[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/co/ - Comics & Cartoons


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_20250829_121249.jpg (544 KB, 1080x1302)
544 KB
544 KB JPG
>Say the film should be like the source material
>Get fired
Why are they like this
>>
>>150108778
m
>>
>>150108778
Why do these people get so mad about comics when they're making comic book movies it makes no sense
>>
The kind of people who get MBAs just really really hate cartoons and comics and geek culture.
That's why they started hiring alt types and hipsters. I remember during the previous dark ages of good culture in cinema there would always been some snippet like.
>the studio want a director who wasn't a fan of the source material
>they made sure to cast actors who'd never heard of the source material
Directors and producers would quite proudly declare in interviews that they hate super heros or magic or fantasy in general.
>>
>>150108778
>anon learns that people making these movies and shows hold comics in the absolute contempt and feel they're above them
And no, this has not changed one bit because "superhero movies nowadays are more comic-booky" or whatever nonsense. It's just hidden behind ten layers of irony now.
>>
>>150108778
And in this house Chris Columbus is a hero!
>>
>>150108778
based C-suites, comics are stupid
>>
>>150108910
>FF 2025 follows the source material
>Movie flops
>>
>>150108962
>FF 2025 follows the source material
in what in universe
>>
>>150108867
What it comes down to is all these people go to parties together and talk about their projects and the hot chick's and cool guys think comics and suoer heros are hella gay. So you have to broadcast on all frequencies that you do not like and it's just a job. Or else the cool kids won't share cocaine and underage hookers with you
>>
>>150108778
Still the best FF film.
>>
>>150108982
*in what universe
>>
>>150108962
Yeah I remember that issue of ff back in 1963 where Reed was a functional retard in a sombrero
>>
>>150108982
What was so different about it
>>
>>150108993
Corman>>>
>>
>>150108778
Because sticking to the source material is for stinky, nerdy chudcels!
>>
>>150109061
This was before the schizo culture war we're in tho
>>
>>150108778
>Why are they like this
Because producers think they are artists but are just to busy to direct.
>>
>>150109007
The setting, the characters, the tone, and the plot. But other than that, they're identical!
>>
>>150109176
All of the points you mention can be debatable
>>
>>150108778
nothing changed
>>
>>150109176
>Fantastic Four's biggest strength is the character dynamics
>barely any character stuff, most of which is told and not shown
BRAVO MCU BRAVO
>>
>>150109187
Wow anon why would I associate a word with it's most common usage nowadays
>>
>>150108778
Chris Columbus is just desperate for attention this week.
>>
>>150108778
based for trying to be accurate
>>
>>150109244
Mf should've never arrived in America
>>
>>150108867
Executives are afraid of audiences being alienated by the source material. They want the broadest appeal to maximize profits. It's also why they treat people like idiots and want simple, dumbed down movies.
>>
>>150108880
>The kind of people who get MBAs just really really hate cartoons and comics and geek culture.
It's this. They want their own stories being made and they just use the names of the franchises because nobody wants to produce their ideas. It's not, for example, Thor, but rather some OG character played by Chris Hemsworth dressed as Thor.
When you see a character acting ooc compared to the comic, it's the writer or director using his own original character in all but name. Gunn really likes immature manchild men as his heroes because that's his favorite archetype. It's not Starlord, it's a Gunn's original.
>>
The people always bagging on about "comic accuracy" never have anything to say when James Gunn is giving Superman a scat fetish
>>
>>150109304
I like Gunn's GotG but I often wonder what it must've felt like being a fan of the comic version and see the characters being irrevocably changed forever.
>>
>>150109194
Fucking everything is debatable, anon. People still argue about the shape of the world and the Greeks mathed that one out fucking thousands of years ago AND we have pictures!
>>
File: peacemaker oooooh.png (1.09 MB, 1006x812)
1.09 MB
1.09 MB PNG
>>150109323
the joke was that Peacemaker was getting false information from a source that was clearly trolling him.
>>
>>150109360
Yes, but you get what I mean, Art discussion is far broader and not subject to the parameters of something like scientific facts.
>>
>>150109138
When do you think the culture war started?
I'll give you a hint: it wasnt when YOU turned 12.
>>
>>150108778
Hollywood hacks are way too full of themselves to ever accept the fact that the funny book guy is more talented than they are.
>>
>>150109427
Correct. It was when *I* turned 12!
>>
>>150109304
>>
>>150109427
Isn't it agreed for the turning point to be during the mid 2010's?
>>
>>150108867
they just want the name recognition
>>
>>150109467
80s is when the term politically correct came into use.
>>
>>150109488
It was definetively a concern, but the advent of social media is what pushed fandom culture to the edge.
>>
>>150109452
Brimstone.
>>
>>150109299
Given that comic book movies cost 200+ million dollahs I'm not entirely unsympathetic
>>
>>150109467
Depends which turning point you mean. There have been multiple even just in my lifetime.

