>Index: When science and magic collide the story begins>Railgun: Science side spin-off>Accelerator: Science side spin-off>Item: Science side spin-offWhy is it so unbalanced. Where's the magic spin-off?
>>292376212Nobody gives a shit about the magic side. It's boring powerscaling nonsense, they even tell you that magic is infinitely more powerful than the science side and it's nothing but constant People Fight wank. But science side as you observed is wildly more popular. Why? Because it's more interesting and has cute girls. Cute girls doing cute things is infinitely more watchable to battleslop. The End.
>>292376212Accelerator spin off was such a crime, coolest character got the lamest spin-off
Railgun is the crown jewel of the series.Everything else is irrelevant.
>>292376425Item has been cute so far
>>292376212railgun secondaries doomed the franchise, unironically.
>>292376373At least it gave us Scavenger
>>292376212Kamachi made Academy City too appealing as a setting so fans typically don't give a fuck when the story goes beyond its borders. Given most magicians are outside the city, no one fucking cares about the magic shit. Especially when they're later series magicians with ridiculous gachabait character designs like the Transcendants and Gremlin. Magic in Raildex is bonkers and uninteresting.
>>292376459Kissable bare shoulders
>>292376323>But science side as you observed is wildly more popular. Why? Because it's more interesting and has cute girls. Cute girls doing cute things is infinitely more watchable to battleslop.So what if you combined magic side with cute girls? What then?
>>292376929More should have been bare.
>>292376323why is the magic side nothing but "punchy" shounen-slop with slapstick humor? it shouldn't be as bad as it is.
>>292376425i don't know why you fags dislike item so much. despite some minor issues, like everything related to fake-item, it's very enjoyable thus far.
>>292376323this. index can't compete with saten sneaking up on uiharu and flipping her skirt. And uiharu, mikasa and saten saving a bunch of jk guys from falling beams and being super cool and cute while doing so? no chance at all.
>>292376212The Main series is more focused in Magic than science tbf>>292376762AC as whole is a temple of Magic, espers are just a variation of thelema and nowdays AC is in the shit. There's a reason why all spin off are always set in OT. With ITEM being a exception cuz is a prequel.
>>292376459Super flat sex
>>292376762>Kamachi made Academy City too appealing as a setting so fans typically don't give a fuck when the story goes beyond its borders.I find it is more that the Magic side is poorly thought out. Academy City is a known factor to the world so it can be big and flashy but it also keeps its tech and esper development a secret and Kamachi has gone into extreme detail in how the city does this, how it censors information, plugs leaks, conducts foreign relations, manipulates media, functions logistically and so on.The magic side is supposedly more secretive than Academy City, so much so that whole nations do not know of its existence let alone the general public. Yet instead of staying small cults and churches, it has continuously been expanded in lore to be massive in scope and scale. Nations are straight up lead by magicians, they have massive organizations in the thousands, there are giant magic structures some of which fly and big magic spells going off here and there. History in this world is supposed to be largely the same as ours but current day shows magic intervenes in big flashy ways all the time, like how are we supposed to believe WW1 and 2 happened when a few skilled magician can make the whole normie side of the wars irrelevant.At least Harry Potter made an effort to both keep the Wizarding World small and have good explanations for how things stay hidden, the Magic side in Toaru is the very definition of "don't think about it to hard". Magic basically either shows up in the city and causes trouble or the main characters go and visits a magic place then leaves before the aftermath of whatever mess needs to be explained and the status quo returns off screen. It's something that is visited for a short while, not something explored in depth because in depth it is an incoherent mess.
>>292376212>>292377611Because the anime was badly adapted. Simple answer.
>>292376212Who on the magic side would you want to give a spin-off?
>>292376323It's intrinsic to the concepts really, magic is made-up by nature while science has to creatively play within universally established rules
>>292377634No, I've read the books, the magic side staying secret for so long while being so massive makes less sense there than in the anime.
>>292377658The church boardhouse full of refugee catholics. I think Laura Stuart is one of the most compelling characters in the series too.
>>292377733>magic is made-up by nature.>science has to creatively play within universally established rules.The novels for the trillionth time explain this. Magic is using real world mythology to explain itself, and the novels explain the mythology relevant to the magic. Look at Renko’s ability here to see that it makes no sense under a scientific glance.https://toarumajutsunoindex.fandom.com/wiki/Futami_Renko
>>292377611Did the Anna's change anything about how you see this?
