>>289263035
Yep, new show is shit.

The film from 1995 was for adults. The new anime is for 10yo children. Simple as that.

File: 1762570394472363.png (136 KB, 500x500)

136 KB PNG

You're telling me a tv anime looks worse than a movie? Woah...

>they both look fine
OP is a faggot

So what third-word country the new GITS anime triggered?

>>289263157
3 fucking DECADES to git gud and they didn't
PATHETIC

File: 0rr7qakfg3l91.png (173 KB, 747x420)

173 KB PNG

>>289263157
An argument can be made that you don't need movie budget to have proper lighting, anatomy, and shot composition.

>>289263373
everything you just listed doesn't happen without budget dumbass

>>289263373
Is 4chan just rehashing xitter posts now? Was 70 updoots not enough and now you want (you)s?

>>289263418
>Drawing skills somehow depend on budget. I have 140 IQ.

>>289263035
background of the shot where she fades out is the only really egregious thing

>>289263035
>cel is better than digital
shocking

>>289263373
>he thinks his fancy movie underlighting didn't take a fuckton more time for inbetweener-kun to draw compared to the standard tv lighting
tourist-kun, i....

File: 1780182617755660.png (389 KB, 1531x539)

389 KB PNG

>>289263060
It's what I expected, I'm liking it but mostly as a jogger for what I have vague memories in the manga. It sticking closely to the manga was a point of concern to me as it was always the weakest of all the iterations I've seen/read so far(except for the live action attempt).
The reality of it is that the true geniuses behind the franchise have always been Oshii and Kamiyama.

>>289263035
Soul vs soulless

>>289263792
The 95 film is just a dumbed down version of the manga.

>>289263035
Movie is grey and nobody smiles.

>>289263482
They're almost entirely reliant on budget.
There is no such thing as a cheap anime that looks good.

>>289263602
That entire scene is covered in CGI

File: 1759749606402153.png (182 KB, 310x493)

182 KB PNG

>>289263846
It removed most of the cartoonish goofyness and tied together multiple arcs into a single story rather well. Hardly dumbed down.

>>289263915
It removes the entire point of the Puppeteer's scheme, and the spiritual aspects of technology are reduced to just, "technology replacing humanity", which is contrary to the comic.

>>289263857
and that's a good thing.

>comparing a movie to a seasonal TV anime

>>289263035
Jesus Christ, panning is the lost technique now? Or the idea was to turn anime into animated panels? This looks static as hell

>>289264038
Anon, the issue here not with the budget or animation but with jarring direction, the scene isn't smooth

>>289263035
1995 will never be topped so...

>>289263747
>both look great
these people are blind, also kys for posting shitter screencaps

>>289263035
'95 looks way too beautiful

>>289263035
modern animators are so creatively bankrupt in utilization of layouts despite all the advancements with the CGI and dynamic camera that it is just sad. Even worse is how the anime fans who are eating this up with muh 90s lineart aesthetic when it's just display of limited skillet with filters doing the job.

File: 1711804436233.jpg (315 KB, 1800x900)

315 KB JPG

>>289263035
I saw this shit on xitter, you're not baiting anybody here, fuck off

>>289263373
who watches anime for proper anatomy? what a stupid claim to make

File: [4chan] Dangaioh 01 [Bdri(...).mp4 (3.33 MB, 720x576)

3.33 MB MP4

>>289264487
>Standard interior scene in 1987

>>289264766
the jap they all sound like teenagers, and in the dub they all sound like teenagers.
the fuck happened.

File: [4chan] The Ghost In The (...).mp4 (3.73 MB, 1280x720)

3.73 MB MP4

>>289264487
>>289264774
>40 years later...

File: 1374641915912.jpg (119 KB, 1280x720)

119 KB JPG

>>289264774
>It's ALWAYS some retard who doesn't understand the difference between OVA and TV budgets

>>289264774
>Bunch of static nonsense scribbles.
>>289264803
>Dynamic practical sets and lighting.
What's your point exactly?

>>289264849
>Acts like Science SARU was Madhouse or Toei to display superiority
You are not fooling anybody.

>>289264803
what was the point of the open jaw? was she VR fellating BBC in her downtime?

>>289264871
To display your fucking monkey IQ. And it worked beyond hope.

>>289264989
Safety feature. If she malfunctions and shuts down, you do not want her mouth to default to shut closed.

>>289264774
There is almost no animation here.

>>289264803
This is far more complex and interesting.
Why the fuck would you compare slow pans >>289264774 to an actually well animated scene?

>>289263035
Why even make a new one if you're just going to reuse the material from the original?

>>289263747
>it looked great
It's a power point presentation.

>>289266736
Because the one doing the slow panning is eye candy while the other looks like cheap slop you can find anywhere.

>>289264774
>>289265025
This is embarrassing anon, even Otaking no longer showing retardation like what you're doing anymore.

>>289266912
It isn't eye candy at all.

>>289266912
>cheap slop you can find anywhere
post 10.

