[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1471180091256.jpg (1.51 MB, 3767x2218)
1.51 MB JPG
Do you miss the battle harem magic highschool era of the early 2010s?
>>
Obviously
>>
>>290491112
No. Most Isekai are magic highschool harems, how are you fags feeling nostalgic for something that hasn't gone away?
>>
>>290491112
They weren't precisely masterpieces, but I take them to the whole isekai shit of today.
>>
anal with Tohka
>>
>>290491184
No, most isekai are european medieval fantasy worlds with game stats, battle harems were Harry Potter wannabes with a Japanese flavor.
>>
>>290491112
No they're just as shit if not worse and more cliche as moden isekai that replaced them. Anyone who thinks they're not both garbage is just nostalgic for threads rather than the shows.
>>
>>290491519
Can you name some examples? Out of curiosity.
>>
No.
They were garbage then and they are garbage now.
>>
>>290491112
Yes.
>>
>>290491112
How many of these are even worth watching
>>
>>290492107
Rakudai has good action scenes; Color Wars is a schizo show which was fun to discuss back then; Shinmai Maou is practically a soft hentai; DxD is kinda overhyped but it's likely the most memorable of the entire list.
>>
>>290491184
Completely different.
>>
>>290491112
No
>>
>>290492273
Color Wars has amazing girls.
>>
>>290492273
DxD is fun, the problem is that the show tries to depict Issei as a horndog who loves breasts but then refrain from have him get intimate with his harem. I'll never understand this.
>>
>>290491112
Bahamut was the best because it had the perflat blue haired girl.
>>
>>290491184
It was a lot easier to find magic high school battle harems with well-realized characters and plots than naroushit, which typically feel like they were written by aliens who have never spoken to a human before, and the magic systems are more believable than the literal video game mechanics that have been standardized today.

>>290492107
>>290492273
Also, DAL is the best on the list by far, but move to the LNs after season 2. Strike the Blood, LNs after season 1. Mahouka isn't a harem at all, but it's still very good and the protagonist is gigabased. HxH is even more softcore porn than Shinmai.
>>
File: Kippu art evolution.jpg (3.07 MB, 3270x2309)
3.07 MB JPG
>>290491112
Kind of but also not really.
>>
Hmm, no.
>>
>>290491519
It's not the same, they don't have that 2010s energy.
>>
File: 1425962548981.jpg (321 KB, 1200x1000)
321 KB JPG
>>290491112
Absolutely not. Give me back my moeshit era.
>>
>>290493712
Moeshit never went away
>>
>>290491112
School setting is the worst so no.
>>
>>290491112
No, kill yourself.
>>
>>290493809
True, CGDCT shows are still made these days.
>>
>>290491201
Based ORDINARYbro.
>>
>>290491112
No but it's too bad that it's replacement is even worse.
>>
>>290492376
For me it's Green > Purple > Dark Green > Yellow > Blue > Red
>>
>>290491112
Yes. I would give anything to get back the color coded battle harem stuff compared to the endless train of “how I went to another world and became a corn farmer” type shows
>>
lol
>>
>>290494790
What the fuck is Zeref doing there? He's not a hatem protagonist.
Also the guy in the second row in the middle is not even the main character, he's the best friend of the main character.
>>
>>290491112
Fuck the bitch from Strike the Blood always saying "ie, senpai, this is our fight".
>>
>>290491112
I stayed far away from these. I watched 1 episode of Absolute Duo and it was one of the most boring things ever, and a couple episodes of DxD which couldn't hold my interest even as a horny teenager.
>>
>>290491112
I blame battle harems for people turning against tsunderes
>>
>>290495207
Nah. It was the SJW/Anti Sjw backlash of the 10s that did that. People couldn’t separate it from angry women irl
>>
>>290495191
To be fair Absolute Duo is considered bad even by those who like battle harems.
>>
>>290495221
That shit didn't touched japan until a decade later and they started hating on tsunderes before the west
>>
>>290491201
looks like shit
>>
>>290491112
hell no
>>
>>290491112
I don’t mind the others, but I kinda wanna forget Infinite Stratos was a thing.
>>
>>290491112
This is such a frustrating genre, in theory it sounds great but no one ever did anything interesting with it
>>
>>290494790
Kirito-cosplayer isn't even the MC
>>
>>290491112
No. 98/100 times there wasn't really a harem and usually the girls were recycled archetypes.
>>
>>290491184
You don't get it, because you weren't born yet.
>>
>>290495667
It depends. Pilot Candidate was sort of an interesting premise for it, but most of them were very risk-averse, unimaginative, and didn't even get a conclusion.
>>
>>290495207
Louise did that all by herself.
>>
>>290491112
At the end of the day these shows were good (?) for one thing and one thing only: sustained waifu wars. None of it matters once the show ends and nobody remembers it for anything else.
>>
>>290495207
Blame Narusegawa
>>
>>290491112
Yes, I miss it. They were fun.
Asterisk War was my favorite.
>>
>>290491201
style is an upgrade over the first season
>>
>>290495207
That's not because of battle harems but rather years of shitty writing where tsundere was a synonym for "massive bitch"
>>
File: vanadis.jpg (123 KB, 592x841)
123 KB JPG
>>290491112
No, but I would have liked more shows like Vanadis.
>>
>>290496371
Honestly not really. Majority of them were just "what if teenagers had magic powers and there was zero effects on civilisation from this" lazy kind of writing where most of the drama came from the cast walking in on each others showering because locks haven't been invented yet. Only redeeming quality was from discussions and memes while they were airing.
>>
>>290491112
I need my Seirei Tsukai S2.
>>
Never understood why the studios didnt join forces to give us the best of everyrhing possible for one or two shows, i miss ovas. The stories were very similar.
>>
File: IMG_0541.jpg (2.15 MB, 1502x2147)
2.15 MB JPG
>>290491112
Chivalry was not a harem and nor was it high school for like half or more of the run.
>>
>>290492273
>>290492107
By the later volumes in the LNs Shinmai Maou is straight hentai. To the point where you probably can't even post some of the LN art on a blue board.
>>
>>290492273
Rakudai really felt like the sendoff / songswan for the genre. It was honestly quite good IMO.
>>
>>290499135
Not enough money to be made in the anime itself.
>>
>>290491112
Not really, but it's a shame they came out before studios and publishers had the balls to adapt them being open to more seasons. Especially Color Wars suffered from this. I don't know what the fuck they were thinking while making it.
>>
File: 1501121685296.jpg (531 KB, 1286x1600)
531 KB JPG
>>290492376
>>
>>290491112
I miss IS.
>>
Trinity Seven was great.
>>
does anyone else think it's interesting that even though most of these animes were forgettable shit and the outfits are all some variation on a school uniform you probably can still remember most of the shows even without the labels just from the character designs? now compare that to isekai characters who all look like they're wearing low level mmo gear. I can't even remember what characters from isekai shows I watched just last year were wearing because it's all so bland.
>>
>>290496125
He's the funniest character from the show at least.
>>
File: lilith6.jpg (539 KB, 1600x2256)
539 KB JPG
>>290500027
I wish it got more seasons. I kind of last track of the plot in the manga after they fought hell though.
>>
File: 1760589802381402.jpg (1.07 MB, 1722x1372)
1.07 MB JPG
>5 seasons and a movie
>6th and final one on the way
>the only anime adaptation on the entire OP image to make it to the finish line
You may kneel desuno yoroshikute.
>>
>>290499504
Unfortunately it only got one season. We will never see an entire box of condoms.
>>
>>290498622
Vanadis is senki.
>>
>>290500621
>one character wearing an outfit that you forget after it finishes
>three hundred characters wearing the same outfit at all times

