[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Does /a/ still remember it?
>>
File: images(2).jpg (20 KB, 588x330)
20 KB JPG
>>
Probably not huh
>>
Only the puke gif as cum
>>
>>
>>
File: 1751074974461.png (669 KB, 730x751)
669 KB PNG
>>
File: images(1).jpg (29 KB, 588x330)
29 KB JPG
>>
File: 1778194798874807.jpg (56 KB, 625x625)
56 KB JPG
>>
>>
what's with the pic spam
>>
>>289520175
how common its too have an idol doppelganger?
>>
I remember the studio that made it.
>>
some things are better left alone
>>
>>289518711
Most oldfags are still bitter about the ending, and put off newfags from picking up the series or continuing with the manga if they're anime onlies.
>>289520186
OP, or the anon in question, is unaware of there being a board for such content >>>/c/.

It's been years since the last Urabe thread, so I'm sure a dump would be welcome there.
>>
File: 1711242846649.png (414 KB, 446x845)
414 KB PNG
>>289518711
I read the manga a long time ago and I watched the anime like a month ago.
I had this mandela effect notion that urabe was confirmed to be an alien in the manga. I guess it's a pretty easy conclusion to draw to but it's kinda weird that I was so sure of it being the case.
>>
It was fun but the ending sucked
>>
I wish they still designed girls like this, and with the classic serafuku.
>>
>>289520683
I still don't understand why people hate the ending. Even on a surface level you're basically complaining that "I was promised to see them have sex and reach some ultimate conclusion" when that's a really shallow complaint that ignores the author's actual intentions. Even on a shallow reading it's probably one of the most competent romance manga ever made, it applies tropes and subverts them expertly. But beyond that as far as I can tell the real ideas behind the manga is that it's psychosexual exploration perhaps influenced by jung or other psycho-analysts. If you read dream chasers he mentions jungian sand play and seems to explore other archetypal stuff along those lines like the perfect hermaphrodite. The theme of ookumo-chan flashback is your relationship to your parents (what does your parents relationship say about you), yume tsukkai is more about the self which is why it especially goes after dreams. In mysterious girlfriend x, Urabe is an anima character that Tsubaki begins to integrate and grow with. It's all suggestive. It is "hinted" that she's an alien but she herself explicitly says she isn't. Real girls already are weird. Of course, Urabe is intentionally unrealistic for the most part. She's simply too cool with too many boundaries and intelligence and creativity. She represents more like the unconscious. MGX is an extremely competent surface level romance story with deeper ideas that are worth thinking about.
>>
File: 1763979419241753.png (1.21 MB, 1920x1080)
1.21 MB PNG
>>289518711
Urabe a cute, but I prefer Oka
>>
File: 1517939918361.png (367 KB, 532x398)
367 KB PNG
>>289523012
That page in particular is what comes to mind when someone makes the argument of the ending being shit, or lacking catharsis.

I hadn't thought to look at the story, or any of the author's other works, under a psychoanalytic lens. What are some concepts or literature I should read up to find any connections made? Whether they're intentional, or purely incidental.

>Real girls already are weird
I suppose the initial concept of her being an ayy lmao was scrapped in favor of a more mundane allusion to the differences between the sexes, and its exacerbation during one's youth and during one's first relationship.
>>
>>289523265
I'm currently attempting to write a review about this. He mentions what books he's been reading throughout the manga so I've been looking been looking back through and writing them down among other things. It just sort of clicked for me one day after pouring over his other manga. His detailed dream landscapes, obsession with material culture, the concepts that he covers in his manga. I really don't know much about jung I intend to read a few books, he could have gotten it from some other psycho-analyst or something I'm not sure. He definitely likes movies like kubrick and history, he references strange love and 2001 a space odyssey in MGX as posters and a name for a train in the dream.
>>
>>289523012
They didn't kiss which was weird. And it burned out it's gimmick pretty quick.
>>
>>289520683
I dropped the manga during the movie arc, holy shit that dragged on forever.
>>
Personally I just want to know what her pubes are like
>>
>>289523324
>I'm currently attempting to write a review about this
Sounds like a potentially interesting read. Do you have a personal website, or do you just plan on making a post here or on some forum?
>>
>>289524306
I'll probably post it on anilist.
>>
>>289523012
I'll think about it
>>
>>289518711
I remember how to take a screenshot.
>>
>>289520175
>850x689
>>
>>289523012
You probably have a point but I'm not reading a shitbrick this dense.
>>
File: IGNORETHIS.png (615 KB, 1675x1200)
615 KB PNG
>>289523012
Premise -> Resolution of premise [story ended]
Premise -> No resolution of premise [story is not ended]

