Which one of these three is THE Top 1 best anime of all time and history?
So what happened to funnyschizo, it's been a while since I saw a FMA hate post. Did he switch his attention to Frieren?
it's Naruto
certainly not frierenshit thats for sure
>Let's settle this once and for allLol
>>291434726>mid adaptation of melodrama >mid source material >mid source material
>>291434877name your top 5
>>2914347261/10 l 7/10 l 6/10Is this really the best anime has to offer?
https://desuarchive.org/a/search/subject/settle%20this/https://desuarchive.org/a/search/subject/debate/type/op/https://desuarchive.org/a/search/image/jd1Kb9QktGNHwZM2sBrK1Q/https://desuarchive.org/a/search/image/6x_1vu5-64fddUrQO8RyHw/Bot threadAll of these threads with an OP image like this are from one spammer
>>291435055And?
>>291434726It shouldn't even be a question.
>>291434726>he left out RezeroBros...
>>291434726None of those deserve it.
>>291434726watch your fourth anime as soon as possible
FMAB is the best of these, followed by Frieren, then S;G last.
>>291434726it's frieren and it's not even close
>>2914347267/10, 8/10, 5/10 (not bad for shounenshit)
>>291434726Witch Hat Atelier > FrierenTatami Galaxy > Steins;GateFMA 2003 > FMAB
>>291435988Yeah I think I'd rate these 5/10, 8/10, and 7/10 so not too dissimilar to yours.
original fma
>>291434726It's a mid off
>>291435359This is for mediocre anime, not garbage dogshit anime
>>29143472610/10 7/10 9/10 for me
>>291435317>pic unrelated
>>291434726MAL really has the worst taste possible. Imagine thinking these 3 are the 3 greatest anime of all time.
>>2914347264/10 7/10 5/10Looking grim for this lineup.
>>291434726Stein gay? Never number 1 so it has no place competing there.
>>291434726Top 3 most overrated shows of all time
>>2914347267/10 8/10 5/10Even top 10 would be a stretch for these.
>>291435988>>291438091Oh lol, my man.
>>291437688Yeah I don't think any of these shows are bad except far maybe s;g, but there's no way any of these come close to my favorites.
>>291438292You understand that your personal favorites are personal to you, right? This is more about overall best anime.
>>291434726They don't make the top 100
>>291434726Where's Attack on Titanâ„¢? The undisputed KING of anime?Shinzo sasageyo my gentlemen.
>>291434726I mildly dislike all of these anime.
>>291434726None of these, for sure
>>291434726I like Frieren the most.
take this to reddit, newfag
I'm a BASED contrarian and think popular things SUCK
>>291438578This but unironically. Everything in the OP was underwhelming as hell.
>>291434726I think FMAB is actually good. It's a shounen but everything that it does is well executed, it's kind of like an Avatar of anime.The other two were mid, they do a couple interesting things each but are overall unpolished and it's hard for me to see why they are supposed to be top 3 of all time.
>>291438578In my opinion the unpopular shit glazed by f/a/ggots is garbage. Recent example: Yani neko (scat-adjacent anime)
>>291438578I'm not like that but Frieren is boring as heck
>>291434726S;G doesn't belong there.Realistically none of them do but especially not S;G.
>>291434726The ratings of these three shows are why I stopped trusting anime ratings.
>>291439575It's amazing what kind of mediocrity rises to the top when the ranking gets decided by reddit and normalfags.
>>291434726In a rare reversal of old good new bad, Frieren is far and away the best of the three.
>>291434726>gate left 0 impact on the industry>elf and her morbidly obese friend havent finished yet>FMA b was a rare good ending for an anime
>>291434726From those? FMAB. We will know for sure once Frieren is finished but FMA has a great plot, characters, is deep and philosophical enough to not feel pretentious and has plenty of action. Plus it´s 50 something episodes and finished which is always a plus. That said i wouldn´t call it the best anime in history. The best entry level one maybe.
>>291440174>0 impact on the industryWhat does this have to do with anything? What matters is quality.
>>291434726>thinking you can decide this when one of the choices hasn't even ended yetSubhumans.
>>291435359Re Zero is only top 2 because the season came out last week, it'll go down after a bit like it always happens with the new stuff. You need to at least surpass the million users to be a real big boy
>>291437760>he doesn't rememberMan I'm getting old, it was number 1 while I was in high school 9 years ago
>>291434726For me its FMA:B, then Steins;Gate, then Frieren and frankly Frieren doesn't deserve to be the #1.FMA:B and S;G are pretty close but FMA:B clears.
>>291434726One Piece.
>>291440133Frieren is actually the worst of the three and it's going to continue to get worse
>>291434726
>>291434772He’s still seethes here and there, he’s also doing it with the new series
>>291434726None of these are terrible, but none of them are good either.
>>291434726I can understand an argument for Brotherhood I guess, even though I disagree. The others shouldn't even be in the conversation for being #1 anime.
>>291434726I have no idea how reddit;gate gets this overrated every time.
>>291434726NoneFor me it was Clannad, Angel beats, and Anohana
>>291435924this
Prepare for one of the worst threads this year.
>>291434726Frieren S1 is a show about nothing with pretty lights
>>291434726These are just the most overhyped anime: MAL edition. None of them actually deserve top 1.