No, it's not interesting at all that the outfit with more time on screen is easier to remember. And this image of iconic academy battle harem uniforms gets posted a lot so you're basically cheating anyways.
>>
File: HSDxD_v15_cover.jpg (441 KB, 1135x1600)
441 KB JPG
Been reading the DxD light novels to see what the fuss was all about.
It's actually not that bad. The world-building is super extensive to the point where its kind of overwhelming. The battle autism is pretty fun, it does have its moments. Besides the MC dragging it down, I mean, why on Earth would the author make a perverted MC only to make him restrain himself while girls are literally throwing themselves at him? It's not just bad writing, the author might as well made the MC have split personalities. The times where he wasn't oblivious and a spineless wimp, he's actually a good MC if he didn't have those terrible qualities. The hentai tropes does drag it down as well, but then again, this is one of the most famous trope-y anime of all time, so I'll give that a pass.
Other than that, I'd say the world-building is probably the best thing about DxD so far. The battles are okay, but not that amazing. Besides that, the girls from this series are definitely top tier. I'm not surprised that this is one of the most famous, if not most famous harem anime of all time. In both the west AND the east.
tl;dr The world-building and the girls are really the only redeeming qualities of this series.
>>
>>290498622
Does anybody have that stitch of when he saw her bathing? And she looks quite comfortable naked being seen except in her reflection she looks freaked?
>>
File: elen 2.jpg (337 KB, 1280x2052)
337 KB JPG
>>290500846
Yes well I wish there were more harem senki

