incompatible with Buddhist thought

Completely wrong. It's not that it is incompatible, it is just not relevant to the practice of the dharma. Buddha himself famously refused to comment on whether there was an eternal self or a non-eternal self, comparing statements and beliefs on such a thing as wasting time. When one is hit with an arrow, the highest priority is taking the arrow out and closing the wound. Asserting that there is no-self or that there is an eternal self is like trying to figure out what material the arrow is made out of while you are bleeding out. Please stop misquoting the Buddha and misrepresenting Buddhism, it is embarrassing.
>>
>>43234498
Nirvana is beyond description, beyond space and time, beyond form. It is not accepting death, it is merely accepting that all that appears to the eye is dependent origination. There is no "dissolution", samsara is nirvana, nirvana is not nonexistence, the Buddha never said as such. The art of negation, of neti-neti, of anatta, is to define what nirvana isn't, not what nirvana is.

Please stop misrepresenting Buddhism. It honestly is dealing lots of damage to the dharma and the spread of it. You preach against dogmatism using dogmatism; do you not see the irony?
>>
>>43232977
Nope, that's something God has appointed for a specific time: “And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain: for the former things are passed away.” (Revelation of John 21:4)
>>
>>43250666
>All concepts and beliefs only have meaning because there is a reference point to compare themselves to. Spicy or hot only have meaning because they are compared to a baseline, in truth this is arbitrary, what is cold to one is hot to another.
Well yes. Lots of words like that are subjective and arbitrary. But that's besides what I meant when I spoke of spicy or high temperature. What is ninety degrees to one person is still ninety degrees to another. The temperature being measured doesn't change depending on who's looking at it. Spicyness does. Our senses are far more arbitrary than our artifical tools. Human senses cannot be depended on to give us the truth, because that's not what they're built for.

>Enlightenment is just a word, a label, but enlightenment is not enlightenment. At some point, terms fail, distinctions cease to matter.
At which point I lose interest, because the messager becomes the message. There's nothing actually being told to me.

>All four views, whether there is self, where there is no-self, whether there is neither self nor no-self, where there is self and no-self, are all wrong
I can't see how they could all be wrong. But they're definitely not very important.
>Buddha simply stated that the truth was beyond category
I remain unconvinced, because technology has yet to advance. I'd bet it's certainly beyond any category our minds can create as they are right now without the brain microchips. And this is not crazy or mystical. There's lots of things like that, such as juggling or breathing or peeing. I can't yet explain how to do those things without leaving out the majority of the task, that must be learned by practice or intuition.
>>
>>43250666
>>43250999
Wtf are these digits lol. That's crazy.
>>
>>43250999
>ninety degrees
Still an arbitrary definition, just like how we all agree the sky is "blue", labeling an arbitrary chosen electromagnetic wavelength frequency
with an arbitrarily chosen label.

Doesn't matter how much people agree on a label or the measurement scheme, all our human lives are subjective interpretations of "objective" data. The temperature measurement system is an agreed upon method, but in the end, temperature is subjectively experienced.

>There's nothing actually being told to me.
Yes, all is dependent origination, messenger and message assumes subject object differentiation.

>they're definitely not very important.
Ye

>technology has yet to advance
Technology has always been advancing. But the state space is infinite. If you know of Godel's incompleteness theorem, you will understand the folly of assuming any sufficiently advanced technological system can capture and distill the truth into propositional statements
>>
>>43250666
>All concepts and beliefs only have meaning because there is a reference point to compare themselves to.
That's a rather stupid weay to put it. This "reference point" is simply the state of being aware.
You try to make it some polarizing hot/cold thing, but an awareness can become aware of sensation without EVER having any other reference.
The only "baseline" is just being.
>>
>>43250666
>When one is hit with an arrow
Buddhism disagrees you were hit with an arrow, and say arrows are illusion.
>>
>>43251025
>Still an arbitrary definition, just like how we all agree the sky is "blue", labeling an arbitrary chosen electromagnetic wavelength frequency
>with an arbitrarily chosen label.
The same temperature can be expressed both in Celsius or Fahrenheit, but it's still the same temperature. The label is chosen arbitrarily, but the actual thing being measured does not change.
>Doesn't matter how much people agree on a label or the measurement scheme, all our human lives are subjective interpretations of "objective" data. The temperature measurement system is an agreed upon method, but in the end, temperature is subjectively experienced.
If temperature were fundamentally a subjective experience, then we'd expect it to change depending on who is experiencing it. Yes, the labels change. But any attempt to quantify the temperature, all I'd need is a conversion rate to get their label back to Fahrenheit and we'd verifiably have the same thing.

> If you know of Godel's incompleteness theorem, you will understand the folly of assuming any sufficiently advanced technological system can capture and distill the truth into propositional statements
Godel did not prove anything supernatural or not expressable with words. He didn't somehow destroy the validity of all propositional statements. He just proved that any formal system as it is now has blind spots, because it only has a finite amount of rules.

If the only rules in my system are: "stop when red go when green, and decide when yellow." Then if the stoplight shuts off, it's true I need to do something, but I'd have no way to prove it's the correct course of action with just my system. I'd need to add to it, and even then blindspots exiar. This is what Godel was saying in a nutshell.

There are a finite amount of neurons in my brain and muscles for it. Juggling or even enlightenment could hypothetically be put to a disgusting number of words with the correct tools, and then read with the correct tools(a brain chip)



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.