The two biggest ones are the culture shift after 9/11 (its undeniable that America culture got a lot more cynical during the Bush years), and then the 2010s were when social media got big and people who didn't understand the internet started using it daily, giving away personal information that us oldfags knew you were supposed to keep secret and diving headfirst into information bubbles and other ways that social media manipulates you and fosters extremism. People will point to 2016 as "when things got bad" but that was the climax, not the cause. These things had already been festering on the internet for years, 2016 was just when it broke containment and curated Facebook news feeds started to swing elections.
>>
>>150109304
James Gunn also told John Cena to NOT read any Peacemaker comics to get ready for the role, so Hollywood hasn't learned anything, they're still doing it.
>>
>>150109543
Yet the money is barely on screen in most of them nowadays
>>
>>150109578
I'd say I'm refering to the 2010's turning point, when woke, PC culture and grifting established themselves as an inescapable point of conversation. Not to say they weren't there before, but I do think they acquired a whole new dimension that wasn't as prevalent before.
>>
>>150109543
It's not a new thing and not even a comic book movie thing. Hollywood loves taking something and changing it drastically. The ones that get messed with the least are book adaptations and even those aren't safe from executive butchering.
>>
>>150109594
Tbf I do think it's more important for the creatives to have a good grasp on the characters than the actors.
>>
>>150108891
True, unless it is Taika Waititi, then he doesn't even bother with the irony part, he just says with all words that he hates comic books and everything about them, he says it in the most obnoxious way possible also, and retards still praise his shitty Thor 3 movie for ignoring the comics.
>>
>>150109689
Thank god all that rethoric ended up biting him in the ass with L&T.
>>
>>150108962
>FF 2025 follows the source material
On opposite day? Yeah.
>>
File: EFPHLMmXYAcM63r.jpg (35 KB, 796x553)
35 KB
35 KB JPG
>>150109805
I disagree

I disagree Gary
>>
>>150109488
You can go back even further if you count other terms with the same meaning.
>>
>>150109671
Actors having a good grasp is important too, so they know what they're trying to do with the performance; also, Gunn doesn't have a good grasp of anything in terms of comic accuracy, his Guardians are basically just Firefly but blander and his Peacemaker is just a clown.
>>
>>150109467
THE CULTURE WAR HAS ALWAYS BEEN HAPPENING
>>
>>150109873
"The culture war" is the same as "the genetics war" and is just as old.
>>
>>150109689
It's weird he said that when the Thor Love & Thunder trailer had shots taken from panels of a Thor comic whole cloth.
>>
>>150109138
It was still that way before the evil times. Hollywood has always looked down its nose at comics.
>>
>>150109906
>his Guardians are basically just Firefly
Scathing
>>
>>150109954
I know, the response was to the idea of creatives having a personal vendetta against the audience ala Last Jedi, not mere disrespect and indifference for the comics.
>>
>>150109949
A lot of cbm's recreate designs and panels to give the pretense of respect for the source material, despite not bothering with character and theme adaptations.
>>
>>150109995
It was a smoke screen. Being obsessively anti-nerd was also a cringey disposition they had to constantly clench their muscles to hide.
After spcmed and the audience could talk shit directly to the people in charge without lublicists filtering it they became more openly vindictive. But mark my words they always were being malicious and doing it shit on purpose as a way to not look uncool to their friends.
>>
>>150108778
Why wasn't he concerned with book accuracy when directing HP then?
>>
>>150109403
I'm gonna be honest, you're incredibly low IQ.
>>
People who think this is just about comics are wrong, literally all corpos are the exact same "positivity" nonsense where disagreeing with what people are doing is LE BAD

