How do we feel about Homura's HATSUKOI for Madoka being canon and romantic?
>>291204004It's cute
>>291204004Shit VAs say do not hold authority over the writing.
>>291204004>being canon and romantic?Hatsukoi is always romantic tho
>>291204080Especially when she didn't call it romantic. She actually called it admiration. OP has to cope with objectively wrong posts like this >>291204096Not even VAoids agree with him kek
Rate the 4th movie megucas!
>>291204096Is it? I know the direct translation means "first love" but it being romantic or not depends on the context.
>>291204113>she didn't call it romantic. She actually called it admirationDebunked.https://japanese.stackexchange.com/questions/112689/does-love-koi-%e6%81%8b-lose-its-romantic-context-when-compared-to-admiration-akogare
>>291204154>Question1234 can't even explain his question properly>Everyone is confused and doesn't understand the question, answers bullshitKEKAROOOOOOO
>>291204113>Lying about what Chiwa saidJust saying >>291204080would be more reasonable. Especially when one of the retards here sent a question to that Japanese learning website about it
>>291204194I didn't lie, only you have to do that because you're desperate for anyone even remotely close to the staff agreeing with you in any capacity lmaobtw it's funny seeing the people on that site not even understand your question because you had to change the wording she used to fit her narrative.
>>291204243Didn't your thread get deleted? Trannies cannot be magical girls.
>>291204266>t. Epstein
>>291204191>Everyone is confused and doesn't understandIs called ask for clarifications.
>>291204233This is like the 6th time you've confused me for someone else>you had to change the wording she used to fit her narrative.>her narrativesharky Also fucking 'やっぱラブなんだと思うよきっと だから憧れに近い恋かもしれないけど だから初恋なんだと思う そうですね 二個目だとちょっと違う 初恋が終わったとしても上手したとしても' is just[30:29] やっぱラブなんだと思うよきっと[30:32] だから憧れに近い恋かもしれないけど[30:34] だから初恋なんだと思う[30:36] そうですね[30:38] 二個目だとちょっと違う[30:41] 初恋が終わったとしても上手したとしてもMashed together. So it's the same fucking Japanese anyway
>>291204274Epstein loved yuri.>>291204299Because your posts were unintelligible.>>291204346And that's still saying it's closer to admiration than romantic love.
>>291204154The guy who asked was a retard but if some Jap sees '憧れに近い恋かもしれないけどやっぱラブなんだと思う' and says that yeah, she means it romantically than it's pretty clear what the answer is.Saito sees it as being first love, meaning a crush
>>291204398The jap didn't have the context, so he just gave you the most common use of the term.Koi can literally be used to refer to objects. How is it inherently romantic?
>>291204482>The Jap didn't know what it meantThen tell him the context and ask him again?
>>291204516I don't need to. I can use logic without needing a third party to think for me.
>>291204536Cool. I'll keep using the Japanese calling it romantic since they know Japanese better than either of us
>>291204556You didn't even specify to him that it was a same sex relationship, so he's also calling Homura straight btw.
>>291204565You should've told him that then Maybe then he wouldn't have called it romantic
"Akogare ni chikai koi" isn't romantic because romantic love isn't close to "akogare" at all.
>>291204482>Because your posts were unintelligible.Because the jap didn't had the context and was asking for it. And whoever made the question gave it later>Sorry for the late reply. Here's the transcript of what I've been talking about. 'やっぱラブなんだと思うよきっと だから憧れに近い恋かもしれないけど だから初恋なんだと思う そうですね 二個目だとちょっと違う 初恋が終わったとしても上手したとしても' It is a discussion between a few people about how a fictional character in love feels. My apologies as I don't seem able to properly separate each line. > So you're referring to this: "憧れに近い恋かもしれないけどやっぱラブなんだと思う (It may be a type of love close to admiration, but I think it's still love)". This means that the feelings in question include elements of respect and admiration, but they are nevertheless romantic feelings. It does not mean that the term 初恋 itself carries no romantic meaning
>>291204665>Because the jap didn't had the contextAnd he still doesn't. A sentence isn't context. He obviously assumed you were talking about a boy and a girl, where actual akogare rarely happens and romantic love often does.
>>291204687>A sentence isn't context.This is>It is a discussion between a few people about how a fictional character in love feels
Can someone ask Saito if Homura would go on a date with Madoka if Madoka asked for one?I think that would make it pretty clear if she means it romantically or not
>>291204721No, it really isn't.>>291204725She would ask you what the fuck is your problem and tell you to stay away from her family.
>>291204740>No, it really isn't.Then give him the "context" and see if he sees it as romantic still or not?Like, you yourself could do this
>>291204740>No, it really isn't.Man, cope can get pretty bad.
>>291204768See >>291204536Only liberals like you rely on other people to do the thinking for them (becacause they have no brain). I can use logic to determine how true something is just fine.In the first place you're retarded for believing a VA would be allowed to go against canon and the writing team's words. Even if she's saying it's just her opinion.