>>291436013Trvke
S;G definitely has the most obnoxious fans of the bunch
>>291442975It does, which is weird because usually the newer anime and newfag attractors like Frieren are the worst.
I can't understand how people can hate frieren. It's literally the nge of our time
>>291434726I wish normalfags had better taste that this.
>>291443409Yeah FMAB/SG have been the most overrated anime for a long time. Worse than shounen somehow.
>>291434726All shit
>>2914347265/10 9/10 8/10It's okay I guess.
>>291440614Before Frieren nothing dethroned Brotherhood as #1, especially not shits gay
FMAB >> Frieren >> S;G in my opinionI don't think any of them are top material though
>>291443834They aren't, all of them are overrated slop
Frieren is no.1
>>291443934True
>>291443834That's my same ranking. I think Frieren is a really good show for what it's worth. Didn't care for S;G.
FMAB and it's not even close. The two others are great too don't get me wrong. Just not all time best.
>>291434726Only frieren even deserves to be within the top 100.
>>291444223This, except Frieren should be ranked #100 and no higher.
>>291434726Why do people shill this garbage trio so much
>>291444382S;G and Frieren are only loved for cheap gimmicks like time travel or the premise being interesting. FMAB is loved for good execution, so that's why it's the only one that deserves to be there.
>>291444411I see your point but I still don't like any of them. I associate these shows mostly with disappointment in the face of their absurdly high ratings.
>>291434726Only Frieren is good out of those
>>291441951It's always ignorant newfags. every single time.
>>291444522Yeah I'm surprised by how much I liked frieren. I was expecting pretty much nothing because of how many disappointments I've had in the past with highly rated anime including the other two in the OP.
>>291444522Yep, this.
People love to shit on everything, but they never talk about what they like or what they think is good. They’re just a bunch of cowards with nothing to contribute to the conversation.
>>291434726Top 1 is uhh none of those. But among those three, to be honest only FMA deserved to be there. Tho I wish there is a composite of FMA and FMAB.
>>291435359I like re: zero, but Mushoku Tensei shits all over it
>>291445249fpbp
>>291445497I like both.
>>291434726None.
The most suspense you'll get from Stein's gate is when Mayuri brings Okabe food because he has no money and looks like a Buchenwald mannequin
>>291434726FMA 2003
>>291434726evangelion
>>291434726The real answer is LotGH, not any of this garbage.
>>291434726princess tutu
>>291434726Good - Dogshit - Great
>>291435924>frierenshitter being sill once again
>>291435988>>291436356>>291437688>>291438091except frieren is 3/10 at best
>>291444522The opposite is true
>>291434726This is why you should never listen to MAL, what a bunch of shit taste.
>>291448224Tell us. What is good taste then?
>>291434726It's legend of the galactic heroesnext question OP. I am here.
>>291434726I liked all three and had a lot of fun watching them and that's what matters.
>>291448360I like all of them too for the most part except for S;G which fell a bit short of my expectations.
lmao
>>291434726Frieren is an easy 10/10. Amazing worldbuilding. Intricate power system. Deep lore. Deep, highly emotive characters. Creative setting. Good slice of life and action. Everything is well done and amazing. Made me cry many times.
>>291448582Frieren will probably end badly, but it's also the only anime in the OP I actually like, at least so far.
>>291434726S;G is just The Time Machine for retards
>>291434726Why does mal have such a hold on this schizo? Are his feelings hurt over his fav animu not being at the top or something?
>>291434877Fifth post best post
>>291434726okay but none of these are on my favorites list so now what.
>>291434792/Thread
>>291449402I don't know, they aren't on mine either.
>>291434726Steins;Gate doesn't deserve to be in the conversation.
>>291448582>Amazing worldbuildingIt's already obvious you're trolling by the second sentence.
>>291435359>>291438431While none of these 3 are close to being contenders for the best, they're still better than trash like Re:Zero and Attack on Titan.
>>291450430That's the one out of the 3 that disappointed me the most. I'm not a huge fan of any of them though.
>>291434726None of them are in the running, there's way better stuff you could've picked for this.
>>291436013All of these are true but Frieren is still a good show.
I remember loving FMA the first time I seen it, but on a somewhat recent rewatch I couldn't stomach to finish it because I hated the solution to dealing with the sins. Just keep hurting them! Great, very interesting.
>>291451673Most of the 3 shows in the OP don't hold up well rewatching them years later. Not sure about Frieren yet because it's too recent for that.
>>291451703I already knew Brotherhood wouldn't hold up but I was surprised at how little I liked Steins;Gate he second time I watched it. So many of the character interactions are trite and meaningless.
>>291451703That's entirely subjective and I disagree. For a fighting/combat show, FMA just falls flat on its face when it came to beating the antagonists. The other 2 shows achieve what they set out to do (at least in my eyes). Doesn't mean they're perfect because the S;G VN exists as a better version of the anime, and Frieren hasn't concluded yet and has almost been on hiatus for a year, so some might question if it's worth bothering with something that may never have an end?
>>291451783Both shows are very very shallow. There's really not a lot there to dig into and in SG's case there isn't even fun action animation to look at.
>>291451783For character interactions involving a chuuni I actually prefer Konosuba over s;g by a lot.