They could be doing the stupidest most retarded shit ever that would backfire massively and cost them billions, but if you pointed that out to them you'd be fired on the spot because
>Listen, we need TEAM PLAYERS OK???? You're being toonegative!
>>
>>150108993
you're not wrong. That guy from The Shield is the best Thing, Alba is the best Invisible Woman and Michael McMahon (may he rest in power) was a great actor, as I loved him in Nip/Tuck as he may not be the best Doom, but he was so good in the movie
>>
>>150108962
and I'm pretty sure 2015 Fantastic Four or 2018 Tomb Raider followed their respective source materials as well. These two franchises are forever cursed
>>
>>150110205
What doesn't make sense in that statement
>>
>>150110260
Fant4stic didn't even follow Ult FF that much
>>
I bet it was Tom Rothman. Fuck him.
>>
>>150110306
>Fucks over FF and Deadpool at Fox
>Fucks over Spider-Man at Sony
>Loses millions of dollars by selling KPDM to Netflix
Might arguably be the most retarded excec in Hollywood
>>
>>150108778
>the source material sells 50,000 comics a month if it's a really good month

>we need to sell millions of tickets just to break even and we won't get there by pandering to a tiny audience like comic fans

They were right to fire him.
>>
>>150110364

I dunno, him or Amy Pascal.
>>
>>150110292
which was why Fantf4stick was just dogshit. Tomb Raider 2018 was also dogshit
>>
>>150110306
>>150110364
Ironic how he also ok'd Morbius and Madame Web
>>
>>150110394

>Lets take a superhero franchise known for campy fun and turn it into body horror! Then fire the director before he can make an ending!
>>
>>150110198
>Why wasn't he concerned with book accuracy when directing HP then?
...uh what? His two HP movies follow the books VERY closely. They're probably the most accurate adaptations in ALL of media.
>>
>>150110198
The first two Harry Potter movies were strongly book accurate, it was after he left they went wildly off the rails.
>>
>>150108778
Hollywood always changes adaptations. In fact a lot of movies are based on books, but capefags are the only ones insist that their former news stand rags are exalted gems that must be veraciously adapted.
>>
Plenty of shills defending faggot execs here.
>>
>>150110596
Trying to memory-hold the Percy Jackson fags sperging over the movie not being book accurate?
>>
>>150108962
Yummy bait
>>
>>150110431
Sad too. Josh Trank wasn't even ready to make a Hollywood blockbuster, and furthermore, he's just not the right guy to direct something as profoundly big as it
>>
>>150109452
I didn't mention politics at all. Gunn being politically leftist isn't the problem, but rather that he doesn't want to adapt stories rather than use other people's characters as avatars for their ideas.
>>
>>150109341
Mixed feelings, first movie was fun enough but I cringe on every rewatch when I look at Groot and Rocket.
>>
>>150110596
Tomb Raider 2018 being a hugely godawful example
>>
>>150109594
This is the exact same attitude D&D got when they told the GoT actors to ignore the books to the point discussions of them were banned and we all know how that turned out.
There is no mystery: these directors think they're much better storytellers then writers who create comics or fantasy, which they consider for kids.