>>291204798You're the living proof of that yes
>>291204806>becacauseShaky
>>291204818>doing the minor spelling mistake i win meme unironicallylol
>>291204806>Asking someone who speaks a language you don't to translate the meaning of stuff from that language is bad Do you watch Madoka without subtitles then or something?
>>291204004>Janny deletes only the picture and not the shitpost itselfFor what purpose
>I understand Japanese better than the Japanese
>>291204853When you already have a logical explanation for why something was said and what it means doing that is unnecessary yes. The only reason why you went to the trouble to do so is because you didn't like the explanation.
>>291204806>In the first place you're retarded for believing a VA would be allowed to go against canon and the writing team's wordsOf course she can'tWhich is why Homura is canonically in love with 'Doka romantically
>>291204884>logical explanationMother fucker I don't want a "logical explanation" from some faggot who can't even speak Japanese I want to know what the fuck Saito meant when she called it hatsukoi. And if the Japanese are saying she meant it romantically than that's what she fucking meant
>>291204892But this constantly gets proven to not be the case though. Maybe you're retarded?>>291204913>I don't want a logical explanationYeah we can tell>I want to know what the fuck Saito meant when she called it hatsukoiEvidently no you don't. You want to pretend she said something she didn't. And have been doing so for weeks.
>>291204940>"But this constantly gets proven to not be the case though.">Has never proven me wrong onceInteresting
It's funny that yuritroons always post the same images because so few yuri art exists for this series
>"No, what the Japanese said was wrong!"Lolcow reminds me of ACK when he was trying to fix the 'bad' Japanese a of a Japanese tripfag. Tabb really is ACK 2.0.
>>291204965I and others do so literally every single thread.Homura says it's nonromanticWriters say it's nonromanticSpinoffs say it's nonromanticEven the fucking VAs say it's nonromantic nowYou're the only one believing otherwise
>>291204994>I and others do so literally every single thread.I don't think this has happened actually. Especially with Saito calling it romantic
>>291204978>because so few yuri art exists for this seriesEveryday there's new ones.
>>291205008It happens every single time. Especially now that Saito also called it nonromantic, which lines up with what the writing team said.>>291205021This isn't yuri though. Which is why you never post it.Then again a lot of what you post isn't even yuri either.
This is what happens when you don't take 4chan seriously enough
>>291204346What's the source for this slop?
>>291205035>He's now starting to lie about what happens every threadThis is pathetic, even for youRegardless, I don't get why you'd go to the threads for a anime who's posters are yurifags if you yourself wasn't one.
>>291205035>This isn't yuri though.>Taged madohomuhttps://www.pixiv.net/en/artworks/150087428I have far more btw
>>291205021Cute
>>291205073But only you enjoy posting about yuri in these threads. And everyone agrees that you get BTFO every single time.>>291205083Japs use that kind of tags for het pics too.
>>291205035Same interview btw.
How can you have hate in your heart after seeing something cute like this?
>only you
>https://www.pixiv.net/en/tags/%E3%81%BE%E3%81%A9%E3%81%BB%E3%82%80/artworks>Yuri not even in the suggested tagsOh nonononono
>>291205098Well I am 'many people'So that does make sense I guess I am everyone who posts to this thread actually
>>291205098>Japs use that kind of tags for het pics too.Yeah, that's what I see here.
>>291205128>MadoHomu is a popular pairing between the characters Homura Akemi and Madoka Kaname in the series Puella Magi Madoka Magica. In the series, Homura explicitly declares her love for Madoka, making them a popular subject in Yuri art.Hetbros... Pixiv disagrees with us. Madoka is yuri
>>291205115I don't because straight girls kissing is hot.It's only disgusting when nonstraight girls do it.
>>291205148It's not even saying that lmao, it's just saying it's popular in yuri art, which isn't even true considering yuri isn't even in the suggested tag meaning they're not tagged together very often.
>>291205152True yurigawd right here
So why did Urobuchi decide to make Homusaya canon anyway?
>>291205128>Yuri not even in the suggested tagsJust press the arrow.
>>291205175Nah, that's actually being based, yuritroons aren't based they fucking hate straight girls and try to make them gay. See this whole thread
>>291205199I don't have it. Maybe it's personalized based on cookies? I rarely ever use pixiv, so I probably have the vanilla ones, yuri is popping up for you because you often search for it.
>>291205216Ah wait, I do have it near the end. No idea how I missed it the first time.>Less popular than "Homura the Creeper"kek
>>291205203Anything with girls kissing is yuri tho
>>291205265Yuritroons are only happy when they can gaslight people into thinking the gay is canon, again, see this thread
>>291205280I did and idk what you are talking about. You seem to take this way too seriously
>>291205236>Less popular than "Homura the Creeper"The order doesn't follow popularity.
>>291205296Liberal trannies shitting up hobbies and making them impossible to discuss is a very serious subject actually, and I'm tired of pretending it's not.
>>291205199>11761 contentsMadohomu is really popular yuri art. The lolcow is coping. Lmaooo
>>291205308Proof? It would make sense for it to follow how much it overlaps with the tag being searched.
>>291205322Most of it isn't yuri though. Look at the first page, there's virtually zero yuri in it.But yes you're right the lolcow is coping.
