[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Fullmetal123.jpg (124 KB, 252x396)
124 KB JPG
This is the most overrated anime/manga in existence.
>>
Funnyschizo thread.
>>
>>289390628
Berserk is considerably worse
its average score on all sites went up by 1+ when Miura died because people felt bad for him, it was insane
>>
yawn. the shota stash is on the next alley, funnyschizo
>>
>>289390628
True. It's one of the most basic shit I have ever watched, and only the most normalfags among the otaku like it.
>>
>>289390628
No, that would be Monogatari
>>
>>289391601
Nah, Monogatari has good visual direction and characters with some depth, FMA and Berserk are respectively very simple or flawed, they are overrated because they are easy to consume unlike Monogatari
>>
File: MAL.png (106 KB, 546x743)
106 KB PNG
>>289390628
I assume you are referring to this list
Then let me ask you, is there ANY anime you wouldn't consider "overrated" if it were at the top of this list?
>>
>>289391720
Steins Gate and Death Note would deserve to be at the top of the list.
>>
https://desuarchive.org/a/search/image/l8S6uiAFA6uIR9EZVh4X1Q/
just one of many
>>
>>289391939
What's this link supposed to prove
Most of those results are aggressively shilling it
>>
>>289390628
adulthood is realizing that doesn't mean it's not good
>>
>>289391809
Steins;Gate doesn't even deserve to be in the top 100, terrible opinion.
>>
>>289391720
The only anime that deserve to be there are Gintama and HxH. Maybe Jojo if the adaptation is good.
The rest is genuine dogshit
>>
>>289390628
Overrated in terms of humor especially, mfs LOVE go on and on about how it's SOOO funny.
>>
>>289393871
gintama is filler garbage with thr same gags over and over again. hxh only has one good arc. jojo is garbage, the only good thing are the drawings, and the studio is bad at that. the only decent anime here are fma and steins but those arent top 100 anime
>>
>>289390628
>most overrated
This can't be so long as the mouth-breathing knuckle dragging species of germ known as one piece fans exist
>>
>>289391720
>MALfags are subhuman, more news at 5:00.
>>
>>289391720
>not a single good anime or movie
I'm not a contrarian, but it's true, this is garbage
>>
>>289391809
Steins gayte is awful though
>>
>>289390628
That would be freiren
>>
>>289391809
Add code geass
>>
>>289391720
All shit except The Chainsaw Man movie.
>>
someone post crocodile ed, that shit was mad funny
>>
>>289396635
loser
>>
>>289394368
>>289395516
both are garbage. fujimoto ruined his career
>>
>>289391720
None of those deserve more than a 6/10. Top 10 my ass.
>>
File: IMG_3519.png (394 KB, 590x1178)
394 KB PNG
>>289390628
>>
>>289391720
Only CSM deserves a spot there.
HxH's manga is top tier but the anime is not top 10 anime material.
Similar discourse for Jojo.
FMA, Steins Gate, Re:Zero are literally plebbitslop.
Gintama is ok but as an anime still not near top tier.
Frieren is a good anime, top 30 material, definitely not top 1.
Shingeki's first 2 seasons are great, idk why it's season 3 the highest there.
Where's shit like Perfect Blue, Eva, End of Eva, Spirited Away, The Wind Rises, Porco Rosso, GITS, the actual good anime series and movies?
>>
>>289390628
Thats not steins;gate.
>>
>>289398635
Csm is garbage and part 2 ruined the franchise. The film and the character of Reze have 0 (zero) impact on the story, and as a self-contained film it leaves much to be desired.

The HxH manga has terrible paneling and poor artwork on several occasions; the anime at least has a memorable soundtrack, I wouldn't say it's worse.
>>
File: 0095-018.jpg (235 KB, 1067x1600)
235 KB JPG
>>289398773
>The HxH manga has terrible paneling
You absolutely have zero clue about what you're talking about.
HxH's manga is a classic and a favorite of pretty much the majority of the most famous mangakas.
CSM part 2 has no impact on the quality of the movie.
>>
>>289391720
Titanbros...we lost to Chenso...
