[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/asp/ - Alternative Sports & Wrestling

[Advertise on 4chan]


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


I googled "Most overrated wrestler of all time" and these were the top 4 results, is it accurate?
>>
>>12934398
Other than Benoit and Cena? Yes
>>
>>12934407
Since everyone shits on Cena for being overrated, does that make him somewhat underrated?
>>
File: underrated.jpg (101 KB, 1417x564)
101 KB
101 KB JPG
>>12934398
Hulk Hogan, Steve Austin, Val Venis, Rhyno, and Dean Malenko are the most underrated wrestlers of all time.
>>
>>12934398
>>12934430
Based Hulkster being overrated and underrated at the same time.
>>
File: based.png (461 KB, 1321x413)
461 KB
461 KB PNG
>>
>>12934430
Based Valbowski had a spinebuster that would make Arn proud
>>
>>12934398
no, they're all pretty correctly rated
except maybe cena with all the moves marks creaming themselves over his US title run
>>
>>12934398
I like all them.
>>
>>12934451
Here's the GOAT's of Japan
>>
>>12934398
Goldburg should be there
>>
>>12934451
More proof Hogan is the GOAT, brother.
>>
>>12934398
Hogan is rated overrated by every publication in the world, same with Cena. Rock is rarely called the GOAT by anyone, other amount of people shitting on him for being overrated cancels it out. The people who don't appear on overrated lists like Ric Flair & The Undertaker are the most overrated
>>
>>12934462
Based kai en tai
>>
File: Untitled.jpg (160 KB, 1605x334)
160 KB
160 KB JPG
>>12934451
>Hulk is simultaneously overrated, underrated, based, and cringe
>>
File: Hulk Hogan.png (567 KB, 900x369)
567 KB
567 KB PNG
>>12934430
>>12934442
>>
>>12934478
Hogan is god
God is all
Everything and nothing
>>
>>12934478
>Val Venis is in second place as underrated, based and cringe
Whoda thunk
>>
>>12934478
You know what Hulk Hogan you are a house hold name but so is garbage and it stinks when it gets old too!
>>
File: gayestofalltime.png (675 KB, 1920x370)
675 KB
675 KB PNG
Well? Are they right?
>>
>>12934474
>Hogan is rated overrated by every publication in the world
and you know darn well why he is, it has nothing to do with the content of Hulk's character and it has everything to do with the complete lack of character of the kleins who write these shitty media hit pieces
>>
>>12934519
Someone needs to tell me who the fuck the five next to Goldust are.
>>
>>12934519
Where’s Shawn?
>>
>>12934521
His matches are shit & he sucks in the ring, that's why he's called overrated. People who rate him high disregard his ability and just go by "Most famous wrestlers". However i agree that people should just disregard journalists and go by fan polls instead
>>
>>12934529
i think the black guy is the gay guy from aew sonny kiss and the guy in the middle is some mexican exotico
>>
>>12934529
That's the AEW upper midcard. you don't watch the show?
>>
File: 1602647040998.gif (320 KB, 708x472)
320 KB
320 KB GIF
>>12934519
>Triple H
KWAB
>>
>>12934545
I haven't watched wrestling in over a year.
>>
>>12934537
>fan polls
really the fan polls have less integrity than the media polls, because instead of jacob and his shitty opinion you have 1500 dorks who worship jacob and parrot his opinion verbatim.
>>
File: basef.png (327 KB, 995x430)
327 KB
327 KB PNG
>>
>>12934398
>Benoit
>The Rock
>Overrate
????
>>
>>12934580
Benoit is overrated by smarks and The Rock is probably the most famous wrestler now.
>>
>>12934416
The fact that he was a good worker that got pigeonholed with his comeback/finish set, just like Hogan and plenty of other top guys did. I don't think he's underrated as a talent overall, just as an in-ring worker.
>>
>>12934573
based rosey
>>
>>12934592
Smarks aren't real, just a boogeyman for "Liking something i don't"
>>
File: KWABwrestlers.png (85 KB, 900x400)
85 KB
85 KB PNG
>>
File: 1612833170400.png (620 KB, 1202x574)
620 KB
620 KB PNG
>>12934606
Since the thread got pruned earlier by the tranny janny. Reminder that anti-Nash and 1992 posters look like this.
>>
>>12934616
>Born 1993
Bah gawd it's Kevin Nash's rape baby
>>
>>12934478
Who TF is that AEW guy in the middle?
>>
>>12934573
mint
>>
>1. The Undertaker
>2. Triple H
>3. John Cena
>4. Hulk Hogan
>5. Ric Flair
There's your real list of overrated shitters
>>
>>12934669
I can smell your estrogen levels from here.
>>
>>12934651
Megabyte Ronnie. Shoot competitive eater who also used it for his wrestling gimmick. Only showed up on Dark and never came back after he talked shit about Joey Janela on twitter.
>>
>>12934733
kek based
>>
File: baddass.png (651 KB, 1071x583)
651 KB
651 KB PNG
Mmmmmm
>>
>>12934749
>lmao who's the mark jerking off PAC
>see the website just barely showing beneath
LIKE
CLOCKWORK
>>
>>12934605
So smarks are like modern day 'fascists'? They don't really exist.
>>
>>12934774
I'm a smark and a fascist. I exist.
>>
>>12934792
anybody to the right of Pol Pot is a fascist these days
>>
>>12934430
Rhyno unironically deserved a bigger push in the 2000s
>>
>>12934807
Vince probably hated him for his height and being a "star" in another company
>>
File: 1612019865413.gif (628 KB, 245x242)
628 KB
628 KB GIF
>>12934749
>>12934519
>>12934451
>>12934430
>>12934398
>Hogan is Overrated, Underrated, Based, Cringe, Gay, and Badass
>>
>>12934838
Big Show, Benoit, Jericho, Eddie, Rey, & Booker got their fame started in ecw and/or wcw and all went on to become world champions in wwe.
>>
>>12934884
Big Show is big.
Fans wanted Benoit, Jericho, Eddie.
Rey won because Eddie died.
Booker might've been ready to cry racism with how Hunter buried him previously.
>>
>>12934616
she's cute
>>
File: That's the Wall.jpg (11 KB, 480x360)
11 KB
11 KB JPG
>>12934478
THAT'S MYSELF BROTHER
I'M BASED, SOMETIMES CRINGE
THAT'S THE HULKSTER UP THERE BROTHER
YOU KNOW SOMETHING ANON?
I'M LETTING YOU KNOW 500 OTHER THINGS ABOUT ME ON TOP OF THAT
GET YOUR POST RIGHT HERE SO I CAN FED YOU ON EVERYTHING I'VE DONE ON MY CAREER BROTHER
>>
>>12934900
>she
>cute
Listen to its voice. You won't think so then.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKEliMbaDeo&t=36s&ab_channel=Cassidy
>>
>>12934920
Would need to see the penis and bussy before making my final assessment, but yeah that's not enticing. 1 hour video too, sad!
>>
>>12934483
>Hogan gets his way even in a court of law
Truly a master politician
>>
Shawn Michaels. Seriously go to any poll or list and you'll see this faggot on Top 4 when he's top 20 at the very best.
>>
>>12934606
Lmao
>>
>>12934521
Exactly, he said a bad word in private so now they're trying to rewrite history. Hogan will be forever based. It's impossible to overrate him.