>>150109671
Both should understand the character. Thing is, you wouldn't tell an actor to not read classic books. It happens with comics or vgs because, even the actors, think they're above it.
>>
>people who actually know the stories/characters want to see them done justice?
>NOOO I'M MELTING
And yes, it's also shit when book adaptations do this. And yes, people who actually read the books do complain about the shitty pointless changes, problem is your average consumer reads neither books nor comics.
>>150110914
Tomb Raider 2018's main problem is that the source material was godawful in the first place. Every issue with the movie, faithful or not stems from that alone.
>>
>>150109906
>Peacemaker is just a clown.
Peacemaker like Quill are both the quirky manchild Gunn thinks he is, except he thinks he's been funny.
>>
>>150110033
They do it in purpose because they know idiots will defend the movie saying "look! It's in the comics, chud!"
>>
>>150110942
>Tomb Raider 2018's main problem is that the source material was godawful in the first place.
and the casting decision was wrong. After Vikander as Lara Croft came out, nobody could hire her in any movie outside of Green Knight movie that came out. She would appear in less indie movies that have completely flopped, because even people couldn't take her seriously as an actress, and the Tomb Raider IP was nothing more than a joke by that point
>>
File: dang ol.jpg (4 KB, 150x150)
4 KB
4 KB JPG
>>150108778
dang ol' Fantastic Four man, franchise forever as dang ol' cursed as King of the Hill man
>>
>>150111095
What's wrong with KotH
>>
>>150109323
Those are Superman fans who are desperate to have their guy get a W for the first time in years since it’s unanimously agreed he sucks and is boring- they have to lap up Gunnslop because it’s the last chance for him to ever have mainstream appeal outside of being slapped onto birthday cakes and t shirts for 10 year olds
>>
>>150111300
Gunnbros are speedrunning and already becoming as annoying as Snyderbros.
>>
>>150111300
>since it’s unanimously agreed he sucks and is boring
No, that's just you being a retarded schizo faggot trying to push a shitty "meme" like an attention-whoring tard you are.
>>
File: IMG_8782.png (131 KB, 254x405)
131 KB
131 KB PNG
>>150111331
Yes it’s quite sad to see what a well respected character like Clark has been reduced to but the cult of Gunn marches forward and has now absorbed the most obnoxious fanbase in the comic medium- I dread his Batman and hope his dcu gets cancelled before he can get there
>>
>>150111371
>I dread his Batman
Personally I'm pissed he kept us from having more Reeves Batman
>>
File: IMG_8700.jpg (148 KB, 800x722)
148 KB
148 KB JPG
>>150111351
Look this whiny ass supermanchild kek, this is exactly the type of people who lap up Gunnslop- a hit dog will holler as they say
>>
>>150111396
>retarded seething schizo cries out like a bitch
Looks like I've hit a nerve
You and Gunn should both get cancer, by the way.
Nothing of value would be lost.
>>
Also just noticed
>it's a snydercuck
Of course, go home my brown "friend". This thread is for humans only.
>>
File: IMG_8554.jpg (75 KB, 1572x1080)
75 KB
75 KB JPG
>>150111436
Actually no, I just used the image to see how you’d respond and of course predictably you immediately turned into a gunntard, you tried to mask yourself in the previous reply but a hit dog hollers like I already said