>>
>>289391720
How the actual fuck is Re:Zero up there now lmao, that shit is fucking awful. Only S;G and the bad parts of Gintama come close to being as bad.
>>
File: 1777175946969.jpg (244 KB, 1912x995)
244 KB JPG
>>289390628
>Aw sweet an FMA thread
>FMA not discussed at all
Sheeeeeeit
>>
File: topgashi.png (409 KB, 757x653)
409 KB PNG
>>289398904
Part 2 impacted the franchise as a whole; it broke the entire story. Likewise, Reze has zero impact on the first part. I don't care that HxH is the favorite manga of four Jumpfaggots; besides, you know that's not a compliment, there are few good manga/mangaka. That pic doesn't have remarkable panneling; I said that on several occasions it's been mediocre, and that's true (the walls of text...), and the art is super inconsistent. There isn't a single battle shonen that stands out if we're talking about a "top of the medium."
>>
>>289398904
Does hxh get really good? I stopped reading during the green island cuz that was absolute trash
>>
>>289398904
Hunter x Hunter has functional paneling, but it's incredibly inconsistent, as the other anon mentioned. There are worse manga with better paneling.
>>
>>289399215
Yes, Chimera Ant arc is great but the rest is not very good except some parts of the Yorknew Arc
>>
>>289391653
Pretending Monogatari has any kind of depth is funny
>>
>>289390628
a shitload of milennials happened to see this when they were growing up just at the right time so it imprinted on them. also it helps that it's one of the only pieces of media in existence that got a remake that legitimately addressed flaws in the original and made it better. personally i don't find it really compelling, the original was such dogshit i dropped it completely, brotherhood was good enough for me to finish and i'll say it's a solid 8/10 just because some of the characters were so fun (although the elrics themselves were pretty boring.)
>>
>>289390628
That's Chainsawman with its retarded fandom
>>
>>289390628
So? It's still really good.
>>
>>289390628
Sorry but not sorry. In the age of broccoli hairs, where genuine subhuman slop like KnY, JJK or Frienen is still considered "good" or "good enough" (or "bestest MAL anime" or something for Frieren specifically), anyone who even dares to bring up FMA is a guaranteed subhuman brownoid himself.
>>
>>289398904
People have legit no idea what good paneling is.
They'll post 1 gimmicky panel like this >>289399219 and tell you X manga has "great paneling" because of it.
They don't care to see how the size of the panels impacts the scenes, or how the panels are placed in regards to the pacing and dialogue and emotions of the characters. They want to see le gimmick cool paneling that happens in that one page in that one chapter, instead of the paneling in the span of the whole manga.
Anyway, this is no manga thread, it's a FMA anime/MAL thread, it's normal it will attract gigaretards, especially in this day and age.
>>
>>289399219
>art-a-few-instances-of-really-creative-manga-panelling-v0-9p91rufjy0y71.jpg
Filename straight out of plebbit lmao
>>
>>289390628
Frieren and S;G are more overrated.
>>
>>289399332
>got a remake that legitimately addressed flaws in the original and made it better
That's not really true. The manga was made before the 2003 anime.
>original was such dogshit i dropped it completely
You have shit taste.
>>
>>289399475
No, it isn't.
>>
>>289401000
k
>>
File: fma ending.jpg (26 KB, 499x283)
26 KB JPG
>>289391538
>aksually well tough out world-building
>complex characters but doesn't le hecking pikle rick everything is meaningless
>mc learns and grows throughout his journey manages to get back his loss by sacrificing his isekay powers
Yeah, I understand how it would go over your head.
>>
>>289401379
>ESL
>pickle rick reference
You proved his point.
>>
>>289391720
Everything in the top 5 is complete slop, MAL opinions are cancer as usual.
>>
>>289390628
FMA is good so no.
>>
>>289402388
It isn't. You just have shit taste.
>>
>>289391809
>Steins Gate and Death Note would deserve to be at the top of the list
lmao get some taste fag.
>>
>>289390628
>funny.jpg
>>
>>289390628
Wrong, that's One Piece
>>
>>289390628
Berserk and One Piece are far more overrated.
>>
>>289400846
This.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.