>>289263915
it literally ended up on a
>to be continued (get fucked lmao)

>>289264512
>you're not baiting anybody here
'erybody's getting baited

>>289263857
The future supposed to be bleak and full of unhappiness. That's the reason why GITS 95 was interesting and unique. Oshii work is just absolutely amazing.

File: 1781397228773054.jpg (21 KB, 475x416)

21 KB JPG

>>289267268
>A bleak and unhappy future is unique
>Imagining this would be unique in 1995

File: file.png (803 KB, 1020x1444)

803 KB PNG

Apprently during early production of SAC, they actually considered drawing Motoko in her classic manga style

>>289263060
Shit can be useful as fertilizer, this is worse than shit.

>>289263964
>the entire point of the Puppeteer's scheme
Is that they want to fuck an adapter just like the prequel robot

>>289263035
Imagine watching nu-anime

>>289263964
it doesn't amd you're a moron that can't pay attention to consecutive lines of dialogue all at once for thinking it does

>>289267529
A shame they didn't went with it. It would've killed all the retards who think Motoko needs to be an emotionless robot.

File: [Erai-raws] Koukaku Kidou(...).jpg (473 KB, 1920x1080)

473 KB JPG

>>289263035
I'm mostly okay with it. There's some nitpicks that are mostly personal preference.
Only thing I take issue with is showing the walls are digital at the start. The coolest part of the movie's opening scene was when the "fish tank" exploded.

File: 123421421521.jpg (14 KB, 193x197)

14 KB JPG

>>289263035
> why does a TV anime have lesser animation quality than a big budget anime movie??
Not to mention they're both going for entirely different aesthetics/tones.

>>289267268
It hits too close to home in 2026 though.,

>>289264989
I assume her whole body is just sitting there slack until someone activates her. Not really much point in keeping her looking nice and 'normal' when no ones there to see/talk to her.

>>289268249
My attitude about cyberpunk completely changed when I realized the grim dystopia the authors were writing about wasn't a prediction. They were describing the world as it already was.

>>289263035
I like the old school style but the pacing was schizophrenic dogshit

>>289268868
Pacing was perfect.

>>289268868
it's a 90s movie
80s movies were worse
especially live action
go watch Jin-Roh and then Kerberos Panzer Cops
you'll be wishing everything had the tight pacing of animation

File: a.jpg (432 KB, 1280x1829)

432 KB JPG

>>289263035
>that little hand wipe cloaking her face is in the layout
Actual genius shit.

>>289264774
SOVL

>>289264803
Lame B-tier scene that I will have forgotten in 20 minutes

OLD GOOD
NEW BAD

>>289267784
You're a pissant. I got kinda mojor Lupin the 3rd vibes from this thing. I didn't even know it was coming down the pipe, didn't know what to expect. It threw me for a loop, but it wasn't shit.

Thing I don't get is why Togusa was there. I was under the impression that he was a fairly new join to Section 13, unmodded, all that, since I basically grew up with SAC.

>>289269051
*major

File: 1756611397080559.png (1.65 MB, 1456x2048)

1.65 MB PNG

Jannies...

>>289269032
We can also discuss composition, artistic direction, character designs, lightning or framing, if you are interested. But I suspect that you are just a seething normgroid hurt by different opinions.

>>289269158
And I suspect your opinion on all of them will be
>the old one is better because it's old
>I only like realistic shit and anything actually stylized is bad

>>289269158
Lighting and art direction is stronger in the new version.

File: 1765133951471185 old good(...).webm (3.19 MB, 720x885)

3.19 MB WEBM

>>289269158
You're a nigger who will said:
>top is better because it has "SOVL".

>>289269227
>Lighting and art direction is stronger in the new version
No.

>>289269342
Its not pallid and lifeless.

>>289269227
>Believes that lens flares are good lighting

>>289269274
Both scenes are mediocre for different reasons. Only a fucking tourist would be impressed by the new version. It's artistic horseshit, and this "clever" comparison simply proves that your tastes are awful. Fuck off.

>>289263035
I dont get why this is making so many people upset. 95 obviously looks way better, not something to be ashamed of though

>>289269498
>believes that using cold tones is mature

>>289269556
Cattle niggers are upset that the things that they adore from their childhood is turn out to be inferior compared to the modern product.

>>289263373
you need a movie budget to have more time to take care on details yes. What is this sudden pajeet posting logic? When did /a/ of all place got filled with drooling retards with no knowledge on the matter like that? we aren't getting grok peasants take over animation technical discussion thanks.

>>289264487
Unironically gigakino

>>289263035
Characters on the left look too goofy. Like some generic pokemon crap.

>>289269637
A lot of people come from the video game world where there is a world of difference between what devs could do in the 90s and today.
But for animation, the difference is far less substantial and they don't realize that.
It's still fundamentally a very similar production cycle. Even more so regarding GITS 95, as that was an early adopter of various CGI and digital coloring and compositing methods.

Shit, a large amount of modern anime is still hand drawn on paper in many cases.

>>289269674
They're drawn in a style that existed in anime a decade before Pokemon
Maybe two decades, I disremember