>>292377738Here’s the thing, others mistake them as either esper or gemstone powers. And the big guys don’t show off their big guns until the day they show up in the timeline.
>>292376212There are a few. There’s Kanzaki, Amakusa, Agnese, and Stiyl. All bonus novels for the BD releases.
>>292376323Cute girls doing cute things is a dead genre. Plus, the Railgun season 1 is a bad adaptation of the manga.
>>292378097Insane take. Cute girls doing cute things always tops nicoratings and (more importantly) viewership numbers.
>>292377360>AC as whole is a temple of Magic, espers are just a variation of thelemaI don't think so. I think Academy City and Thelema is outside of Magic, it's more like it is running on the source code magic is based on.>“Science and magic? Don’t make me laugh! If everything here is true, then there never were two different worlds. A single person’s wickedness was only making it look that way!! You can explain the world with a single unified theory!!”People take this to believe that Espers are an off shoot of Magic but series explains early on that Magic is an offshoot of Gemstones who are at the heart of everything. Look at how many concepts at the very core of Magic are created by Espers. Their AIM fields create an artificial phase or heaven. Networking them produces a Third Tree. AIM fields take on angelic form like Kazekuri or the AIM Burst. An Esper turns into an Angel if they grow powerful enough like Mikoto 5.3. You might say, that's all Magic but Magicians don't do any of that, they use it. The things that Espers can become are the things Magicians use as power sources for their spells, it is what their Magic is on the most fundamental level. Behind all that the Magic side is just a bunch of regular people using power that isn't theirs.What Aleister is doing is creating an alternate power source that exists outside of the one used by magicians made of artificial Gemstones. So that begs the question, if Academy City is the alternate power source, what is the original? Where did the naturally made Phases, Trees, Angelic/Phase beings come from, the ones that Magicians use? I think the answer is Gemstones. In Seniors story we see her gain Angelic properties before death but when she dies, she persists as an invisible force. Later we find that Gemstones are unable to turn off their powers, so if every Gemstone that ever existed persists after death, their Personal Realities would form countless Phases and Beings. That is the unified theory.
>>292376531The perfect example of one.>>292376762
>>292378162>"He's gathered a bunch of adolescent boys and girls in one place, he's spreading unique teachings, and he's even injecting them with drugs to achieve further knowledge. To Aleister, Academy City is the return of Thelema."Tsuchi un NT17>"I will give you the alternatively-shaped temple known as Academy City"From aleister himself, NT19Luca also realized what AC truly is during NT17 and im sure that it was also mentioned during the coronzon arc
>>292377938More like it made me question why this never happened before with so many magicians at odds with one another. It would take one simple spell being mass distributed to blow the lid off of everything. It's too easy for everything to break containment. I know the answer is probably that there is some big force keeping it all in check which is probably also why the world survives it's by weekly evil cult / scientist is going to destroy the world event. I think the lid is finally being blown off because everything is finally coming to a head in-universe.>>292377950That works in individual incidents but the magic side is sooo big and has been going on sooo long that it becomes hard to believe that the cat only got out of the bad around NT and no where in the century before it. It's too big to keep secret with sooo many people knowing it, many at odds with each other and not caring if it is secret. It's unbelievable without an some big force to keep it in check and I think that is SYSTEM more than anything the Magic side does to keep itself secret .
>>292378318Found it, from NT21>"Its name was Academy City and it was the Abbey of Thelema itself, created by gathering the shards of the dream that had failed in Sicily and repackaging them in the form of science"
>>292378318Along with this quote from Railgun SS3.>“I am not some bizarre Academy City technology, nor am I one of your garbage esper powers that simply rewrite the concepts of Thelema using arbitrary new terminology like Personal Reality… I am a crystallization of the Rosicrucian age that predates even the Golden cabal.”
>>292378129If you weren't insane you'd no better than to keep coming back to 4chan
>>292377738Archetype controller.
>>292378412Can you explain this. I know Archetype controller is responsible for the rift between science and magic making people see the two sides as separate but how does that hide magic? There are superstitious people everywhere who should lean towards magic than science but they still know science exists.