>>290500911
Here you go, ace
>>
>>290493378
are all the LNs tl'd?
seems 12 and 13 are missing on nya
same for rakudai for some reason
or maybe ill have to search through some random name alternative like with other stuff
>>
>>290500942
That's the one. Elen is best Vanadis, clear perfection.
>>
File: 78676756756757657.jpg (233 KB, 1007x1431)
233 KB JPG
>>290500942
They're still being made.
Quality is not the first Vanadis LN level especially the first 6 vol level but still its not bad.
>>
>>290500879
the characters in isekai are on screen wearing their outfits for basically the same amount of time as the ones in school animes are wearing their uniforms
>>
File: 1587845355569.jpg (356 KB, 1920x1080)
356 KB JPG
>>290500896
Agreed. I liked how the world-building developed for the Supernatural realm as the series went on. The initial premise made it seem like just Angels and Devils existed. Then we slowly start to get more Religions and Mythologies introduced with their own societies/cultures and it was cool to see how they all intertwined and interacted together.
>>
>>290500991
>>290500942
Did he ever marry Elen? Or fuck her?
>>
>>290501073
They bang in Volume 13
>>
File: 1535914922619.jpg (256 KB, 847x1200)
256 KB JPG
>>290500991
>Elen is best Vanadis
*Blocks your path*
>>
>>290501000
Does he rape her? It sure looks like it.
>>
>>290501098
I said what I said.
>>
>>290500822
But Season 2-5 look like total shit, that's the caveat.
>>
>>290501108
No in the end it was consensual. Kinda. Sorta.
>>
>>290491112
Crimsonheads really do make for the best girls
>>
File: elen ending.jpg (435 KB, 2255x1600)
435 KB JPG
>>290501073
they do
>>290501098
God Imagine trying to brag about your character after she was completely redesigned from the ground up
>>
>>290491112
I still listen to the OP and ED of Color Wars from time to time.
>>
File: elen is best girl.jpg (601 KB, 1908x2152)
601 KB JPG
>A girl will never look at you and say this
>>
File: 1447249625574.jpg (171 KB, 960x768)
171 KB JPG
>>290501189
All versions of Lewdmila are great
>>
>>290501003
The outfits lose screen time every time a different character is on screen which doesn't happen in an academy where everyone is wearing the same thing.
>>
>>290494790
WTF why is Zeref there?
>>
File: vanadis 2.jpg (421 KB, 1280x1429)
421 KB JPG
>>290501256
One of the things I think is lost in a lot of harem is actual interaction between the girls. A lot of the lesser ones will basically just hover around the MC purely independent of each other or only interact with basic group chatter. There needs to be rivalries and banter. The Vanadis girls all stood out really well because of that.
>>
>>290498622
>>290500942
>>290501251
Ellen was great and I'm sad she's in a harem show. She deserved the main character all for herself.
>>
File: elen pretty.jpg (577 KB, 1908x2140)
577 KB JPG
>>290501317
As far as Harems go this was a pretty good one. Tigre was a pretty strong MC.
>>
>>290492107
Mahouka, because it's not HSBH.
The story quickly pivots outside the titular high school when the main character nukes China and the US military starts harassing him with micro black holes and shit. It's also not a harem because he was engineered to only like 1 girl from the beginning.
>>
>>290501189
>they do
Good. It's strange, when I was younger I enjoyed huge harems, edge, fucking random women, and all that, but as I get older I just want to see a happy family end.
>>
>>290501268
no one pays attention to side characters.
>>
>>290491112
>>290494790
Which anime is the Isekai Smartphone of high school battle harems where if you watch that one you can guess how the rest develops/progresses just knowing that it's a high school battle harem?
>>
>>290501317
Does she not get him? Her blonde maid doesn't count though.
>>
>>290501452
Harem end
>>
>>290501507
That's actually disappointing.
>>
>>290491112
Yes, it’s kino. Best genre alongside mahou shoujo

>>290491184
Medieval settings are boring
>>
DAL having a mono ending is such a fucking crime.
>>
>>290499985
>Color Wars
CHAD taste
>290500027
CHADDEST taste
>>
>>290495252
But I loved Absolute Duo...
Btw I'm a high heels fetishist
>>
>>290491112
If you recognize more than 4 of those seek help.
>>
>>290501296
>>290501338
I could never get into that show because of character designs. Significant characters will always have more unique/detailed/colorful designs than background ones, sure, but there is a level of disconnect when everyone looks like a peasant and only the girls have those idol like "armors" and weird hair colors. Even MC has that dark green outfit that fits in just fine, but then the girls look like they are from another show.
>>
File: mpv-shot1321.jpg (257 KB, 1920x1080)
257 KB JPG
>>290500846
Senki shows are fun
even when they are not harems
>>
File: 2015100414064212b.jpg (426 KB, 1500x3057)
426 KB JPG
>>290499504
Fall 2015 in general felt like the sendoff of the genre with the whole Astarisk War vs Rakudai anime airing at the same time.
>>
>>290502290
This show was surprisingly fun.

Blonde mage in that picture is best girl.
>>
>>290502290
Never watched that show, I only remember it was infamous because it had a NTR scene or some shit.
>>
>>290502301
In the end, Anti-Magic won
>>
>>290502313
One female character makes a deal with a not!Arab Prince to get him to side with her instead of her enemies, so she can gain an advantage in winning a war, she says she will pay any price. She is in love with another prince. Not!Arab Prince says in exchange for his help he wants to fuck her, because she's well known for her chastity and that she was going to marry said Prince before the wedding was broken off. He wants her to prove that she will pay ANY price to gain power and win the war.

She agrees and fucks him. It's rough and brutal.

This is shown, in the show, alongside MC and his blonde mage love interest in >>290502290 who are confessing love to one another, promising to stand by each other (and that he would never put gaining power above her, because she is his strength, and so on and later he declares publicly that he will win the war FOR HER out of love and kisses her in front of everybody) and having a much more tender sex scene.