>>291205313>Shitposting on 4chan is very serious Truthnuke
>>291205351Japanese think is yuri.
>>291205331Just compare the search results.>Look at the first page, there's virtually zero yuri in it.Literaly in the first page.
>>291205357Only you see it as shitposting.Others are unironically pushing an agenda, and low IQ shitposters like you don't see it and only see that as an excuse to waste your time online like retards>>291205386No.
>>291205331Do you think more madohomu is tagged with Kyousaya than with 'Puella Magi Madoka Magica' or Madoka's name?
>>291205398forgot to quote>>291205351
>>291205398Learn what virtually means, retard.>>291205402Probably not, true. Not sure why they wouldn't order them, but maybe that's what's going on.Doesn't change the fact that it has visibly low overlaps with the yuri tag.
>>291205401>He actually believes this
>>291205398Nothing's Yuri to him unless Urobuchi signed off on the kissing first
>>291205425>Learn what virtually means, retard.You should, since the first page is full of that.
>>291205430>He actually ignores how there is always at least one retard arguing unironically and getting mad every threadChenalos is unironic and wrote a whole fanfic about calling Homura gay (and brown)DashRapid is unironic and constantly spouts his garbage on twitter tooThe "yurib8" schizo is unironic and actually believes Chiwa called Homura's love romantic and that her opinion matters, that it "confirms" Homura's love is romantic (despite the same person already saying it was confirmed romantic before that interview)Thinking your shitposter butt buddies are the whole thread and that nobody is serious is retarded.
>>291205401>art has Madohomu tag on a Japanese site for Japanese artists>"Noo, Japanese don't think that art is yuri"Cope.
>>291205525It's not even tagged as yuri.
>>291205473I don't know who half those people are or where the fuck you got them from. The only one I know I know is the guy from twitter and I haven't seen him in these threads since the movie came out.As far as I'm concerned the first and last guy are your equivalent of fucking rinfag and just do not fucking exist
>>291205456Learning is hard for the mentally illEspecially after Chiwa called Homura's first love (Madoka) romantic
>>291204985Every thread is made to bait him now just like it was with ACK back in the day. Truly ACK 2.0
>>291205548>I'm too retarded to use the archiveswe know
>>291205473>The "yurib8" schizoWho the fuck is that?
>It's all baiting and shitposting!So you're admitting nobody actually believes the Madoka girls aren't straight? Sweet
>>291205590I've used the archives to try and find where the fuck this started and all I could find was you screaming about a literal who fanfic writer out of nowhere.
>>291205609Saito believes Homura isn't, she wouldn't be using the term 'hatsukoi' (first love) if she didn't
As a Japanese person, it's fascinating watching anons try to turn Japanese ambiguity into a binary definition.Sorry for our vague national character.
>>291205627>I can't readwe know>>291205641So suddenly it's serious and no longer shitposting? Make up your mind.Also, I really don't need to say it again, but you're wrong.>>291205652Especially since "koi" can also be used for objects. Goyjin amirite?
>>291205652Flamewaring would be less fun without the new interview, so thank Saito personally for us random Japanese Anon
>>291205669>He hasn't realised it's bothYou're ngmi
>>291205699>He hasn't realized what he's been saying since the beginning
>>291205534Yuri is in the suggested tags. On that site Madohomu is related to yuri. You're free to find the het tag on that list now.
>>291205669The voices in your head own you or whatever
So is this series yuri or not
RintabMadokanonGachafagSteins;Gate haterSteins;Gate schizo!-AkemiACKChenalosRapidDashLapdogKyschizo
>>291205722>Yuri is in the suggested tagsBecause they’re sometimes tagged together, but evidently it’s an absolute minority.Also, there’s no het tag on pixiv because het is normal>>291205766Your pic proves it isn’t.
Some day the number imaginary enemies living rent free in Tabb's mind will be greater than the number of unique posters on this thread. Absolute madness.
>>291205898Kyouko and Sayaka seem pretty gay in it to me
>>291205921True, he’s stupid for thinking it’s more than one schizo samefagging.>>291205922>I’m autistic and have never talked to a womanYeah we noticed
>>291205985>Yeah we noticedYou forgot the giga
>>291205898>Because they’re sometimes tagged togetherBecause madohomu is a yuri ship. They tell it.>there’s no het tag on pixiv Yes, there is.
>>291205815My imaginary enemies...
>>291206038>He's larping Pixiv nowAs expected of him
>>291206013It would be gigaquotable if you actually did admit to that and wear it as a token of pride but you don’t. You’re a feminist >>291206038> Because madohomu is a yuri shipWhen used as a ship (unless there’s GB involved) which it more often than not isn’t.> Yes, there isNo. Only porn tags, or stuff signaling a male character is present.
If Madohomu wasn't seen as yuri there'd be posts tagged with both it and the hetro tagThere aren't any
>>291206079>which it more often than not isn’t.The description tells you the tag is only used for pairing.>Only porn tagsSo there's one or not?
>>291206079>Pixiv doesn't have a hetro tagYou really are a larper lmao