Superman sucks and always will
>>
>>150111390
I haven’t seen Reeves Batman yet but I’m sure it’s better than whatever that hack could crank out, but I think he’ll win out in the end- I don’t think Supergirl will do the numbers WB hopes
>>
>>150111471
>muh Gunn
I know it's difficult for a tiny brown "brain" to comprehend, but one can easily hate both.
>S-s-s-superman s-s-s-sucks, p-please agree with me
And nobody cares what some no-name autistic loser on 4chan thinks about one of the most iconic superheroes in the world.
You will die one day (that day can't come soon enough) and Superman will still keep getting media, lmao.
>>
>>150108778
Damn, a post-Potter Chris Columbus Fantastic Four would've been fucking GOOD.
I hate these studios.
>>
>>150111390
>Personally I'm pissed he kept us from having more Reeves Batman
?
The Batman 2 is still happening, script is complete, shooting next Spring.
>>
>>150111704
I hope the villain is Mister Freeze, because he is technically a normal guy, but he also has sci-fi tech, so he could serve as a bridge from the more realistic villains to the more comic book ones, so the third one could have Batman fight a more out there one, like Clayface or Man-Bat.
>>
File: Untitled.png (1.44 MB, 750x1139)
1.44 MB
1.44 MB PNG
>>150111738 (Me)
I also hope they have Bruce improve his suit as the movies go; the suit he wears in the Reeves movie looks very provisional, and I think that was done on purpose, because this is early Batman, so his equipment is meant to be kind of half-baked, and we'll see him improving it as the movies go. I hope by the third movie he's wearing something like this.
>>
>>150109427
>>150109467
The internet's nature changed significantly in the 2010s. There wasn't such a pervasive culture war online in the 90s and 2000s, normal people weren't online 24/7 on social media using their real names, and there weren't the social media propaganda wars where foreign nations are funding the spread of radical views through artificially pumped up accounts and bots.
>>
>>150111704
It was heavily delayed because of Gunn and probably having all sorts of bullshit forced on it
>>
>>150111924
Things are only going to get worse with AI. At best there will be an arms race between truth spreading AI and malicious AI.
>>
>>150111371
>but the cult of Gunn marches forward and has now absorbed the most obnoxious fanbase in the comic medium
You can thank whatever retard turned it into a console between muh Snyder and muh Gunn
>>
>>150112133
Fandom always devolves into tribalistic shit
>>
>>150112133
I like Superman generally, but I'm tired of both camps dominating all the discussion with their shitty versions of him.
It's not just a Superman problem either. Spider-Man has it just as bad because nobody wants to actually adapt the character. We haven't had a worthwhile cartoon since almost 20 years ago, MCU slop is actively offensive to me as a (former) fan of Spider-Man, and that's not even mentioning how bad the comics are.
>inb4 m-m-muh box office, please be happy for all the money that goes to millionaires and billionaires like a good little dog slave you are
>>
>>150111528
correct, because no one cares about Superman in general kek
>>
>>150112344
>screeching brownoid cope noise that doesn't make sense to anybody who's actually human
Didn't expect anything else. Off you go, seething brown monkey.
>>
File: IMG_8655.jpg (34 KB, 640x320)
34 KB
34 KB JPG
>>150112369
Look at this Supermanchild seething lmao grow up nigga
>>
>>150108778
Because the entire movie industry is actually a front. The real goal of making movies is to produce hate and rage to feed Lord Moloch, the insane demon god who embodies evil and despises everything good.
>>
>eek eek eek eek ooga booga
Lmao.
Why is this brownoid perma-seething about Superman anyway?
>>
>>150108778
Tom Rothman was involved. That's why it was like this.
>>
>>150108778
Ok, what does it mean to "feel more like"?
>>
File: GykF6JQXcAAQOTx.png (440 KB, 834x491)
440 KB
440 KB PNG
>>150112369
>seething brown monkey
What does Hawkgirl have to do with this?
>>
>anti-Superman brownoid continues to seethe
How about you post hand and outlet with a timestamp, so we could all see what kind of a golem you are. Failure to comply immediately outs you as the darkest shade of brown.
>>
Why is the racist bro shilling for the pro-brown immigration and anti-American Gunn movie?
>>
>no photo
And like that concession accepted.
>racist
Cry about it, monkey.
>>
>>150112633
Wrong anon, but okay.
>>
>>150110391
And then the movie flopped
>>
>totally not the same brown faggot, just happen to be just as retarded and repeat his retarded talking points
Slash your throat already, nobody is fooled.
>>
File: GykF6JQXcAAQOTx.png (6 KB, 661x107)
6 KB
6 KB PNG
>>150112731
>No "(You)"
>>
>I totally didn't edit it
Nobody cares, retard.
Let me summarize my opinion, so you would look even more retarded next time you try to play up "muh gunn shill" angle.
Superman is a good character.
You, Snyder and Gunn should are all worthless negative-IQ retards whose best contributions to the world were turds in the toilet. (then again, your kind hates toilets)
Anything else?
>>
>>150111191
Nothing, it's still quality. But it's still a shame that the majority of the cast died, especially during production of the revival
>>
File: m4z3O6mD_o.png (554 KB, 720x540)
554 KB
554 KB PNG
>>150112836
>Snyder and Gunn are all worthless negative-IQ retards whose best contributions to the world were turds in the toilet
Well, can't argue with that one.
>>
>>150112421
and the producers' cocaine binges
>>
>>150108778
>Why are they like this
they made billions with movies who gave a fuck about the source material
/co/ always told you to never wank the MCU, the nolan movies, phoenix joker and the jackmanverse
>>
>>150112918
Good then.
Repugnant nepotism-driven pricks should stay away from my capeshit.
>>
>>150109594
John Cena can read?
>>
>>150108778
they hate jack that's why
>>
>>150109671
Actors are part of the creative process too and I can't really see a scenario where the actor reading the source material is going to be a detriment unless you plan on in a completely different direction.
>>
>>150108867
They want the normie audience
>>
>>150110876
You've misinterpreted the story.
No one spent money on the movies
>>
>>150108778
>>150108867
Those people are the most insufferable people that I could ever imagined. What kind of people actually respected them?
>>
The really fucked up part is, this is Chris Columbus. Ontop of a long career making some of the biggest movies ever, he recently was making a billion dollars with Harry Potter IN THE EARLY 2000s! imagine being so dedicated to an idea that you're willing to risk a massive political headache for the rest of your career....and it's for a terrible decision, a terrible decision that doesn't even make sense since it's not like these were serious movies in the first place.
>Galatctus has to be a turd cloud because people wouldn't accept it in a movie....but half the movie can be cornball jokes about Nascar and body swapping
>>
>>150109360
if you actually read the greek writings its not infallible calculation its assumption laid on top of assumption, same with modern physicists and quantum theory and String theory etc its just guesswork and calculation laid on top of the assumptions.
>>
>>150108778
they made one with everything the reddit crowd always wanted and it flopped way worse
>>
>>150115054
Is the reddit in the room here with us
>>
>>150110198
The first two HP movies catch the feel of both books almost perfectly. And they’re both really good.
>>
>>150111371
I loved Superman as a stand-alone movie. But it pretty much solidified that his DCU is gonna be shit. The world building is awful and Supergirl’s movie is probably gonna be shit. He’s got one woman writing like five scripts for five separate films, and I have no faith in his interpretation of Batman.
>>
>>150108778
Studios demand control, having anyone involved give the slightest bit of pushback can't be allowed.
>>
>>150116446
Now that is sad for real.
>>
>>150108896
Kek
>>
>>150112836
Superman is not a good character, he’s boring derivative schlock with too many hats on- at some point you manchildren need to stop blaming the writers and audience and accept that
>>
>>150108778
How the fuck does Chris fucking Columbus manage to have too many opinions when he's the stereotype of a Hollywood hack yes-man?
>>
>>150109452
What sort of coked up schizo brain dreamt this up from the eldritch depth of their mind?
>>
>>150108778
One of the biggest reasons this keeps happening is because the more money that goes into a movie, the more it needs to be a "four quadrants" film so some success can be guaranteed (in the eyes of the people funding and managing production). A big budget movie that appeals to families will make five times the money per person and be a safer return on investment versus an identically budgeted film that single men and couples will watch.