It basically contrasts the blonde princess whose name I forget as making a deal she shouldn't to gain power in the short term, and it getting her nothing. While MC and his true love don't do that, and rely on each other long term, and eventually win the day.
>>
>>290492107
I've had DxD open in the background while playing vidya and its pretty comfy.
>>
>>290502382
>not!Arab fucking a blondie
I bet the threads for that episode were a blast.
>>
File: 1785220680326750.jpg (25 KB, 340x252)
25 KB JPG
>>290491112
>mahouka
>>
>>290502896
I was there, I remember them being more angry at the NTR than it being an Arab stand-in. Bookfags spoiled it going in, but she herself was consistently a cunt about things.
>>
>>290502222
I only recognize 6. I’m disappointed in myself as a haremgod
>>
>>290502896
Marrine was more reviled than Milza was. He was kind of funny.

Most of /a/ preferred Aishela.
>>
>>290501128
I don't like the sound of that one bit...
>>
>>290502290
>Theo CHADnaro
>becomes Emperor
>saves the world, retires
>lives in a /comfy/ mansion, spends his days alternating between helping out his peasants plowing his farm's fields during the day and during the night plowing Siluca as he pumps a steady stream of babies into her
He got the Cincinnatus good end. Abe would approve.
>>
>>290491112
>>290491112
Of course I miss battle harems. Nothing will ever come close. Isekai killed battle harems as a lot of plot points were similar in isekai anime to the battle harem anime.

Honorable mentions: Nothing will top Trinity Seven in terms of writing a battle harem. It's such a natural progression and culmination of the entire subgenre.

Honorable mention 2: Shoujo Machiavelism was the last great battle harem. Great writing, fun characters, good fights, fresh take on the school setting, all the girls are the best girls and the MC is a gigachad.

Honorable mention 3: Strike the Blood's openings and how long the franchise actually lasted with regular 2 cour anime still baffles me to this day.
>>
I think Maou Gakuin is the only battle harem magic highschool from the 2020s I remember became relatively popular.
>>
File: kino time.jpg (1.4 MB, 3000x2127)
1.4 MB JPG
>>290502290
not a whole lot of them get anime adaptions unfortunately. Pic related might though
>>
>>290498622
>>290500846
Vanadis deserved a better studio, because a war show with CGI soldiers kills the appeal of great scale battles. At least the dragons weren't CGI thankfully.
>>
>>290491112
All garbage
>>
>>290491112
It was unironically better than isekai slop.
>>
>>290504187
DAL isn’t garbage by any stretch of the imagination.
>>
>>290504387
True, and they weren't as frequent too.
>>
>>290502896
Kinda yeah, but the other Queen (or princess?) going full naked with her not!spartan naked soldiers was even greater fun.
>>
>>290491112
Does Assassins pride counts as a battle harem?
>>
>>290491112
I don't miss them but I'd take them back if it meant Isekai would go away.
>>
>>290495221
You must have started watching anime very recently if you think feminism was a factor in people turning on Tsunderes and not the over saturation of low quality implementations of the trope. I'm guessing your political awakening was gamergate and you've been applying its logic to every medium you enter?
>>
>>290504495
Kurumi couldn't salvage the Tohka-centric epilogue.
Geektoys also using 3DCG also ruin some good stuff.
>>
>>290491112
Not really. They're better than isekais but ultimately it's all slop churned out by bad writers that need a template.
>>
>>290491112
Yes, I do miss them. Not because they were good, but they remind me of better times.
>>
>>290506439
Well, Tohka is the heroine.
>>
File: 1446672932117.png (176 KB, 278x377)
176 KB PNG
>>290500976
Should still be up on the Translator's site.
>>
>>290500822
Peruvians are loyal after all.
>>
>>290491112
god no
>>
>>290491112
Is Hagure Yuusha fun? That one was quite infamous back then.
>>
No, and good riddance.
>>
>>290510518
Yes, because they've replaced with so much better. Shut up.
>>
>>290510549