You can't lie to your audience about your premise.
>>
File: Dance.jpg (153 KB, 736x527)
153 KB JPG
I honestly wish he kept doing drugs until the end of this series. As soon as he went sober he didn't have the balls to complete the original intention.
>>
>>289518711
my wife crook is based on her, so yeah i remember it
>>
i remember how shit it is
no hole is worth that much simping
>>
>>289523012
>>289523265
The manga is shit because it's simp garbage for spineless faggots.
>bUt i hAvE tO pSyChOaNaLyZe iT
>>
>>289523012
>Even on a shallow reading it's probably one of the most competent romance manga ever made
Holy shit you are fucking warped.
>>
Uh oh, melty
>>
>>289518711
I actually read it just last month. Easily one of my favourite romance manga.
I love Youko. She's such a sweetheart.
>>
>>289525843
Uh oh, sexless simp
>>
>>289518711
Yeah, it's great, only midwits hate it
>>
>>289525843
>didn't tag the post
coward
>>
>>289525619
There's an implied resolution in that Urabe's relationship with Tsubaki parallels (in some part) Youko's relationship with her boyfriend back during her schooldays. While Youko's relationship with her boyfriend was serious, it ultimately fell through due to distance and tapering communication, even though they were arguably closer and slightly further along in their relationship (affection-wise) than Urabe and Tsubaki's.

Urabe makes the proclamation to Youko that she'd like to continue being with Tsubaki. She also mentions at some point wanting a sister like her too. The main pair's bond goes beyond physical skinship, and sometimes even surpasses it through Urabe's weird acts of intimacy.

There's also the fact that the author resolves the question of the future of their relationship--albeit, in a rather half-assed way--in Ookumo-chan flashback, by having the pair parodied by two characters part of a manga within the series. That, I will admit, was a mistake. He could have just done a canon one page resolution in a similar vein desu.

>>289525919
The whole "THEY DIDN'T HAVE SEX, SO IT SUCKS!" argument just comes off as low-brow complaints from sex pests. There are many issues with the series--as with most other romance series--yet the matter of them not having had sex by the series' end just seems like an odd fixation on a set of lines that were made in the one-shot.

The author should've used an entirely different set of lines, seeing as how it would come back to bite him in the ass. Actually, I'm curious what the original Japanese text says (though I assume it's more or less the same).
>>289525644
He (probably) didn't do drugs, he just got old.
>>
>>289523427
Really? I read it in one sitting. Quite a thrilling arc imo.
>>
>>289526826
You can't read it in one sitting if you're reading the chapters as they release, you mongoloid.
>>
>>289526848
Ah, I see. Yeah, reading ongoing romance manga is a drag.
So go binge MGX. It's good.
>>
File: Brown_bitch.jpg (1.05 MB, 1920x2173)
1.05 MB JPG
>>289526192
Just one question; Did they ever kiss in the manga?
>>
>>289518711
The only thing I remember about it aside from the general premise is this theme from a dream sequence in the show:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1sBxKh54Xzw
Absolutely beautiful
>>
>>289518711
I jerk off to Urabe NTR about every other day. Not even a joke, I think she's perfect for it
>>
>>289520186
4chan is an imageboard
>>
File: 1768584610975207.png (811 KB, 827x1169)
811 KB PNG
>>
File: 1761248399420.jpg (102 KB, 736x1288)
102 KB JPG
>>289523060
>>289527270
Wasted design in a crappy show
>>
>>289527021
post the page
>>
>>289522376
>>289520683
What was wrong with the ending? I don’t remember it
>>
File: 1760455900126356.jpg (1.42 MB, 2209x3745)
1.42 MB JPG
>>
>>289527929
>>289527966
The blueball of all time
>>
>>289518711
Ruined the specialness of spit swapping when she started sharing it with her girl friend. Deflated the magic for me
>>
>>289528785
That still pisses me off. You built up the entire Manga to that point and you just don't. You fucking coward.
>>
>>289523012
>that's a really shallow complaint that ignores the author's actual intentions
I'd still resent the author for kicking me in the balls even if he intended to kick me in the balls.
>>
>>289529224
Then he goes to fuck up an Oedipus manga.
>>
>>289523012
Embarrassing post



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.