>>12934537
>ability
Spamming Canadian Destroyers doesn't make you a good wrestler. Hogan is what the total package of a pro wrestler should be, not workrate shit.
>>
>>12935490
Even Bret would tell you he’s incredibly talented. In terms of homegrown wwe stars, he’s as good as you’ll ever get. Bret, Jericho, Benoit, Liger all came from the Hart Dungeon, Guerrero came from a legendary family. So they were good long before joining WWE. Shawn was very green, and you saw his entire career grow in front of your very eyes. Everyone else left or was already established, he had to work his way up from undercard tag team, to a single’s midcard to a championship. Nobody else has ever had that. Undertaker is kind of the same way
>>
>>12935539
LARp more, nobody likes his matches. They pretend to like him because Meltzer created the narrative about x wrestlers making x amount of money, which people parrot. You have two groups the Hardcore fans who rate based on enjoyment in ring & diehard analytic fags who over analyze meltzer’s numbers on drawing and cannot form opinions of their own
>>
Shawn Michaels is good, but the ridiculous amount of hype he receives also makes him the most overrated wrestler of all time. He's definitely in the conversation for too 5 US wrestling GOATs, but the marketing BS that surrounds him now actually works against its own intention.
>>
>>12935562
Enjoyment isn't only based on in ring work. And good in ring work isn't about the amount of flips per minute. Hogan was an excellent in ring worker because he knew how to put a logical match together, he knew how to adapt and read a crowd. If you can't understand that then you don't understand what pro wrestling is and can only derive your opinions from star ratings.
>>
>>12935572
Nope, i started watching in 2007 and had no idea Shawn was a legend. They buried him 6 feet deep, and i thought he was just HHH’s quirky sidekick in DX. JBL always said on Smackdown Edge was the greatest ever that year, on Raw when Jericho & Shawn returned i had no idea why fans were so hyped about them. But they made sure to remind me HHH was a huge deal
>>
>>12934451
Based Alpha Female.
>>
>>12935586
This is your brain on r/scjerk.
>>
>>12935572
I think Shawn as a character and mic worker is underrated. People only talk about his wrestling and when people say his wrestling wasn't as great as people say they call him overrated. Same with Kurt Angle who I would consider underrated as a character as well.
>>
>>12935592
You like gymnastics not wrestling.
>>
>>12935592
>Posts a pic with Nash in it
>92
Why does it keep happening?
>>
>>12934454
Pal penis is a QAnon conspiracy theory retard
>>
>>12935597
Nobody cares what r/scjerk fags think, have fun being a minority that only journos agree with
>>
>>12935606
>have fun being a minority that only journos agree with
One of the most stupid arguments I think I've ever read.
>>
>>12935606
And yet it's you who rely on journalists star ratings to form an opinion.
>>
>>12935554
>he had to work his way up

You must be at least 18 to post here Shawncel.
>>
>>12934616
kek kevin trash getting dunked on by a tranny
>>
>>12934478
>>12934483
/asp/ made me appreciate Hulkamania again, brothers
>>
bump
>>
>>12935592
>Nash
>92
OH NO NO NO NO
>>
>>12934749
God bless Scott Steiner
>>
>>12935605
T. /leftypol/
>>
>>12935592
IT JUST KEEPS HAPPENING
>>
File: hmmmm.png (464 KB, 1255x360)
464 KB
464 KB PNG
Google has spoken.
>>
>>12937366
>Charles Flair
>Female
>>
>>12934430
i honestly can't think of a more accurately rated wrestler than val venis



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.