What replaced it? Isekai?
>>
>>290510549
>replaced with so much better
Lmao
>>
File: bestplanever.webm (2.68 MB, 854x480)
2.68 MB
2.68 MB WEBM
>>290505304
>>
File: bestplanever2.webm (2.01 MB, 854x480)
2.01 MB
2.01 MB WEBM
>>290510407
it was better than shinmai maou from the same author but it wasn't as popular because it's not as porny.
>>
>>290491112
>I’ve only watched 2 of these in their entirety therefore the genre is bad
/nua/
>>
>>290498622
It could've been good but the mahou shoujo shit was so out of place.
>>
>>290500896
>why on Earth would the author make a perverted MC only to make him restrain himself while girls are literally throwing themselves at him?
The editor made him do it, literally.
>>
>>290502164
Geek Toys butchered everything they touched.
>>
Hatred for battle harem is positively correlated with anti loli faggotry, yuricuckery and overall left wing politics and trannyism. This is an objective fact
>>
>>290491112
Out of those I only really liked Rakudai and Hundred. Also, you're missing Horizon.
I also prefer not to limit my battle harems to highschools, magical or not, since Madan no Ou to Vanadis was great.
>>290498622
Lim is the best girl
>>290503106
I was actually disappointed in Milza, I liked him from the get-go since he was filling in for Lord Kashue but as a rival rather than a mentor. It was cheap to see him pull that trick, felt out-of-character for someone who boasts so much about honor on the battlefield.
>>
>>290491112
wasn't negima patient zero for this
>>
>>290491112
>The Blade Dancer adaptation stopped right before the Blade Dance
Why? That's when it got good.
>>
>>290491112
I miss shinmai maou
>>
>>290512327
3 episodes per 1 volume is the "usual" pace.
Unless you're Mahou Sensou then you do like 7 volumes and become a disaster.
>>
>>290512490
Unrelated with battle harem, but Rokka no Yuusha did the opposite and adapted one volume into 12 episodes and it was wild. That likely contributed to the failure of the anime, but I read the light novels years after watching the anime and it was insane how it was like reading the anime, all the dialogues and scenes were kept intact.
>>
>>290491738
Reincarnation Coliseum is the current apex of the genre
>>
>>290512634
>Rokka no Yuusha
Season 2 when?
>>
>>290491184
The OG school battle harems had a distinct formula isekai implementing magic school settings not always replicate. You would get it if you were born before 9/11.
>>
>>290512707
Anon, I...
>>
File: Lodoss.jpg (151 KB, 480x720)
151 KB JPG
>>290491112
No, I only miss the non-isekai fantasy of the 80s and 90s.
>>
>>290512328
S3 when?
Maria was based
>>
File: vanadis poetry.jpg (1.1 MB, 3800x2176)
1.1 MB JPG
>>290512327
>>290512490
Stuff like this is why I hate LN adaptations. It always feels like they introduce the characters and then rush to a climax where nothing really happens. It's also why I consider Vanadis an outlier. Because shit actually happens. They introduce a lord trying to save his land from a civil war? You get a resolution to that civil war. There's a few obvious unresolved plot hooks but it feels more sequel bait than a lack of resolution.
>>
File: lodoss book.jpg (35 KB, 338x499)
35 KB JPG
>>290512833
It's a real shame that light novels only really caught on in the west long after most things I care about stopped being relevant. Seven Seas put out ONE volume of Lodoss and that was it.
>>
>>290512676
Yeah, but that one is an isekai, right?
>>
>>290513949
Yeah, and it's not even a highschool magical harem either.
>>
>>290491201
The first season was unexpectedly good (apart from the last arc where they lost a lot of steam).
>>
Now I feel the urge to fap to the main girl from Vanadis.
>>
>>290516370
Based, she's hot af.
>>
File: elen.webm (2.81 MB, 1280x720)
2.81 MB
2.81 MB WEBM
>>290516370
>>290517033
You guys are alright sometimes
>>
Why did Dragonar have so many random tentacle scenes
>>
>>290491201
Iceblade feels more like a descendant of the genre than a representative
>>
Green > Yellow > Blue > Red > Purple
>>
File: ass.png (2.5 MB, 1920x1080)
2.5 MB PNG
>>
File: 1777880530699051.jpg (133 KB, 932x887)
133 KB JPG
>SLASH
>DASHING SLASH ATTACK
>SLASHING THE AIR AND IT TURNS INTO A PROJECTILE ATTACK
>THE ABOVE BUT YOU DRAW KANJI AS A PROJECTILE
>LIGHTLY GRIP MY SWORD BUT YOU'RE STILL DAMAGED ATTACK
>THE ABOVE BUT IT'S LONG RANGE
>MULTIPLE SLASHES THAT DON'T DO ANYTHING UNTIL I SEATHE MY SWORD ATTACK
>FINAL TECHINQUE SECRET ART #3492 SAKURA PETAL STOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORM
>(unlocked after obtaining demon form) FORBIDDEN FINAL TECHINQUE SECRET ART #666 CRIMSON SAKURA PETAL STOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORM

Battle harem MC for this feel?
>>
File: Vol 6.jpg (719 KB, 1057x1079)
719 KB JPG
>>290519469
Sword autist MC with properly named moves and evolving moveset? Yeah
>>
>>290519469
I really can't tell if Falcom is taking a piss with this character. He's like every shameful light novel harem chuuni character combine in a way that can't be anything other than intentional but if there's a joke I'm missing it.
>>
File: 1627555221866.jpg (218 KB, 1024x1265)
218 KB JPG
>>290491112
It's actually crazy just how hard Rias mogs absolutely everyone here.
>>
>>290491112
I remember that for Anti-Magic there was a list of Metal Gear Rising songs one should listen while reading certain fights but I lost it, does anyone here has it?
>>
>>290520489
I think the saddest part of DxD fags isn't that they think their shit is the best, that they think it's good.
>>
>>290513014
I've been reading Vanadis, as far as my memory goes the anime adaptation somehow misses very little from the books, it's amazing. I'm not very used to LNs but maybe this one is more descriptive of battles in a way that saves a lot of anime time with those 3d model mockups, but still, things like Urz and Ludmilla's hunt, or Roland, they all seem to be almost better in the anime. It is an incredibly satisfactory watch.
>>290519632
Falcom is just unironically in love with that particular era of anime.
>>
File: Felli Loss Full Maid.jpg (235 KB, 704x812)
235 KB JPG
>>290491112
>Do you miss the battle harem magic highschool era of the early 2010s?
What about the late 2000s?
>>
>>290521511
I forgot to add that Felli Loss WON and Nina is an expired Christmas cake.
>>
File: vanadis battle.jpg (422 KB, 1920x1080)
422 KB JPG
>>290521198
The 3d models are pretty obviously a way to cut cost but I also love them. It gives the series an identity. There's a lot of QUALITY mixed but you can tell they were giving it an honest effort rather than phoning it in.
>>
I wish DAL threads on this board didn’t always die
I want to talk about it
>>
>>290523802
Speak then, anon.
I was a pretty big fan of DAL before the anime adaptations and the later volumes kind of soured me on it all. I still have fond memories of it.
>>
>>290491112
What are the top five shows on this list? I need something to watch.
>>
>>290521198
the vanadis director was a veteran who had previously directed nadesico and some other well known shows. he died a few months ago.
>>
File: mpv-shot0722.jpg (263 KB, 1920x1080)
263 KB JPG
>>290524290
Damn, I had no idea. RIP. It does kind of have the vibe of something older than it was though.
>>
>>290522595
Yeah, they probably had to cut corners somewhere, doing so in a visually interesting way that cuts through the slog of medieval warfare is a nice touch.
>>290524290
>Nadesico
Nice, may he rest in peace. Any other senki, harem or both, made by unexpectedly estabilished pros?
>>290524180
I'd say Madan no Ou to Vanadis > Rakudai > Asterisk > Hundred > Mahouka
>>
>>290524032
I hope they eventually make an alternative ending where it’s truly a harem
Are nips also complaining about the mono ending?
>>
>>
>>290521511
Damn I forgot that show was a thing.
>>
>>290524836
Is this isekai?
>>
>>290521511
I vaguely remember this girl but I can't remember the anime name for the love of my life.
>>
>>290526871
Battle harem has isekai arc
>>
>>290526934
Koukaku no Regios
>>
>>290526982
Thanks, anon
>>
>>290491112
Houki a shit
>>
>>290527061
True, Laura best girl btw.
>>
File: IMG_7106.jpg (1.03 MB, 764x2160)
1.03 MB JPG
>>290527337
>>290527061
For me it is the English rose.
>>
>>290527455
Agreed
>>
File: eiko02.png (166 KB, 848x773)
166 KB PNG
>>290517615
Dark Green was the best.
>>
>>290524808
We can only look towards the VN spin-off games for that sort of thing.
No idea what the elevens think since the series has been underwater for some time and Kurumi is the only thing keeping them relevant in the buyfag department.
>>
>>290491112
No, but I miss battle harem sci-fi anime.
>>
>>290491112
No, because fossilized shit may have lost the smell but is still shit.
>>
File: marika parrotbot.jpg (1.43 MB, 2896x4096)
1.43 MB JPG
>>290524524
>Any other senki, harem or both, made by unexpectedly estabilished pros?
It's not really any of those but Bodacious Space Pirate's writer is old school having worked on Ariel and Venus Wars.
>>
>>290491184
Highschool harems (usually) had female characters and side characters that were actually good for something other than figuratively or literally jerking the MC off
>>
>>290529609
Such as?
>>
>>290530073
Did they though?

>>290530641
Tenchi?
>>
Man, do big bitty blonde knight girls ever get to win?
>>
File: 62024_ll2.jpg (133 KB, 640x800)
133 KB JPG
>>290532016
didn't bahamut end with a harem ending?
>>
>>290533516
That's not good enough for me.
>>
File: 024.jpg (983 KB, 2866x2048)
983 KB JPG
>>290533618
sucks to be you then
>>
>>290534686
Sorry I don't want my girl to be a cuck.
>>
>>290529428
I don’t understand how DAL isn’t more popular nowadays
>>
File: 1400700715422.gif (2.04 MB, 902x1080)
2.04 MB GIF
>>290535454
Because it looks like complete shit past Season 1?
>>
File: 1394771693814.jpg (134 KB, 1438x705)
134 KB JPG
>>290491112
I miss the early 2010s in general. 4chan was better; /a/ was better.
>>
>>290491112
I miss the battle harem part, but definitely not the school/academy part.
>>
>>290535553
I don’t think that’s true. The last couple seasons are less soulful than the first ones but it’s still watchable
>>
I don’t get how there still isn’t a magical girl harem anime
You would think 90s Sailor Moon and its almost comical Mamoru wank would have inspired people to do one
>>
>>290536614
The QUALITY in Season 2-3 are whack while Seasons 4-5 have half decent visuals until they pull out the 3D models for fights, which look fucking godawful.
I can't blame anyone for being weirded out by those. But when plot got more serious with far less "dates" in the title and the cast being so big that it got a lot easier to mismanage them outside of Tohka, Kurumi, and Kotori.
>>
>>290536663
A harem of magical girls all competing for the same guy would be peak, but they only do yurishit with the concept.
>>
>>290491112
>>290492107
>>290502440
DxD is actually a banger if you distract from *mostly* pointless fanservice.
However I don't get why Rias got the all the cards - in first seasons the animation is lame and unpleasantly sharp because of cel-digital transition era and in later seasons there was too much fanservice and despite other characters been looking better Rias was downgraded even more.
Though, if I were a le "hair" thing, I would choose H ga Dekinai main girl.
>>
>>290530641
Maybe Vandread.
>>
>>290535802
>but definitely not the school/academy part
I find that the ones I've finished tend to drop that part later on.
>>
>>290512762
>the new slop isn't as repetitive as the old slop
Grim.
>>
>>290491112
No because many refused to go harem route, sure, there were lots of girls but the primary girl always gets the most focus to the point the rest don't matter if more of them pulled the plug it'd be better
>>
>>290538137
You basically have two options.