The average big blockbuster (after the Great Recession) just can't exclusively appeal to young men anymore (UNLESS you're Bayformers and have the means/connections/clout to get away with it) since no one knows how to budget properly and because Hollywood is exclusively filled with rich people. And when you factor in how female consumers spend more money than men and are willing to go into debt more than men....
>>
>>150109304
MBA stands for Masters of Business Administration
i.e. the suits
>>
>>150110459
>>150110467
>>150115209
If you ask various fans who read the books before the first HP film came out, some of them will tell you that it accurately captured almost exactly they pictured in their minds but then other fans will tell you that every single film took a huge shit on all the books and completely desecrated them (yes including the chris columbus ones). Opinions on this heavily vary and it depends on what exactly you're referring to when it comes to "book accuracy" because I could list a bunch of things from the books that the films changed or completely cut out
>>
>>150117705
Shut the fuck up and die already, you mentally ill schizo cunt.
You have to accept that your life is worthless and commit suicide instead of shitting this board up daily.
You still haven't posted your brown hand and the outlet, by the way.
>>
>>150109452
Wow...you sure owned the chuds with that one...
>>
>>150117705
So who IS a good character by your standards?
>>
>>150117705
You people are always like this, man.
>>
>>150118781
>but then other fans will tell you that every single film took a huge shit on all the books and completely desecrated them
It's okay, JK said they can always just magic that away.
>>
>>150119845
Whoever is not popular so he can feel special by being a contrarian.
>>
>>150108778
>>150108867
Is there a way we could kill this kind of people?
>>
DC and Marvel have people who make comics that hate it and people who make movies that hate it
Make it make sense
>>
>>150109299
>Executives are afraid of audiences being alienated by the source material.
What movie can be pointed to where people have been alienated by the source material of the comic they're making a movie of?

Watchmen 2009 got hated BECAUSE of what they changed, and that was otherwise a 1:1 of the comic.
>>
>>150123216
It is a senseless world and an even more senseless existance.
>>
>>150123284
Snyder's direction also played a part on Watchmen's polaryizing reception
>>
>>150123284
>What movie can be pointed to where people have been alienated by the source material of the comic they're making a movie of?
None because no Hollywood movie would ever dare take that risk and do shit like Electro wearing his green and yellow suit while throwing solid bolts of lightning like he did in his original Spider-Man appearances. Can you imagine how shitty that would look in live action?

Also, some of the things from the comics are not very marketable. I have a feeling that if Wolverine was played by an actual manlet rather than Hugh Jackman he'd be significantly less popular today.
>>
>>150108982
>>150109002
>>150109805
FF 2025, like every adaptation, takes a ton of liberties. But it is nonetheless by far the most faithful FF adaptation in film.