Option A) Where the show is basically just a regular love story with extra cock orbiters who exist solely to pad things out
Option B) The harem is a secondary plot point where there's some big battle to focus on and the actual romance is unresolved. Of the two I think this at least works better for given the characters agency.
>>
File: 1787866786395346~2.jpg (1.37 MB, 3767x2218)
1.37 MB JPG
>>290538274
Yeah I've made the connection
>>
>>290538667
Tokha may as well be wife with how much one-sided focus she gets.
>>
>>290491112
Color Wars made no fucking sense
>>
>>290538667
I'm sure Color Wars had the redhead as the main girl and the others were just cock orbiters. Not that it mattered since the show ended with everything restarting from episode 1.
>>
>>290538667
>>290491112
Man World Break was the dumbest shit ever.
>I REMEMBER!
>>
>>290539346
You now remember the rapid air writing
>>
>>290491112
I keep confusing World Break and Blade Dance for some reason.
>>
>>290538667
I kind of forgot about the anime, but later on I'd say Blade Dance should be more in the harem category.
>>
File: images.jpg (30 KB, 521x589)
30 KB JPG
>>290539346
At least He ended with a harem including the loli
>>
>>290538667
Lol at Mahouka and Infinite Stratos.
>>
>>290501342
quick rundown on magical jesus?
>>
>>290510844
I watched all of those except for Kuusen Madoushi, World Break and Blade Dance. Most of them were pretty bad
>>
>>290528525
Start reciting the alphabet
>>
>>290537242
>Seasons 4-5 have half decent visuals until they pull out the 3D models for fights, which look fucking godawful
The new art style was also awful and they censored some of the designs. They ruined the story too, albeit not something anime-onlies would necessarily pick up on.
>Tohka, Kurumi, and Kotori
Add Origami. She became infinitely more likeable and helpful after her arc, at least.
>>
File: 1785273763458821.jpg (214 KB, 1920x1080)
214 KB JPG
>>290506439
>tohka slander
>>
>>290519469
Haha, that's our Rean!
>>
>>290528525
Best at being worst girl.
>>
>>290542400
That would be Red.
>>
File: 1444350884572.jpg (172 KB, 1024x768)
172 KB JPG
>>290541003
>He's the real heir to one of the most secretly powerful families in Japan. But he changes his name to blend with the common folk just so he can keep it real.
>He's a weed who mows down blooms just because he doesn't like the cut of their jib.
>He's a master inventor/physicist/engineer, but chooses to publish anonymously because the Nobel Prize would bore him.
>He can wipe out the entire countries with minor preparation but is still respectful of his superior officers.
>When a woman dances with him, her life is complete and if there's a second dance, she's likely to end up pregnant with triplets by the end of the song -- siblings are not exempt.
>He can directly convert matter to energy and fuck you the mc^2 up.
>He knows more ninjitsu than every Kishimoto character combined.
>If he could cry, his tears would be 1959 Dom Pérignon Rosé.
>>
File: 1782087711413366.png (253 KB, 471x302)
253 KB PNG
>>290542249
>>
>>290542582
Sasuga Onii-Sama
>>
>>290542582
Sasuga, Onii-sama
>>
File: xover.jpg (106 KB, 1200x601)
106 KB JPG
>>290491112
same energy
>>
>>290542582
Sasuga ONII-sama!
>>
File: dark_green_boing.mp4 (968 KB, 1280x720)
968 KB
968 KB MP4
>>290528525
She truly was the hottest bitch of the show.
>>
>>290544969
so naturally she has the least amount of images
>>
>>290545252
Unfortunately.
>>
File: green slut.gif (600 KB, 480x270)
600 KB GIF
>>
>>290546340
some girls just need to get knocked down and fucked Rance style.
>>
>>290546407
>Rance style.
well, she kinda looks like budget Shizuka
>>
>>290492107
None of them
>>
File: 1446776280081.jpg (23 KB, 656x368)
23 KB JPG
My favorite onii-sama expy is from Antimagic. Completely busted character in power scale but he's a side character.
>>
>>290529704
It even has the same director, cool. I never watched Ariel either, looks interesting.
>>
>>290491184
Nah
Westoids complained about the setting always being in a middle to high school, and the bankers threatened them, so they removed it and replaced it with high fantasy instead
Now you get Frieren, MT, Rezero, Tensura, and other fantasy ones, and instead of middle-high school it's now "magic academy" and the like, usually for about 3 episodes, to make it kosher for westoids
>>
File: HQydNJlbYAA-OO3.jpg (553 KB, 1980x1320)
553 KB JPG
Not a battle harem but
>>
>>290491112
For me, it was the better HxH
>>
>>290492107
All of them.
>>
>>290538667
Rakudai has maybe one cock orbiter, the sister, and Ikki shut her down hard as soon as he declared for Stella in like book 2.
>>
>>290491112
Color Wars drives me color blindness insane. The girl there IS supposed to be RED right? All the other Reds on that image look VERY red to me but for some reason she fucks my shit up.
>>
>>290552011
She certainly doesn't has blue hair.
>>
>>290491112
What about SF Battle Harem?
>>
>>290552011
She's just too powerful for us mortals.
>>
>>290551189
I liked Haganai (besides the retarded ending), but that one was just a regular harem show.
>>
File: aine2.gif (949 KB, 800x461)
949 KB GIF
>>290552773
Mahouka. IS, Hundred, HxH and STB?
>>
>>290491112
Why do all the guys in these shows look so boring and utterly devoid of sex appeal
>>
>>290553396
You don't watch harem shows for the guy, anon.
>>
>>290553396
Are you gay, anon?
>>
>>290491112
which of these ends in an actual harem?
>>
>>290553941
Issei in DxD ends up marrying most of his harem I think, but only at the very end.
>>
>>290552773
SF? Like Science Fiction
>>
File: IMG_1242.jpg (2.69 MB, 2160x1503)
2.69 MB JPG
>>290552773
Sci-fi? There's one now/coming, but it's isekai.

There is also stuff like Tenchi Muyo, which is harem. HxH as well.
>>
>>290553941
Shinmai Maou.
>>
>>290538667
Was there ever a "winner", but its not main girl?
>>
>>290548036
>Antimagic
This one aired alongside Rakudai and Asterisk, right?
>>
File: 1444659828925.jpg (988 KB, 1500x3057)
988 KB JPG
>>290557716
Yes.
Those two weekly episode threads were on fire with shitposting while Antimagic was a refuge for actual discussion and talking about the LNs
>>
>>290559056
Was Antimagic fun? I watched the other two for the shitposting, but that one flew under my radar.
>>
Do anyone remember Akashic Records? It was the one where the main character was a teacher and the female students had a school uniform exposing their stomach.
>>
File: TMG_v10_002-003.jpg (1.35 MB, 2721x2100)
1.35 MB JPG
>>290559260
Had a good OST and absolutely amazing voice-casting.
Unfortunately Silver Link was working on Rakudai AND Shomin Sample that season and they bet it all on the former.
Even still, I think the mediocre anime adaptation clearly showcased Antimagic being a different beast because it bothered to start off differently than the other two and treat its cast better. And also not having the entire series based around fucking tournaments.
The side and side comparison of the main heroines show off how formulaic their archetype is but Antimagic introduces its female lead being reprimanded for executing someone on the job again.
>>
>>290559336
People definitely remember the uniforms and the rape attempt
>>
>>290491112
kinda repetitive and boring. but gave us some surprisingly fun best girls.
>>
>>290559792
I don't remember anything this girl aside from her looks.
>>
File: 1535774520054.png (3.3 MB, 2888x3737)
3.3 MB PNG
>>290559336
the mc didn't even plap his white pig
so it was trash
>>
>>290491112
Isekai harem just doesn't hit the same. Battle harem had a more balance focus between MC and the girls while in Isekai the MC tends to be so strong and great the harem just feels like accessory
>>
>>290559792
She deserved way better...
>>
>>290559792
Literally the only good thing of the anime.
>>
>>290491112
I kinda miss it because it used to be a genre that provided good fap material. Good character designs here and there and good clothes and uniforms. Everything else was absolute garbage, but that doesn't matter that much because it's a disposable genre.
>>
>>290562816
Clearly if they went through the trouble of branding her there then they must have also raped her.
>>
>>290491112
Nah I thought that period was kind of a dark age
>>
>>290563425
We're still in a dark age, just with isekaishit
>>
>>290563425
>>290564211
Anime truly died in 2007.
>>
>>290562816
That is a good point, I find battle harem girls hotter than isekai girls for some reason.
>>
>>290566886
It helps not being ACTUAL slaves
>>
>>290567476
That too, kek.
>>
File: 1424109625773.png (2.83 MB, 1280x2417)
2.83 MB PNG
Blondie was the best
>>
File: 1389327189785.jpg (349 KB, 1600x1138)
349 KB JPG
Does this series count as one?
>>
>>290559579
There was a rape attempt in that show? I forgot, I watched the show long ago back when it first aired, so I don't remember it well.
>>
>>290570112
Yeah it happened in the first or second episode.
>>
>>290495207
I think we just got too many shit ones in a row. When was the last time we got one on the caliber of Full Metal Panic Chidori?
>>
File: 1780169467348626.jpg (1.14 MB, 1920x1329)
1.14 MB JPG
Is Yuusha no Kuzu a battle harem?
>>
>>290552773
Magic high schools are magitech 90% of the time

>>290566227
Based Zero no Tsukaima bro



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.