>retro aesthetic
>goofy villains referenced
>them barely being able to hurt Galactus
>Surfer turning on Galactus
>Sue being OP
>Johnny actually being not as much of a retard as cultural osmosis made him seem
>>
>>150123366
>huurduuurrrr me make retarded xankle huujr wut if loky costume ahuahuahu
you are stupid and the reason movies don't take risks, kill yourself
>>
>>150123366
>Can you imagine how shitty that would look in live action?
I mean, if you can make the entire film to match that aesthetic, it wouldn't stand out as too goofy
>>
>>150108778
because hollywood execes are still the late 90's/early 00's understanding that comics are "immature stuff for kids" so whenever they want to make a film they have to "adapt it for a more mature audience"
>>
>>150123414
You might think pic related is the coolest-looking shit ever, but casuals would just laugh and use that as an excuse to mock the movie. I don't make the rules, that's how it works.
>>
>>150123467
I think we're past that point, altough they still feel ashamed of what they're adapting. We just moved on from edgy/black aesthetic to irony poisoning. Different package, same content.

Tho both Superman and FF felt more sincere than your average cbm so I'll give them that. Hopefully a trend follows.
>>
>>150123510
looks kino to me chum
>>
>>150123510
You just need to put some effort, which to be honest I don't actually expect from Hollywood
>it's a videogame
With a semi-realistic visual style (for its time)
Principle is the same, just keep trying until it looks cool.
>>
>>150123619
Web of Shadow's Electro design is widely disliked though
>>
>>150123619
I liked the approach Spectacular took by having the bolt mask actually be electricity constantly being expelled by Max. I get it could be a VFX nightmare but it's a nice alternative, all the while keeping the green suit of course.
>>
>>150108778
They seriously fired the Home Alone and Harry Potter director, for suggesting a throw-back aesthetic that worked perfectly fine for Incredibles.
>>
>>150123646
Moreso the rewrote the script of the '05 film to avoid similarities with The Incredibles.
>>
>>150123670
>to avoid similarities with The Incredibles.
God that's dumb
>>
>>150123510
>cheap cosplay is totally the same as what hollywood costume designers can do if they put in the effort
Were you dropped on your head as a baby?
>>
>>150108896
He'll always be a hero for writing the first Gremlins movie.
https://youtu.be/dZVeyibVA40?si=NEsu9ZBjksvs4rYt
>>
>>150109304
Besides Adam Warlock being fucked I thought Guardians were good for making them appeal to mass audiences, the comic team was unironically too serious for a concept that goofy. the problem is they just overdid the humor
same for Thor desu with Ragnarok, people blame Whedon but that shit started with Gunn, it was like the watershed moment for millennial writers when writing an ensemble
>>
File: file.png (656 KB, 820x794)
656 KB
656 KB PNG
Why didn't /co/ bust a nut when Sony gave them their accurate campy shitty-looking Rhino? No gay armors, just a big guy in rhino suit. Why didn't /co/ love it?
>>
>>150108896
I'll tell you what it is: it's anti-geek discrimination.
>>
>>150123822
>the comic team was unironically too serious for a concept that goofy
I think that would've make it feel more earnest. I do like the films but wonder what a more faithful adaptation in both tone and character would be like. Just find a different approach from what Gunn did and it could work.
>>
>>150124140
That's not a guy in a Rhino suit.
>>
>>150124140
Doesn't look like a guy in a rhino suit, doesn't even look like Kingpin, I think that was in Kraven which nobody watched, fuck off

>>150123822
>the comic team was unironically too serious for a concept that goofy
Are you sure you read the DnA run? The problem is they shifted everyone's personality. They pushed Rocket from chill and occasionally goofy to all angsty and a bastard. Groot went from all grumpy to a precious cinnamon roll, and then died and replaced with the kid version.
>>
>it's supposed to be a villain movie
>nobody knows how to write a villain anymore
>so it's a bogstandard superhero movie
Funny, I was intending to make it a post talking about Kraven but it applies to way too many things to just stop at that.
The Penguin show, while not flawless, was a nice surprise for not sticking to that formula.
>>
>>150108867
I think the guy that made the X-men cartoon sequel (and got the boot) said it best (not like we needed his word for confirmation but whatever): These fags want to leave THEIR mark on the product, not make Stan Lee/Jack Kirby/etc stories, but THEIR story.
>>
>>150108867
Because movie executives are all insane jews drunk off child blood and foreskins



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.